Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Is an upgrade worth the Cost"
I have a 1999 Merc 125, Have not really been happy about its performance or
reliability. I would like to upgrade it to a 150HP but not sure if I should stick to Mercury. A few questions on this: 1. If you were upgrading to a 150 HP engine, which one would you look at? 2. What can I expect to get for the 1999 Merc 125 Thanks |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Is an upgrade worth the Cost"
Depends on the boat your using this on. The 125 is not a very good engine
in my opinion. It has that jump from about 1500 rpms to 3000 rpms. It was designed for a bass boat or small runabout application where you would not be trying to run at very low speeds. Again, what boat and what is it rated for. You just found out why I always recommend the max hp for a boat. As for value of that engine. You are not going to be happy w/ the trade value. Probably about $3500 at best. Go w/ either Merc or Yamaha EFI. Depends on the dealer in your area as both are very good engines. Tony my boats at http://t.thomas.home.mchsi.com "JGK" wrote in message .. . I have a 1999 Merc 125, Have not really been happy about its performance or reliability. I would like to upgrade it to a 150HP but not sure if I should stick to Mercury. A few questions on this: 1. If you were upgrading to a 150 HP engine, which one would you look at? 2. What can I expect to get for the 1999 Merc 125 Thanks |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Is an upgrade worth the Cost"
The boat is a 19ft Pro-line Center Console, Max Rated hp is 150.
"Tony Thomas" wrote in message news:79n2c.60263$PR3.1063594@attbi_s03... Depends on the boat your using this on. The 125 is not a very good engine in my opinion. It has that jump from about 1500 rpms to 3000 rpms. It was designed for a bass boat or small runabout application where you would not be trying to run at very low speeds. Again, what boat and what is it rated for. You just found out why I always recommend the max hp for a boat. As for value of that engine. You are not going to be happy w/ the trade value. Probably about $3500 at best. Go w/ either Merc or Yamaha EFI. Depends on the dealer in your area as both are very good engines. Tony my boats at http://t.thomas.home.mchsi.com "JGK" wrote in message .. . I have a 1999 Merc 125, Have not really been happy about its performance or reliability. I would like to upgrade it to a 150HP but not sure if I should stick to Mercury. A few questions on this: 1. If you were upgrading to a 150 HP engine, which one would you look at? 2. What can I expect to get for the 1999 Merc 125 Thanks |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Is an upgrade worth the Cost"
"JGK" wrote in message . .. The boat is a 19ft Pro-line Center Console, Max Rated hp is 150. "Tony Thomas" wrote in message news:79n2c.60263$PR3.1063594@attbi_s03... Depends on the boat your using this on. The 125 is not a very good engine in my opinion. It has that jump from about 1500 rpms to 3000 rpms. It was designed for a bass boat or small runabout application where you would not be trying to run at very low speeds. Again, what boat and what is it rated for. You just found out why I always recommend the max hp for a boat. As for value of that engine. You are not going to be happy w/ the trade value. Probably about $3500 at best. Go w/ either Merc or Yamaha EFI. Depends on the dealer in your area as both are very good engines. Tony my boats at http://t.thomas.home.mchsi.com "JGK" wrote in message .. . I have a 1999 Merc 125, Have not really been happy about its performance or reliability. I would like to upgrade it to a 150HP but not sure if I should stick to Mercury. A few questions on this: 1. If you were upgrading to a 150 HP engine, which one would you look at? 2. What can I expect to get for the 1999 Merc 125 Thanks I think that the price on the 150 XR6 is about 7000. How much faster do you expect to go with a 150 over a 125? |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Is an upgrade worth the Cost"
Not about speed... more about dependability
"del cecchi" wrote in message ... "JGK" wrote in message . .. The boat is a 19ft Pro-line Center Console, Max Rated hp is 150. "Tony Thomas" wrote in message news:79n2c.60263$PR3.1063594@attbi_s03... Depends on the boat your using this on. The 125 is not a very good engine in my opinion. It has that jump from about 1500 rpms to 3000 rpms. It was designed for a bass boat or small runabout application where you would not be trying to run at very low speeds. Again, what boat and what is it rated for. You just found out why I always recommend the max hp for a boat. As for value of that engine. You are not going to be happy w/ the trade value. Probably about $3500 at best. Go w/ either Merc or Yamaha EFI. Depends on the dealer in your area as both are very good engines. Tony my boats at http://t.thomas.home.mchsi.com "JGK" wrote in message .. . I have a 1999 Merc 125, Have not really been happy about its performance or reliability. I would like to upgrade it to a 150HP but not sure if I should stick to Mercury. A few questions on this: 1. If you were upgrading to a 150 HP engine, which one would you look at? 2. What can I expect to get for the 1999 Merc 125 Thanks I think that the price on the 150 XR6 is about 7000. How much faster do you expect to go with a 150 over a 125? |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Is an upgrade worth the Cost"
The 150 uses a completely different design and powerhead. It will produce a
lot more torque and probably 10 mph top end speed difference. I would recommend you go for it in the long run if you like the boat and plan on keeping it. Now, not sure what you mean by dependability. The 125 should not be giving you and problems in terms of maintenance or down time. Please give details if you are having a problem. Should be solvable. Tony my boats at http://t.thomas.home.mchsi.com "JGK" wrote in message . .. Not about speed... more about dependability "del cecchi" wrote in message ... "JGK" wrote in message . .. The boat is a 19ft Pro-line Center Console, Max Rated hp is 150. "Tony Thomas" wrote in message news:79n2c.60263$PR3.1063594@attbi_s03... Depends on the boat your using this on. The 125 is not a very good engine in my opinion. It has that jump from about 1500 rpms to 3000 rpms. It was designed for a bass boat or small runabout application where you would not be trying to run at very low speeds. Again, what boat and what is it rated for. You just found out why I always recommend the max hp for a boat. As for value of that engine. You are not going to be happy w/ the trade value. Probably about $3500 at best. Go w/ either Merc or Yamaha EFI. Depends on the dealer in your area as both are very good engines. Tony my boats at http://t.thomas.home.mchsi.com "JGK" wrote in message .. . I have a 1999 Merc 125, Have not really been happy about its performance or reliability. I would like to upgrade it to a 150HP but not sure if I should stick to Mercury. A few questions on this: 1. If you were upgrading to a 150 HP engine, which one would you look at? 2. What can I expect to get for the 1999 Merc 125 Thanks I think that the price on the 150 XR6 is about 7000. How much faster do you expect to go with a 150 over a 125? |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Is an upgrade worth the Cost"
"Tony Thomas" wrote in message
news:d4w2c.491243$I06.5326755@attbi_s01... The 150 uses a completely different design and powerhead. It will produce a lot more torque and probably 10 mph top end speed difference. I would recommend you go for it in the long run if you like the boat and plan on keeping it. Now, not sure what you mean by dependability. The 125 should not be giving you and problems in terms of maintenance or down time. Please give details if you are having a problem. Should be solvable. Since I have had the boat, I bought it new in 1999, I have had to rebuild the carbs, the dealer claimed the gas gummed them up, The stator/rectifier went out, Tach did not work but Voltage gauge was still showing 13+ volts, impellors, last one only lasted 4 months. all work was done at a Merc factory Dealership. Not to mention the engine still runs rougher than I think it should and hesitates on take off. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Is an upgrade worth the Cost"
"JGK" wrote in message . .. "Tony Thomas" wrote in message news:d4w2c.491243$I06.5326755@attbi_s01... The 150 uses a completely different design and powerhead. It will produce a lot more torque and probably 10 mph top end speed difference. I would recommend you go for it in the long run if you like the boat and plan on keeping it. Now, not sure what you mean by dependability. The 125 should not be giving you and problems in terms of maintenance or down time. Please give details if you are having a problem. Should be solvable. Since I have had the boat, I bought it new in 1999, I have had to rebuild the carbs, the dealer claimed the gas gummed them up, The stator/rectifier went out, Tach did not work but Voltage gauge was still showing 13+ volts, impellors, last one only lasted 4 months. all work was done at a Merc factory Dealership. Not to mention the engine still runs rougher than I think it should and hesitates on take off. I've got the same motor (115 version). It is a 2+2, so if that bothers you, then by all means upgrade. It will be worth the few thousand to not be p.o.'d all the time. Carbs, impellers, stator, etc can happen to any motor. There is nothing unique about the 125. On the other hand, I wonder about that dealer. My motor is a 98, and I have not yet had gummed up carbs. The impeller is original. I keep asking the dealer and he says they last a long time in clean Minnesota water. Sounds like the dealer screwed up the impeller. About the carbs, how do you prepare for storage? Where do you live? del cecchi |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Is an upgrade worth the Cost"
No Storage...I live in South Florida and the boats sees the water at least
once a month year round.. The dealer told me it was bad gas and not under warranty. I think the longest it went just sitting was about 60 days. "del cecchi" wrote in message ... "JGK" wrote in message . .. "Tony Thomas" wrote in message news:d4w2c.491243$I06.5326755@attbi_s01... The 150 uses a completely different design and powerhead. It will produce a lot more torque and probably 10 mph top end speed difference. I would recommend you go for it in the long run if you like the boat and plan on keeping it. Now, not sure what you mean by dependability. The 125 should not be giving you and problems in terms of maintenance or down time. Please give details if you are having a problem. Should be solvable. Since I have had the boat, I bought it new in 1999, I have had to rebuild the carbs, the dealer claimed the gas gummed them up, The stator/rectifier went out, Tach did not work but Voltage gauge was still showing 13+ volts, impellors, last one only lasted 4 months. all work was done at a Merc factory Dealership. Not to mention the engine still runs rougher than I think it should and hesitates on take off. I've got the same motor (115 version). It is a 2+2, so if that bothers you, then by all means upgrade. It will be worth the few thousand to not be p.o.'d all the time. Carbs, impellers, stator, etc can happen to any motor. There is nothing unique about the 125. On the other hand, I wonder about that dealer. My motor is a 98, and I have not yet had gummed up carbs. The impeller is original. I keep asking the dealer and he says they last a long time in clean Minnesota water. Sounds like the dealer screwed up the impeller. About the carbs, how do you prepare for storage? Where do you live? del cecchi |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Is an upgrade worth the Cost"
"JGK" wrote in message .. . No Storage...I live in South Florida and the boats sees the water at least once a month year round.. The dealer told me it was bad gas and not under warranty. I think the longest it went just sitting was about 60 days. "del cecchi" wrote in message ... "JGK" wrote in message . .. "Tony Thomas" wrote in message news:d4w2c.491243$I06.5326755@attbi_s01... The 150 uses a completely different design and powerhead. It will produce a lot more torque and probably 10 mph top end speed difference. I would recommend you go for it in the long run if you like the boat and plan on keeping it. Now, not sure what you mean by dependability. The 125 should not be giving you and problems in terms of maintenance or down time. Please give details if you are having a problem. Should be solvable. Since I have had the boat, I bought it new in 1999, I have had to rebuild the carbs, the dealer claimed the gas gummed them up, The stator/rectifier went out, Tach did not work but Voltage gauge was still showing 13+ volts, impellors, last one only lasted 4 months. all work was done at a Merc factory Dealership. Not to mention the engine still runs rougher than I think it should and hesitates on take off. I've got the same motor (115 version). It is a 2+2, so if that bothers you, then by all means upgrade. It will be worth the few thousand to not be p.o.'d all the time. Carbs, impellers, stator, etc can happen to any motor. There is nothing unique about the 125. On the other hand, I wonder about that dealer. My motor is a 98, and I have not yet had gummed up carbs. The impeller is original. I keep asking the dealer and he says they last a long time in clean Minnesota water. Sounds like the dealer screwed up the impeller. About the carbs, how do you prepare for storage? Where do you live? del cecchi OK. I have heard that with today's "reformulated gasoline" that letting it sit for a month or two, especially in heat and high humidity, can cause problems. And it may be that salt water and maybe a little sand are hard on impellers. I'd at least consider another dealer. del cecchi |
Reply |
|
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
(OT ) The unseen cost of the war in Iraq | General | |||
Any boat repair will take longer and cost more than originally guessed! | General | |||
Lowest Cost GPS Tracking System on the Market | General | |||
Surveying a used boat -- Cost Effective? | General | |||
rebuild cost question | General |