(Bob) wrote in message
our charter as the auxiliary comes from congress. it would, literally,
take an act of congress to militarize the auxiliary. although the aux.
was armed during ww2, there is no plan to do so now and it's unclear
how it would be done.


Thank goodness for that. As a conservative, I'm concerned enough about
the spread of police-state powers in this country recently. The idea
of being involuntarily boarded or given "orders" by the USCGA is
absolutely repugnant, as is the idea of fingerprinting volunteers.
It's bad enough when the Power Squadron/USCGA types confront you at
every boat ramp and marina for permission to snoop around your boat.

I'm really out of step with today's conservatives. Real conservatives
want to strictly limit governmental powers. Many of today's
conservatives apparently are enjoying watching us evolve into a police
state.

It's bad enough when the Power Squadron/USCGA types confront you at
every boat ramp and marina for permission to snoop around your boat.
Ok, this has come up twice in this thread...I've been boating all my life
and have never been "confronted" by anyone from the USCGA or US/PS at any
time. I have, on occasion, been approached in a polite and neighborly manner
for boat safety checks. This is absolutley voluntary! In addition to
enhancing everyone's safety, vessels that are found to be properly equipped
get a decal that gives the regular Coasties notice that you're operating a
safe boat...thus decreasing your odds of an on the water stop & check.
Where. pray tell, is the problem in that?

James

On Sat, 17 Jan 2004 18:53:11 GMT, "James W. Sloan"
wrote:

It's bad enough when the Power Squadron/USCGA types confront you at
every boat ramp and marina for permission to snoop around your boat.

Ok, this has come up twice in this thread...I've been boating all my life
and have never been "confronted" by anyone from the USCGA or US/PS at any
time. I have, on occasion, been approached in a polite and neighborly manner
for boat safety checks. This is absolutley voluntary! In addition to
enhancing everyone's safety, vessels that are found to be properly equipped
get a decal that gives the regular Coasties notice that you're operating a
safe boat...thus decreasing your odds of an on the water stop & check.
Where. pray tell, is the problem in that?

James

excellent point. the CG aux doesn't 'snoop' around folk's boats.
thanks for the update...
---------------------------
to see who "wf3h" is, go to "qrz.com"
and enter 'wf3h' in the field

"James W. Sloan" wrote in message link.net...
It's bad enough when the Power Squadron/USCGA types confront you at
every boat ramp and marina for permission to snoop around your boat.
Ok, this has come up twice in this thread...I've been boating all my life
and have never been "confronted" by anyone from the USCGA or US/PS at any
time. I have, on occasion, been approached in a polite and neighborly manner
for boat safety checks. This is absolutley voluntary! In addition to
enhancing everyone's safety, vessels that are found to be properly equipped
get a decal that gives the regular Coasties notice that you're operating a
safe boat...thus decreasing your odds of an on the water stop & check.
Where. pray tell, is the problem in that?

James

I see it not much different than inviting the police into your house
so they can look through your rooms, closets and stuff. Besides the
sticker does not ensure you are operating a safe boat. All it states
is that you have certain minimal equipment on boatd. The operation of
a safe boat is entirely up to the vessel's captain.

No big deal. I just say no when approached. It is annoying when the
same guys ask every other weekend, though.

" I see it not much different than inviting the police into your house
so they can look through your rooms, closets and stuff.

Apples & Oranges Mad Dog. When my local Aux. folks check a boat, they hardly
even even get in the thing. They ask to see the jackets, flares, turn on the
nav lights, etc. All done while standing on the dock or alongside the
trailer. Perhaps your experiences differ.

Besides the
sticker does not ensure you are operating a safe boat. All it states
is that you have certain minimal equipment on boatd. The operation of
a safe boat is entirely up to the vessel's captain.

Agreed. It does, however, tend to reduce the stop & checks from the Coasties
and DNR.

No big deal. I just say no when approached. It is annoying when the
same guys ask every other weekend, though.

Say yes and get a sticker for the next years worth of ramp visits...its
really not painful at all.

Regards,

James Sloan
Saint Simons Island, GA

"Mad Dog Dave" wrote in message
om...
"James W. Sloan" wrote in message
link.net...
It's bad enough when the Power Squadron/USCGA types confront you at
every boat ramp and marina for permission to snoop around your boat.
Ok, this has come up twice in this thread...I've been boating all my
life
and have never been "confronted" by anyone from the USCGA or US/PS at
any
time. I have, on occasion, been approached in a polite and neighborly
manner
for boat safety checks. This is absolutley voluntary! In addition to
enhancing everyone's safety, vessels that are found to be properly
equipped
get a decal that gives the regular Coasties notice that you're operating
a
safe boat...thus decreasing your odds of an on the water stop & check.
Where. pray tell, is the problem in that?

James

I see it not much different than inviting the police into your house
so they can look through your rooms, closets and stuff. Besides the
sticker does not ensure you are operating a safe boat. All it states
is that you have certain minimal equipment on boatd. The operation of
a safe boat is entirely up to the vessel's captain.

No big deal. I just say no when approached. It is annoying when the
same guys ask every other weekend, though.

Where ARE these auxiliary guys, anyway? Send them to Irondequoit NY, please.
With breath analysis kits and 1911s equipped with silencers. I'll give them
$100 for every corpse that lands in the water.

Hey DoUg!

I prefer a 37mm myself. It leaves less corpse to deal with.



Capt. Frank

Doug Kanter wrote:

"Mad Dog Dave" wrote in message
om...

"James W. Sloan" wrote in message

link.net...

It's bad enough when the Power Squadron/USCGA types confront you at

every boat ramp and marina for permission to snoop around your boat.

Ok, this has come up twice in this thread...I've been boating all my

life

and have never been "confronted" by anyone from the USCGA or US/PS at

any

time. I have, on occasion, been approached in a polite and neighborly

manner

for boat safety checks. This is absolutley voluntary! In addition to
enhancing everyone's safety, vessels that are found to be properly

equipped

get a decal that gives the regular Coasties notice that you're operating

a

safe boat...thus decreasing your odds of an on the water stop & check.
Where. pray tell, is the problem in that?

James

I see it not much different than inviting the police into your house
so they can look through your rooms, closets and stuff. Besides the
sticker does not ensure you are operating a safe boat. All it states
is that you have certain minimal equipment on boatd. The operation of
a safe boat is entirely up to the vessel's captain.

No big deal. I just say no when approached. It is annoying when the
same guys ask every other weekend, though.


Where ARE these auxiliary guys, anyway? Send them to Irondequoit NY, please.
With breath analysis kits and 1911s equipped with silencers. I'll give them
$100 for every corpse that lands in the water.

One more time.....NO! I DON"T NEED NO %##@%% INSPECTION
1. USCG-A examiners NEVER report the findings of a courtesy inspection
to law enforcement.
2. Inspections are strictly voluntary. The captain is under no
obligation whatsoever to get his / her
vessel inspected.
3. Inspections save lives.
4. Some inspection results.
A. Mechanic had installed automotive carburetor, starter and fuel
pump on marine engine. Skipper declined to have the units replaced
with approved, marine grade units. Results: 2 weeks later, engine
caught fire, damaged boat, adjacent boat and dock. Insurance company
inspectors refused to pay on that basis.

B. Vessel inspected and life vests, flares and other safety equipment
found defective or grossly out of date. Battery cables found frayed and
worn. Battery out of date. 3 months later, boat lost power offshore of
Grand Bahama Island. A thunderstorm begin filling the boat with
rainwater and wave water. Swimmers sighted passing vessel, but flares
would not fire. 1 person drowned when life jacket straps tore off
overnight. Rescue was delayed due to lack of operational flares.
Passing private aircraft sighted Mae Wests in water and notified
Coast Guard.

Every captain worth his or her salt knows a safety inspection is one of
the few FREE help items available to the boating public. It is also one
of the most valuable. The examiner is not there to punish you, but, to
give a trained, certified examination as to the condition of your boat
and its safety equipment. What you do with that information is strictly
up to you. No report is ever given to any agency, government office, or
law enforcement official.

We "Coasties," noticing a lack of sticker, will ask politely if you
would like a safety inspection. Yes. But, we won't force you to save
your own hide by having one. We will always try to fish you out alive,
after your preventable disaster occurs too!

Capt. Frank
www.home.earthlink.net/~aartworks

Mad Dog Dave wrote:

"James W. Sloan" wrote in message link.net...

It's bad enough when the Power Squadron/USCGA types confront you at

every boat ramp and marina for permission to snoop around your boat.

Ok, this has come up twice in this thread...I've been boating all my life
and have never been "confronted" by anyone from the USCGA or US/PS at any
time. I have, on occasion, been approached in a polite and neighborly manner
for boat safety checks. This is absolutley voluntary! In addition to
enhancing everyone's safety, vessels that are found to be properly equipped
get a decal that gives the regular Coasties notice that you're operating a
safe boat...thus decreasing your odds of an on the water stop & check.
Where. pray tell, is the problem in that?

James


I see it not much different than inviting the police into your house
so they can look through your rooms, closets and stuff. Besides the
sticker does not ensure you are operating a safe boat. All it states
is that you have certain minimal equipment on boatd. The operation of
a safe boat is entirely up to the vessel's captain.

No big deal. I just say no when approached. It is annoying when the
same guys ask every other weekend, though.

"Capt. Frank Hopkins" wrote in message
ink.net...

Every captain worth his or her salt knows a safety inspection is one of
the few FREE help items available to the boating public.

Even for a captain like me who's anal retentive about safety equipment, a
second opinion can always be useful. Sometimes someone sees a better way of
mounting a fire extinguisher that makes it easier to reach, but less likely
to smack you in the shoulder as you walk by. This doesn't sound like an
Orwellian inspection to me.

It's bad enough when the Power Squadron/USCGA types confront you at
every boat ramp and marina for permission to snoop around your boat.
Ok, this has come up twice in this thread...I've been boating all my life
and have never been "confronted" by anyone from the USCGA or US/PS at any
time. I have, on occasion, been approached in a polite and neighborly manner
for boat safety checks. This is absolutley voluntary! In addition to
enhancing everyone's safety, vessels that are found to be properly equipped
get a decal that gives the regular Coasties notice that you're operating a
safe boat...thus decreasing your odds of an on the water stop & check.
Where. pray tell, is the problem in that?

James

James:

Exactly the definition of the purpose of the VSC program. Voluntary, and no
law enforcement reporting are involved. See the VSC manual, available at:
http://www.cgaux.org/cgauxweb/manual...al/vsc_man.pdf

For those not wanting to read the whole manual, here's the definition taken
right from the text:

"The mission of the Coast Guard Recreational Boating Safety (RBS) program is to
minimize the loss of life, personal injury, property damage and environmental
impact associated with the use of recreational boats, through preventive means,
in order to maximize safe use and enjoyment of U.S. waterways by the public.
The Vessel Safety Check program fully supports this mission.

The VSC program helps to achieve voluntary compliance with federal and state
recreational boating safety laws, particularly regarding the carriage of safety
equipment. It also raises boaters’ awareness of safety issues through
one-on-one contact by volunteer vessel examiners.

Using the information in this manual, vessel examiners will educate boaters
through direct, face-to-face boating-safety information exchanges. With this
knowledge, it is hoped that recreational boaters will become more involved in
maintaining and operating their boats in a safe manner, taking boating safety
courses to increase their knowledge and skills in boating, and promoting safe
boating to others.

The Vessel Safety Check is intended to serve as a “prevention through
education, outreach and volunteer compliance� activity and to help
recreational boaters gain a respect for the boating environment as a result of
the Vessel Safety Check encounter.

Vessel Safety Checks are generally performed on recreational boats under 65
feet. Vessel Safety Check requirements parallel federal and individual state
regulations regarding equipment and safety conditions of the vessel. A VSC is
not a law enforcement action. No official report is made to any law enforcement
authority. A Vessel Safety Check is performed only with the consent of the
owner or operator, who must be present at the time of the examination. A Vessel
Safety Check does not circumvent the right of any federal, state or local law
enforcement officer to verify the presence and condition of safety equipment."

In regard to the last paragraph above, the State of Michigan has passed
legislation recognizing the VSC program. If the vessel has a current VSC decal
it is no longer legal for a state LE officer to stop and board a vessel to
check for required safety equipment without cause, other than to ask the
operator to display the required number of PFDs. The State DNR and Michigan
Sheriffs will also, in the near future, offer the exact same VSCs through their
officers, who will be trained in the program initially by the Auxiliary. They
will then issue the same decal, instead of the myriad of county sheriff decals
and the DNR decal.

On the subject of the original post, in our district we've had no uprising
relating to the new security check requirements. No one at our last flotilla
meeting expressed any reluctance to comply with the mandate. If one wants
membership not operationally-related, the requirements only add fingerprinting
to what was asked at enrollment- namely, that the prospective member was a U.S.
citizen, over 17 years old, and had no felony convictions. I'd imagine that
the only way to check on the felony issue is to have fingerprints to verify
identity.

Semper Paratus.

Bud (9CR 10-05)