BoatBanter.com

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)
-   General (https://www.boatbanter.com/general/)
-   -   Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction Blocks Traffic (https://www.boatbanter.com/general/87726-cruise-ship-runs-aground-atlantic-icw-obstruction-blocks-traffic.html)

Wayne.B November 10th 07 02:37 AM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction Blocks Traffic
 
Old news to some perhaps but probably not everyone.

A 210 ft coastal cruise ship, the Spirit of Nantucket, struck a
previously unknown submerged object south of the Pungo Ferry Bridge
and began taking on water. The captain ran the ship aground to
prevent sinking. Passengers have been taken off and the leakage
stabilized. A salvage plan is in progress.

The Atlantic ICW south of Great Bridge, VA is now closed to all
commercial traffic, and recreational boats drawing more than 6 ft
until further notice. For them, the only way south is around Cape
Hatteras and the Outer Banks.

http://content.hamptonroads.com/stor...6626&ran=68933



HK November 10th 07 02:49 AM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction BlocksTraffic
 
Wayne.B wrote:
Old news to some perhaps but probably not everyone.

A 210 ft coastal cruise ship, the Spirit of Nantucket, struck a
previously unknown submerged object south of the Pungo Ferry Bridge
and began taking on water. The captain ran the ship aground to
prevent sinking. Passengers have been taken off and the leakage
stabilized. A salvage plan is in progress.

The Atlantic ICW south of Great Bridge, VA is now closed to all
commercial traffic, and recreational boats drawing more than 6 ft
until further notice. For them, the only way south is around Cape
Hatteras and the Outer Banks.

http://content.hamptonroads.com/stor...6626&ran=68933




Did they run into the transmission you dropped?

Wayne.B November 10th 07 03:03 AM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction Blocks Traffic
 
On Fri, 09 Nov 2007 21:49:02 -0500, HK wrote:

Wayne.B wrote:
Old news to some perhaps but probably not everyone.

A 210 ft coastal cruise ship, the Spirit of Nantucket, struck a
previously unknown submerged object south of the Pungo Ferry Bridge
and began taking on water. The captain ran the ship aground to
prevent sinking. Passengers have been taken off and the leakage
stabilized. A salvage plan is in progress.

The Atlantic ICW south of Great Bridge, VA is now closed to all
commercial traffic, and recreational boats drawing more than 6 ft
until further notice. For them, the only way south is around Cape
Hatteras and the Outer Banks.

http://content.hamptonroads.com/stor...6626&ran=68933




Did they run into the transmission you dropped?


I think I know where that one is. The real mystery is where this
obstruction came from. I guess it's possible that last week's storm
could have moved something around.

Short Wave Sportfishing November 10th 07 03:10 AM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction Blocks Traffic
 
On Fri, 09 Nov 2007 21:37:14 -0500, Wayne.B
wrote:

Old news to some perhaps but probably not everyone.

A 210 ft coastal cruise ship, the Spirit of Nantucket, struck a
previously unknown submerged object south of the Pungo Ferry Bridge
and began taking on water. The captain ran the ship aground to
prevent sinking. Passengers have been taken off and the leakage
stabilized. A salvage plan is in progress.

The Atlantic ICW south of Great Bridge, VA is now closed to all
commercial traffic, and recreational boats drawing more than 6 ft
until further notice. For them, the only way south is around Cape
Hatteras and the Outer Banks.

http://content.hamptonroads.com/stor...6626&ran=68933


Yipe - that sucks.

In this recently passed "water projects" bill, did they have any money
in it for dredging the waterway?

Wayne.B November 10th 07 03:51 AM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction Blocks Traffic
 
On Sat, 10 Nov 2007 03:10:50 GMT, Short Wave Sportfishing
wrote:

In this recently passed "water projects" bill, did they have any money
in it for dredging the waterway?


That would be nice but I haven't heard anything about it. The "thing"
that bit the cruise ship does not appear to have been shoaling
related. My guess is an old wreck that got pushed out of position
somehow, or possibly the cruise ship got wide of the channel in the
dark and moved something around when they hit it.

HK November 10th 07 04:24 AM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction BlocksTraffic
 
Wayne.B wrote:
On Fri, 09 Nov 2007 21:49:02 -0500, HK wrote:

Wayne.B wrote:
Old news to some perhaps but probably not everyone.

A 210 ft coastal cruise ship, the Spirit of Nantucket, struck a
previously unknown submerged object south of the Pungo Ferry Bridge
and began taking on water. The captain ran the ship aground to
prevent sinking. Passengers have been taken off and the leakage
stabilized. A salvage plan is in progress.

The Atlantic ICW south of Great Bridge, VA is now closed to all
commercial traffic, and recreational boats drawing more than 6 ft
until further notice. For them, the only way south is around Cape
Hatteras and the Outer Banks.

http://content.hamptonroads.com/stor...6626&ran=68933



Did they run into the transmission you dropped?


I think I know where that one is. The real mystery is where this
obstruction came from. I guess it's possible that last week's storm
could have moved something around.



Something big enough to put a hole in a steel ship?

Wayne.B November 10th 07 04:48 AM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction Blocks Traffic
 
On Fri, 09 Nov 2007 23:24:12 -0500, HK wrote:

I think I know where that one is. The real mystery is where this
obstruction came from. I guess it's possible that last week's storm
could have moved something around.



Something big enough to put a hole in a steel ship?


According to the news article they located the obstruction but have to
send down divers to identify it. It would have to be a wreck or a
rock in my opinion. There are a fair number of tree stumps and logs
in that area but I don't think that would be enough to gash the hull.

Don White November 10th 07 04:50 AM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction Blocks Traffic
 

"HK" wrote in message
. ..

Something big enough to put a hole in a steel ship?



Caught a news clip first of the week where a guy claimed that a hugh wave,
generated by Post Tropical Storm Noel, moved a 100 ton granite boulder
some distance at Peggys Cove.



Calif Bill November 10th 07 05:08 AM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction Blocks Traffic
 

"Wayne.B" wrote in message
...
On Sat, 10 Nov 2007 03:10:50 GMT, Short Wave Sportfishing
wrote:

In this recently passed "water projects" bill, did they have any money
in it for dredging the waterway?


That would be nice but I haven't heard anything about it. The "thing"
that bit the cruise ship does not appear to have been shoaling
related. My guess is an old wreck that got pushed out of position
somehow, or possibly the cruise ship got wide of the channel in the
dark and moved something around when they hit it.


Poop happens. We had a cargo ship hit the 2nd tower on the San Francisco
Bay bridge yesterday and it spilled 150K+ gallons of fuel oil. The quick
response teams did not respond and some harbors are closed by oil booms and
the coast is getting covered in oil.



Eisboch November 10th 07 07:59 AM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction Blocks Traffic
 

"Wayne.B" wrote in message
...
On Sat, 10 Nov 2007 03:10:50 GMT, Short Wave Sportfishing
wrote:

In this recently passed "water projects" bill, did they have any money
in it for dredging the waterway?


That would be nice but I haven't heard anything about it. The "thing"
that bit the cruise ship does not appear to have been shoaling
related. My guess is an old wreck that got pushed out of position
somehow, or possibly the cruise ship got wide of the channel in the
dark and moved something around when they hit it.



The initial report that I read indicated that the ship was taking on water
and the captain purposely grounded it so that it did not sink in the middle
of the ICW.

Eisboch



Wayne.B November 10th 07 11:10 AM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction Blocks Traffic
 
On Sat, 10 Nov 2007 02:59:20 -0500, "Eisboch"
wrote:

The initial report that I read indicated that the ship was taking on water
and the captain purposely grounded it so that it did not sink in the middle
of the ICW.


Yes, but that was after the initial damage which went unnoticed until
they started taking on water.

Short Wave Sportfishing November 10th 07 11:28 AM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction Blocks Traffic
 
On Sat, 10 Nov 2007 06:10:40 -0500, Wayne.B
wrote:

On Sat, 10 Nov 2007 02:59:20 -0500, "Eisboch"
wrote:

The initial report that I read indicated that the ship was taking on water
and the captain purposely grounded it so that it did not sink in the middle
of the ICW.


Yes, but that was after the initial damage which went unnoticed until
they started taking on water.


One of the more acceptable opinions about the Edmond Fitzgerald is
that the hatches were leaking and it wasn't noticed until the ship
started to list.

Seems to be a common theme in these types of accidents.

Reginald P. Smithers III November 10th 07 11:30 AM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction BlocksTraffic
 
Wayne.B wrote:
On Fri, 09 Nov 2007 21:49:02 -0500, HK wrote:

Wayne.B wrote:
Old news to some perhaps but probably not everyone.

A 210 ft coastal cruise ship, the Spirit of Nantucket, struck a
previously unknown submerged object south of the Pungo Ferry Bridge
and began taking on water. The captain ran the ship aground to
prevent sinking. Passengers have been taken off and the leakage
stabilized. A salvage plan is in progress.

The Atlantic ICW south of Great Bridge, VA is now closed to all
commercial traffic, and recreational boats drawing more than 6 ft
until further notice. For them, the only way south is around Cape
Hatteras and the Outer Banks.

http://content.hamptonroads.com/stor...6626&ran=68933



Did they run into the transmission you dropped?


I think I know where that one is. The real mystery is where this
obstruction came from. I guess it's possible that last week's storm
could have moved something around.


The winter storms in Lake Michigan and Lake Superior move some monster
boulders very long distances, but I would be surprised if last weeks
storm could have moved a large boulder in the ICW. You don't have
enough fetch to really generate really powerful waves in the ICW.

It will be interesting to see what they turn up. My guess is someone
unloaded a derelict boat.

Short Wave Sportfishing November 10th 07 11:58 AM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction Blocks Traffic
 
On Sat, 10 Nov 2007 06:30:09 -0500, "Reginald P. Smithers III"
wrote:

Wayne.B wrote:
On Fri, 09 Nov 2007 21:49:02 -0500, HK wrote:

Wayne.B wrote:
Old news to some perhaps but probably not everyone.

A 210 ft coastal cruise ship, the Spirit of Nantucket, struck a
previously unknown submerged object south of the Pungo Ferry Bridge
and began taking on water. The captain ran the ship aground to
prevent sinking. Passengers have been taken off and the leakage
stabilized. A salvage plan is in progress.

The Atlantic ICW south of Great Bridge, VA is now closed to all
commercial traffic, and recreational boats drawing more than 6 ft
until further notice. For them, the only way south is around Cape
Hatteras and the Outer Banks.

http://content.hamptonroads.com/stor...6626&ran=68933



Did they run into the transmission you dropped?


I think I know where that one is. The real mystery is where this
obstruction came from. I guess it's possible that last week's storm
could have moved something around.


The winter storms in Lake Michigan and Lake Superior move some monster
boulders very long distances, but I would be surprised if last weeks
storm could have moved a large boulder in the ICW. You don't have
enough fetch to really generate really powerful waves in the ICW.

It will be interesting to see what they turn up. My guess is someone
unloaded a derelict boat.


Three or four years ago, an oiler heading up to the Providence, RI
fuel depot in Narragansett Bay hit something right along the starbord
side of the navigation channel about 100 yards ESE to the T-wharf at
Prudence Island. A slightly below average low tide was at ebb.

Lo and behold, a wreck nobody knew was there. 130 foot long, partially
wooden hull and partial steel super structure.

Researchers can't seem to identify the ship other than to say that it
shows aspects of being a coal collier and is at least 80 years old -
possibly older.

So you never know. :)

HK November 10th 07 01:46 PM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction BlocksTraffic
 
Don White wrote:
"HK" wrote in message
. ..
Something big enough to put a hole in a steel ship?



Caught a news clip first of the week where a guy claimed that a hugh wave,
generated by Post Tropical Storm Noel, moved a 100 ton granite boulder
some distance at Peggys Cove.




That would be some wave...

Scotty November 10th 07 03:31 PM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction Blocks Traffic
 
I heard he was trying 'to wake' a small sailboat and ran too
close to the edge.

:0

"Wayne.B" wrote in message
...
Old news to some perhaps but probably not everyone.

A 210 ft coastal cruise ship, the Spirit of Nantucket,

struck a
previously unknown submerged object south of the Pungo

Ferry Bridge
and began taking on water. The captain ran the ship

aground to
prevent sinking. Passengers have been taken off and the

leakage
stabilized. A salvage plan is in progress.

The Atlantic ICW south of Great Bridge, VA is now closed

to all
commercial traffic, and recreational boats drawing more

than 6 ft
until further notice. For them, the only way south is

around Cape
Hatteras and the Outer Banks.


http://content.hamptonroads.com/stor...y=136626&ran=6
8933





Don White November 10th 07 03:33 PM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction Blocks Traffic
 

"HK" wrote in message
. ..
Don White wrote:
"HK" wrote in message
. ..
Something big enough to put a hole in a steel ship?



Caught a news clip first of the week where a guy claimed that a hugh
wave, generated by Post Tropical Storm Noel, moved a 100 ton granite
boulder
some distance at Peggys Cove.



That would be some wave...


I'll drive down before the weather turns for the worse and investigate.
It's always a beautiful place to visit..... unless you're one of the small
lake sailors here who are terrified by a 5 foot swell.



HK November 10th 07 03:36 PM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction BlocksTraffic
 
Don White wrote:
"HK" wrote in message
. ..
Don White wrote:
"HK" wrote in message
. ..
Something big enough to put a hole in a steel ship?

Caught a news clip first of the week where a guy claimed that a hugh
wave, generated by Post Tropical Storm Noel, moved a 100 ton granite
boulder
some distance at Peggys Cove.


That would be some wave...


I'll drive down before the weather turns for the worse and investigate.
It's always a beautiful place to visit..... unless you're one of the small
lake sailors here who are terrified by a 5 foot swell.



Bang your fist on that boulder and see if it is hollow!

Wayne.B November 10th 07 06:39 PM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction Blocks Traffic
 
On Sat, 10 Nov 2007 10:31:14 -0500, "Scotty" wrote:

I heard he was trying 'to wake' a small sailboat and ran too
close to the edge.



Do you really believe that people run around on the water deliberately
trying to wake sailboats?

http://tinyurl.com/6hp2x


Scotty November 10th 07 09:47 PM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction Blocks Traffic
 

"Wayne.B" wrote in message
...
On Sat, 10 Nov 2007 10:31:14 -0500, "Scotty"

wrote:

I heard he was trying 'to wake' a small sailboat and ran

too
close to the edge.



Do you really believe that people run around on the water

deliberately
trying to wake sailboats?



Some do, it's a fact. Ask the GC.


SBV



HK November 10th 07 09:51 PM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction BlocksTraffic
 
Scotty wrote:
"Wayne.B" wrote in message
...
On Sat, 10 Nov 2007 10:31:14 -0500, "Scotty"

wrote:
I heard he was trying 'to wake' a small sailboat and ran

too
close to the edge.


Do you really believe that people run around on the water

deliberately
trying to wake sailboats?



Some do, it's a fact. Ask the GC.


SBV




I've seen plenty of guys in floating RV-Condo boats coming down the ICW,
oblivious to their wakes. They didn't give a damn they were damaging
shell banks, or rocking the hell out of small boats along the way.
Justice arrived when some of them ran aground on a sandbar a little
south of where we lived near St. Augustine.

[email protected] November 10th 07 10:05 PM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction Blocks Traffic
 
On Sat, 10 Nov 07, HK wrote:
I've seen plenty of guys in floating RV-Condo boats coming down the ICW,
oblivious to their wakes.


Not sure the type you're referring to but the worst around here are
the 25'-35' space ship looking planing boats that run along half way
up on plane. They'd do everybody a favor if they either speed up or
slow down. Doesn't really matter which. Either way they'd leave a much
smaller wake. And yes, they're totally oblivious to what they're
doing.

Rick

HK November 11th 07 12:24 AM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction BlocksTraffic
 
lid wrote:
On Sat, 10 Nov 07, HK wrote:
I've seen plenty of guys in floating RV-Condo boats coming down the ICW,
oblivious to their wakes.


Not sure the type you're referring to but the worst around here are
the 25'-35' space ship looking planing boats that run along half way
up on plane. They'd do everybody a favor if they either speed up or
slow down. Doesn't really matter which. Either way they'd leave a much
smaller wake. And yes, they're totally oblivious to what they're
doing.

Rick



Those are some of the worst offenders.

Ernest Scribbler November 11th 07 01:00 AM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction Blocks Traffic
 
wrote
Not sure the type you're referring to but the worst around here are
the 25'-35' space ship looking planing boats that run along half way
up on plane. They'd do everybody a favor if they either speed up or
slow down. Doesn't really matter which. Either way they'd leave a much
smaller wake. And yes, they're totally oblivious to what they're doing.


That's exactly what I get here on my river. And I have to believe they're
oblivious, because it's disturbing to think that anyone would intentionally
drive a boat around like that.



Marc Heusser[_2_] November 11th 07 09:25 AM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction Blocks Traffic
 
In article ,
lid wrote:

Not sure the type you're referring to but the worst around here are
the 25'-35' space ship looking planing boats that run along half way
up on plane. They'd do everybody a favor if they either speed up or
slow down. Doesn't really matter which. Either way they'd leave a much
smaller wake. And yes, they're totally oblivious to what they're
doing.


I guess they would not even appreciate saving half the fuel.
Possibly related to boasting behaviour of our nearest relatives ;-)

Marc

--
remove bye and from mercial to get valid e-mail
http://www.heusser.com

Geoff Schultz November 11th 07 11:42 AM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction Blocks Traffic
 
HK wrote in
:

Scotty wrote:
"Wayne.B" wrote in message
...
On Sat, 10 Nov 2007 10:31:14 -0500, "Scotty"

wrote:
I heard he was trying 'to wake' a small sailboat and ran

too
close to the edge.


Do you really believe that people run around on the water

deliberately
trying to wake sailboats?



Some do, it's a fact. Ask the GC.


SBV




I've seen plenty of guys in floating RV-Condo boats coming down the

ICW,
oblivious to their wakes. They didn't give a damn they were damaging
shell banks, or rocking the hell out of small boats along the way.
Justice arrived when some of them ran aground on a sandbar a little
south of where we lived near St. Augustine.



I wrote a trip report (http://www.geoffschultz.org/Log_Page.php?id=980)
talking about a spot just S of St. Augustine where we watched a small
power boat go aground at full speed on a sand bar and then the couple
proceeded to beat the crap out of one another while calling each other
every name in the book. We called the marine patrol, but they never
showed up.

In that same report I lamented about travelling on the ICW on weekends.
I complained about:

Tons of boat traffic

Jet skies that use you as a slalom course

Boaters who don't know the rules

Boaters who know the rules and just don't care

A special case of the above is the Sports Fishing boats who have
important places to be and pass close by throwing up 4' wakes

Boaters who think that they're doing you a favor by going along at a
slow pace, but their speed is such that their stern is as deep in the
water as possible throwing up the maximum wake. I guess that falls under
#3.

Boats pulling skiers or people in tubes who fall right in front of you.

Too many people drinking and boating

-- Geoff
www.GeoffSchultz.org

Scotty November 11th 07 03:54 PM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction Blocks Traffic
 

"Geoff Schultz" wrote in
message .. .



Boaters who don't know the rules

Boaters who know the rules and just don't care

A special case of the above is the Sports Fishing boats

who have
important places to be and pass close by throwing up 4'

wakes


Acording to someone on this group, it's his God given right
to wake a smaller boat and you should just deal with it, or
get off ''his'' waters.

Not sure if he falls under #1 or # 2.



SBV



HK November 11th 07 04:06 PM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction BlocksTraffic
 
Scotty wrote:
"Geoff Schultz" wrote in
message .. .


Boaters who don't know the rules

Boaters who know the rules and just don't care

A special case of the above is the Sports Fishing boats

who have
important places to be and pass close by throwing up 4'

wakes


Acording to someone on this group, it's his God given right
to wake a smaller boat and you should just deal with it, or
get off ''his'' waters.

Not sure if he falls under #1 or # 2.



SBV




Well, you can always put torn-up nets in their path. There's nothing
like 100' of fishing net wrapped around the propshaft to slow down these
inboard behemoths!

Wayne.B November 11th 07 08:05 PM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction Blocks Traffic
 
On Sun, 11 Nov 2007 10:54:08 -0500, "Scotty" wrote:

Acording to someone on this group, it's his God given right
to wake a smaller boat and you should just deal with it, or
get off ''his'' waters.

Not sure if he falls under #1 or # 2.


============================

No whine before its time.

One man's ripple is another man's tsunami. "Waking a smaller boat"
implies an intentional malicious action, and I don't think much, if
any, of that goes on. I'd be the first to call someone to task if I
suspected it.

That said, wakes happen. Get over it, buy a bigger boat, or stay away
from where the big boys play.

Wayne.B November 11th 07 08:06 PM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction Blocks Traffic
 
On Sun, 11 Nov 2007 11:06:24 -0500, HK wrote:

Well, you can always put torn-up nets in their path. There's nothing
like 100' of fishing net wrapped around the propshaft to slow down these
inboard behemoths!


How do we slow the outboard behemoths?

Capt. JG November 11th 07 08:17 PM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction Blocks Traffic
 
"Wayne.B" wrote in message
...
On Sun, 11 Nov 2007 10:54:08 -0500, "Scotty" wrote:

Acording to someone on this group, it's his God given right
to wake a smaller boat and you should just deal with it, or
get off ''his'' waters.

Not sure if he falls under #1 or # 2.


============================

No whine before its time.

One man's ripple is another man's tsunami. "Waking a smaller boat"
implies an intentional malicious action, and I don't think much, if
any, of that goes on. I'd be the first to call someone to task if I
suspected it.

That said, wakes happen. Get over it, buy a bigger boat, or stay away
from where the big boys play.



Wayne... doesn't matter if it's intentional or not. You're responsible for
your wake. Having a bigger boat doesn't absolve you of your
responsibilities; it increases them.

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com




HK November 11th 07 08:28 PM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction BlocksTraffic
 
Wayne.B wrote:
On Sun, 11 Nov 2007 10:54:08 -0500, "Scotty" wrote:

Acording to someone on this group, it's his God given right
to wake a smaller boat and you should just deal with it, or
get off ''his'' waters.

Not sure if he falls under #1 or # 2.


============================

No whine before its time.

One man's ripple is another man's tsunami. "Waking a smaller boat"
implies an intentional malicious action, and I don't think much, if
any, of that goes on. I'd be the first to call someone to task if I
suspected it.

That said, wakes happen. Get over it, buy a bigger boat, or stay away
from where the big boys play.


HK November 11th 07 08:28 PM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction BlocksTraffic
 
Wayne.B wrote:
On Sun, 11 Nov 2007 10:54:08 -0500, "Scotty" wrote:

Acording to someone on this group, it's his God given right
to wake a smaller boat and you should just deal with it, or
get off ''his'' waters.

Not sure if he falls under #1 or # 2.


============================

No whine before its time.

One man's ripple is another man's tsunami. "Waking a smaller boat"
implies an intentional malicious action, and I don't think much, if
any, of that goes on. I'd be the first to call someone to task if I
suspected it.

That said, wakes happen. Get over it, buy a bigger boat, or stay away
from where the big boys play.




Geez...what an arrogant ass you are.

Eisboch November 11th 07 09:04 PM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction Blocks Traffic
 

"Wayne.B" wrote in message
...

One man's ripple is another man's tsunami. "Waking a smaller boat"
implies an intentional malicious action, and I don't think much, if
any, of that goes on. I'd be the first to call someone to task if I
suspected it.

That said, wakes happen. Get over it, buy a bigger boat, or stay away
from where the big boys play.


In my limited experience traveling the ICW I saw no "intentional" waking
of a slower or smaller vessel by the larger boats, with one exception. A
large sportsfish blew by us and others at full speed, ignoring all speed
zones. I heard on the radio that he was coming and to watch out. He was
caught further down the ICW about an hour later.

To be truthful, I saw more sailboat operators running on their engine,
ignoring the "rules of the road". Not all, but many refused to give way or
slow down a bit to allow safe, minimal wake passing by large power boats.
Most at least moved over a bit and waved us by, but more than a few simply
ignored the fact that we intended to overtake them, despite radio calls or
appropriate toots on the horn to signal intent.

I see more crazy powerboat operation in a single weekend at the entrance to
Scituate harbor during the summer than anything I witnessed on the ICW and
the biggest offenders are in smaller, outboard or I/O powered boats.

Eisboch



Don White November 11th 07 09:04 PM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction Blocks Traffic
 

"HK" wrote in message
...
Wayne.B wrote:
On Sun, 11 Nov 2007 10:54:08 -0500, "Scotty" wrote:

Acording to someone on this group, it's his God given right
to wake a smaller boat and you should just deal with it, or
get off ''his'' waters.

Not sure if he falls under #1 or # 2.


============================

No whine before its time.

One man's ripple is another man's tsunami. "Waking a smaller boat"
implies an intentional malicious action, and I don't think much, if
any, of that goes on. I'd be the first to call someone to task if I
suspected it.

That said, wakes happen. Get over it, buy a bigger boat, or stay away
from where the big boys play.




Geez...what an arrogant ass you are.


He's a 'professional boater'..don't ya know, heads & shoulders above the
common weekend recreational types.



Eisboch November 11th 07 09:12 PM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction Blocks Traffic
 

"HK" wrote in message
...
Wayne.B wrote:
On Sun, 11 Nov 2007 10:54:08 -0500, "Scotty" wrote:

Acording to someone on this group, it's his God given right
to wake a smaller boat and you should just deal with it, or
get off ''his'' waters.

Not sure if he falls under #1 or # 2.


============================

No whine before its time.

One man's ripple is another man's tsunami. "Waking a smaller boat"
implies an intentional malicious action, and I don't think much, if
any, of that goes on. I'd be the first to call someone to task if I
suspected it.

That said, wakes happen. Get over it, buy a bigger boat, or stay away
from where the big boys play.




Geez...what an arrogant ass you are.


Harry, there are some people on the ICW that you would have to drift by in
neutral to satisfy. Most of them are sailboaters and local fishermen in jon
boats sitting at anchor in the middle of the channel. On my trip, being the
first time, I had studied up on all the rules and courtesies expected on the
ICW. After a couple of days I realized that when others don't respect them
and give you a one-finger salute instead ..... wake 'em! :-)

Eisboch




HK November 11th 07 09:12 PM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction BlocksTraffic
 
Eisboch wrote:
"Wayne.B" wrote in message
...
One man's ripple is another man's tsunami. "Waking a smaller boat"
implies an intentional malicious action, and I don't think much, if
any, of that goes on. I'd be the first to call someone to task if I
suspected it.

That said, wakes happen. Get over it, buy a bigger boat, or stay away
from where the big boys play.


In my limited experience traveling the ICW I saw no "intentional" waking
of a slower or smaller vessel by the larger boats, with one exception. A
large sportsfish blew by us and others at full speed, ignoring all speed
zones. I heard on the radio that he was coming and to watch out. He was
caught further down the ICW about an hour later.

To be truthful, I saw more sailboat operators running on their engine,
ignoring the "rules of the road". Not all, but many refused to give way or
slow down a bit to allow safe, minimal wake passing by large power boats.
Most at least moved over a bit and waved us by, but more than a few simply
ignored the fact that we intended to overtake them, despite radio calls or
appropriate toots on the horn to signal intent.

I see more crazy powerboat operation in a single weekend at the entrance to
Scituate harbor during the summer than anything I witnessed on the ICW and
the biggest offenders are in smaller, outboard or I/O powered boats.

Eisboch



When you have powerboaters like Wayne B., who says,
"That said, wakes happen. Get over it, buy a bigger boat, or stay away
from where the big boys play," then you don't have to wonder whether
there are ill-mannered guys out there who don't give a damn about the
havoc their wakes cause."

I have seen plenty of powerboaters who do not give a tinker's dam about
their wakes. I've seen it in the ICW, and I see it out on Chesapeake
Bay, and I have seen it on the Patuxent River and its tributaries.

HK November 11th 07 09:17 PM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction BlocksTraffic
 
Eisboch wrote:
"HK" wrote in message
...
Wayne.B wrote:
On Sun, 11 Nov 2007 10:54:08 -0500, "Scotty" wrote:

Acording to someone on this group, it's his God given right
to wake a smaller boat and you should just deal with it, or
get off ''his'' waters.

Not sure if he falls under #1 or # 2.
============================

No whine before its time.

One man's ripple is another man's tsunami. "Waking a smaller boat"
implies an intentional malicious action, and I don't think much, if
any, of that goes on. I'd be the first to call someone to task if I
suspected it.

That said, wakes happen. Get over it, buy a bigger boat, or stay away
from where the big boys play.



Geez...what an arrogant ass you are.


Harry, there are some people on the ICW that you would have to drift by in
neutral to satisfy. Most of them are sailboaters and local fishermen in jon
boats sitting at anchor in the middle of the channel. On my trip, being the
first time, I had studied up on all the rules and courtesies expected on the
ICW. After a couple of days I realized that when others don't respect them
and give you a one-finger salute instead ..... wake 'em! :-)

Eisboch





We lived in a house along the ICW for a number of years, and I spent a
lot of time fishing along its banks and in its creeks. I saw - literally
- hundreds of guys in large boats tossing up huge wakes and totally
oblivious to where they were in time and space. I saw all manner of
small boats swamped by these wakes, and I've seen the watercops chase
after the slobs whose boats caused the damage.

But that's neither here nor there. What does stand out is Wayne's
arrogance.

BAR November 11th 07 09:33 PM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction BlocksTraffic
 
HK wrote:
Eisboch wrote:
"HK" wrote in message
...
Wayne.B wrote:
On Sun, 11 Nov 2007 10:54:08 -0500, "Scotty" wrote:

Acording to someone on this group, it's his God given right
to wake a smaller boat and you should just deal with it, or
get off ''his'' waters.

Not sure if he falls under #1 or # 2.
============================

No whine before its time.

One man's ripple is another man's tsunami. "Waking a smaller boat"
implies an intentional malicious action, and I don't think much, if
any, of that goes on. I'd be the first to call someone to task if I
suspected it.

That said, wakes happen. Get over it, buy a bigger boat, or stay away
from where the big boys play.


Geez...what an arrogant ass you are.


Harry, there are some people on the ICW that you would have to drift
by in neutral to satisfy. Most of them are sailboaters and local
fishermen in jon boats sitting at anchor in the middle of the
channel. On my trip, being the first time, I had studied up on all
the rules and courtesies expected on the ICW. After a couple of days
I realized that when others don't respect them and give you a
one-finger salute instead ..... wake 'em! :-)

Eisboch





We lived in a house along the ICW for a number of years, and I spent a
lot of time fishing along its banks and in its creeks. I saw - literally
- hundreds of guys in large boats tossing up huge wakes and totally
oblivious to where they were in time and space. I saw all manner of
small boats swamped by these wakes, and I've seen the watercops chase
after the slobs whose boats caused the damage.

But that's neither here nor there. What does stand out is Wayne's
arrogance.


Arrogance is in the eye of the beholder.


Short Wave Sportfishing November 11th 07 09:35 PM

Cruise Ship Runs Aground in Atlantic ICW - Obstruction Blocks Traffic
 
On Sun, 11 Nov 2007 15:06:58 -0500, Wayne.B
wrote:

On Sun, 11 Nov 2007 11:06:24 -0500, HK wrote:

Well, you can always put torn-up nets in their path. There's nothing
like 100' of fishing net wrapped around the propshaft to slow down these
inboard behemoths!


How do we slow the outboard behemoths?


You don't.

~~ snerk ~~


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 03:50 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com