Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
posted to rec.boats.cruising
|
|||
|
|||
Engine alarm oddity
About 10 minutes after departing from my first anchorage under power, there
was a shrieking sound like a slipping alternator belt or bad bearing from the engine area. I shut right down and investigated. Belt tension was proper, no sign of rubber powder or wear. Started the engine up and it was fine. About half an hour later, static like chirping noises began coming from the engine panel alarm speaker. These were intermittent and in a random pattern. The best explanation I could come up with was that something was trying intermittently to send an alarm signal to the panel but wasn't getting enough power through to light an alarm light or fully engage the buzzer. At the next anchorage, I rechecked the alternator belt tension and verified that it wasn't the coolant alarm by disconnecting that sender unit. I couldn't disconnect the oil pressure sender due to a corroded screw that will have to wait until I take the oil filter off. The prime suspect is the charging circuit. Battery voltage makes the alarm sound and the light go on. The voltage regulator in the alternator sends voltage through a diode to counteract this current. When they balance, the light and buzzer are off. If they don't balance, the lights and alarms go on. It seems therefore, that a slight imbalance occurring intermittently could cause the annoying chirps in the buzzer. This didn't re-occur during the remaining 7 days of the cruise but I'm curious if anyone has experience anything like this or if one of our battery and alternator experts can make anything of it. The big question is whether this is an early warning of something going south in the alternator or voltage regulator. -- Roger Long |
#2
posted to rec.boats.cruising
|
|||
|
|||
Engine alarm oddity
"Roger Long" wrote in
: This didn't re-occur during the remaining 7 days of the cruise but I'm curious if anyone has experience anything like this or if one of our battery and alternator experts can make anything of it. The big question is whether this is an early warning of something going south in the alternator or voltage regulator. We need a hand held ammeter you can buy at any auto parts place like NAPA. It reads -100-0-+100 amps. The meter runs off the magnetic field that surrounds a DC wire with current flowing through it proportional to the curren flow. It clamps over the wire to the batteries, for instance, but any wire will do, even if the clamps are too big. What I want you to do is to run the diesel about 1500 RPM while watching your voltmeter and this little ammeter (or your charging ammeter if the boat has one). Turn every 12V load in the place on and see what happens to the DC voltage with the alternator heavily loaded, and loading the belt hard driving it. Even a tight belt will slip under heavy load when its surface gets polished from the slippage they all go through. The alternator with the slipping belt will make that squealing noise when something heavy, like a load on an inverter, refridgeration or an intermittent short goes on the load. The other possibility we are checking for is ONE open alternator rectifier diode, reducing us from 6 phases to one if one is open. The belt will squeal like hell as the shorted diode locks the alternator until the diode guts melt open and reduce the load to near nothingness. If ONE diode is open, there are two indications. Instead of SIX power pulses per revolution, you get ONE, which will make the stereo and radios "whine" at a frequency dependent on RPM of the engine....alternator whine. The other indication is it can't hold its voltage on a charged battery UNDER LOAD on a CHARGED battery. Once the house battery charges, no matter what the load up to the capacity of the alternator, its output voltage should stay near float voltage when the regulator goes into voltage regulation at 14.2VDC, or there abouts. Heavily loaded, it'll drop to 13.9 or so due to internal resistances and the usual corroded connections. If ONE diode is open, the load simply overwhelms the poor charging current of one phase and battery voltage drops off sharply as if the engine weren't running at all. If you have a built-in ammeter, disregard my hand-held magnetic and use yours. Harbor Freight, the Chinese machine tool outlet stores, has a dandy LOAD tester for cheap: http://www.harborfreight.com/cpi/cta...emnumber=90636 It's a 100 amp nichrome resistor (nice electric heater) with a quite accurate, but simple, built-in voltmeter you watch while loading and unloading the running alternator. There are scales for alternator testing as well as uncharging battery testing at 0 and 100 amps. only $15! Everyone should have one! While you're there, buy a few of their $3 red DIGITAL multimeters! These multimeters test everything from transistors and diodes to amps/volts/resistance...very accurately. The meter leads that come with them are MORE EXPENSIVE than the whole multimeter/leads and all at Radio Shack. I buy them just to get the meter leads and give the meters away! |
#3
posted to rec.boats.cruising
|
|||
|
|||
Engine alarm oddity
On Sat, 23 Aug 2008 22:31:15 -0400, "Roger Long"
wrote: The big question is whether this is an early warning of something going south in the alternator or voltage regulator. An accurate voltmeter across your battery(s) is a good thing to have for many reasons but one of the most important is monitoring your alternator. With the engine runnning at cruising speed you should be seeing somewhere between 13.8 and 14.2 volts. Anything less than 13.5 you definitely are not getting full output and should get it checked. The problem you describe could also be a loose or corroded connection between the alarm panel and alternator. |
#4
posted to rec.boats.cruising
|
|||
|
|||
Engine alarm oddity
Thanks, I'll look into all that.
I have a volt meter on the panel and checked it frequently after this event. It held steady at 14.0 but electric loads on my boat are about as minimal as they get. No refridgeration or big screen TV. Half the interior lighting and the anchor light are LED. Question about belts. Mine is toothed (smooth pulleys). On airplanes, we would check for belt slippage by feeling the belt and pulleys and finding our fingers black from rubber dust. You mention belt polishing. My fingers came away from both the pulleys and belt absolutely clean. Is the formulation of the new belts different? (Remember, the FAA makes aircraft use 30 - 50 year old technology for everything). -- Roger Long |
#5
posted to rec.boats.cruising
|
|||
|
|||
Engine alarm oddity
On Sat, 23 Aug 2008 22:31:15 -0400, "Roger Long"
wrote: About 10 minutes after departing from my first anchorage under power, there was a shrieking sound like a slipping alternator belt or bad bearing from the engine area. I shut right down and investigated. Belt tension was proper, no sign of rubber powder or wear. Started the engine up and it was fine. Check the fixing of all pulleys to shafts. We lost (and fixed) the raw water cooling on last year's delivery from NI. In that case the pump pulley was only attached by grub screws which had loosened. Sounded like a bearing squeaking.. and then steam started coming out the blunt end. |
#6
posted to rec.boats.cruising
|
|||
|
|||
Engine alarm oddity
|
#7
posted to rec.boats.cruising
|
|||
|
|||
Engine alarm oddity
"Roger Long" wrote in
: Thanks, I'll look into all that. I have a volt meter on the panel and checked it frequently after this event. It held steady at 14.0 but electric loads on my boat are about as minimal as they get. No refridgeration or big screen TV. Half the interior lighting and the anchor light are LED. Question about belts. Mine is toothed (smooth pulleys). On airplanes, we would check for belt slippage by feeling the belt and pulleys and finding our fingers black from rubber dust. You mention belt polishing. My fingers came away from both the pulleys and belt absolutely clean. Is the formulation of the new belts different? (Remember, the FAA makes aircraft use 30 - 50 year old technology for everything). -- Roger Long Your hands came away from the belt clean? Has the engine been started since it was put on??....(c Belts grind their whole lives...planned obsolescence. Get one of the 100A load testers for $15. That will tell us. What may have happened is a rectifier diode shorted during operation, locking the now-shorted alternator making the belt squeal until the shorted diode burned itself open due to the massive current from its own coils and the now-shorted battery....for just a few seconds at most. After that it wouldn't short anything because it's an open. You hardly hear it in a car when it happens. |
#8
posted to rec.boats.cruising
|
|||
|
|||
Engine alarm oddity
"Larry" wrote
Your hands came away from the belt clean? Has the engine been started since it was put on??....(c Belts grind their whole lives...planned obsolescence. Get one of the 100A load testers for $15. That will tell us. I went down this morning and tightened the belt up a bit and did get my hands a little dirty. Nothing like I'm used to seeing though. I did notice that the alternator pulley is nearly mirror polished inside. The belt on my engine goes around the cast iron flywheel so no polishing there. This belt has about 80 hours on it. No strange radio sounds and the system seemed to charge perfectly over the next 8 days. Is it still possible I have a burned out diode? -- Roger Long |
#9
posted to rec.boats.cruising
|
|||
|
|||
Engine alarm oddity
|
#10
posted to rec.boats.cruising
|
|||
|
|||
Engine alarm oddity
On Sun, 24 Aug 2008 04:51:57 +0000, Larry wrote:
We need a hand held ammeter you can buy at any auto parts place like NAPA. It reads -100-0-+100 amps. The meter runs off the magnetic field that surrounds a DC wire with current flowing through it proportional to the curren flow. It clamps over the wire to the batteries, for instance, but any wire will do, even if the clamps are too big. I have heard of AC clamp on meters that form a transformer when in use. This doesn't seem to work with DC. Casady |
Reply |
|
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Engine Audible Alarm on Sea Ray 185 | General | |||
Mercruiser 6.2L Engine Alarm Problem - Part II (and conclusion) | General | |||
Mercruiser 6.2L engine alarm problem | General | |||
Engine Alarm - Should I worry? | General | |||
"Low Oil Alarm" | General |