On Thu, 08 Apr 2004 19:14:39 GMT, Jack Dale
wrote:

I have heard stories, uncorroborated, of keel-stepped masts carrying
away the coach roof during dismasting.

Me, too. But if the choice is a big hole in the roof or a big hole at
the waterline....G

There are probably well and poorly designed keel and deck stepped
masts. A good solid step and a well engineered compression post are
necessary on a deck-stepped mast.

Absolutely. This is key in anything, and from what I've seen of them,
I wouldn't sneer at a Pacific Seacraft for a second. I simply indicate
a slight personal preference that, if not met, would in no sense be a
deal breaker.

Of course, I always like stowing stuff in hammocks secured to the
keel-stepped mast, too...G

R.

On Thu, 08 Apr 2004 19:14:39 GMT, Jack Dale
wrote:

I have heard stories, uncorroborated, of keel-stepped masts carrying
away the coach roof during dismasting.

Me, too. But if the choice is a big hole in the roof or a big hole at
the waterline....G

There are probably well and poorly designed keel and deck stepped
masts. A good solid step and a well engineered compression post are
necessary on a deck-stepped mast.

Absolutely. This is key in anything, and from what I've seen of them,
I wouldn't sneer at a Pacific Seacraft for a second. I simply indicate
a slight personal preference that, if not met, would in no sense be a
deal breaker.

Of course, I always like stowing stuff in hammocks secured to the
keel-stepped mast, too...G

R.

On 8 Apr 2004 09:52:55 -0700, (Parallax) wrote:

I have heard ppl say they would only have a keel stepped mast on an
offshore boat. Why? A well built deck stepped mast is as strong as a
keel stepped one and easier to put up or down. If either loses a
stay, it is coming down in a hurry? I fail to see the reason for this
odd preference.

I used to be of the school that favored keel-stepped masts as be more
sound.

Some things that have changed my mind.

Pacific Seacraft builds very strong boats with deck-stepped masts, as
do some other builders.

I have heard stories, uncorroborated, of keel-stepped masts carrying
away the coach roof during dismasting.

There are probably well and poorly designed keel and deck stepped
masts. A good solid step and a well engineered compression post are
necessary on a deck-stepped mast.

Jack

__________________________________________________
Jack Dale
Swiftsure Sailing Academy
Director
ISPA and CYA Instructor
http://www.swiftsuresailing.com
Phone: 1 (877) 470-SAIL (toll free)
__________________________________________________

I think one of the 2002 issues of Wooden Boat Magazine had a design article
by Ted Brewer in which he gave some reasons for preferring keel stepped
masts. Don't recall what they were though.

"Parallax" wrote in message
om...
I have heard ppl say they would only have a keel stepped mast on an
offshore boat. Why? A well built deck stepped mast is as strong as a
keel stepped one and easier to put up or down. If either loses a
stay, it is coming down in a hurry? I fail to see the reason for this
odd preference.

I think one of the 2002 issues of Wooden Boat Magazine had a design article
by Ted Brewer in which he gave some reasons for preferring keel stepped
masts. Don't recall what they were though.

"Parallax" wrote in message
om...
I have heard ppl say they would only have a keel stepped mast on an
offshore boat. Why? A well built deck stepped mast is as strong as a
keel stepped one and easier to put up or down. If either loses a
stay, it is coming down in a hurry? I fail to see the reason for this
odd preference.