Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
posted to rec.boats
|
|||
|
|||
Ping: Wayne
I found a 36' Grand Banks Classic (1994) that has caught my interest
and might be worth going to check out. It has twin Cummins diesels rated at 210 hp each at 2600 rpm. I think these are the same engines that are used in the Dodge Ram pickups. They must be repowers because they only have 1,100 hours on them. (The GB we had before was a single screw, 120 hp Ford Leyman with almost 8,000 hours. I missed having twins on that boat.) Do you have any guess what the cruise speed would be on the Cummins powered twin? The listing shows no performance specs. I will call them obviously, but I'd like to have a rough idea before going to check it out. Other things I like is a newer, 8kw genset (ours had a old 4kw) plus it has three reverse cycle A/C/Heat systems, one for the forward berth, one for the main cabin and one for the aft cabin. The one we had before no heat or A/C. It's also fully equipped with newer RayMarine electronics, chartplotter, etc. Heads have been updated to electric. (ours had the original hand pump). I am going to give them a call later today. |
#2
posted to rec.boats
|
|||
|
|||
Ping: Wayne
On 6/25/13 5:29 AM, Eisboch wrote:
Do you have any guess what the cruise speed would be on the Cummins powered twin? 17 knots |
#3
posted to rec.boats
|
|||
|
|||
Ping: Wayne
On 6/25/2013 6:21 AM, F.O.A.D. wrote:
On 6/25/13 5:29 AM, Eisboch wrote: Do you have any guess what the cruise speed would be on the Cummins powered twin? 17 knots Sure Harry, If you want to destroy the engines in a hurry. Hull speed of between 8-9 kts. would be an appropriate cruise speed. Here's what an actual owners say http://gbbeacon.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?p=33257 |
#4
posted to rec.boats
|
|||
|
|||
Wayne
"F.O.A.D." wrote in message m... On 6/25/13 5:29 AM, Eisboch wrote: Do you have any guess what the cruise speed would be on the Cummins powered twin? 17 knots ------------------------------------------ My initial guess was 16 knots but I think that may be high due to the hull. I just don't know for sure. A Grand Banks is supposed to have a modified "V" hull (I think) however the one we had before was so underpowered I can't be sure how it would perform with the added horsepower and twin engines. The one I am looking at is also a bit heavier. |
#5
posted to rec.boats
|
|||
|
|||
Wayne
On 6/25/13 7:51 AM, Eisboch wrote:
"F.O.A.D." wrote in message m... On 6/25/13 5:29 AM, Eisboch wrote: Do you have any guess what the cruise speed would be on the Cummins powered twin? 17 knots ------------------------------------------ My initial guess was 16 knots but I think that may be high due to the hull. I just don't know for sure. A Grand Banks is supposed to have a modified "V" hull (I think) however the one we had before was so underpowered I can't be sure how it would perform with the added horsepower and twin engines. The one I am looking at is also a bit heavier. Actually, I overstated. That would be my guess as to WOT speed. I have some familiarity with a similarly sized semi-displacement trawler with two slightly larger diesels and she'll do about 20 knots, WOT, and about 17 cruise. I think 14-16 cruise, right about where you estimated. |
#6
posted to rec.boats
|
|||
|
|||
Wayne
"Hank©" wrote in message eb.com... On 6/25/2013 6:21 AM, F.O.A.D. wrote: On 6/25/13 5:29 AM, Eisboch wrote: Do you have any guess what the cruise speed would be on the Cummins powered twin? 17 knots Sure Harry, If you want to destroy the engines in a hurry. Hull speed of between 8-9 kts. would be an appropriate cruise speed. Here's what an actual owners say http://gbbeacon.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?p=33257 -------------------------------------------------- Ah, that's kinda what I thought. It's funny because the single, 120 hp Ford Leyman version we had cruised at 6-7 knots comfortably all day while sipping fuel. So, with twin 210 hp Cummins that improves by a couple of knots and that's about it. That's ok with me .... a trawler isn't supposed to be fast ... and I really like the idea of going back to twins again. |
#7
posted to rec.boats
|
|||
|
|||
Ping: Wayne
On Tue, 25 Jun 2013 05:29:58 -0400, "Eisboch" wrote:
Do you have any guess what the cruise speed would be on the Cummins powered twin? The listing shows no performance specs. I will call them obviously, but I'd like to have a rough idea before going to check it out. ============ That's a lot of power for a 36. If you run the engines hard it might get up on plane and do something in the mid-teens, albeit with a lot of commotion, and a fuel burn in the 15 to 20 gph range. The boat, fuel burn and engines will be a lot happier running at displacement speeds well under 10 kts. There are two big advantages to twins as you probably know: Maneuverability at slow speed; and "get home" redundancy. The redundancy is nice but for coastal cruising somewhat over rated. Offshore in the boondocks? Priceless. |
#8
posted to rec.boats
|
|||
|
|||
Wayne
"Wayne.B" wrote in message ... On Tue, 25 Jun 2013 05:29:58 -0400, "Eisboch" wrote: Do you have any guess what the cruise speed would be on the Cummins powered twin? The listing shows no performance specs. I will call them obviously, but I'd like to have a rough idea before going to check it out. ============ That's a lot of power for a 36. If you run the engines hard it might get up on plane and do something in the mid-teens, albeit with a lot of commotion, and a fuel burn in the 15 to 20 gph range. The boat, fuel burn and engines will be a lot happier running at displacement speeds well under 10 kts. There are two big advantages to twins as you probably know: Maneuverability at slow speed; and "get home" redundancy. The redundancy is nice but for coastal cruising somewhat over rated. Offshore in the boondocks? Priceless. ---------------------------------------------- Thanks. That's consistent with the reports of owners with that engine setup that Jim posted. I think that the GBs have a modified "V" hull but I don't think it's a true planning hull. Takes a lot of power and fuel to get them up on a plane. I remember going down the ICW in South Carolina on the Navigator. I was just putt-putting along at idle because we were coming up on a congested area with a bunch of people fishing in small boats in the middle of the channel. I had to weave my way through all the small boats, many of which were anchored in the middle of the channel. Some of them were glaring at me, a few giving me the finger. What the hell? They were fishing in the middle of the ICW and I was going as slow as my boat would go. The ICW took a sharp turn to the left just beyond where all the fishing boats were. All of a sudden I heard a horn, turned around to see who it was and a Grand Banks was coming up fast on our port side. He was on a plane and making time. I forget what size it was but he was moving. The guy in the GB tried to cut the corner too far over to the left of the channel to avoid the small boats. He ran aground. Guys in the fishing boats were laughing their asses off and cheering. That's the area where I had my first grounding also. After making the turn and leaving the congested area that I had slowly picked my way through, the ICW opened up a bit. was straight and no fishing boats. I got the Navigator back up on plane, relaxing a little bit after getting through the mess of boats. Then we came up on a what appeared to be a "fork in the road". There was a single small fishing boat right at the fork and he looked like he was either waving at us or giving me the finger. I was focusing on him as I started throttling back and didn't notice that my chart plotter indicated the ICW went off to the right. I kept going straight and didn't notice the channel marker. Fortunately I had backed down quite a bit and it was a soft grounding that I easily backed off of. Turns out the guy in the fishing boat was waving to point us in the right direction of the ICW. Felt a little foolish, but no damage done. |
#9
posted to rec.boats
|
|||
|
|||
Wayne
On Tue, 25 Jun 2013 09:19:27 -0400, "Eisboch" wrote:
"Wayne.B" wrote in message .. . On Tue, 25 Jun 2013 05:29:58 -0400, "Eisboch" wrote: Do you have any guess what the cruise speed would be on the Cummins powered twin? The listing shows no performance specs. I will call them obviously, but I'd like to have a rough idea before going to check it out. ============ That's a lot of power for a 36. If you run the engines hard it might get up on plane and do something in the mid-teens, albeit with a lot of commotion, and a fuel burn in the 15 to 20 gph range. The boat, fuel burn and engines will be a lot happier running at displacement speeds well under 10 kts. There are two big advantages to twins as you probably know: Maneuverability at slow speed; and "get home" redundancy. The redundancy is nice but for coastal cruising somewhat over rated. Offshore in the boondocks? Priceless. ---------------------------------------------- Thanks. That's consistent with the reports of owners with that engine setup that Jim posted. I think that the GBs have a modified "V" hull but I don't think it's a true planning hull. Takes a lot of power and fuel to get them up on a plane. I remember going down the ICW in South Carolina on the Navigator. I was just putt-putting along at idle because we were coming up on a congested area with a bunch of people fishing in small boats in the middle of the channel. I had to weave my way through all the small boats, many of which were anchored in the middle of the channel. Some of them were glaring at me, a few giving me the finger. What the hell? They were fishing in the middle of the ICW and I was going as slow as my boat would go. The ICW took a sharp turn to the left just beyond where all the fishing boats were. All of a sudden I heard a horn, turned around to see who it was and a Grand Banks was coming up fast on our port side. He was on a plane and making time. I forget what size it was but he was moving. The guy in the GB tried to cut the corner too far over to the left of the channel to avoid the small boats. He ran aground. Guys in the fishing boats were laughing their asses off and cheering. That's the area where I had my first grounding also. After making the turn and leaving the congested area that I had slowly picked my way through, the ICW opened up a bit. was straight and no fishing boats. I got the Navigator back up on plane, relaxing a little bit after getting through the mess of boats. Then we came up on a what appeared to be a "fork in the road". There was a single small fishing boat right at the fork and he looked like he was either waving at us or giving me the finger. I was focusing on him as I started throttling back and didn't notice that my chart plotter indicated the ICW went off to the right. I kept going straight and didn't notice the channel marker. Fortunately I had backed down quite a bit and it was a soft grounding that I easily backed off of. Turns out the guy in the fishing boat was waving to point us in the right direction of the ICW. Felt a little foolish, but no damage done. Hope you threw a bottle of Chivas 25 year-old to the fisherman. At least he tried. John (Gun Nut) H. -- Hope you're having a great day! |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
PING Wayne B | Cruising | |||
PING: Wayne | Cruising | |||
PING: Wayne | Electronics | |||
Ping: Wayne B..... | General |