Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
posted to rec.boats.cruising
|
|||
|
|||
Wilbur and Redcloud
Wilbur and Redcloud
As long-termers here know, I (well, we) had a wreck (not a sinking) which later involved an extraction courtesy of the USCG. Sure wish I'd had my camera, as apparently the MIA Sector doesn't do video. It was an adventure I'd like to have had a record of, and the FOIA aside, it seems impossible to get a record of the occasion from the USCG (I tried, with one of the reps there, for months). I don't recall Wilbur's persona being on the scene at the time, but that could be just because I'd published my post-mortem (well, that's extreme; post-event) analysis of how we'd gotten to that point, in my various mailing lists and the several forums I annoy, meeting a firestorm of response, of which Wilbur's might have gone unnoticed in the maelstrom. The response was, to be charitable, "mixed" - including the variety of what we've seen here about the Redcloud. Back to Wilbur, I don't recall his weighing in on my "I learned about Sailing from that" (a riff on the last page of Flying Magazine's examination of crashes), but there were plenty of others. We didn't have mechanical issues - they were pretty much human error issues - but my analysis was fairly close to Wilbur's in style. "How did we get to that position, and what might we have done differently?" was the nature of my post. Likewise, the responses were fairly similar (knives digging/character attacks aside) to what we've seen about Redcloud - lots of sympathy and charitable response, and lots of armchair quarterbacking, along with polite inquiries along the lines of "what happened?" While we did have several mechanical incidents (strong enough winds to shred a tightly furled genny, remove and take flight a wind generator and newly installed hailer horn, along with one leg entirely and one tab on the remaining leg of the windex, e.g.), none were voyage-threatening. The voyage ended on a rock, and the boat was stout enough to survive the experience and sail again... Yes, we made several avoidable errors. Most of the knife throwers laid it to inexperience or simple boneheadedness. There may have been some - or, even, a lot - of that. But, on reflection, long after I wrote that, the real culprit was fatigue. We'd been going at it, hammer and tongs, for months, and didn't take time for decompression before setting out. It caught up with us in the end. However, like Wilbur's latest blast postulated, there were many points along the way in which a different decision would have resulted in an entirely different outcome. It's very easy to armchair quarterback, and entirely unfair, as those who do/did so weren't on the boat to see what the realities were. However, analysis (without the character attacks) is entirely appropriate. It might save someone else from having the same experience, later. Woulda, coulda, shoulda, etc., but when it comes from the participant, it's more like, "Here's where we screwed up." So, for us, as we thoroughly decompress ashore, and prepare for an upcoming long voyage, we recognize that fatigue may join us, regardless of how well we're rested, due to the length of time out there. We learned about sailing from that, so to speak, and will be especially vigilant about both getting our rest, but more so, to doublecheck our decisions if we're tired. Fortunately, our routing won't have many opportunities for rocks :{)) until we get "there" (Maine)... You knew there was a point in this, right? It is that, character attack and tone aside, and without the benefit of participation from Joe, I agree with Wilbur on that one. The presentation could benefit from the "kinder, gentler" approach advocated by the political party Wilbur favors, but otherwise, it's probably pretty close. We didn't lose our boat - but we sure took a lot of flack when we talked about it :{)) However, once we got past the "don't you dare set sail within 25 miles of me, you danger-to-all-marine-traffic" set, there were constructive suggestions we've incorporated into our mindset. L8R Skip Morgan 461 #2 SV Flying Pig KI4MPC See our galleries at www.justpickone.org/skip/gallery ! Follow us at http://groups.yahoo.com/group/TheFlyingPigLog and/or http://groups.google.com/group/flyingpiglog "You are never given a wish without also being given the power to make it come true. You may have to work for it however." (and) "There is no such thing as a problem without a gift for you in its hands. You seek problems because you need their gifts." (Richard Bach, in The Reluctant Messiah) |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
I almost met Wilbur! | ASA | |||
Bobsprit and/or 'Commodore Joe Redcloud' FBI profile | ASA | |||
Captain Joe Redcloud, Binary Bill, Rusty Redcloud = creepy! | ASA | |||
Jim Cate visits RedCloud | ASA |