Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Polyester or Epoxy?
For more than twenty years, we did almost all the fiberglass work that
we did with one or the other kinds of polyester and then a little bit of vinylester. These were the industries lead materials. Epoxy was reserved for high temperature and polystrene foam assemblies largely because of cost. In that time I did experience several dozen mix failures (where the pot kicks too soon or does not harden correctly) and all mixing was done on a balance - no by guess and by gosh. Also, while working with polyester, we (my father and I ran the boat shop) had numerous bond failures in the work we had done. We also repaired a significant number of bond failures in other people's work - four that I remember were factory jobs. Two of those factory jobs were conversions to wheel steer that lost cable turning point anchors. Shortly before my father died in 1980, we started to change to epoxy. This was mostly driven by the little pumps that could be used measure the material for mixing. We soon discovered that, except for large builds where material was a big part of the overall cost, the epoxy jobs were at least no more expensive because of the lack of lost material. I have one mix failure (caused by a helper that did not understand the mix ratio was 1 pump stroke to 1 pump stroke), and have never been able to identify a bond failure in my own work. We now do all or clean up with white vinegar and reserve acetone and MEK for work outside. Matt Colie www.southpointechandler.com BruceM wrote: As one who has need for some poly glassing I have often thought there should be another news group for "ordinary" people. My whole boat is poly so why do some alterations in epoxy? BruceM "Terry Spragg" wrote in message ... Michael O'Dell wrote: In article , "Allan" wrote: Hi. I'll probably get some thoughts on this. I built a 20' Osprey Triple kayak using epoxy resin. Nice boat. Now I'm building an 18' Trident Power Cat ( johnsboatstuff.com ). He's recommending epoxy for structural work and polyester (either orthothalic or the other one, I can't remember right now, would have to look at my plans) for glassing up. Anyway it's the "better" polyester. I like the price of the polyester, but.................. Anybody have any thoughts on why I should go all epoxy or use the epoxy/polyester combo??? Thanks for any comments, thoughts. Amateur 2nd boat builder in the Great White Frozen North, Allan build in epoxy - period. polyester has no secondary bond strength and not a lot of primary bond strength. epoxy is not that much more expensive and could well save your boat. epoxy actually sticks to the glass where polyester does not; it merely hardens *around* the glass fibers. that's why a polyester laminate peels apart along the surface of the reinforcement when it goes into failure. -mo I guess that's why all my 30 year old poly boats just collapsed into piles of hairy dust in my backyard, eh? Zero strength, eh? How do you calculate the cost benefit from this supposed longer life for epoxy, given that the life span is still generally indeterminate for both types under reasonable stresses? I have heard of very few poly boats disintegrating in any remarkably shorter time than epoxy, even in contests involving rocks and stuff. Such extremeist statements suggest you must be a berserker stock market manipulator with interests and positions in the epoxy chemicals market bordering so extremely on the insane as to suggest you sell epoxy mainly to be able to continue to dispose of toxic chemicals added in small amounts to the resins, just like some shampoo vendors I suspected of doing just that until your arguement was so strongly stated and foolishly revealed ;-) Now, as far as skin irritation and developed allergies and consequent lifetime sensitivities and costs associated with respirators, deformed babies, etc, I would favour poly quite strongly for a hobby builder, especially a relatively inexperienced one, especially for a first build. Commercially, the evidence is overwhelming. I cannot imagine anyone smart enough to be able to afford the costs of epoxy being insensitive to those cost benefit analyses so evidently performed and adhered to by professional builders. You just try to get an informed professional to build in epoxy and then count the costs. -- Terry K - My email address is MY PROPERTY, and is protected by copyright legislation. Permission to reproduce it is specifically denied for mass mailing and unrequested solicitations. Spamspoof salad by spamchock TM - SofDevCo ® |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Epoxy or Poly for poly repairs? | Boat Building | |||
epoxy does so pass water | Boat Building | |||
Epoxy sales | Boat Building | |||
Polyester epoxy | Boat Building | |||
polyester - epoxy bonding | Boat Building |