Neal, could you please take a photo showing us the repair area of the boom. I
don't believe you EVER made a repair. Had you done so, you would never have
allowed a bend to remain.
I also don't believe you're dumb enough to repair a broken spar at the expense
of far greater weight when you could have easily replaced it with a proper one.

RB

And the best way to repair is to sleeve the area.

Kryptonite works fine. Just use a Phaser to make the weld.

RB

You can see the repair in the following photo:

http://captneal.homestead.com/files/Closehaul2.jpg

See the lighter line forward of the aft bale. That's
were the boom broke in two. The aft bale used
to be right there and the boom broke where it
was weakened by the (4) screws that held the bale
to the boom.

S.Simon - the one and only


"Bobsprit" wrote in message ...
Neal, could you please take a photo showing us the repair area of the boom. I
don't believe you EVER made a repair. Had you done so, you would never have
allowed a bend to remain.
I also don't believe you're dumb enough to repair a broken spar at the expense
of far greater weight when you could have easily replaced it with a proper one.

RB

It appears that the boom is bent at the forward bail, or just forward of that. How far
does the pipe extend? Are you now at risk of snapping the boom again?



"Simple Simon" wrote in message
...


You can see the repair in the following photo:

http://captneal.homestead.com/files/Closehaul2.jpg

See the lighter line forward of the aft bale. That's
were the boom broke in two. The aft bale used
to be right there and the boom broke where it
was weakened by the (4) screws that held the bale
to the boom.

S.Simon - the one and only


"Bobsprit" wrote in message
...
Neal, could you please take a photo showing us the repair area of the boom. I
don't believe you EVER made a repair. Had you done so, you would never have
allowed a bend to remain.
I also don't believe you're dumb enough to repair a broken spar at the expense
of far greater weight when you could have easily replaced it with a proper one.

RB

It appears that the boom is bent at the forward bail, or just forward of that.
How far
does the pipe extend? Are you now at risk of snapping the boom again?

That pic shows little more than the bend itself. There is no "repair."

RB

The pipes were about five feet long. So they are extending
about 2-1/2 feet on either side of the break. Not to worry,
it's been over 12 years since the repair and it's working
just fine. The boom always did bend when the sheet is
tightened down even before the repair. If I want to take
the bend out and make the boom really strong I can fit
a short strut in the middle near the break and fit a length
of rigging wire to each end of the boom underneath and
tighten the wire with a turnbuckle. I don't think this necessary,
however.

S.Simon - a Captain who's serious about sailing

"Jeff Morris" jeffmo@NoSpam-sv-lokiDOTcom wrote in message news
It appears that the boom is bent at the forward bail, or just forward of that. How far
does the pipe extend? Are you now at risk of snapping the boom again?



"Simple Simon" wrote in message
...


You can see the repair in the following photo:

http://captneal.homestead.com/files/Closehaul2.jpg

See the lighter line forward of the aft bale. That's
were the boom broke in two. The aft bale used
to be right there and the boom broke where it
was weakened by the (4) screws that held the bale
to the boom.

S.Simon - the one and only


"Bobsprit" wrote in message
...
Neal, could you please take a photo showing us the repair area of the boom. I
don't believe you EVER made a repair. Had you done so, you would never have
allowed a bend to remain.
I also don't believe you're dumb enough to repair a broken spar at the expense
of far greater weight when you could have easily replaced it with a proper one.

RB

"Bobsprit" wrote in message ...
It appears that the boom is bent at the forward bail, or just forward of that.
How far
does the pipe extend? Are you now at risk of snapping the boom again?

That pic shows little more than the bend itself. There is no "repair."


Bet me! I've got some of those little round magnets that come
in the bottom of a shower curtain that I could put on the aluminum
boom. If they stick it means there's iron inside.

Put up a hundred bucks and I'll go to the trouble of taking a
picture or two of the magnets on the aluminum boom.

Waiting to hear how you try to weasel out of this one. . .

S.Simon - Bobsprit's mentor

If I want to take
the bend out and make the boom really strong I can fit
a short strut in the middle near the break and fit a length

This is getting worse by the second. "Really strong?" I thought it was already
really strong...guess not.

RB

The boom always did bend when the sheet is
tightened down even before the repair.

Holy christ.

RB

Put up a hundred bucks and I'll go to the trouble of taking a
picture or two of the magnets on the aluminum boom.

Oh my. Like I said, there's no repair. You didn't repair it so would look like
a bent noodle, dopey.

RB