Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Downsides to a long trailer tongue?
Designing our trailer it looks like for our 22' boat we could have the tongue as litle as 2' from the bow -- or 24' total rig. But we'ld like to put the wheels (tandem) as far back as possible so less boat and less weight is hanging out past the wheels. This should help stability. SO, the longer the tongue, the furthur back we can put the wheels. ~ Storage of the trailer is no problem and though a longer rig makes tight manuvering harder I don't think we'll have any major prolems with that. So, any other problems with having a longer trailer tongue? |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Downsides to a long trailer tongue?
Gary, I'm not understanding the part about "the longer the tongue, the
furthur back we can put the wheels." To maintain the ~10% of the weight on the hitch rule, increasing the tongue length works the opposite way. In my case, my trailer has a short tongue; it's just a couple feet forward of the bow. I find it to be a pain in the arse because I can't back down the ramp far enough for the boat to float off the trailer. I have to give the boat a pretty good push to slide down the bunks. If the trailer had a longer tongue, the boat could float right off. "Gary Warner" wrote in message ... Designing our trailer it looks like for our 22' boat we could have the tongue as litle as 2' from the bow -- or 24' total rig. But we'ld like to put the wheels (tandem) as far back as possible so less boat and less weight is hanging out past the wheels. This should help stability. SO, the longer the tongue, the furthur back we can put the wheels. ~ Storage of the trailer is no problem and though a longer rig makes tight manuvering harder I don't think we'll have any major prolems with that. So, any other problems with having a longer trailer tongue? |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Downsides to a long trailer tongue?
Snafu wrote:
Gary, I'm not understanding the part about "the longer the tongue, the furthur back we can put the wheels." To maintain the ~10% of the weight on the hitch rule, increasing the tongue length works the opposite way. Absolutely the longer the tongue (drawbar?) the further "forward" the wheels will by to keep the balance right. K In my case, my trailer has a short tongue; it's just a couple feet forward of the bow. I find it to be a pain in the arse because I can't back down the ramp far enough for the boat to float off the trailer. I have to give the boat a pretty good push to slide down the bunks. If the trailer had a longer tongue, the boat could float right off. "Gary Warner" wrote in message ... Designing our trailer it looks like for our 22' boat we could have the tongue as litle as 2' from the bow -- or 24' total rig. But we'ld like to put the wheels (tandem) as far back as possible so less boat and less weight is hanging out past the wheels. This should help stability. SO, the longer the tongue, the furthur back we can put the wheels. ~ Storage of the trailer is no problem and though a longer rig makes tight manuvering harder I don't think we'll have any major prolems with that. So, any other problems with having a longer trailer tongue? |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Downsides to a long trailer tongue?
Snafu wrote:
Gary, I'm not understanding the part about "the longer the tongue, the furthur back we can put the wheels." To maintain the ~10% of the weight on the hitch rule, increasing the tongue length works the opposite way. Absolutely the longer the tongue (drawbar?) the further "forward" the wheels will by to keep the balance right. Say you have a rig, single axel, 24' long from back to tip of tongue. The center of gravity of boat + trailer is @ 8' from the back. So if the axel was at 8' the thing would essentially be balanced over the axel, no weight on the tongue. Then you move the wheels back until you get the desired 10% / 400# on the tongue. Say you have to move it 1' to do that. So now the axel is at 7' from the back. Now, you make the tongue longer. That tongue has more leverage to the piviting point (the axel). It would be easier to lift that tongue. It would have *less* weight when put on the ball. To get back to the 400# you would have to move the wheels *back* more. By tongue I do NOT mean the draw bar on the truck. I mean that the length of the "pole" hanging out the front of the trailer is extended and made longer. If I'm thinking of this wrong I'd love to hear it...but I think I'm right and more likely we just aren't picturing the same thing / using the same language. Thanks, Gary PS: Ours will actually be dual-axel and these numbers are just a guess at what our situation will be...I don't know the actual weights or centers-of-gravity yet. Our boat is 3800 to 4000 lbs and I think the trailer will be 1200 or so. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Downsides to a long trailer tongue?
On Sun, 7 Dec 2003 02:57:24 -0500, "Gary Warner"
wrote: Now, you make the tongue longer. That tongue has more leverage to the piviting point (the axel). It would be easier to lift that tongue. It would have *less* weight when put on the ball. To get back to the 400# you would have to move the wheels *back* more. ====================== Your analysis is correct. You could either move the axles back a little more, or bring the boat forward. I have a similar setup to yours: 24 ft boat, approx 5,000 lbs, tandem axle trailer about 28 ft long. Moving the boat forward 1 foot increases tongue weight by about 300 lbs. Once you get the axles about right, it's easier to adjust the boat position. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Downsides to a long trailer tongue?
"Wayne.B" wrote: Your analysis is correct. You could either move the axles back a little more, or bring the boat forward. I have a similar setup to yours: 24 ft boat, approx 5,000 lbs, tandem axle trailer about 28 ft long. Moving the boat forward 1 foot increases tongue weight by about 300 lbs. Once you get the axles about right, it's easier to adjust the boat position. Thanks. Note: In our case we don't want to move the boat forward. Reason is that it's a wood boat and there is a 50 gallon gas tank right at the back going across the boat. We want support right under the transom. So we want the transom directly over the end of the trailer where the risers will be. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Downsides to a long trailer tongue?
Gary Warner wrote:
Snafu wrote: Gary, I'm not understanding the part about "the longer the tongue, the furthur back we can put the wheels." To maintain the ~10% of the weight on the hitch rule, increasing the tongue length works the opposite way. Absolutely the longer the tongue (drawbar?) the further "forward" the wheels will by to keep the balance right. Say you have a rig, single axel, 24' long from back to tip of tongue. The center of gravity of boat + trailer is @ 8' from the back. So if the axel was at 8' the thing would essentially be balanced over the axel, no weight on the tongue. Then you move the wheels back until you get the desired 10% / 400# on the tongue. Say you have to move it 1' to do that. So now the axel is at 7' from the back. Now, you make the tongue longer. That tongue has more leverage to the piviting point (the axel). It would be easier to lift that tongue. It would have *less* weight when put on the ball. To get back to the 400# you would have to move the wheels *back* more. By tongue I do NOT mean the draw bar on the truck. I mean that the length of the "pole" hanging out the front of the trailer is extended and made longer. If I'm thinking of this wrong I'd love to hear it...but I think I'm right and more likely we just aren't picturing the same thing / using the same language. Thanks, Gary PS: Ours will actually be dual-axel and these numbers are just a guess at what our situation will be...I don't know the actual weights or centers-of-gravity yet. Our boat is 3800 to 4000 lbs and I think the trailer will be 1200 or so. Now you say it that way yes I now totally accept you're correct all along & my apologies. I screwed up. K |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Downsides to a long trailer tongue?
"K Smith" wrote: Now you say it that way yes I now totally accept you're correct all along & my apologies. I screwed up. K Thanks for the input, no appologies ever necessary if the intent is all good. |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Downsides to a long trailer tongue?
K Smith wrote in message ...
Snafu wrote: Gary, I'm not understanding the part about "the longer the tongue, the furthur back we can put the wheels." To maintain the ~10% of the weight on the hitch rule, increasing the tongue length works the opposite way. Absolutely the longer the tongue (drawbar?) the further "forward" the wheels will by to keep the balance right. K Once again, you've proven you stick your nose where it doesn't belong. You certainly don't understand simple physics. If you make the tongue longer, you will need to move the wheels BACK to keep the balance the same. Say you have the tongue 10' from the wheels, and the tongue weight is 100 pounds, to say, at that 10', you need to resist 100 pounds to lift the tongue. Now, we extend the tongue, to 15'. Now you have a longer lever, thereby LESS tongue weight. To compensate, you need to move the wheels BACK. |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Where to find ramp stories? | General | |||
trailer bearings | General | |||
Trailer Brakes: Electric vs Hydraulic-Surge | General | |||
Where to buy trailer axels ?? | General | |||
Correct Trailer set up for towing my speedboat. | General |