BoatBanter.com

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)
-   ASA (https://www.boatbanter.com/asa/)
-   -   GPS-an honest answer...? (https://www.boatbanter.com/asa/61702-gps-honest-answer.html)

Capt. Rob October 19th 05 05:15 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 
How many of you rely on your GPS without consulting charts these days?
How many of you back that up by using a handheld compass?
No judgements, and I'm sure some will get on a high horse after lying
about it. Just curious.

Robert B
Beneteau First 35s5
NY


Martin Baxter October 19th 05 05:33 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 
"Capt. Rob" wrote:

and I'm sure some will get on a high horse after lying
about it. Just curious.


New tactic Bubbles? Insult people before they reply?

I guess the bowels must be acting up again.

Cheers
Martin

Capt. Rob October 19th 05 05:54 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 
and I'm sure some will get on a high horse after lying
about it. Just curious.


New tactic Bubbles? Insult people before they reply?


Well, you know I must have been talking about Martin!

Hoooh ahhh!

RB


Bob Crantz October 19th 05 06:21 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 
My GPS has no mapping feature. I must use maps and charts to figure out
where I am from GPS UTC or Long/Lat.

I'm too cheap to buy on of those fancy GPS anyway.




"Capt. Rob" wrote in message
oups.com...
How many of you rely on your GPS without consulting charts these days?
How many of you back that up by using a handheld compass?
No judgements, and I'm sure some will get on a high horse after lying
about it. Just curious.

Robert B
Beneteau First 35s5
NY




Joe October 19th 05 06:43 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 
I use paper charts all the time, and a compass doing DR's. Then block
numbers.

Joe


Jonathan Ganz October 19th 05 06:51 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 
In article .com,
Capt. Rob wrote:
How many of you rely on your GPS without consulting charts these days?


If anyone does, they shouldn't admit it.

How many of you back that up by using a handheld compass?
No judgements, and I'm sure some will get on a high horse after lying
about it. Just curious.


--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com



~^ beancounter ~^ October 19th 05 07:37 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 
Jonathan...nice web url for bay area sailing....
hey, have you ever run into a david brodsky doing
sailing charters in the bay area? i am trying to look
him up..i am not sure how tight the sailing community
is, so i thought it worth asking...thanx....


Jonathan Ganz October 19th 05 07:55 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 
In article .com,
~^ beancounter ~^ wrote:
Jonathan...nice web url for bay area sailing....
hey, have you ever run into a david brodsky doing
sailing charters in the bay area? i am trying to look
him up..i am not sure how tight the sailing community
is, so i thought it worth asking...thanx....


Thanks

I don't know him, but I'm really not doing chartering through an
established company, so I'm not that well connected.





--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com



Joe October 19th 05 07:58 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 
You might update the putzsail section....it's a bit dated.

Joe


Jonathan Ganz October 19th 05 08:07 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 
In article .com,
Joe wrote:
You might update the putzsail section....it's a bit dated.

Joe


Yeah, I was thinking of removing it, but a couple of people thought it
was pretty funny.



--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com



~^ beancounter ~^ October 19th 05 08:32 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 
cool...thanx for the reply...enjoy the bay
sailing...i raced 505's a few times in the bay...

what a blast....@ 20 kts of wind...


Jonathan Ganz October 19th 05 08:47 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 
In article .com,
~^ beancounter ~^ wrote:
cool...thanx for the reply...enjoy the bay
sailing...i raced 505's a few times in the bay...

what a blast....@ 20 kts of wind...


Easily. We did a slightly late full moon sail on Monday
night. Usually, the wind calms down in the evening, and it started out
that way, with barely a breeze... definitely under 5 knots. We put up
the biggest sail on the boat (110%) and took the nearly permanant reef
out of the main (mostly, we just leave it in). We were just ghosting
along, keeping an eye out for tankers and such. Then, about 10 pm, the
wind really picked up. Switched to the smallest jib, reefed the main,
and got back to find 25+ kts near the dock. Docking was
fuuuun. Fortunately, the wind blows toward the dock (that's the good
news), but then we have to swing the boat around (it's difficult to
back down the narrow channel if there's more than 10 kts, as the wind
tends to drive you into the boats).



--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com



~^ beancounter ~^ October 19th 05 09:02 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 
sounds pretty good (and fun) from near
boulder colorado this afternoon......


John Cairns October 19th 05 09:57 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 

"Capt. Rob" wrote in message
oups.com...
How many of you rely on your GPS without consulting charts these days?
How many of you back that up by using a handheld compass?
No judgements, and I'm sure some will get on a high horse after lying
about it. Just curious.

Robert B
Beneteau First 35s5
NY


Odd question from someone who's never sailed out of sight of land.

John Cairns



DSK October 19th 05 10:02 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 
"Capt. Rob" wrote
How many of you rely on your GPS without consulting charts these days?
How many of you back that up by using a handheld compass?
No judgements, and I'm sure some will get on a high horse after lying
about it. Just curious.



John Cairns wrote:
Odd question from someone who's never sailed out of sight of land.


You mean, from someone who never sails out of sight of his slip?

I'm curious about the "handheld compass." Doesn't Booby realize that
many boats have larger, more accurate, installed compasses?

DSK


John Cairns October 19th 05 10:06 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 

"DSK" wrote in message
...
"Capt. Rob" wrote
How many of you rely on your GPS without consulting charts these days?
How many of you back that up by using a handheld compass?
No judgements, and I'm sure some will get on a high horse after lying
about it. Just curious.



John Cairns wrote:
Odd question from someone who's never sailed out of sight of land.


You mean, from someone who never sails out of sight of his slip?

I'm curious about the "handheld compass." Doesn't Booby realize that many
boats have larger, more accurate, installed compasses?

DSK


Thanks for pointing that out, Doug. Was so struck by the irony of the
initial question didn't even notice it.

John Cairns



Capt. Rob October 19th 05 10:40 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 
I'm curious about the "handheld compass." Doesn't Booby realize that
many boats have larger, more accurate, installed compasses?



Sorry, I thought that a sailor would have realized that a handheld
compass must be a heandheld BEARING COMPASS!!!! Guess not!!! Wait, let
me look up NON BEARING compasses in my sailing books....NOPE!!!

Bwahahahahahahahahaha! You farted in the elevator again, losers! Oh,
and I have the better boat!

RB


Scotty October 19th 05 11:04 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 

"Joe" wrote in message
oups.com...
I use paper charts all the time, and a compass doing DR's.


me too.

Then block
numbers.



What's that?

Scotty



Scotty October 19th 05 11:19 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 

OzOne wrote i

I'll ask again, what use is a hand held compass without a

chart?


It's for when he forgets where the marina outhouse is.

Scotty



Capt.Mooron October 19th 05 11:21 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 

OzOne wrote in message

I'll ask again, what use is a hand held compass without a chart?


You can use it to confirm the binnacle?

If it has a sight you can still provide a better fix?

It's always proper to have a spare?

Of what use is a chart without a compass or chronograph?

Makes a nice table cloth?

Provides identification to Aids to Navigation?

Anyway......


CM





CM




NotPony October 19th 05 11:22 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 
You're joking, right?
A commercial boat recently ran aground when their
electronics went out. They had no paper charts.
Both the captain and the owner were held
responsible.
You should ask if there is anyone foolish enough
not to carry a paper chart.
S.

"Capt. Rob" wrote in message
oups.com...
: How many of you rely on your GPS without
consulting charts these days?
: How many of you back that up by using a handheld
compass?
: No judgements, and I'm sure some will get on a
high horse after lying
: about it. Just curious.
:
: Robert B
: Beneteau First 35s5
: NY
:


Capt. Rob October 19th 05 11:25 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 
You're joking, right?
A commercial boat recently ran aground when their
electronics went out. They had no paper charts.


You're living outer space if you think even 75% of boaters are carrying
paper charts anymore, but I was referring to actual use of them. I love
Doug's comment about hand compasses, so obviously a hand bearing
compass and I hope he has one...but I doubt it.

RB


Scotty October 19th 05 11:25 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 

"Capt.Mooron" wrote in message
news:KFz5f.37686$S4.33085@edtnps84...


Of what use is a chart without a compass or chronograph?



Soundings.

SBV



Capt. Rob October 19th 05 11:26 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 
I'll ask again, what use is a hand held compass without a chart?


Ozzy, take a deep breath. Do you mean to suggest that ANY compass has
no use without a chart?


RB


Jonathan Ganz October 19th 05 11:26 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 
In article gGz5f.8240$Yk6.2098@trnddc01, NotPony wrote:
You're joking, right?
A commercial boat recently ran aground when their
electronics went out. They had no paper charts.
Both the captain and the owner were held
responsible.
You should ask if there is anyone foolish enough
not to carry a paper chart.
S.


Here's an even better one... when was the last time you updated your
charts with the local notice to mariners?


--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com



Capt.Mooron October 19th 05 11:27 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 

"Scotty" wrote in message
...

"Joe" wrote in message
oups.com...
I use paper charts all the time, and a compass doing DR's.


me too.

Then block
numbers.



What's that?


I believe that might mean fixes triangulated from differing sources/methods
like DR, Sextant, GPS, Radar etc.... plotted and their location "boxed" to
provide the best fix?A circle, square and triangle are often used to denote
type of fix.

Unless of course it's a reference to boxing a compass?

CM



Scotty October 19th 05 11:30 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 

"Capt.Mooron" wrote in message
news:uLz5f.37688$S4.5233@edtnps84...

"Scotty" wrote in message
...

"Joe" wrote in message
oups.com...
I use paper charts all the time, and a compass doing DR's.


me too.

Then block
numbers.



What's that?


I believe that might mean fixes triangulated from differing

sources/methods
like DR, Sextant, GPS, Radar etc.... plotted and their location

"boxed" to
provide the best fix?A circle, square and triangle are often

used to denote
type of fix.



Oh, yeah, that.

Scotty



Scotty October 19th 05 11:32 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 

"Jonathan Ganz" wrote
Here's an even better one... when was the last time you updated

your
charts with the local notice to mariners?



Bob updates his charts with McDonalds locations.

SV




Jonathan Ganz October 19th 05 11:37 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 
In article .com,
Capt. Rob wrote:
You're joking, right?
A commercial boat recently ran aground when their
electronics went out. They had no paper charts.

You're living outer space if you think even 75% of boaters are carrying
paper charts anymore, but I was referring to actual use of them. I love
Doug's comment about hand compasses, so obviously a hand bearing
compass and I hope he has one...but I doubt it.


It's just highly recommended for rec boaters. Electronics can fail. Of
course, it's highly recommended that people not be over weight and
watch their cholesterol levels, but I bet 75% of people don't do that
either.





--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com



DSK October 19th 05 11:45 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 
You're joking, right?
A commercial boat recently ran aground when their
electronics went out. They had no paper charts.


More and more common, I'm afraid.

Capt. Rob wrote:
You're living outer space if you think even 75% of boaters are carrying
paper charts anymore, but I was referring to actual use of them. I love
Doug's comment about hand compasses, so obviously a hand bearing
compass and I hope he has one...but I doubt it.


Nope. Haven't had one on the tugboat, don't need it.

OTOH we have quite a nice binnacle compass and I swung it earlier this year.

How many people swing their compass... how many know how to make up a
dev card?

How many sailors realize that a bearing can be taken with a binnacle
compass? Obviously not Bubbles.

Fresh Breezes- Doug King



Scotty October 19th 05 11:48 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 

OzOne wrote in Of
course, it's highly recommended that people not be over weight

and
watch their cholesterol levels, but I bet 75% of people don't

do that
either.


It's law here!



it's illegal to be fat in Oz?

Scotty



Joe October 19th 05 11:52 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 
Sheeeze you yankee clowns...

Block navigation in the Gulf is long practiced by coonasses who can not
read or write.

Block Charts document the location of oil and gas drilling locations in
the Gulf of Mexico. Each oil platform has a block number on a hailing
board on the side of the platform. You go up to the platform, read the
number and look at a block chart of the gulf. You know exactly where
you are. On most courses out into the gulf you can pass close enough to
an oil platform to read the block number. The Govt leases blocks to oil
companies for the right to drill.

Joe


Scotty October 19th 05 11:56 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 

"DSK" wrote

OTOH we have quite a nice binnacle compass and I swung it

earlier this year.

How many people swing their compass... how many know how to

make up a
dev card?


Know how to, haven't done it.


How many sailors realize that a bearing can be taken with a

binnacle
compass? Obviously not Bubbles.



I very seldom need my GPS, usually at night. Mostly use
piloting and a waterproof chart in the cockpit.

Scotty



Jeff October 19th 05 11:57 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 
Capt. Rob wrote:
How many of you rely on your GPS without consulting charts these days?
How many of you back that up by using a handheld compass?
No judgements, and I'm sure some will get on a high horse after lying
about it. Just curious.


My GPS is a very early handheld mapping unit (GPSMap 175) which
provides limited charting info, assuming I have the chart chip. I
always have a paper chart on deck and consider that my primary tool.

I'm thinking about getting the new small Garmin that has NEXRAD
updates and can also be used in a car, but the screen is still pretty
small so I doubt it will replace paper charts. BTW, my boat is wired
for computer charting, and I have software and charts, but I never
felt comfortable relying on it. A close friend, who is a
traditionalist in many other ways, has his autopilot driven by the
computer.

I hardly ever use a handbearing compass nowadays, but I used to use it
a lot before GPS. I do use soundings frequently to double check
positions. Also, when I travel outside of home waters, I often have
dividers and sometimes parallel rules on deck.

As for Notice to Mariners, I subscribe to the local edition and read
it weekly, though I don't update charts.

Scotty October 19th 05 11:59 PM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 
Well, geeze Joe, how or why would WE know that?

Scotty


"Joe" wrote in message
oups.com...
Sheeeze you yankee clowns...

Block navigation in the Gulf is long practiced by coonasses who

can not
read or write.

Block Charts document the location of oil and gas drilling

locations in
the Gulf of Mexico. Each oil platform has a block number on a

hailing
board on the side of the platform. You go up to the platform,

read the
number and look at a block chart of the gulf. You know exactly

where
you are. On most courses out into the gulf you can pass close

enough to
an oil platform to read the block number. The Govt leases

blocks to oil
companies for the right to drill.

Joe




Jonathan Ganz October 20th 05 12:01 AM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 
In article , Jeff wrote:
Capt. Rob wrote:
How many of you rely on your GPS without consulting charts these days?
How many of you back that up by using a handheld compass?
No judgements, and I'm sure some will get on a high horse after lying
about it. Just curious.


My GPS is a very early handheld mapping unit (GPSMap 175) which
provides limited charting info, assuming I have the chart chip. I
always have a paper chart on deck and consider that my primary tool.

I'm thinking about getting the new small Garmin that has NEXRAD
updates and can also be used in a car, but the screen is still pretty
small so I doubt it will replace paper charts. BTW, my boat is wired
for computer charting, and I have software and charts, but I never
felt comfortable relying on it. A close friend, who is a
traditionalist in many other ways, has his autopilot driven by the
computer.

I hardly ever use a handbearing compass nowadays, but I used to use it
a lot before GPS. I do use soundings frequently to double check
positions. Also, when I travel outside of home waters, I often have
dividers and sometimes parallel rules on deck.

As for Notice to Mariners, I subscribe to the local edition and read
it weekly, though I don't update charts.


Do you get your via their email service? It's nice... I just print the
sections that apply to where I'm going, then I update the paper chart
in pencil the night before. When something changes, I make the change
or erase the notation as necessary.


--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com



Capt. Rob October 20th 05 01:19 AM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 
How many sailors realize that a bearing can be taken with a binnacle
compass? Obviously not Bubbles.


And suppose your binacle fails or is broken?

I guess you'll just pick up the cell phone!

RB


Capt. Rob October 20th 05 01:20 AM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 
I very seldom need my GPS, usually at night. Mostly use
piloting

Uh, yeah. If you use a GPS it's not piloting!!!

Bwahahahahahaha!

RB


Capt. Rob October 20th 05 01:22 AM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 
My GPS is a very early handheld mapping unit (GPSMap 175)


Jeff, have a look at the new Garmin GPS 192c. It comes fully loaded
with all US Charts. I ordered one for the 35s5. It's quite a good value
and has a great screen.

RB


John Cairns October 20th 05 01:23 AM

GPS-an honest answer...?
 

"Captain Joe Redcloud" wrote in message
...
You had better have a charting GPS on board when your chart gets blown
overboard
in that squall! Anyone who relies on just paper charts is a fool. And god
forbid
somebody falls with the winch handle in thier hand and smashes the
compass!


Captain Joe Redcloud


Bwahahhahahaahhahahhahhahaahhahahhaahhahahaha

John Cairns




All times are GMT +1. The time now is 11:35 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com