BoatBanter.com

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)
-   ASA (https://www.boatbanter.com/asa/)
-   -   What If # 6 (https://www.boatbanter.com/asa/20039-what-if-6-a.html)

Scott Vernon June 27th 04 04:02 AM

*** I R O N Y ***
 
Very ironic.


"Scott Vernon" wrote in message
...
Isn't it ironic? At the very same time boob**** posted this juvenile,
jealous ridden post, I was out sailing.

Scotty


"Bobsprit" wrote in message
...


You'd win that bet. Scotty Potty does not sail.

RB




Bart Senior June 27th 04 06:15 AM

***S A D I R O N Y ***
 
More and more time aboard--at the dock?

Bob,

You have never been past Execution Rock! That's only
2.5 miles from you! You know what and where that is
don't you? In the old days, that's where the Conservatives
tied up the worst Liberals at low tide and left the bodies
for the sharks and the fishes! I think it was you that told
me Hillary Clinton's, and Michael Moore's names are
painted out there? Anyway, a quick trip like that will help
you get used to being away from shore power!

Captain Harbor, off Greenwich, is 15 miles from you,
that's less than 1.5 hours, if you time it with a current lift,
or you could try Sheffield or Chimon Islands, 25 miles.
Both spots are beautiful, and of course, in Connecticut,
the hunting season on Liberals is only one day a year,
July 4th. So your safe except then--hug the Long Island
side of the sound on that day.

Once you feel comfortable getting farther from land you
can work your way up to me. I'm only 40 miles from you.
I bet you could get up here in 5 hours with favorable wind
and current. You would probably motor back instead of
beating to weather for 12 hours. I can get you dock space
overnight at both my clubs. I'll take you out for a spin on
HOOT if you promise not to talk about your intern days
with Bill Clinton.

Bart

Bobsprit wrote
Isn't Scotty Potty sad? At the time he posted the item below I was sitting

at
my nav station drinking ice water having spent two days aboard. We're

spending
more and more time aboard and sailing, while Scotty Potty tries to squeeze

in a
daysail here and there!


Scotty Potty wrote:
Isn't it ironic? At the very same time boob**** posted this juvenile,
jealous ridden post, I was out sailing.


RB




Capt. Mooron June 27th 04 01:07 PM

***S A D I R O N Y ***
 
Bwahahahahahahaaa.... SLAM! ;-)

CM

"Bart Senior" wrote in message
et...
| More and more time aboard--at the dock?
|
| Bob,
|
| You have never been past Execution Rock! That's only
| 2.5 miles from you! You know what and where that is
| don't you? In the old days, that's where the Conservatives
| tied up the worst Liberals at low tide and left the bodies
| for the sharks and the fishes! I think it was you that told
| me Hillary Clinton's, and Michael Moore's names are
| painted out there? Anyway, a quick trip like that will help
| you get used to being away from shore power!
|
| Captain Harbor, off Greenwich, is 15 miles from you,
| that's less than 1.5 hours, if you time it with a current lift,
| or you could try Sheffield or Chimon Islands, 25 miles.
| Both spots are beautiful, and of course, in Connecticut,
| the hunting season on Liberals is only one day a year,
| July 4th. So your safe except then--hug the Long Island
| side of the sound on that day.
|
| Once you feel comfortable getting farther from land you
| can work your way up to me. I'm only 40 miles from you.
| I bet you could get up here in 5 hours with favorable wind
| and current. You would probably motor back instead of
| beating to weather for 12 hours. I can get you dock space
| overnight at both my clubs. I'll take you out for a spin on
| HOOT if you promise not to talk about your intern days
| with Bill Clinton.
|
| Bart
|
| Bobsprit wrote
| Isn't Scotty Potty sad? At the time he posted the item below I was
sitting
| at
| my nav station drinking ice water having spent two days aboard. We're
| spending
| more and more time aboard and sailing, while Scotty Potty tries to
squeeze
| in a
| daysail here and there!
|
|
| Scotty Potty wrote:
| Isn't it ironic? At the very same time boob**** posted this juvenile,
| jealous ridden post, I was out sailing.
|
|
| RB
|
|



Bobsprit June 27th 04 02:21 PM

***S A D I R O N Y ***
 
Bob,

You have never been past Execution Rock! That's only
2.5 miles from you!

Bart, stop being silly. I posted pics from the Thimble Islands, NY Harbor and
Jersey Shore.

RB

Bobsprit June 27th 04 02:23 PM

***S A D I R O N Y ***
 
I can get you dock space
overnight at both my clubs. I'll take you out for a spin on
HOOT if you promise not to talk about your intern days
with Bill Clinton.


Actually, Bart...Suzanne is working next weekend and I may grab some of the
girls and bring the boat your way. We'll see how the weather shakes loose. This
past friday was terrible, stunting our plans again.

RB

Jim Cate June 27th 04 06:19 PM

What If # 6
 


Scott Vernon wrote:
"Jim Cate" wrote


"...You've badly grounded your boat. You just left for
a 4 week cruise and now her wing keel has settled atop a group of rocks
at high tide, WHICH YOU THOUOGHT YOU'D BE CLEAR OF. At the top of every
swell, the keel grinds and as the tide slacks (soon!) you know things
could get worse.. . ."

Obviously the guy wouldn't conclude he had anchored the boat
successfully if the boat was grinding against the bottom. Obviously the
water level, or the swing,or the chop, etc., changed after the anchoring
process, resulting in the unexpected grounding.



Anchor? What anchor? Was anchoring mentioned in the question. Jimbo,
remember what your 10th grade teacher would tell you when he gave you a
test? - Remember to READ THE QUESTION first .

Scotty


How did the boat SETTLE down on a group of rocks? Whether or not the
boat was anchored (and if the boat SETTLED on a group of rocks and was
then grounded, he was probably either anchored or drifting around), the
Mac would provide several advantages for getting out of the situation.

In any case, here are a few of the Mac's advantages in such a situation.
A. The dagger board can be lifted and it can be motored away from the
rocks in only 2 feet of water. If there is still a few feet of
displacement, the boat can still sail. B. Because it isn't fixed in an
extended position, the dagger board automatically rises in its trunk or
housing if the boat settles down on the bottom. - It's free to move
upwardly within its housing, minimizing the probability of serious
damage before the skipper can get away from the area. C. The boat is
sufficiently light that even if the board merely brushes against the
bottom, contact by the board with the bottom would result in an audible
sound within the cabin, giving advance warning of the problem and
providing more time for evasive action. In a heavy fixed keel boat,
being more insulated and with a keel that usually doesn't project
upwardly within the boat, the "grinding" noise would be insulated and
muffled and would not be heard as quickly (wouldn't be noticeable until
it became severe, too late for easy maneuvering). D. The Mac, with it's
shallow draft, can be anchored conveniently in shallow waters with
relatively little anchor line, if it were desired to steady the boat in
a current or winch it away from the rocks. By contrast, a displacement
boat with fixed keel would require far more anchor rode, assuming a 7-10
scope, and is not conveniently anchored in such emergency circumstances.
E. With its shallow draft and its relatively light displacement, in
an emergency, in some conditions in relatively shallow water, a crew
member can jump into the water and help move the boat in the desired
direction. If near a sandy shore, the boat can be beached. F. In deeper
water, because of the 50 hp motor, on a relatively lightweight boat,
there is adequate power relative to the weight of the boat to provide
considerable maneuvering capability for getting through chop and into
deeper water.

The point isn't that all of the above solutions would be practicable in
every circumstance; the point is that there are a number of
possibilities with the Mac that wouldn't be available with a heavy
displacement boat that was foundering on the bottom. (Once more, NOT
ALL THE ABOVE would be feasible in every circumstance. - The most
probable solution would be to raise the board a foot or so and motor away.)

Jim


Jim Cate June 27th 04 06:21 PM

What If # 6
 


Scott Vernon wrote:

"Jim Cate" wrote in message
...

Scott, don't forget that the dagger board on the mac isn't fixed, or
tied down. Actually, the only thing holding it down is gravity. What
this means in the context of Question #6 is that if the board hit the
bottom as the boat fell down off a wave or during a falling tide, the
boat would merely slide downwardly on the dagger board, or, the dagger
board would be pushed upwardly relative to the dagger board trunk.



That is true. But, if you 'run into' a rock, as opposed to falling down onto
it, the daggar board may break or break the trunk or both.

SV


As I read the question, the boat had "settled" down on the rocks, not
run into them.

Jim




Scott Vernon June 27th 04 06:28 PM

What If # 6
 
"Jim Cate" wrote


How did the boat SETTLE down on a group of rocks?


He was sailing ( a sailboat leans over, or heels, while sailing) and the
wind died?

The tide went out? hove to and drifted on the rocks?
Ask boob****, he made up the stupid scenerio.




The most
probable solution would be to raise the board a foot or so and motor away.



yup, motor out of trouble, that's the MacX owners' creedo.


--
Scotty
S/V Lisa Marie
Balt. MD USA


Jonathan Ganz June 27th 04 07:30 PM

What If # 6
 
Sort of like how you settled for an inferior boat?

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com

"Jim Cate" wrote in message
...


Scott Vernon wrote:

"Jim Cate" wrote in message
...

Scott, don't forget that the dagger board on the mac isn't fixed, or
tied down. Actually, the only thing holding it down is gravity. What
this means in the context of Question #6 is that if the board hit the
bottom as the boat fell down off a wave or during a falling tide, the
boat would merely slide downwardly on the dagger board, or, the dagger
board would be pushed upwardly relative to the dagger board trunk.



That is true. But, if you 'run into' a rock, as opposed to falling down

onto
it, the daggar board may break or break the trunk or both.

SV


As I read the question, the boat had "settled" down on the rocks, not
run into them.

Jim






Bart Senior June 28th 04 01:58 AM

***S A D I R O N Y ***
 
Ok, I was being silly. I'm sure you've been past
Execution Rock.

Seriously, you are welcome to visit up here, and there
is dock space available for you, or any of my other
newsgroup friends.

Perhaps we can meet up somewhere in between as
circumstances warrant.

Bart

Bobsprit wrote

Bob,

You have never been past Execution Rock! That's only
2.5 miles from you!

Bart, stop being silly. I posted pics from the Thimble Islands, NY Harbor

and
Jersey Shore.

RB





All times are GMT +1. The time now is 10:09 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com