BoatBanter.com

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)
-   ASA (https://www.boatbanter.com/asa/)
-   -   What If #4-Answer (https://www.boatbanter.com/asa/20029-what-if-4-answer.html)

Scott Vernon June 21st 04 04:51 AM

What If #4-Answer
 
sadly, you posted this pathetic crap at 4:20 PM, at that time, I was sailing
by Pooles Island at 7 kts.

Scotty
S/V Lisa Marie
Balt. MD USA



"Bobsprit" wrote in message
...
see?

"Bobsprit" wrote in message

See what? That you're home, while I'm getting some writing done on board?
Yup!
Going sailing tonight!

RB



Bobsprit June 21st 04 04:56 AM

What If #4-Answer
 
sadly, you posted this pathetic crap at 4:20 PM, at that time, I was sailing
by Pooles Island at 7 kts.


Sorry, Scotty...I spent the day on my boat and working on another boat (Cal
35). Glad you finally went sailing. Perhaps you can salvage the rest of the
season.

RB

Horvath June 21st 04 10:35 AM

What If #4-Answer
 
On 21 Jun 2004 03:56:20 GMT, (Bobsprit) wrote this
crap:

Sorry, Scotty...I spent the day sitting on my boat at the mooring ball.



Maybe some day you can try sailing.






Pathetic Earthlings! No one can save you now!

Scott Vernon June 21st 04 10:39 AM

What If #4-Answer
 

"Donal" wrote

I've made
some big gaffs here over the years - and most of them have been due to the
fact that I am really a powerboater at heart..





We all sail in completely different waters.


That's not true, several of us sail in the same water.

Scotty


Scott Vernon June 21st 04 10:44 AM

What If #4-Answer
 
On Sat., Lisa was in the V-berth reading with the forward hatch open a few
inches. I told her about the 'closed hatch' thread. Sure enough, 15 minutes
later some bow spray got her. She closed it and moved to the salon bunk.
;)

Scotty



"Jeff Morris" wrote
Now that's a low blow! BTW, I did realize one factor I had ignored from

your
weather report: the temperature there is only 60 degrees - if it's that

cold
when I go out, I have the hatches closed too! We were sealed up today

because
it was only 70. The issue gets more important when the air temp is over

90 and
the water is over 80.




Bobsprit June 21st 04 11:27 AM

What If #4-Answer
 
On Sat., Lisa was in the V-berth reading with the forward hatch open a few
inches. I told her about the 'closed hatch' thread. Sure enough, 15 minutes
later some bow spray got her.

You have a badly designed boat. There were no conditions on Sat. that should
have brought spray over the bow aboard a 30 footer.
Nuff said!

RB

Jonathan Ganz June 21st 04 06:36 PM

What If #4-Answer
 
Is that where you like your boyfriend?

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com

"Horvath" wrote in message
...
I believe that puts him several steps above you.




Pathetic Earthlings! No one can save you now!




Jonathan Ganz June 21st 04 06:36 PM

What If #4-Answer
 
Maybe someday you can try a diet.

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com

"Horvath" wrote in message
...
On 21 Jun 2004 03:56:20 GMT, (Bobsprit) wrote this
crap:

Sorry, Scotty...I spent the day sitting on my boat at the mooring ball.



Maybe some day you can try sailing.






Pathetic Earthlings! No one can save you now!




Donal June 22nd 04 12:33 AM

What If #4-Answer
 

"Jeff Morris" wrote in message
...
Sorry Ozzy, I acknowledged several posts back that the Channel was a

special
situation. I said: "... you sail in an area with particularly heavy

commercial
traffic, plus a strong current that often opposes the wind."


I also do large chunks of sailing in areas devoid of commercial traffic.


I was surprised by one forecast that listed the wave height for most of

the
Channel as being under a meter for the next few days - I assumed it would

almost
always be rougher than that. BTW, I don't think Donal keeps his boat in

the
Channel.


The wave height is often less than 1m. That doesn't mean that the hatches
can be left open. Waves are not uniform in height. On the small lake in
Ireland that I go trout fishing on, the locals say that every 7th wave will
be twice as big as the rest.

A similiar thing seems to happen at sea.... especially after a wind shift.
It is often possible to pick out yesterday's waves travelling at 90 degrees
to today's wind/waves. Every so often these two wave patterns will combine
to produce a much bigger wave. I assume that this effect must be observable
in any strecth of open water. That is one of the reasons that I think that
you must sail in extremely sheltered waters.




This isn't about what is appropriate for a Channel crossing, or the
Sydney-Hobart race. Donal has declared that all sailboats must always

stay
sealed up, regardless of the boat or the situation. It just isn't so.


In my experience, it is necessary to seal up before leaving the berth. Even
on calm days, you get the odd rogue wave that appears from nowhere.

In the protected waters of the Solent, on an absolutely flat calm day, you
get the occasional big "slapper". I'm fairly sure that they are caused by
the wakes of big ships bouncing (reflecting) off one shore and crossing the
Solent for a second time.

Regards


Donal
--




Donal June 22nd 04 12:39 AM

What If #4-Answer
 

OzOne wrote in message ...
On Sun, 20 Jun 2004 22:45:36 +0100, "Donal"
scribbled thusly:

I checked out the wave heights for your neighborhood - for the next

several days
it will be 1 foot or less. It sounds pretty rough out there, you

better
batten
down your Bendytoy.


Hmmmm! You are beginning to sound like Bobsprit.

Regards


Donal


Pretty obvious he's never seen The Channel let alone read about or
sailed upon it eh Donal.


AFAIK, the Channel isn't particularily difficult. Then again, I haven't
done much sailing anywhere else. I've sailed in the Med twice, and done
Brittany a couple of times. Did you ever visit Brittany?


Regards


Donal
--




Donal June 22nd 04 12:45 AM

What If #4-Answer
 

"Bobsprit" wrote in message
...
I am fortunate enough to be able to absorb
wisdom. I guess that I am luckier than you.

Guess again. Jeff bought a good quality boat. He has managed to avoid your
mistake.


6/10....... but I enjoyed it!

Regards


Donal
--




Scott Vernon June 22nd 04 12:47 AM

What If #4-Answer
 
"Bobsprit" wrote

There were no conditions on Sat. that should
have brought spray over the bow aboard a 30 footer.

RB


Well no, not if you don't leave the slip.


--
Scotty
S/V Lisa Marie
Balt. MD USA


Scott Vernon June 22nd 04 12:47 AM

HEY DONAL !
 
Did you see this one?


"Bobsprit" wrote in message
...
On Sat., Lisa was in the V-berth reading with the forward hatch open a few
inches. I told her about the 'closed hatch' thread. Sure enough, 15

minutes
later some bow spray got her.

You have a badly designed boat. There were no conditions on Sat. that

should
have brought spray over the bow aboard a 30 footer.
Nuff said!

RB



Donal June 22nd 04 12:56 AM

What If #4-Answer
 

"Peter Wiley" wrote in message
. ..

Keep in mind that if Donal tried to go 30 miles offshore, he'd hit
France.


Idiot!!!

The last person who made that dumb mistake was Jax!!!!!

Stick to English literature. You know nothing about geography. Cherebourg
is my nearest French port, and it is 74 nautical miles from Portsmouth
Harbour entrance.


You don't do the nav on your big, polluting, ship - do you?


Bwahahahahahahahaaaaaaa!


Regards


Donal
--




Donal June 22nd 04 01:05 AM

HEY DONAL !
 

"Scott Vernon" wrote in message
...
Did you see this one?


I did. Once again, I am reminded of Bob's true genius. He has managed,
through meticilous research, to pose as a sailor for many years. Yet, it
is clear that he has never been more than a few hundred yards from his slip.

Bobsprit's encyclopediac knowledge is only surpassed by his awesome
ignorance of all things nautical.




Regards


Donal
--




Bobsprit June 22nd 04 02:04 AM

HEY DONAL !
 
Bobsprit's encyclopediac knowledge is only surpassed by his awesome
ignorance of all things nautical.



Well said, Donal...except you're troll is somewhat pointless. You have no idea
of the conditions here this past Sat.
Nice butt licking of Scotty Potty for you! Congrats!

Bwahahahaha!

RB

Bobsprit June 22nd 04 02:06 AM

What If #4-Answer
 
That doesn't mean that the hatches
can be left open. Waves are not uniform in height.


Right, 1m, but then that odd 8m wave comes a calling!

Bwahahaha! What a dope!


RB

Bobsprit June 22nd 04 02:06 AM

What If #4-Answer
 
Every so often these two wave patterns will combine
to produce a much bigger wave. I assume that this effect must be observable
in any strecth of open water. That is one of the reasons that I think that
you must sail in extremely sheltered waters


Good gravy! A much bigger wave??? Ahhhhhhh!!!!

RB

Bobsprit June 22nd 04 02:07 AM

What If #4-Answer
 
have brought spray over the bow aboard a 30 footer.

RB


Well no, not if you don't leave the slip.

You didn't leave the slip? Winds were less than 20 knots. Care to explain how
you were taking water over the bow? Did you capsize???

RB

Jeff Morris June 22nd 04 02:14 AM

What If #4-Answer
 
"Donal" wrote in message
...


The wave height is often less than 1m. That doesn't mean that the hatches
can be left open. Waves are not uniform in height. On the small lake in
Ireland that I go trout fishing on, the locals say that every 7th wave will
be twice as big as the rest.


Actually, wave height is usually measured as the average of the highest third of
all waves. Do the math and you'll find that the stated wave height is the
"seventh" wave.

But this is beside the point. I'm not talking about leaving the forward hatch
wide open in all conditions. Many boats, and most larger boats, have hatches
that will stay dry even if the bow is catching occasional spray.




A similiar thing seems to happen at sea.... especially after a wind shift.
It is often possible to pick out yesterday's waves travelling at 90 degrees
to today's wind/waves. Every so often these two wave patterns will combine
to produce a much bigger wave. I assume that this effect must be observable
in any strecth of open water.


Its particular obvious when you pass behind an island that blocks the direct
path of otherwise benign swells. Two wave fronts radiate from the sides of the
island and cause great mischief when you thought you were headed into the lee.
Close the hatches.

That is one of the reasons that I think that
you must sail in extremely sheltered waters.


Much of my sailing is inside of Boston Harbor, or in Buzzard's Bay. Frankly,
they are both often sloppier than the open ocean. But at least 10 times a year
(often more) for the last 30 years I've had 3000 miles of fetch to the East.
However, as I've said the prevailing winds are from the West, so there are
plenty of times where the waves just aren't that bad.




This isn't about what is appropriate for a Channel crossing, or the
Sydney-Hobart race. Donal has declared that all sailboats must always

stay
sealed up, regardless of the boat or the situation. It just isn't so.


In my experience, it is necessary to seal up before leaving the berth.


This may indeed be your experience. You must have a very wet boat. I've got
one hatch that hasn't been sealed in 8000 miles.

Even on calm days, you get the odd rogue wave that appears from nowhere.


Is that like the fog, which you claim can happen anytime without notice?


In the protected waters of the Solent, on an absolutely flat calm day, you
get the occasional big "slapper". I'm fairly sure that they are caused by
the wakes of big ships bouncing (reflecting) off one shore and crossing the
Solent for a second time.



Are you actually claiming that on a calm day everyone in the cockpit could get
totally soaked??? You must have a *very* wet boat.





Scott Vernon June 22nd 04 02:51 AM

HEY DONAL !
 

"Bobsprit" wrote in message
...
Bobsprit's encyclopediac knowledge is only surpassed by his awesome
ignorance of all things nautical.



You have no idea
of the conditions here this past Sat.


and neither do you.


Nice butt licking of Scotty Potty


keep your filthy fantasies to yourself.

SV


Scott Vernon June 22nd 04 02:54 AM

What If #4-Answer
 

"Bobsprit" proving yet again that he never leaves his wifes' slip wrote ...
Waves are not uniform in height.



Right, 1m, but then that odd 8m wave comes a calling!

Bwahahaha! I'm a dope!


RB



Scott Vernon June 22nd 04 02:57 AM

What If #4-Answer
 
ya don't really know, now, do ya?

Scotty, playing more line........

"Bobsprit" wrote ...
have brought spray over the bow aboard a 30 footer.

Care to explain how

you were taking water over the bow?

RB



Bobsprit June 22nd 04 03:01 AM

What If #4-Answer
 
Many boats, and most larger boats, have hatches
that will stay dry even if the bow is catching occasional spray.

Scotty Potty thinks a big wave will crash down on his bow and flood the
boat...in less than 20 knots!

RB

Bobsprit June 22nd 04 03:02 AM

What If #4-Answer
 
ya don't really know, now, do ya?


Nope...and it didn't rain on Saturday either, but you HAD to keep the hatch
shut!!!! Maybe you were washing the boat? Wakes from jetski's???

Bwahahahahaha!

RB

Bobsprit June 22nd 04 03:04 AM

HEY DONAL !
 
You have no idea
of the conditions here this past Sat.


and neither do you.



Get the gaff...he's right along side!

Bwahahahaha!

RB

Scott Vernon June 22nd 04 03:07 AM

What If #4-Answer
 

"Bobsprit" wrote ...
ya don't really know, now, do ya?


Nope...and it didn't rain on Saturday either,


you sure about that? Care to make a bet? Chicken?

SV



Bobsprit June 22nd 04 03:11 AM

What If #4-Answer
 
Nope...and it didn't rain on Saturday either,

you sure about that? Care to make a bet? Chicken?



So...let's get this straight, folks!!! It rained on saturday with winds under
20 knots (later in the day BTW) and Scotty ended up with water coming over his
bow!!!!
He's landed right in the cockpit!!! Pass the salt!!!!!

Bwahahahahahahaha!

RB

Scott Vernon June 22nd 04 03:19 AM

What If #4-Answer
 
Have you ever even been on a boat?

Your stupidity is really showing on this thread. The more you write, the
dumber you appear.

SV


"Bobsprit" wrote in message
...
Nope...and it didn't rain on Saturday either,


you sure about that? Care to make a bet? Chicken?



So...let's get this straight, folks!!! It rained on saturday with winds

under
20 knots (later in the day BTW) and Scotty ended up with water coming over

his
bow!!!!
He's landed right in the cockpit!!! Pass the salt!!!!!

Bwahahahahahahaha!

RB



Horvath June 22nd 04 03:45 AM

HEY DONAL !
 
On 22 Jun 2004 01:04:53 GMT, (Bobsprit) wrote this
crap:

Bobsprit's encyclopediac knowledge is only surpassed by his awesome
ignorance of all things nautical.



Well said, Donal...except you're troll is somewhat pointless. You have no idea
of the conditions here this past Sat.


So you couldn't pole around the harbor with your whisker pole?





Pathetic Earthlings! No one can save you now!

Peter Wiley June 22nd 04 04:07 AM

What If #4-Answer
 
In article , Donal
wrote:

"Peter Wiley" wrote in message
. ..

Keep in mind that if Donal tried to go 30 miles offshore, he'd hit
France.


Idiot!!!


Well, yeah, we already established that.


The last person who made that dumb mistake was Jax!!!!!

Stick to English literature. You know nothing about geography. Cherebourg
is my nearest French port, and it is 74 nautical miles from Portsmouth
Harbour entrance.


Oh well a little over 2X the distance. Still not very far really.

You don't do the nav on your big, polluting, ship - do you?


How's the backyard veggie garden going, Donal? Have you stopped eating
imported food and using imported fossil fuels yet? Own/drive a car made
in England? Was your Bendy made locally or imported?

BTW, your 'frozen snot' boat is made from petrochemicals that were
undoubtedly transported by big, polluting ships. Perhaps you should
give it back and build your own environmentally friendly ship yourself,
using native timbers or other local materials.

Oh that's right - you can't. You trashed your ecosystem a couple
centuries ago and have been surviving by importing ever since.

Bwahahahahahahahaaaaaaa!


Indeed. Your hypocrisy is entertaining.

PDW

Jeff Morris June 22nd 04 02:58 PM

What If #4-Answer
 
"Peter Wiley" wrote in message
news:220620041307036781% wrote:
"Peter Wiley" wrote in message

Keep in mind that if Donal tried to go 30 miles offshore, he'd hit
France.

Stick to English literature. You know nothing about geography. Cherebourg
is my nearest French port, and it is 74 nautical miles from Portsmouth
Harbour entrance.


Oh well a little over 2X the distance. Still not very far really.


Closer than you think - Cherbourg is less than 60 miles from St. Catherine's on
the Isle of Wight. If you went 30 miles out you'd be more than half way to
France. Donal complains about your geography, but he considers the Portsmouth
Harbour entrance, which is about 8 miles up the Solent, to be "offshore."

But this brings up a question: at what point is one "Offshore"? Is it off
soundings? Out of sight of land? In the US it could be the 3-mile line, or the
ColRegs line (dividing Inland from International Rules). For license purposes
on the US East Coast, 10 miles out is still "Inland", out to 200 miles is
Near-Coastal, further out is Offshore.



Thom Stewart June 22nd 04 11:48 PM

What If #4-Answer
 
Nutsy;

I hope some one; some where; at some time, explained the FIRE TRIANGLE
to you!

By closing up the Cabin you are probably creating a very large BOMB!
After closing the Companion Way, You better be damn sure Air (Oxygen)
isn't allowed to enter again!

Ole Thom


Thom Stewart June 23rd 04 12:02 AM

What If #4-Answer
 
Hey Nutsy,

Do you store that Hatch Board in the Cockpit? Most people that have
Hatch Board store them below where they would be engulfed in the Fire!!!

They are stored below so as not to be lost overboard. Please tell us
where you keep yours and how you secure it and we'll look for it in your
pictures that you have posted. :^)

Ole Thom
P/S My boat has Companionway Doors.


Bobsprit June 23rd 04 12:16 AM

What If #4-Answer
 
By closing up the Cabin you are probably creating a very large BOMB!
After closing the Companion Way, You better be damn sure Air (Oxygen)
isn't allowed to enter again!

Sealing off a fire is key for fighting it. One of my best friends for the last
18 years is a fireman for the FDNY and he agreed with the idea of closing the
hatch as a final line of defense.

RB

Thom Stewart June 23rd 04 12:20 AM

What If #4-Answer
 
Nutsy,

A three piece hatchboard is the better of companion way closure. It
allows better storage (easier) You can add a single board to increase
the height of the bridge deck. You can add the top & bottom boards and
duce tape plastic screening over the middle for ventilation. The single
Fibre glass Hatch board is the cheapest but far from being the best.

Ole Thom


Scott Vernon June 23rd 04 12:20 AM

What If #4-Answer
 
Anybody that would store an anchor behind the mast on the coach roof
probably stows his hatchboard(s) in the anchor locker.

Scotty

"Thom Stewart" wrote in message
...
Hey Nutsy,

Do you store that Hatch Board in the Cockpit? Most people that have
Hatch Board store them below where they would be engulfed in the Fire!!!

They are stored below so as not to be lost overboard. Please tell us
where you keep yours and how you secure it and we'll look for it in your
pictures that you have posted. :^)

Ole Thom
P/S My boat has Companionway Doors.



Scott Vernon June 23rd 04 12:33 AM

What If #4-Answer
 

"Bobsprit" wrote

Sealing off a fire is key for fighting it. One of my boyfriends for the

last
18 years is a fireman for the FDNY and he agreed with the idea of closing

the
hatch as a final line of defense.

RiBit



Scott Vernon June 23rd 04 12:40 AM

What If #4-Answer
 
I was mistaken, I have 4 boards. MacGregors have one big FG board. Nuff
said?

Scotty


"Thom Stewart" wrote in message
...
Nutsy,

A three piece hatchboard is the better of companion way closure. It
allows better storage (easier) You can add a single board to increase
the height of the bridge deck. You can add the top & bottom boards and
duce tape plastic screening over the middle for ventilation. The single
Fibre glass Hatch board is the cheapest but far from being the best.

Ole Thom



Thom Stewart June 23rd 04 12:40 AM

What If #4-Answer
 
Nutsy,

If your friend in the NYFD advices sealing the fire, please have him
explain the need for Fire Axes on their trucks.

Nutsy, I do believe you've busted yourself once again.

Ole Thom



All times are GMT +1. The time now is 03:19 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com