Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#26
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
I've read a lot of the test reports. As you might guess, this is a topic I've
followed a bit. The general conclusion from most of the tests is that if an anchor is well set in a good bottom, it has a lot of holding power. What the test don't tell is how an anchor responds to a foul bottom, or how much it drags before setting, or how much care it needs to set, or how well it resets after its upset. However, it you want to look test results, I haven't found any for the FX-11 because, I suspect, its considered too small for cruisers. However, the USSailing tests used a FX37, and larger Fortresses (It was funded by Nav-X, the manufacturer) were tested. The Fortresses did rather well in sand compared to the others, by still, frequently dragged before achieving the holding power listed on the web site. They did all easily surpass the listed "working load." In the "mud" version of the test, the Fortress also did well, but did not even come close to the web site claims. Note that these test were conducted by Nav-X, with special care taken to make sure they were measuring the actual holding power, as opposed to ease of setting, etc. http://www.ussailing.org/safety/Stud...nchor_test.htm http://www.ussailing.org/safety/Stud...nchor_test.htm In another test, the Fortress failed to set at all: http://www.creativemarine.com/newpro.../absreport.htm But the issue is not how well the larger Fortresses performs in straight line tests. They do damn well most of the time, especially for its weight. That's why I've carried one for a dozen years and recommend them. The issue is the holding power of the 7 pound version. Frankly, its not that high, even according to their own data, which seems to be optimistic. I have no doubt it satisfies your needs, but this is not a good choice for someone that wants to get a good night's sleep on the hook. "SAIL LOCO" wrote in message ... Yes, you would only drag at about 3 knots in Chesapeake t-storm. It would probably be over before you washed up in Crisfield. LOL..... Funny but maybe you should read the test reports that used tug boats as a test vessel. S/V Express 30 "Ringmaster" "No shirt, no skirt, full service" |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Forum | |||
land anchor vs fluke anchor for anchors set directly on beach | Cruising | |||
Bruce vs. Lewmar and Simpson Lawrence / Horizon claw anchors? | Cruising | |||
Techniques for retrieving stuck anchors | General | |||
mooring anchors | General |