Its hard to imagine that an Irwin is better than any boat. The one that I
chartered for a season was falling apart, quite literally.

I've been aboard two Siedlemanns. They are worse, perhaps as bad as the US
Yachts. The only thing worse than seeing one is meeting the poor fool who
bought it.

RB

Bob is soooooo jealous of my boat , it drives him nuts.

Scotty

"Jeff Morris" wrote in message
...
Its hard to imagine that an Irwin is better than any boat. The one that I
chartered for a season was falling apart, quite literally. It was 8 years
old.



"Bobsprit" wrote in message
...

An irwin is still better than a Siedleman or Mac and probably some
Lancers.

RB

Hey, I was going to say that.
"katysails" wrote in message
...
That's because Neal worked at the Irwin factory. A Coronado was a big
quality leap for him.

--
katysails
s/v Chanteuse
Kirie Elite 32
http://katysails.tripod.com

"Women and cats will do as they please, and men and dogs should relax
and get used to the idea." - Robert A. Heinlein

An irwin is still better than a Siedleman or Mac and probably some Lancers.

RB

yeaaaahhhh.

jeffies, you have been on what three boats in your life? A Coronado, a
Hinckley and the Staten Island ferry?

Its hard to imagine that an Irwin is better than any boat. The one that I
chartered for a season was falling apart, quite literally. It was 8 years
old.



"Bobsprit" wrote in message
...

An irwin is still better than a Siedleman or Mac and probably some Lancers.

RB

I've been aboard two Siedlemanns. They are worse, perhaps as bad as the US
Yachts. The only thing worse than seeing one is meeting the poor fool who
bought it.

RB

Siedlemanns were (not many left) pretty bad, but US Yachts is what became of
Bucaneer.

define 'better'


"JAXAshby" wrote in message
...
An irwin is still better than a Siedleman or Mac and probably some
Lancers.

RB

yeaaaahhhh.

"****Head" wrote

The only thing worse is being outsailed by the poor fool who
bought it.


maybe if you took some lessons.......

You ever sail one jaxy?

"JAXAshby" wrote in message
...
I've been aboard two Siedlemanns. They are worse, perhaps as bad as the
US
Yachts. The only thing worse than seeing one is meeting the poor fool who
bought it.

RB

Siedlemanns were (not many left) pretty bad, but US Yachts is what became
of
Bucaneer.

You ever sail one jaxy?


Scotty, no one doubts that your boat can move. But the fact, and I do think you
know this, is that the Siedlemann line is known for poor quality with some
boats being lemons. I've looked at the Sailnet boards and some of the owners
operate on the "I've got a good one" theme. Not exactly the level of better
O'Days and even Macs.

RB