BoatBanter.com

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)
-   General (https://www.boatbanter.com/general/)
-   -   Confusion over engine oils (https://www.boatbanter.com/general/94900-confusion-over-engine-oils.html)

HK May 29th 08 11:01 PM

Confusion over engine oils
 
Larry wrote:
wrote in news:46f38d0b-e4c0-49ee-a381-
:

One of the trolls may answer this, you will notice that most of us
left here will ignore the response.. we already know what it says
anyway;)

Nice to see you back Larry, stick around, we could use the input.

In case you don't know my new sock puppet, JWAFM (me) is Scotty from
SmallBoats.



I usually just ignore the trolls, even pointed at me. I'm 62 and retired
now and never get excited by much,



I was sorta figuring that some young gal's dad did you in with a shotgun....
:)

Richard Casady May 29th 08 11:52 PM

Confusion over engine oils
 
On Thu, 29 May 2008 08:59:13 -0400, "John" wrote:

Most all 2 stroke oils still recomend 50:1 but
AMSOIL is 100:1?


I don'at even play a lawyer on USENET, but that sounds like a good way
to murder the warrantee.

Casady

[email protected] May 30th 08 02:24 AM

Confusion over engine oils
 
On May 29, 10:38*am, John H. wrote:
On Thu, 29 May 2008 06:55:53 -0700 (PDT),
wrote:







But some people are just too poor to be able to afford an oil that may
end up costing you $5.00 dollars each change, apparently.


Then they should trade their boat in for one of these:


http://i98.photobucket.com/albums/l2...ardBoating.jpg


--
John *H*- Hide quoted text -


- Show quoted text -


That ain't backyard boating.. this is:
http://trip-reports.com/coppermine/d...album=6&pos=21
;)


Holy ****! Do the neighbors not get on your case?

One time I was living on an Army post, and I had an old MGB GT in the
driveway. The engine, transmission radiator, hood, and all the other
assorted stuff removed to pull the engine, tranny and clutch was laying all
over the yard.

About six o'clock that night, I got a call from the Commanding General's
aide. He politely informed me that if my yard wasn't cleaned up by 0600 the
next morning, the moving trucks would be there to move me off post - at
*my* expense!

Luckily, I had some friends close by who would help, and by about three in
the morning we had the thing all back together. Close call!
--
John *H*- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -


One neighbor owned a a marina most of her life, a 26 foot Lyman,and a
30 foot Sparkman and Stevens she used to single hand out on the sound.
The other neighbor is a great older lady who was always happy to have
freindly neighbors, another I spent a considerable time helping him
restore the interior of his old farmhouse.. etc.... One neighbor did
complain once but the zoning commish basically giggled as he told me
"they want me to shut down a wooden boat builder in Essex CT. what a
joke", then he showed me where on my property I could build a
garage;)

The picture you see was one day when I had a lot of stuff there
cleaning out the shop, it was kind of a joke, but I will admit there
were days when it did look somewhat like that. I had a lot of real
good freinds down there, can't wait to go back someday, I still own
the place but my kid loves the school system up here so we won't be
back for at least 4 more years.

Scotty

John H.[_4_] May 30th 08 02:30 AM

Confusion over engine oils
 
On Thu, 29 May 2008 18:24:47 -0700 (PDT),
wrote:

On May 29, 10:38*am, John H. wrote:
On Thu, 29 May 2008 06:55:53 -0700 (PDT),
wrote:







But some people are just too poor to be able to afford an oil that may
end up costing you $5.00 dollars each change, apparently.


Then they should trade their boat in for one of these:


http://i98.photobucket.com/albums/l2...ardBoating.jpg

--
John *H*- Hide quoted text -


- Show quoted text -


That ain't backyard boating.. this is:
http://trip-reports.com/coppermine/d...album=6&pos=21
;)


Holy ****! Do the neighbors not get on your case?

One time I was living on an Army post, and I had an old MGB GT in the
driveway. The engine, transmission radiator, hood, and all the other
assorted stuff removed to pull the engine, tranny and clutch was laying all
over the yard.

About six o'clock that night, I got a call from the Commanding General's
aide. He politely informed me that if my yard wasn't cleaned up by 0600 the
next morning, the moving trucks would be there to move me off post - at
*my* expense!

Luckily, I had some friends close by who would help, and by about three in
the morning we had the thing all back together. Close call!
--
John *H*- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -


One neighbor owned a a marina most of her life, a 26 foot Lyman,and a
30 foot Sparkman and Stevens she used to single hand out on the sound.
The other neighbor is a great older lady who was always happy to have
freindly neighbors, another I spent a considerable time helping him
restore the interior of his old farmhouse.. etc.... One neighbor did
complain once but the zoning commish basically giggled as he told me
"they want me to shut down a wooden boat builder in Essex CT. what a
joke", then he showed me where on my property I could build a
garage;)

The picture you see was one day when I had a lot of stuff there
cleaning out the shop, it was kind of a joke, but I will admit there
were days when it did look somewhat like that. I had a lot of real
good freinds down there, can't wait to go back someday, I still own
the place but my kid loves the school system up here so we won't be
back for at least 4 more years.

Scotty


I figured it was a garage cleaning day!
--
John *H*

[email protected] May 30th 08 02:42 AM

Confusion over engine oils
 
On May 29, 9:30*pm, John H. wrote:
On Thu, 29 May 2008 18:24:47 -0700 (PDT),
wrote:





On May 29, 10:38*am, John H. wrote:
On Thu, 29 May 2008 06:55:53 -0700 (PDT),
wrote:


But some people are just too poor to be able to afford an oil that may
end up costing you $5.00 dollars each change, apparently.


Then they should trade their boat in for one of these:


http://i98.photobucket.com/albums/l2...ardBoating.jpg


--
John *H*- Hide quoted text -


- Show quoted text -


That ain't backyard boating.. this is:
http://trip-reports.com/coppermine/d...album=6&pos=21
;)


Holy ****! Do the neighbors not get on your case?


One time I was living on an Army post, and I had an old MGB GT in the
driveway. The engine, transmission radiator, hood, and all the other
assorted stuff removed to pull the engine, tranny and clutch was laying all
over the yard.


About six o'clock that night, I got a call from the Commanding General's
aide. He politely informed me that if my yard wasn't cleaned up by 0600 the
next morning, the moving trucks would be there to move me off post - at
*my* expense!


Luckily, I had some friends close by who would help, and by about three in
the morning we had the thing all back together. Close call!
--
John *H*- Hide quoted text -


- Show quoted text -


One neighbor owned a a marina most of her life, a 26 foot Lyman,and a
30 foot Sparkman and Stevens she used to single hand out on the sound.
The other neighbor is a great older lady who was always happy to have
freindly neighbors, another I spent a considerable time helping him
restore the interior of his old farmhouse.. etc.... One neighbor did
complain once but the zoning commish basically giggled as he told me
"they want me to shut down a wooden boat builder in Essex CT. what a
joke", then he showed me where on my property I could build a
garage;)


The picture you see was one day when I had a lot of stuff there
cleaning out the shop, it was kind of a joke, but I will admit there
were days when it did look somewhat like that. I had a lot of real
good freinds down there, can't wait to go back someday, I still own
the place but my kid loves the school system up here so we won't be
back for at least 4 more years.


Scotty


I figured it was a garage cleaning day!
--
John *H*- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -


It was:)

Tim May 30th 08 04:05 AM

Confusion over engine oils
 
On May 28, 7:12 pm, Larry wrote:
John H. wrote :



On 4-stroke oils, there is a fairly new certification system endorsed
by the
oil blenders and the 4-stroke manufacturers, called "four-stroke,
water-cooled" or FC-W. Because an outboard may run in sal****er, sit
unused for long periods of time, and runs high rpms for hours on end
unlike a car motor, the industry wanted a spec for approved outboard
oils. New owners manuals now state what oil grades to use and say an
FC-W certified oil if you don't use an OEM lubricant. If you are into
synthetics, surprisingly the
Amsoil 4-stroke oil is FC-W approved unlike their 2-stroke oils which
are not TC-W3 approved. Here is more info on the FC-W lubes:


http://nmma.org/certification/programs/oils/fc-w.asp
**********************************************


We can't have you boys just dropping by WalMart and buying Quaker State
to put in your 4-strokers, like the rest of the world. We just HAVE to
make an NMMA-friendly spec of oils only the damned dealers will be
selling for $20/gallon, like the OEM crap.

What nonsense. More sales gimmicks. The only reason they don't tell you
you MUST use their OEM oils is the Magnusson-Moss Warranty Protection Act
(15USC50 section 2304) which states that if they tell you you MUST use
OEM consumables, then they MUST PROVIDE those consumables at no cost for
the life of the item, no matter what item it is. That puts a stop to
being forced to buy Mr Goodwrench's oil for your Chevy to keep the
warranty working.

Sure would like to take two brand new Hondas on the back of a boat, put
Rotella T diesel oil in one of them and this overpriced **** in the other
and track everything that goes wrong with both of them for the next
20,000 hours of heavy use on some water taxi. I bet you'd never tell the
difference.

Amsoil....

Amsoil is a SCAM! Call 'em. Ask 'em where the REFINERY or CHEMICAL
PLANT is that AMSOIL OWNS. Ask for the address of that factory where
they make it. The only thing Amsoil owns is a BOTTLING PLANT! You can
see it on Google Earth in Superior, Wisconsin.

"Facilities
THE AMSOIL CORPORATE HEADQUARTERS, MANUFACTURING PLANT, AND MAIN
DISTRIBUTION CENTER are located in Superior, Wisconsin, with several
regional warehouses strategically located throughout North America and
overseas. These facilities cover a total of nearly 700,000 square feet.

The state-of-the-art lubricant production plant contains materials
blending and bulk storage facilities, as well as highspeed bottling lines
and packaging equipment. The main warehouse serves as the hub of a global
distribution network; bottles, cases, drums and totes bearing the AMSOIL
label are shipped worldwide. Capacity is geared to meet projected market
demands decades away.

The AMSOIL administrative functions are centrally located and outfitted
with the latest in communications and information processing equipment.
The entire complex is staffed by a cooperative, knowledgeable and well-
disciplined team of approximately 300 employees."

http://www.amsoil.com/distribution_centers_map.aspx
Here ya go. The address of every one of their "distribution centers" is
on this map. Look down on 'em from Google Earth and see if you see any
CHEMICAL FACTORY anywhere. They're all just WAREHOUSES!

Scam written all over it....."Just believe", it's like a goddamned cult.

Man it's raining HARD outsid


Tim May 30th 08 05:01 AM

Confusion over engine oils
 
On May 28, 7:12*pm, Larry wrote:
John H. wrote :





On 4-stroke oils, there is a fairly new certification system endorsed
by the
oil blenders and the 4-stroke manufacturers, called "four-stroke,
water-cooled" or FC-W. Because an outboard may run in sal****er, sit
unused for long periods of time, and runs high rpms for hours on end
unlike a car motor, the industry wanted a spec for approved outboard
oils. New owners manuals now state what oil grades to use and say an
FC-W certified oil if you don't use an OEM lubricant. If you are into
synthetics, surprisingly the
Amsoil 4-stroke oil is FC-W approved unlike their 2-stroke oils which
are not TC-W3 approved. Here is more info on the FC-W lubes:


http://nmma.org/certification/programs/oils/fc-w.asp
**********************************************


We can't have you boys just dropping by WalMart and buying Quaker State
to put in your 4-strokers, like the rest of the world. *


I mst not be part of the rest of the world, because I don't want my
engine filled full of wax.



We just HAVE to
make an NMMA-friendly spec of oils only the damned dealers will be
selling for $20/gallon, like the OEM crap.

What nonsense. *More sales gimmicks. *The only reason they don't tell you
you MUST use their OEM oils is the Magnusson-Moss Warranty Protection Act
(15USC50 section 2304) which states that if they tell you you MUST use
OEM consumables, then they MUST PROVIDE those consumables at no cost for
the life of the item, no matter what item it is. *That puts a stop to
being forced to buy Mr Goodwrench's oil for your Chevy to keep the
warranty working.

Sure would like to take two brand new Hondas on the back of a boat, put
Rotella T diesel oil in one of them and this overpriced **** in the other
and track everything that goes wrong with both of them for the next
20,000 hours of heavy use on some water taxi. *I bet you'd never tell the
difference.

Amsoil....

Amsoil is a SCAM! *Call 'em. *Ask 'em where the REFINERY or CHEMICAL
PLANT is that AMSOIL OWNS. *Ask for the address of that factory where
they make it. *The only thing Amsoil owns is a BOTTLING PLANT! *You can
see it on Google Earth in Superior, Wisconsin.

"Facilities
THE AMSOIL CORPORATE HEADQUARTERS, MANUFACTURING PLANT, AND MAIN
DISTRIBUTION CENTER are located in Superior, Wisconsin, with several
regional warehouses strategically located throughout North America and
overseas. These facilities cover a total of nearly 700,000 square feet.

The state-of-the-art lubricant production plant contains materials
blending and bulk storage facilities, as well as highspeed bottling lines
and packaging equipment. The main warehouse serves as the hub of a global
distribution network; bottles, cases, drums and totes bearing the AMSOIL
label are shipped worldwide. Capacity is geared to meet projected market
demands decades away.

The AMSOIL administrative functions are centrally located and outfitted
with the latest in communications and information processing equipment.
The entire complex is staffed by a cooperative, knowledgeable and well-
disciplined team of approximately 300 employees."

http://www.amsoil.com/distribution_centers_map.aspx
Here ya go. *The address of every one of their "distribution centers" is
on this map. *Look down on 'em from Google Earth and see if you see any
CHEMICAL FACTORY anywhere. *They're all just WAREHOUSES!

Scam written all over it....."Just believe", it's like a goddamned cult.

Man it's raining HARD outside!- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -


I'd say the same about using OE filters and oil[s] especially under a
dome of warranty. And while it's under warranty, I'd probably have the
dealer service the engine that is, until the warranty is over. Then
there's hardly any backing out of a bad deal if the engine goes down.
It's better to pay a bit up front then have to pay a lot more because
one would think they were saving a couple bucks by picking a cheap
brand of anything and DIY. because something messed up whether it was
in or out of your control, something could go badly wrong then who's
liable? Yeah, then it's always somebody else's fault. until the
warranty is over I want it to be somebody else's, and I'd go to an
extreme to make sure it wasn't mine.


Mike[_6_] May 30th 08 06:19 AM

Confusion over engine oils
 
I'd say the same about using OE filters and oil[s] especially under a
dome of warranty. And while it's under warranty, I'd probably have the
dealer service the engine that is, until the warranty is over.

No offense, but that's the line any dealer would try to sell. I'm not
accusing you of doing that mind you. If you keep records of what you do, and
when you do it, as long as it's along the mfg's recommended procedure, the
warranty is in full effect.

I had a truck a few years ago, and the transmission started making a wierd
sound at about 60,000 miles. I still had 15,000 on the warranty. I brought
it to the dealer, and they called later that day saying that the trans fluid
looked "burnt," and they had no record of any of the recomended services.
Obviously, they were looking for an out. I went down there with my reciepts
from Jiffy Lube showing what was serviced and when. I got a new
transmission.

Just keep your recepts, and in the case of a boat, jot down the engine hours
on each receipt. Then, save your money by doing it yourself.

--Mike

"Tim" wrote in message
...
On May 28, 7:12 pm, Larry wrote:
John H. wrote
:





On 4-stroke oils, there is a fairly new certification system endorsed
by the
oil blenders and the 4-stroke manufacturers, called "four-stroke,
water-cooled" or FC-W. Because an outboard may run in sal****er, sit
unused for long periods of time, and runs high rpms for hours on end
unlike a car motor, the industry wanted a spec for approved outboard
oils. New owners manuals now state what oil grades to use and say an
FC-W certified oil if you don't use an OEM lubricant. If you are into
synthetics, surprisingly the
Amsoil 4-stroke oil is FC-W approved unlike their 2-stroke oils which
are not TC-W3 approved. Here is more info on the FC-W lubes:


http://nmma.org/certification/programs/oils/fc-w.asp
**********************************************


We can't have you boys just dropping by WalMart and buying Quaker State
to put in your 4-strokers, like the rest of the world.


I mst not be part of the rest of the world, because I don't want my
engine filled full of wax.



We just HAVE to
make an NMMA-friendly spec of oils only the damned dealers will be
selling for $20/gallon, like the OEM crap.

What nonsense. More sales gimmicks. The only reason they don't tell you
you MUST use their OEM oils is the Magnusson-Moss Warranty Protection Act
(15USC50 section 2304) which states that if they tell you you MUST use
OEM consumables, then they MUST PROVIDE those consumables at no cost for
the life of the item, no matter what item it is. That puts a stop to
being forced to buy Mr Goodwrench's oil for your Chevy to keep the
warranty working.

Sure would like to take two brand new Hondas on the back of a boat, put
Rotella T diesel oil in one of them and this overpriced **** in the other
and track everything that goes wrong with both of them for the next
20,000 hours of heavy use on some water taxi. I bet you'd never tell the
difference.

Amsoil....

Amsoil is a SCAM! Call 'em. Ask 'em where the REFINERY or CHEMICAL
PLANT is that AMSOIL OWNS. Ask for the address of that factory where
they make it. The only thing Amsoil owns is a BOTTLING PLANT! You can
see it on Google Earth in Superior, Wisconsin.

"Facilities
THE AMSOIL CORPORATE HEADQUARTERS, MANUFACTURING PLANT, AND MAIN
DISTRIBUTION CENTER are located in Superior, Wisconsin, with several
regional warehouses strategically located throughout North America and
overseas. These facilities cover a total of nearly 700,000 square feet.

The state-of-the-art lubricant production plant contains materials
blending and bulk storage facilities, as well as highspeed bottling lines
and packaging equipment. The main warehouse serves as the hub of a global
distribution network; bottles, cases, drums and totes bearing the AMSOIL
label are shipped worldwide. Capacity is geared to meet projected market
demands decades away.

The AMSOIL administrative functions are centrally located and outfitted
with the latest in communications and information processing equipment.
The entire complex is staffed by a cooperative, knowledgeable and well-
disciplined team of approximately 300 employees."

http://www.amsoil.com/distribution_centers_map.aspx
Here ya go. The address of every one of their "distribution centers" is
on this map. Look down on 'em from Google Earth and see if you see any
CHEMICAL FACTORY anywhere. They're all just WAREHOUSES!

Scam written all over it....."Just believe", it's like a goddamned cult.

Man it's raining HARD outside!- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -


I'd say the same about using OE filters and oil[s] especially under a
dome of warranty. And while it's under warranty, I'd probably have the
dealer service the engine that is, until the warranty is over. Then
there's hardly any backing out of a bad deal if the engine goes down.
It's better to pay a bit up front then have to pay a lot more because
one would think they were saving a couple bucks by picking a cheap
brand of anything and DIY. because something messed up whether it was
in or out of your control, something could go badly wrong then who's
liable? Yeah, then it's always somebody else's fault. until the
warranty is over I want it to be somebody else's, and I'd go to an
extreme to make sure it wasn't mine.



John H.[_4_] May 30th 08 11:30 AM

Confusion over engine oils
 
On Thu, 29 May 2008 21:01:06 -0700 (PDT), Tim wrote:

On May 28, 7:12*pm, Larry wrote:
John H. wrote :





On 4-stroke oils, there is a fairly new certification system endorsed
by the
oil blenders and the 4-stroke manufacturers, called "four-stroke,
water-cooled" or FC-W. Because an outboard may run in sal****er, sit
unused for long periods of time, and runs high rpms for hours on end
unlike a car motor, the industry wanted a spec for approved outboard
oils. New owners manuals now state what oil grades to use and say an
FC-W certified oil if you don't use an OEM lubricant. If you are into
synthetics, surprisingly the
Amsoil 4-stroke oil is FC-W approved unlike their 2-stroke oils which
are not TC-W3 approved. Here is more info on the FC-W lubes:


http://nmma.org/certification/programs/oils/fc-w.asp
**********************************************


We can't have you boys just dropping by WalMart and buying Quaker State
to put in your 4-strokers, like the rest of the world. *


I mst not be part of the rest of the world, because I don't want my
engine filled full of wax.



We just HAVE to
make an NMMA-friendly spec of oils only the damned dealers will be
selling for $20/gallon, like the OEM crap.

What nonsense. *More sales gimmicks. *The only reason they don't tell you
you MUST use their OEM oils is the Magnusson-Moss Warranty Protection Act
(15USC50 section 2304) which states that if they tell you you MUST use
OEM consumables, then they MUST PROVIDE those consumables at no cost for
the life of the item, no matter what item it is. *That puts a stop to
being forced to buy Mr Goodwrench's oil for your Chevy to keep the
warranty working.

Sure would like to take two brand new Hondas on the back of a boat, put
Rotella T diesel oil in one of them and this overpriced **** in the other
and track everything that goes wrong with both of them for the next
20,000 hours of heavy use on some water taxi. *I bet you'd never tell the
difference.

Amsoil....

Amsoil is a SCAM! *Call 'em. *Ask 'em where the REFINERY or CHEMICAL
PLANT is that AMSOIL OWNS. *Ask for the address of that factory where
they make it. *The only thing Amsoil owns is a BOTTLING PLANT! *You can
see it on Google Earth in Superior, Wisconsin.

"Facilities
THE AMSOIL CORPORATE HEADQUARTERS, MANUFACTURING PLANT, AND MAIN
DISTRIBUTION CENTER are located in Superior, Wisconsin, with several
regional warehouses strategically located throughout North America and
overseas. These facilities cover a total of nearly 700,000 square feet.

The state-of-the-art lubricant production plant contains materials
blending and bulk storage facilities, as well as highspeed bottling lines
and packaging equipment. The main warehouse serves as the hub of a global
distribution network; bottles, cases, drums and totes bearing the AMSOIL
label are shipped worldwide. Capacity is geared to meet projected market
demands decades away.

The AMSOIL administrative functions are centrally located and outfitted
with the latest in communications and information processing equipment.
The entire complex is staffed by a cooperative, knowledgeable and well-
disciplined team of approximately 300 employees."

http://www.amsoil.com/distribution_centers_map.aspx
Here ya go. *The address of every one of their "distribution centers" is
on this map. *Look down on 'em from Google Earth and see if you see any
CHEMICAL FACTORY anywhere. *They're all just WAREHOUSES!

Scam written all over it....."Just believe", it's like a goddamned cult.

Man it's raining HARD outside!- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -


I'd say the same about using OE filters and oil[s] especially under a
dome of warranty. And while it's under warranty, I'd probably have the
dealer service the engine that is, until the warranty is over. Then
there's hardly any backing out of a bad deal if the engine goes down.
It's better to pay a bit up front then have to pay a lot more because
one would think they were saving a couple bucks by picking a cheap
brand of anything and DIY. because something messed up whether it was
in or out of your control, something could go badly wrong then who's
liable? Yeah, then it's always somebody else's fault. until the
warranty is over I want it to be somebody else's, and I'd go to an
extreme to make sure it wasn't mine.


The scam at the Toyota dealer's is to 'suggest' that every auto be serviced
every 3000 instead of 5000 miles, regardless of usage. And then they have
about $25 worth of 'extra dealer items', such as 'friction proofer' and
other additives that are routinely added, unless they're told up front not
to do it.

I'm very careful to tell them I want the 'book' service when I go in.
--
John *H*

Richard Casady May 30th 08 06:29 PM

Confusion over engine oils
 
On Thu, 29 May 2008 21:01:06 -0700 (PDT), Tim
wrote:

I mst not be part of the rest of the world, because I don't want my
engine filled full of wax.


I have heard of wax in the fuel filters of diesels in cold weather.
One local vender sold a 50/50 mix of #1 and #2, which solved the
problem. How do you keep wax from melting at engine temperature?

Casady


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 04:55 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com