BoatBanter.com

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)
-   General (https://www.boatbanter.com/general/)
-   -   ( OT ) In Search Of A Plan (https://www.boatbanter.com/general/4234-ot-search-plan.html)

Harry Krause April 23rd 04 01:30 AM

( OT ) In Search Of A Plan
 
John H wrote:

On Thu, 22 Apr 2004 17:49:37 -0400, Harry Krause
wrote:


Don White wrote:


Jim wrote in message
...


: "About one in every 10 members of Iraq's security forces 'actually

worked


against' U.S. troops during the recent militia violence in Iraq, and an
additional 40 percent walked off the job because of intimidation."


This can't be! I remember all those army press releases John H. produced,
saying how well things were going and making much of the graduating classes.
What happened!
Could the army pr people be wrong?



John simply is playing the same lying, deceitful game the Pentagon
played during its Vietnam fiasco. he hopes by spreading meaningless
flackery, he can help obfuscate the disaster that has become Bush's
policy in Iraq. It's just lying by another name. He probably got used to
it during his days in the military.




Speaking of good news. Luckily the defeatist attitude doesn't live in the US
Marine Corps.



Marines pin hopes on new Iraqi police




Yet another example of stupidity.

John H April 23rd 04 01:35 AM

( OT ) In Search Of A Plan
 
On 23 Apr 2004 00:26:11 GMT, (Gould 0738) wrote:

Harry are you talking about those bunch of scared kids who were surrounded
by 1000's of anger protestor throwing rocks and bottles?


Oh, Christ!!!
Some things cannot be left unchallenged.
Aplogies in advance to all:

No. Harry is not talking about a group of scared kids "surrounded by 1000's of
anger (sic) protestors throwing rocks and bottles"

Shut off the Limbaugh show and do some acutal research on Kent State. Think it
might be signfiicant that not a *single* guardsman was injured? Those thousands
of protestors with rocks and bottles must have all been lousy shots. If not,
thousands of peope throwing rocks would have simply killed off the entire squad
on the spot. The shooters were initially separated from the crowd by the brow
of a hill, and had to
crest that hill in order to open fire. You must be very young.
Here are a few incidents related to Kent State and its aftermath to help you
begin your liberation from propanganda and set you upon your quest for truth.

May 3 Ohio Governor James A. Rhodes personally appears on campus and promises
to use "every force possible" to maintain order. Rhodes denounces the
protesters as worse than brownshirts and vows to keep the Guard in Kent "until
we get rid of them."

May 4 Four students are killed and nine others are wounded when a contingent of
Guardsmen suddenly opens fire during a noontime demonstration.

July 23 Key portions of a secret Justice Department memo are disclosed by the
Akron Beacon Journal. The memorandum describes the shootings as unnecessary and
urges the Portage County Prosecutor to file criminal charges against six
Guardsmen.

October 4 The President's Commission on Campus Unrest concludes: "The actions
of some students were violent and criminal and some others were dangerous,
reckless, and irresponsible." The shootings are branded as "unnecessary,
unwarranted, and inexcusable."

October 16 The "special" state grand jury exonerates the Guardsmen, but indicts
25 individuals, mostly students, for a variety of offenses that occurred on
campus before the shootings.

Late October-November Demands for a federal grand jury mount after it is
revealed that the "special" state grand jury ignored key evidence and that one
of the "special" prosecutors told a newsman he felt the Guardsmen should have
shot more students.

Following year:

The "special" state grand jury is even further discredited when Ohio officials
dismiss charges against 20 of the 25 individuals indicted by the grand jury.
Ohio prosecutors claimed they had insufficient evidence to convict any
protesters.

1973:

May 10 In a meeting with the student petitioners, K. William O'Connor, a
high-level Justice Department official, admits that the Justice Department
already has sufficient evidence to prosecute six Guardsmen.


A bit of truth leaks out:

August 3 Assistant Attorney General J. Stanley Pottinger announces that the
Justice Department will officially conduct a new inquiry. Senator Birch Bayh
follows Pottinger's announcement by releasing a letter he received from one of
the Guard's company commanders. On the basis of that letter Bayh charges that
armed FBI informant Terry Norman may have been "the fatal catalyst" for the
tragedy.

NOTE: That letter was from one of the Guard's own company commanders, not some
left wing apologist.

1974:

October 7-17 Attorneys for James A. Rhodes unsuccessfully try to block the
release of Rhodes's deposition in the civil case until after the Ohio
gubernatorial election. The deposition reveals that Rhodes's attorney, in a
move reminiscent of the Watergate cover-up, offered into evidence an incomplete
transcript of Rhodes's May 3, 1970, press conference. Among the remarks deleted
was a comment by an official that the Guard would resort to shooting if
necessary.


Etc, etc, etc,


Now, other than "Everybody knows" and/or "I heard on Fox News, Hannity, or
Limbaugh" what facts can you cite that support your allegation that thousands
of angry protestors surrounded the troops and pelted them with rocks and
bottles?

Those innocent kids exercising their First Amendment Rights don't deserve to
have their memories villified, especially when there isn't a shred of evidence
supporting the wild allegation.

A real man would apologize for such a slanderous error.


Has Hannity or Limbaugh discussed this recently? You must listen to them a lot
more than I, Chuck, as I don't recall anything about this matter. Of course, I
focus a lot more on Mr Colmes. :)

John H

On the 'Poco Loco' out of Deale, MD
on the beautiful Chesapeake Bay!

John H April 23rd 04 01:37 AM

( OT ) In Search Of A Plan
 
On 23 Apr 2004 00:26:11 GMT, (Gould 0738) wrote:

Harry are you talking about those bunch of scared kids who were surrounded
by 1000's of anger protestor throwing rocks and bottles?


Oh, Christ!!!
Some things cannot be left unchallenged.
Aplogies in advance to all:


No apologies necessary. Harry needs all the help he can get now. His credibility
seems to have taken a big hit.

John H

On the 'Poco Loco' out of Deale, MD
on the beautiful Chesapeake Bay!

Joe April 23rd 04 01:42 AM

( OT ) In Search Of A Plan
 

"Gould 0738" wrote in message
...
Harry are you talking about those bunch of scared kids who were

surrounded
by 1000's of anger protestor throwing rocks and bottles?


Oh, Christ!!!
Some things cannot be left unchallenged.
Aplogies in advance to all:


He's baaa-aack!



DSK April 23rd 04 01:49 AM

( OT ) In Search Of A Plan
 
John Smith wrote:
Harry are you talking about those bunch of scared kids who were surrounded
by 1000's of anger protestor throwing rocks and bottles?


Whoa right there hoss.

You are flat wrong. The protestors never "surrounded" anybody.


... Unfortunately a
small group of the guardsmen feeling in danger of their life, freaked out
and shot into the crowd trying to disperse the angry students.


Actually, they shot at a crowd across a big lawn, and two of the people
killed were not even in the protest.



You should not be angry at the guardsmen,


Yes, you should. They murdered their countrymen over a political
disagreement.

... you should be upset at LBJ who
sent young Americans to an war that we could never win.


Agreed, but with the added notice that LBJ did not initiate US
involvement in Viet Nam nor formulate an original policy. All he did was
follow bad advice and indulge in a Southerner's instinct to not back
down from a fight.

Viet Nam was a disaster in the making back in the 1800s, and we should
*never* have backed the French to go back in after WW2.

DSK


John Smith April 23rd 04 01:55 AM

( OT ) In Search Of A Plan
 
I don't listen to Rush, Fox News, or Hannity. Below I have copied the order
of events from the Kent May 4 Center www.may4.org. A web site to
remember those killed at Ohio State, so hopefully it will not happen again.

I can't imagine many 18 - 21 yr old soldiers who would not be scared to
death. If you saw pictures of the students yelling at the guardsmen and the
guardsman faces you would agree they were very scared.

A real man would realize that it was a terrible situation for all, the
students and the guardsmen. Both of them were put in that position due to
a failed attempt to wage a ill conceived war, that LBJ escalated. LBJ knew
the war was totally out of control, and for that reason he refused to accept
his parties nomination for presidency

This is from May4.org web site

May 2

On the morning of May 2, some KSU students assisted with the downtown
cleanup. Rumors of radical activities were widespread, and KSU's ROTC
building was believed to be the target of militant student actions that
evening. During the Vietnam War, students on many college campuses opposed
the presence of ROTC and often were successful in forcing the removal of
ROTC from their campuses. A dusk-to-dawn curfew was imposed on the city of
Kent, and students were restricted to the campus. At 5 p.m., shortly after
assessing the situation, Mayor Satrom alerted the Ohio National Guard. KSU
officials were unaware of this decision.
Shortly after 8 p.m., about 300 people gathered on the Commons, where a few
anti-war slogans were chanted and a few brief speeches given. An impromptu
march began and participants headed toward the dormitories to gain strength.
Large numbers of people joined the march.

The now 2,000 marchers swarmed down the hill over looking the Commons,
crossed the Commons. They then surrounded the ROTC building, an old wooden
World War II barracks which was scheduled to be demolished. Windows were
broken, and a few persons eventually set the building on fire.

Plain-clothed police who were standing nearby mce who were standing nearby
made no attempt to stop the students at this point. Firemen arrived on the
scene but their action were abandoned because some of the crowd attacked the
firemen and slashed their hoses. The blaze quickly died out.The firemen
eventually regained control and the fire died out.

The building was ignited again. This time, however, firemen arrived with
massive police protection. Police surrounded the building and dispersed the
students with tear gas. The firemen again got the tire under control. The
crowd then moved to the front of the campus and were astonished to see units
of the Ohio national Guard arriving on their campus. The students retreated
to the Commons to find the ROTC building smoldering at both ends. Within
minutes, the building was fully ablaze.

The crowd then assembled on the wooded hillside beside the Commons and
watched as the building burned. Many shouted anti-war and anti-ROTC slogans.
In the first two weeks of May, thirty ROTC buildings would be burned
nationwide.

Armed with tear gas and drawn bayonets, the Guard pursued students,
protesters and bystanders alike, into dormitories and other campus
buildings. Some stones were thrown and at least one student was bayoneted.
The question of who set the fire that destroyed ROTC building has never been
satisfactorily answered by any investigative body.



May 3

May 3rd was a relatively quiet day. By now, however, the campus was fully
occupied by Ohio National Guard troops, and armored personnel carriers were
stationed throughout the campus. Although some students and guardsmen
fraternized, the feeling, for the most part, was one of mutual hostility.
That morning, Ohio Governor James Rhodes, who was running for U.S. Senate,
arrived in Kent and along with city officials, held a news conference.
Rhodes, running on a "law and order" platform, attempted to use this
opportunity to garner votes in the primary election, which was only two days
away.
In a highly inflammatory speech, Rhodes claimed that the demonstrations at
Kent were the handiwork of a highly organized band of revolutionaries who
were out to "destroy higher education in Ohio." These protesters, Rhodes
declared, were "the worst type of people we harbor in America, worse than
the brown shirts and the communist element...we will use whatever force
necessary to drive them out of Kent!"

Later that evening, a National Guard commander would tell his troops that
Ohio law gave them the right to shoot if necessary. This merely served to
heighten guardsmen's hostility toward students.

Arity toward students.

Around 8 p.m., a crowd gathered on the Commons near the Victory bell. As the
group increased in size, Guard officials announced the immediate enforcement
of a new curfew. The crowd refused to disperse. At 9 p.m., the Ohio Riot Act
was read. Tear gas was fired from helicopters hovering overheard, and the
Guard dispersed the crowd from the area.

Students attempted to demonstrate that the curfew was unnecessary by
peacefully marching toward the town, but were met by guardsmen. Students
then staged a spontaneous sit-in at the intersection of East Main and
Lincoln streets and demanded that mayor Saytrom and KSU President Robert
White speak with them about the Guard's presence on campus. Assured that
this demand would be met, the crowd agreed to move from the street onto the
front lawn of the campus.

The Guard then betrayed the students and announced that the curfew would go
into effect immediately. Helicopters and tear gas were used to disperse the
demonstrators. As the crowd attempted to escape, some were bayoneted and
clubbed by the guardsmen. Students were again pursued and prodded back to
their dormitories. Tear gas inundated the campus, and helicopters with
searchlights hovered overheard all night.

,


May 4, 1970
At 11 a.m., about 200 students gathered on the Commons. Earlier that
morning, state and local officials had met in Kent. Some officials had
assumed that Gov. Rhodes had declared Martial law to be in effect * but he
had not. In fact, martial law was not officially declared until May 5.
Nevertheless, the National Guard resolved to disperse any assembly.

As noon approached, the size of the crowd increased to 1,500. Some were
merely spectators, while others had gathered specifically to protest the
invasion of Cambodia and the continued presence of the National Guard on the
campus. Upon orders of Ohio's Assistant Adjutant General Robert Canterbury,
an army jeep was driven in front of the assembled students. The students
were told by means of a bullhorn to disperse immediately. Students responded
with jeers and chants. When the students refused to disperse, Gen.
Canterbury ordered the guardsmen to disperse them. Approximately 116 men,
equipped with loaded M-1 rifles and tear gas, formed a skirmish-line toward
the students. Aware of the bayonet injuries of the previous evening,
students immediately ran away from the attacking National Guardsmen.
Retreating up Blanket Hill, some students lobbed tear some students lobbed
tear gas canisters back at the advancing troops, and one straggler was
attacked with clubs.

The Guard, after clearing the Commons, marched over the crest of the hill,
firing tear gas and scattering the students into a wider area. The Guard
then continued marching down the hill and onto a practice football field.
For approximately 10 minutes, the Guard stayed in this position. During this
time, tear gas canisters were thrown back and forth from the Guard's
position to a small group of students in the Prentice Hall parking at, about
100 yards away. Some students responded to the guardsmen's attack by
throwing stones. Guardsmen also threw stones at the students. But because of
the distance, most stones from both parties fell far short of their targets.
The vast majority of students, however, were spectators on the veranda of
Taylor Hall. While on the practice field, several members of Troop G which
would within minutes fire the fatal volley, knee and aimed their weapons at
the students in the parking lot.

Gen. Canterbury concluded that the crowd had been dispersed and ordered the
Guard to march back to the Commons area. Some members of Troop G then
huddled briefly. After reassembling on the field, the guardsmen seemed to
begin to retreat as they marched back up the hill retracing their previous
steps.

Members of Troop G, while advancing up the hill, continued to glance back to
the parking at, where the mos parking at, where the most militant and vocal
students were located. The students assumed the confrontation was over. Many
students began to walk to their next classes. As the Guard reached the crest
of the Blanket Hill, near the Pagoda of Taylor Hall, about a dozen members
of Troop G simultaneously turned around 180 degrees, aimed and fired their
weapons into the crowd in the Prentice Hall parking lot. The 1975 civil
trials proved that there was a verbal command to fire.

A total of 67 shots were fired in 13 seconds. Four students; Allison Krause,
Jeffrey Miller, Sandra Scheuer and William Schroeder were killed. Nine
students were wounded: Joseph Lewis, John Cleary, Thomas Grace, Robbie
Stamps, Donald Scott MacKenzie, Alan Canfora, Douglas Wrentmore, James
Russell and Dean Kahler. Of the wounded, one was permanently paralyzed and
several were seriously maimed. All were full-time students.


"Gould 0738" wrote in message
...
Harry are you talking about those bunch of scared kids who were

surrounded
by 1000's of anger protestor throwing rocks and bottles?


Oh, Christ!!!
Some things cannot be left unchallenged.
Aplogies in advance to all:

No. Harry is not talking about a group of scared kids "surrounded by

1000's of
anger (sic) protestors throwing rocks and bottles"

Shut off the Limbaugh show and do some acutal research on Kent State.

Think it
might be signfiicant that not a *single* guardsman was injured? Those

thousands
of protestors with rocks and bottles must have all been lousy shots. If no

t,
thousands of peope throwing rocks would have simply killed off the entire

squad
on the spot. The shooters were initially separated from the crowd by the

brow
of a hill, and had to
crest that hill in order to open fire. You must be very young.
Here are a few incidents related to Kent State and its aftermath to help

you
begin your liberation from propanganda and set you upon your quest for

truth.

May 3 Ohio Governor James A. Rhodes personally appears on campus and

promises
to use "every force possible" to maintain order. Rhodes denounces the
protesters as worse than brownshirts and vows to keep the Guard in Kent

"until
we get rid of them."

May 4 Four students are killed and nine others are wounded when a

contingent of
Guardsmen suddenly opens fire during a noontime demonstration.

July 23 Key portions of a secret Justice Department memo are disclosed by

the
Akron Beacon Journal. The memorandum describes the shootings as

unnecessary and
urges the Portage County Prosecutor to file criminal charges against six
Guardsmen.

October 4 The President's Commission on Campus Unrest concludes: "The

actions
of some students were violent and criminal and some others were dangerous,
reckless, and irresponsible." The shootings are branded as "unnecessary,
unwarranted, and inexcusable."

October 16 The "special" state grand jury exonerates the Guardsmen, but

indicts
25 individuals, mostly students, for a variety of offenses that occurred

on
campus before the shootings.

Late October-November Demands for a federal grand jury mount after it is
revealed that the "special" state grand jury ignored key evidence and that

one
of the "special" prosecutors told a newsman he felt the Guardsmen should

have
shot more students.

Following year:

The "special" state grand jury is even further discredited when Ohio

officials
dismiss charges against 20 of the 25 individuals indicted by the grand

jury.
Ohio prosecutors claimed they had insufficient evidence to convict any
protesters.

1973:

May 10 In a meeting with the student petitioners, K. William O'Connor, a
high-level Justice Department official, admits that the Justice Department
already has sufficient evidence to prosecute six Guardsmen.


A bit of truth leaks out:

August 3 Assistant Attorney General J. Stanley Pottinger announces that

the
Justice Department will officially conduct a new inquiry. Senator Birch

Bayh
follows Pottinger's announcement by releasing a letter he received from

one of
the Guard's company commanders. On the basis of that letter Bayh charges

that
armed FBI informant Terry Norman may have been "the fatal catalyst" for

the
tragedy.

NOTE: That letter was from one of the Guard's own company commanders, not

some
left wing apologist.

1974:

October 7-17 Attorneys for James A. Rhodes unsuccessfully try to block the
release of Rhodes's deposition in the civil case until after the Ohio
gubernatorial election. The deposition reveals that Rhodes's attorney, in

a
move reminiscent of the Watergate cover-up, offered into evidence an

incomplete
transcript of Rhodes's May 3, 1970, press conference. Among the remarks

deleted
was a comment by an official that the Guard would resort to shooting if
necessary.


Etc, etc, etc,


Now, other than "Everybody knows" and/or "I heard on Fox News, Hannity, or
Limbaugh" what facts can you cite that support your allegation that

thousands
of angry protestors surrounded the troops and pelted them with rocks and
bottles?

Those innocent kids exercising their First Amendment Rights don't deserve

to
have their memories villified, especially when there isn't a shred of

evidence
supporting the wild allegation.

A real man would apologize for such a slanderous error.




Doug Kanter April 23rd 04 02:29 AM

( OT ) In Search Of A Plan
 
"John Smith" wrote in message
news:gZXhc.5422$IW1.488827@attbi_s52...
Harry are you talking about those bunch of scared kids who were surrounded
by 1000's of anger protestor throwing rocks and bottles? Unfortunately a
small group of the guardsmen feeling in danger of their life, freaked out
and shot into the crowd trying to disperse the angry students.

You should not be angry at the guardsmen, you should be upset at LBJ who
sent young Americans to an war that we could never win. If LBJ had not
escalated the war, the protestors would not have threaten the guardsmen,

and
the guardsmen would have been home with their family.

You do seem to make a habit of placing the blame on the wrong people.


Here we go again: Lights on, nobody home. Truman authorized the war in
Vietnam.



Doug Kanter April 23rd 04 02:31 AM

( OT ) In Search Of A Plan
 
"John H" wrote in message
...


Has Hannity or Limbaugh discussed this recently? You must listen to them a

lot
more than I, Chuck, as I don't recall anything about this matter. Of

course, I
focus a lot more on Mr Colmes. :)


John, I have to tell you something. Sit down. This is serious.

Are you ready?

Really ready?

You are a corpse.



Gould 0738 April 23rd 04 02:50 AM

( OT ) In Search Of A Plan
 
No apologies necessary. Harry needs all the help he can get now. His
credibility
seems to have taken a big hit.

John H


I'm not standing up for Harry. He makes his own bed here, and enjoys the abuse.

I'm protesting the vile, hateful, inaccurate misrepresentation of a tragic
incident.
Most National Guardsmen would have never shot into a crowd of protestors, but
some did. Trying after all these years to characterize the tragedy as a case of
the Guardsmen acting in self defense is pure
BS.

Hell, even the NIXON administration concluded the shootings were "inexcusable".
Is Nixon suddenly too liberal for our politically conservative sect?



John Smith April 23rd 04 02:54 AM

( OT ) In Search Of A Plan
 
Doug,

Do you have a problem comprehending English? I said LBJ "escalated the war.

As far as your other comment about Truman, Truman did provide financial
assistance to the French and provided a few military advisors (35 in 1950)
to help train the Vietnamese troops, but it was the French-Indochina War
until May, 1954. Truman's presidency ended before the French had withdrawn
from Vietnam.

Please turn on the lights.


"Doug Kanter" wrote in message
...
"John Smith" wrote in message
news:gZXhc.5422$IW1.488827@attbi_s52...
Harry are you talking about those bunch of scared kids who were

surrounded
by 1000's of anger protestor throwing rocks and bottles? Unfortunately

a
small group of the guardsmen feeling in danger of their life, freaked

out
and shot into the crowd trying to disperse the angry students.

You should not be angry at the guardsmen, you should be upset at LBJ who
sent young Americans to an war that we could never win. If LBJ had not
escalated the war, the protestors would not have threaten the guardsmen,

and
the guardsmen would have been home with their family.

You do seem to make a habit of placing the blame on the wrong people.


Here we go again: Lights on, nobody home. Truman authorized the war in
Vietnam.






All times are GMT +1. The time now is 04:25 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com