BoatBanter.com

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)
-   General (https://www.boatbanter.com/general/)
-   -   Manatees in court (https://www.boatbanter.com/general/3409-manatees-court.html)

Capt Frank Hopkins March 3rd 04 04:09 AM

Manatees in court
 
2 Florida counties filed intent to sue Federal Fish and Wildlife over new
manatee zones. The suit alleges the zones are unnecessarily restrictive to
local users and instituted based on unsound science.

Duval and St. Johns counties claim old boundaries worked they way they
were intended and draconian limits on the usage of the river are
unnecessary. "We will not waste any more time on fruitless and unproductive
dialog," states official.

The save the manatee club based in Maitland, FL, commented they have spent
thousands of dollars to prove the limits are absolutely required.

Dr. Carole DeMort, State Marine Biologist and Marine Biology Department
Chair for University of North Florida said " I can't imagine how the Save
The Manatee Club arrived at their scientific evaluation of the number of
manatees killed annually. Using their model, manatees became extinct 12
years ago." "The manatee has made a great recovery in the past 10 years.
Their numbers have grown from an perhaps 3000 in 1980 to an estimated 40,000
state wide. Their species status should be changed from endangered to
threatened." It is only natural, that with so many more creatures, more will
interact with boats and other portions of technology.





--
Capt. Frank

__c
\ _ | \_
__\_| oooo \_____
~~~~|______________/ ~~~~~
www.home.earthlink.net/~aartworks




Florida Keyz March 3rd 04 04:18 AM

Manatees in court
 
Are you sure on that number, 40,000?
I have been hearing much lower number, but no longer endangered.

DSK March 3rd 04 11:56 AM

Manatees in court
 
Capt Frank Hopkins wrote:

2 Florida counties filed intent to sue Federal Fish and Wildlife over new
manatee zones. The suit alleges the zones are unnecessarily restrictive to
local users and instituted based on unsound science.

Duval and St. Johns counties claim old boundaries worked they way they
were intended and draconian limits on the usage of the river are
unnecessary. "We will not waste any more time on fruitless and unproductive
dialog," states official.

The save the manatee club based in Maitland, FL, commented they have spent
thousands of dollars to prove the limits are absolutely required.


They would have been better off spending the money to buy Kevlar jackets for the
manatees. If everyone who hit a manatee broke their prop and/or destroyed their
lower unit, instead of merely injuring the animal, then the need for slowing
down (or not) would be obvious... and wouldn't need law enforcement.

Fair Skies-
Doug King


Don White March 3rd 04 02:00 PM

Manatees in court
 
Some kind of governor on the throttle that could be activated within a mile
or so of land might also be worthwhile.
After all, the problem isn't the manatees..but the yahoo cowboys who want to
roar around wasting precious non-renewable
energy sources.



Calif Bill March 3rd 04 06:42 PM

Manatees in court
 

"Don White" wrote in message
...
Some kind of governor on the throttle that could be activated within a

mile
or so of land might also be worthwhile.
After all, the problem isn't the manatees..but the yahoo cowboys who want

to
roar around wasting precious non-renewable
energy sources.



How much non-renewable resources does it take to make a 50' sailboat? And
to replace the sails.



Don White March 3rd 04 09:09 PM

Manatees in court
 

Calif Bill wrote in message news:qGp1c.19797
How much non-renewable resources does it take to make a 50' sailboat? And
to replace the sails.



Sailboats are in a whole different category...at one with nature..quiet yet
beautiful.
I think the gov't should offer a tax deduction to encourage sailboat buyers
and discourage power.



Doug Kanter March 3rd 04 09:14 PM

Manatees in court
 
"Don White" wrote in message
...

Calif Bill wrote in message

news:qGp1c.19797
How much non-renewable resources does it take to make a 50' sailboat?

And
to replace the sails.



Sailboats are in a whole different category...at one with nature..quiet

yet
beautiful.
I think the gov't should offer a tax deduction to encourage sailboat

buyers
and discourage power.



Whoah...cowboy. Can't do that. That particular money is reserved for people
who buy Hummers.



JGK March 3rd 04 09:29 PM

Manatees in court
 
What is the cost in renewable resources for all the cars waiting in line as
the draw bridge opens so that you can get the last 3 feet of your mast
through? Sail boater ought to be charged a service fee for each opening of
a bridge.

"Don White" wrote in message
...

Calif Bill wrote in message

news:qGp1c.19797
How much non-renewable resources does it take to make a 50' sailboat?

And
to replace the sails.



Sailboats are in a whole different category...at one with nature..quiet

yet
beautiful.
I think the gov't should offer a tax deduction to encourage sailboat

buyers
and discourage power.





NOYB March 3rd 04 10:00 PM

Manatees in court
 

"Capt Frank Hopkins" wrote in message
link.net...

" I can't imagine how the Save
The Manatee Club arrived at their scientific evaluation of the number of
manatees killed annually. Using their model, manatees became extinct 12
years ago."


Hehehe



NOYB March 3rd 04 10:02 PM

Manatees in court
 

"Don White" wrote in message
...
Some kind of governor on the throttle that could be activated within a

mile
or so of land



Great idea. Let's just shut down the entire ICW on the East and West
Coasts, too, while we're at it!

Putz.




NOYB March 3rd 04 10:04 PM

Manatees in court
 

"Don White" wrote in message
...

Calif Bill wrote in message

news:qGp1c.19797
How much non-renewable resources does it take to make a 50' sailboat?

And
to replace the sails.



Sailboats are in a whole different category...at one with nature..quiet

yet
beautiful.
I think the gov't should offer a tax deduction to encourage sailboat

buyers
and discourage power.


I think *your* government should. Our government is happy the way things
are.



NOYB March 3rd 04 10:05 PM

Manatees in court
 

"JGK" wrote in message
...
Sail boater ought to be charged a service fee for each opening of
a bridge.


Excellent idea.



Calif Bill March 3rd 04 11:51 PM

Manatees in court
 

"Don White" wrote in message
...

Calif Bill wrote in message

news:qGp1c.19797
How much non-renewable resources does it take to make a 50' sailboat?

And
to replace the sails.



Sailboats are in a whole different category...at one with nature..quiet

yet
beautiful.
I think the gov't should offer a tax deduction to encourage sailboat

buyers
and discourage power.



30,000 pounds of renewable energy products and 10,000 pounds of lead
leaching into the waters. Should ban them. Wooden, dugout canoes that
warrants a tax credit.
Bill



LaBomba182 March 4th 04 12:26 AM

Manatees in court
 
Subject: Manatees in court
From: "Don White"


Sailboats are in a whole different category...at one with nature..quiet yet
beautiful.
I think the gov't should offer a tax deduction to encourage sailboat buyers
and discourage power.


ROTFLMAO!!!!!

Now that was funny!

Capt. Bill

LaBomba182 March 4th 04 12:28 AM

Manatees in court
 
Subject: Manatees in court
From: "Capt Frank Hopkins"


"The manatee has made a great recovery in the past 10 years.
Their numbers have grown from an perhaps 3000 in 1980 to an estimated 40,000
state wide.


Is that 40,000 number your misprint or theirs?

Capt. Bill

Backyard Renegade March 4th 04 12:31 AM

Manatees in court
 
"Calif Bill" wrote in message thlink.net...
"Don White" wrote in message
...
Some kind of governor on the throttle that could be activated within a

mile
or so of land might also be worthwhile.
After all, the problem isn't the manatees..but the yahoo cowboys who want

to
roar around wasting precious non-renewable
energy sources.



How much non-renewable resources does it take to make a 50' sailboat? And
to replace the sails.


Really, my boat is made of wood and runs on an 8 horse engine. Most
sailboats are made with more petrolium based products than I will use
boating in a lifetime. Not to mention, many folks who own these larger
sailboats also have 3-4000 sq foot homes, jet around the country in
747's, and run indoor swimming pools, and drive SUV's. Admittedly not
all of them do, but if you sail and fall into three or more of these
catagories, you should lay off the non-renewable resources bull****.
Scotty

Bert Robbins March 4th 04 12:55 AM

Manatees in court
 

"Don White" wrote in message
...

Calif Bill wrote in message

news:qGp1c.19797
How much non-renewable resources does it take to make a 50' sailboat?

And
to replace the sails.



Sailboats are in a whole different category...at one with nature..quiet

yet
beautiful.
I think the gov't should offer a tax deduction to encourage sailboat

buyers
and discourage power.


Where do all forms of plastic come from? Oil.

Your rag merchant sales display couldn't have ever come into being without
oil.

Bert



Florida Keyz March 4th 04 02:39 AM

Manatees in court
 
I am assuming most of you have not experiences boating with Mantatees. I have
been doing it sucessfully for 25 years.

Imagine, trying to avoid an animal that unless you know the signs, you can NOT
avoid, imagine even if you do know the signs, you may still kill him. Even in
Clear water 6 foot deep.

This is the reality of boating with manatees in this area.

How the hell do you prevent hitting them?

Avoid hitting an annimal that Is not from Florida, does not belong here, is not
endangered, and had taken over your voting, boating, and docking (building )
rights.

Just not right! my opinion Damn it!
Sterling


Harry Krause March 4th 04 02:43 AM

Manatees in court
 
Florida Keyz wrote:


Avoid hitting an annimal that Is not from Florida, does not belong here, is not
endangered, and had taken over your voting rights...


Indeed, if you are in Florida and you hit George w. Bush, you will be in
serious trouble.

Don White March 4th 04 03:02 AM

Manatees in court
 

Harry Krause wrote in message
...
Scotty, you see, has a doctorate in sociology and statistical research,
and has conducted several surveys before proclaiming that most larger
sailboats are owned by folks with larger houses who also have 747s,
indoor swimming pools and SUVs.

Me, I think he drinks out of the varnish cup.


Wow, I was packing for a move to the USA. If that's the lifestyle of the
average American sailor.....the one's up here would be poor country cousins
by comparison.



Don White March 4th 04 03:05 AM

Manatees in court
 

NOYB wrote in message
hlink.net...

Great idea. Let's just shut down the entire ICW on the East and West
Coasts, too, while we're at it!

Putz.


From what I read in here, it's almost that way already.



Bchbound March 4th 04 03:44 AM

Manatees in court
 
In article .net,
says...
2 Florida counties filed intent to sue Federal Fish and Wildlife over new
manatee zones. The suit alleges the zones are unnecessarily restrictive to
local users and instituted based on unsound science.

Duval and St. Johns counties claim old boundaries worked they way they
were intended and draconian limits on the usage of the river are
unnecessary. "We will not waste any more time on fruitless and unproductive
dialog," states official.

The save the manatee club based in Maitland, FL, commented they have spent
thousands of dollars to prove the limits are absolutely required.

Dr. Carole DeMort, State Marine Biologist and Marine Biology Department
Chair for University of North Florida said " I can't imagine how the Save
The Manatee Club arrived at their scientific evaluation of the number of
manatees killed annually. Using their model, manatees became extinct 12
years ago." "The manatee has made a great recovery in the past 10 years.
Their numbers have grown from an perhaps 3000 in 1980 to an estimated 40,000
state wide. Their species status should be changed from endangered to
threatened." It is only natural, that with so many more creatures, more will
interact with boats and other portions of technology.





--
Capt. Frank

__c
\ _ | \_
__\_| oooo \_____
~~~~|______________/ ~~~~~
www.home.earthlink.net/~aartworks




Survival of the fittest.. Enough said!!

Doug Kanter March 4th 04 05:56 AM

Manatees in court
 
"Florida Keyz" wrote in message
...

Avoid hitting an annimal that Is not from Florida, does not belong here,

is not
endangered, and had taken over your voting, boating, and docking

(building )
rights.


Believe me when I tell you that I try very hard to see both sides of this
issue, especially since I don't know a lot about it. But "does not belong
here"? Wherever they are, they're there for a reason, so you may as well
adjust as much as possible. It sounds like you try.



Doug Kanter March 4th 04 05:57 AM

Manatees in court
 
"NOYB" wrote in message
link.net...

"Don White" wrote in message
...

Calif Bill wrote in message

news:qGp1c.19797
How much non-renewable resources does it take to make a 50' sailboat?

And
to replace the sails.



Sailboats are in a whole different category...at one with nature..quiet

yet
beautiful.
I think the gov't should offer a tax deduction to encourage sailboat

buyers
and discourage power.


I think *your* government should. Our government is happy the way things
are.



Actually, our government doesn't KNOW where it is. :-) A tax break for
buying light trucks? Hello???



Florida Keyz March 4th 04 04:32 PM

Manatees in court
 
When I said manatee do not belong here, is because there were inported from
West India to miami to eat the plants clogging the cannals.

Doug Kanter March 4th 04 04:41 PM

Manatees in court
 
"Florida Keyz" wrote in message
...
When I said manatee do not belong here, is because there were inported

from
West India to miami to eat the plants clogging the cannals.


OK, but so what? They're here. If you move to a new neighborhood and the
locals don't like your family, is it OK for them to run you down with their
cars? :-)



Florida Keyz March 4th 04 05:49 PM

Manatees in court
 
your arguments are childish, probably from you lack of experience, and bogus
email name.

Bill,Your a coward, hiding behind it. but then,,,,that figures.

Guess I asked for it, trying to post on topic, with factual information,
instead of grade school banter.







Terry Spragg March 4th 04 06:01 PM

Manatees in court
 
Doug Kanter wrote:

"Florida Keyz" wrote in message
...


Avoid hitting an annimal that Is not from Florida, does not belong here,


is not

endangered, and had taken over your voting, boating, and docking


(building )

rights.



Believe me when I tell you that I try very hard to see both sides of this
issue, especially since I don't know a lot about it. But "does not belong
here"? Wherever they are, they're there for a reason, so you may as well
adjust as much as possible. It sounds like you try.


They are there because they can. They eat a particular type of sea
plant which otherwise quickly fills shallow water so it is unuseable
by boats, power and sail. I believe the plant is an exotic import,
like zebra mussels are. Manatees are the only way to control the
Japanese sea cabbage, or whatever it is.

To be cynical, the only reason they need protecting is so that
waters attractive to boats remain open.

Mind you, they also destroy habitat for young fish, who find shelter
from predators in the weeds, and snails to eat, or something that
lives on the weed. I forget the names of all the interacting organisms.

That's why its called ecology, because it's complex.

Who is to define the "Proper natural balance?"

What will we eat when the little fish do thier thing, or don't?

Speed should be regulated according to depth. Who's in a hurry,
anyway, and why?

Terry K


Terry Spragg March 4th 04 06:04 PM

Manatees in court
 
Doug Kanter wrote:

"NOYB" wrote in message
link.net...

"Don White" wrote in message
...

Calif Bill wrote in message


news:qGp1c.19797

How much non-renewable resources does it take to make a 50' sailboat?


And

to replace the sails.



Sailboats are in a whole different category...at one with nature..quiet
yet beautiful.


I think the gov't should offer a tax deduction to encourage sailboat
buyers and discourage power.


I think *your* government should. Our government is happy the way things
are.


Actually, our government doesn't KNOW where it is. :-) A tax break for
buying light trucks? Hello???


Relaxed emission and economy regulations for light trucks? Hello?

That's like a discount for high rate of fire guns and ammo. Goodbye?

Terry K


Greg March 4th 04 06:20 PM

Manatees in court
 
The reason these laws keep getting thrown out is they don't use any science to
determine what the speed limit should be.
Around here they have the 25MPH zones exactly where you are most likely to hit
a manatee and it is "slow" speed where you seldom ever see one. That is what
happens when you have knee jerk polititians making these rules.

Doug Kanter March 4th 04 07:02 PM

Manatees in court
 
"Terry Spragg" wrote in message
able.rogers.com...

Speed should be regulated according to depth. Who's in a hurry,
anyway, and why?


Guys with leeetle tiny pee-pees. :-)



Doug Kanter March 4th 04 07:03 PM

Manatees in court
 
"Terry Spragg" wrote in message
able.rogers.com...
Doug Kanter wrote:

"NOYB" wrote in message
link.net...

"Don White" wrote in message
...

Calif Bill wrote in message

news:qGp1c.19797

How much non-renewable resources does it take to make a 50' sailboat?

And

to replace the sails.



Sailboats are in a whole different category...at one with nature..quiet
yet beautiful.


I think the gov't should offer a tax deduction to encourage sailboat
buyers and discourage power.


I think *your* government should. Our government is happy the way

things
are.


Actually, our government doesn't KNOW where it is. :-) A tax break for
buying light trucks? Hello???


Relaxed emission and economy regulations for light trucks? Hello?

That's like a discount for high rate of fire guns and ammo. Goodbye?


So THAT'S why I can't find discounts on full cases of ammo! There's no law
suggesting such discounts?



Florida Keyz March 4th 04 09:07 PM

Manatees in court
 
ust answer the questions, coward!

BB


Just answer what?

John H March 4th 04 09:34 PM

Manatees in court
 
On Thu, 04 Mar 2004 19:02:07 GMT, "Doug Kanter"
wrote:

"Terry Spragg" wrote in message
. cable.rogers.com...

Speed should be regulated according to depth. Who's in a hurry,
anyway, and why?


Guys with leeetle tiny pee-pees. :-)

Or enlarged prostates and no holding tank!

John H

On the 'Poco Loco' out of Deale, MD
on the beautiful Chesapeake Bay!

Harry Krause March 4th 04 09:37 PM

Manatees in court
 
John H wrote:


Or enlarged prostates and no holding tank!

John H


No wonder you are so ****y.

Paul Schilter March 4th 04 10:52 PM

Manatees in court
 
Doug,
Good idea, that would also help them out with possible shark attacks.
:-) How it may not be politically correct, but have you given any thought to
mines! Now I realize that a few manatees would have to make the ultimate
sacrifice, but the rest of the herd would be better off for it. I mean after
a few boats blew up, EVERYBODY would slow down. Hey, you know, if this idea
takes off I'm going to invest in companies that make sonar gear. :-)
Paul

"DSK" wrote in message
...
snipped
They would have been better off spending the money to buy Kevlar jackets

for the
manatees. If everyone who hit a manatee broke their prop and/or destroyed

their
lower unit, instead of merely injuring the animal, then the need for

slowing
down (or not) would be obvious... and wouldn't need law enforcement.

Fair Skies-
Doug King




Paul Schilter March 4th 04 10:53 PM

Manatees in court
 
Don,
Land mines and water don't mix. Ya need to get the underwater mines. :-)
Paul

"Don White" wrote in message
...
Some kind of governor on the throttle that could be activated within a

mile
or so of land might also be worthwhile.
After all, the problem isn't the manatees..but the yahoo cowboys who want

to
roar around wasting precious non-renewable
energy sources.





Paul Schilter March 4th 04 11:04 PM

Manatees in court
 
Doug,
Off course not. Stay on topic.:-) Cars no! Now with boats, it's okay.
Paul

"Doug Kanter" wrote in message
...
"Florida Keyz" wrote in message
...
When I said manatee do not belong here, is because there were inported

from
West India to miami to eat the plants clogging the cannals.


OK, but so what? They're here. If you move to a new neighborhood and the
locals don't like your family, is it OK for them to run you down with

their
cars? :-)





Don White March 4th 04 11:40 PM

Manatees in court
 

Paul Schilter paulschilter@comcast,dot,net wrote in message
...
Don,
Land mines and water don't mix. Ya need to get the underwater mines.

:-)
Paul

Another neat trick would be miniature submarines built like the original
Nautilus form 20,000 Leagues Under fame.
I like that jagged battering ram they used to sink wood ships.
Suppose they would work on speeding fiberglass boats?



John H March 4th 04 11:55 PM

Manatees in court
 
On Thu, 04 Mar 2004 16:37:48 -0500, Harry Krause
wrote:

John H wrote:


Or enlarged prostates and no holding tank!

John H


No wonder you are so ****y.


Ewwwh, that hurt!

John H

On the 'Poco Loco' out of Deale, MD
on the beautiful Chesapeake Bay!


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 05:56 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com