The Seahunt Escape 175 or the Boston Whaler 170 Montauk. The Seahunt has
more "cushioned" seating where as the Boston Whaler is an obvious workhorse.
Primary use will be just cruising along in the lake and ocean off of Rhode
Island. Not much in the way of fishing but I want people on board to be
comfortable. Any thoughts?

On Wed, 18 Feb 2004 18:45:12 -0500, "blahb" wrote:

The Seahunt Escape 175 or the Boston Whaler 170 Montauk. The Seahunt has
more "cushioned" seating where as the Boston Whaler is an obvious workhorse.
Primary use will be just cruising along in the lake and ocean off of Rhode
Island. Not much in the way of fishing but I want people on board to be
comfortable. Any thoughts?

The Montauk hands down. The Seahunt is a good boat, but form, fit and
function, the Whaler is the better boat.

For the waters you will be running in, I assume the Bay and adjacent
waters, the Montauk is a much more capable boat.

If you are looking for comfortable rides, you might want to consider
something like the 18 Ventura from Whaler or similar type boat. It's a
capable boat, considerate of passengers and at the same time has some
sea run capability which would allow you to get outside the Bay and
run around a little on good days.

Later,

Tom
S. Woodstock, CT
----------

"Fisherman are born honest, but they get
over it." - Ed Zern

"blahb" wrote in message
...
The Seahunt Escape 175 or the Boston Whaler 170 Montauk. The Seahunt has
more "cushioned" seating where as the Boston Whaler is an obvious
workhorse.
Primary use will be just cruising along in the lake and ocean off of Rhode
Island. Not much in the way of fishing but I want people on board to be
comfortable. Any thoughts?

There's not even a doubt. Go with the Whaler.

Yeah, don't buy a boston whaler.. they're a fishing boat : )


-j
"blahb" wrote in message
...
The Seahunt Escape 175 or the Boston Whaler 170 Montauk. The Seahunt has
more "cushioned" seating where as the Boston Whaler is an obvious
workhorse.
Primary use will be just cruising along in the lake and ocean off of Rhode
Island. Not much in the way of fishing but I want people on board to be
comfortable. Any thoughts?

Far as I can tell, someone wrote:
The Seahunt Escape 175 or the Boston Whaler 170 Montauk. The Seahunt has
more "cushioned" seating where as the Boston Whaler is an obvious workhorse.
Primary use will be just cruising along in the lake and ocean off of Rhode
Island. Not much in the way of fishing but I want people on board to be
comfortable.

The Montauk is NOT a comfortable boat. It's a good boat, but it isn't a
comfortable boat.

"Petey the Wonder Dog" wrote in message
...
Far as I can tell, someone wrote:
The Seahunt Escape 175 or the Boston Whaler 170 Montauk. The Seahunt has
more "cushioned" seating where as the Boston Whaler is an obvious
workhorse.
Primary use will be just cruising along in the lake and ocean off of
Rhode
Island. Not much in the way of fishing but I want people on board to be
comfortable.

The Montauk is NOT a comfortable boat. It's a good boat, but it isn't a
comfortable boat.

Petey,
You're referring to the older montauks...not the new Montauk 170. It's a
bigger, wider, smoother-riding, and more comfortable boat.

I looked closely at it before buying a mid-90's Outrage 17. My boat was the
second-to-last year that Whaler sold a non-Commercial Brad
Dougherty-designed hull. Dougherty now makes Edgewater boats...which is
another 17' boat blahb should look at.

On Sat, 21 Feb 2004 13:14:37 GMT, "NOYB" wrote:


"Petey the Wonder Dog" wrote in message
.. .
Far as I can tell, someone wrote:
The Seahunt Escape 175 or the Boston Whaler 170 Montauk. The Seahunt has
more "cushioned" seating where as the Boston Whaler is an obvious
workhorse.
Primary use will be just cruising along in the lake and ocean off of
Rhode
Island. Not much in the way of fishing but I want people on board to be
comfortable.

The Montauk is NOT a comfortable boat. It's a good boat, but it isn't a
comfortable boat.

Petey,
You're referring to the older montauks...not the new Montauk 170. It's a
bigger, wider, smoother-riding, and more comfortable boat.

I looked closely at it before buying a mid-90's Outrage 17. My boat was the
second-to-last year that Whaler sold a non-Commercial Brad
Dougherty-designed hull. Dougherty now makes Edgewater boats...which is
another 17' boat blahb should look at.

Here's another thought - wonder why I didn't mention this the other
day.

You might want to look at Polar boats. While they are new to the
market in terms of fiberglass boats, they appear to have built one
hell of a center console. Well made, everything fits, solid as a rock
and the ride is beautiful and dry. Prices are very competitive with
boats like Edgewater and Whaler.

As in all things, five years down the road, they might not even exist,
but Godfrey Marine has been around for a while so the probability is
that they might not go away.

Later,

Tom
S. Woodstock, CT
----------

Basic Fishing Program:

10 - Fish
20 - Eat
30 - Sleep
40 - Goto 10