|
Religious Craziness Sends Man Back to Jail
|
Religious Craziness Sends Man Back to Jail
On 29 Aug 2013 16:08:26 GMT, F.O.A.D. wrote:
iBoaterer wrote: In article , says... On 8/29/13 9:42 AM, iBoaterer wrote: In article , says... On 8/29/13 8:48 AM, iBoaterer wrote: In article , says... On 8/28/13 11:57 PM, wrote: On Wed, 28 Aug 2013 17:40:56 -0400, "F.O.A.D." wrote: On 8/28/13 5:35 PM, wrote: OK your turn. Show me some peer reviewed studies about the 10 year success of "rehab". I'm sure you can do your own lit search. Have at it. I have not found any reliable study that says any significant number of substance abusers come out of rehab, therapy or any or any other program with a 10 year success rate. There are a few people selling rehab who say they have amazing success rates but they are selling something, not doing research. It was your contention I was wrong. Prove it. I would accept 25% as a win for you if it was a real study that actually tracked patients for any significant amount of time. (not just people who stopped coming back) I only have to look at the half million or more addicted homeless to see all is not going well in paradise. That does not include those dis functionals who are living with friends or family. Then you have the addicts who are working at some level of functionality and the high functioning addicts. Once again, you are exhibiting an inability to think abstractly. Drug addiction is not an illness like, oh, the usual childhood diseases that can be prevented by an inoculation or that caught once, tend not to haunt you again. Drug addiction treatment, once administered, does not mean the individual who receives it has lifetime or even 10-year protection from a relapse. Drug addiction is a chronic disease, and it can be managed properly and successfully. But relapses are more than possible, as they are with other chronic medical illnesses, such as asthma or hypertension. And because there are strong possibilities of relapses with drug addiction doesn't mean treatment is a failure. As with other chronic illnesses, treatment for drug addiction necessitates lifetime evaluation and perhaps modifications when necessary. If you suffer from diabetes, proper treatment can help you get it under control and most of the symptoms will disappear, and the treatment is successful. What happens if you discontinue treatment for your chronic disease? It probably returns and you have a relapse. When a drug addict relapses, it doesn't necessarily mean the treatment he is receiving (or ignoring) has failed. It may just mean the treatment needs to be re-started or changed. Many people with certain mental/emotional illnesses get relief with a combination of medications and therapy that help them feel better and regain control of their lives. Some of those illnesses will require patients to take medications for the rest of their lives. After a while on meds, though, some patients talk themselves into believing they are "cured," so they stop the medications. So, what happens? In many cases the symptoms of the mental/emotional illness returns. Oh, and once again, 12-step programs are not treatment?they provide support. Wait!!!! YOU said that once an addict always an addict was hyperbole. Now you are saying it's a "chronic disease that can be managed..." Which is it? I don't believe calling someone who is having success at controlling a substance abuse problem a "junkie" adds anything to the discussion. What would you like to call them? Frank, Joe, Debbie, whatever. Or '****head' or 'conservatrash' or "whine" or some such? Substance abuse is a medical condition; being conservatrash Is a choice! ? The effects of substance abuse may be a medical condition. The actual abuse is a choice - made in the head - just as was your choice to abuse the federal income tax system. I suppose you'll say that any decision is a psychological, and therefore medical, condition. But, that will be more bull****. John (Gun Nut) H. -- Hope you're having a great day! |
Religious Craziness Sends Man Back to Jail
|
Religious Craziness Sends Man Back to Jail
On Thu, 29 Aug 2013 13:23:31 -0400, "F.O.A.D." wrote:
On 8/29/13 1:12 PM, wrote: On Thu, 29 Aug 2013 09:24:04 -0400, BAR wrote: In article , says... Oh, and once again, 12-step programs are not treatment?they provide support. The interesting thing is that the 12 step programs have a higher "success" rate than the institutional or non 12 step programs. I know several people who have been in 12 step programs and they have been sober for 15 and 20 years. They were never institutionalized, they never received "professional" help with their addiction. People have to want to change and forceing them to change or trying to modify their behavior isn't going to succeed. I believe that is because of the support component that Harry dismisses in such a cavalier way. I don't dismiss support programs for substance abusers. Once again, apparently, you cannot comprehend what you read. What I did say is that the religious-osity, as it were, of 12-step programs, is offputting to a substantial percentage of substance abusers. There is significant published criticism for various reasons of 12-step programs. .....especially when you consider all the 'published criticism' you've posted right here. John (Gun Nut) H. -- Hope you're having a great day! |
Religious Craziness Sends Man Back to Jail
In article ,
says... On Wed, 28 Aug 2013 21:31:08 -0400, "Mr. Luddite" wrote: "Tim" wrote in message ... On Wednesday, August 28, 2013 11:12:24 AM UTC-5, F.O.A.D. wrote: On 8/28/13 11:22 AM, wrote: The religious underpinnings and overlay of 12-step programs are off-putting for many addicts. A lot of people simply don't want religion shoved down their throats. There's a lot of substance/alcohol abusers who while in the `12-step' programs , follow the religious overtones closely. --------------------- Last year when I was involved with a family member's rehab and first steps with recovery I got a copy of the "Big Book" to read what the 12 step thing was all about. I had never heard of the "Big Book" and had only heard about the "12 step program" in the form of jokes. I had no clue what they actually were. Pretty naïve I guess for a guy my age. I confess that I didn't read the Big Book cover to cover, but I read enough to get the history, ideas and concepts. I didn't think it overly pushes religion at all, and certainly doesn't push any particular theology. I got the it really doesn't care what you believe in as long as you acknowledge that there are bigger things in the universe than yourselves. I was also fortunate to have several people who I had met (mostly through the guitar shop) who confided their status as recovering addicts to me. Prior to that I had no idea. They helped me and my wife deal with my family member's addiction and explained their respective adaptations of and implementation of the 12 step program as it applied to them . Some took it more literally than others, but it seemed to benefit them all. I certainly don't think it "shoves" religion down anyone's throats. AA pushes the concept of a 'higher power', which may be different for different folks. The higher power may be God, for those who believe, or it may be peer pressure from the group, or maybe just a 'big brother'. One thing is for sure, the success of AA groups does not put a lot of money into the pockets of psychologists. However, many hospitals for those needing psychological treatment also have an AA group on the premises. (That is also true for many military hospitals.) John (Gun Nut) H. Okay, Bill W. |
Religious Craziness Sends Man Back to Jail
In article ,
says... On Thu, 29 Aug 2013 08:52:17 -0400, iBoaterer wrote: In article , says... On 8/28/2013 11:28 PM, Wayne.B wrote: On Wed, 28 Aug 2013 21:31:08 -0400, "Mr. Luddite" wrote: I got the it really doesn't care what you believe in as long as you acknowledge that there are bigger things in the universe than yourselves. === That's an important first step. Literally, the more we learn about the universe, the stranger it becomes. It is doubtful to me that we will ever understand the whole enchilada since new layers of the onion always seem to appear as the old ones are peeled away. Some choose to explain it with science, others with religion. In the end it may not make any difference but I lean towards science. Ha, I believe God *is* a Scientist... of sorts.... chew on that:) What are some of God's scientific breakthroughs? Here. Ponder. http://tinyurl.com/6ddknwj Not a 'Dip**** Test' either. John (Gun Nut) H. Wow, I looked the whole thing over and didn't see any mention of a "God". Could you point that out, please? |
Religious Craziness Sends Man Back to Jail
In article ,
says... On Thu, 29 Aug 2013 09:44:00 -0400, iBoaterer wrote: In article , says... The interesting thing is that the 12 step programs have a higher "success" rate than the institutional or non 12 step programs. I know several people who have been in 12 step programs and they have been sober for 15 and 20 years. They were never institutionalized, they never received "professional" help with their addiction. People have to want to change and forceing them to change or trying to modify their behavior isn't going to succeed. Cite? It is going to be hard. I looked at this for about 4 hours last night. I can find hundreds of articles saying THEIR program works "X"% of the time (with questionable stats) but it is very hard to find any actual studies that track the people in a verifiable case study. Places like CDC and NIH where you would expect this to happen don't seem to be doing it. The studies where they are actually looking at particular therapies seen to show pretty dismal results and the longest term study I saw was that methadone deal. They tried to polish that turd but the numbers expose the truth. Over half the patients were using illegal drugs 18 months in, while still in therapy. 12 step, particularly AA, does seem to work as long as the person stays in the program but a lot of people simply walk away and they still may fall off the wagon occasionally. The question is whether they try to get back on. I have been to a few meetings as a visitor and it is an interesting process. There is a certain religious component but it is far from the main driver of the program. They are really trying to say this is YOUR problem and YOU have to fix it. Then they give you some tools. They don't seem to care which god you want to use if that is the tool you decide on. I think the sponsor relationship might be the best tool. Some of the biggest AA meetings, believe it or not, happen in prison. People there are remorseful, and also they get coffee and cigarettes! So, they go, until they get out, then it's same old same old. |
Religious Craziness Sends Man Back to Jail
On 8/29/13 2:35 PM, iBoaterer wrote:
In article , says... On Wed, 28 Aug 2013 21:31:08 -0400, "Mr. Luddite" wrote: "Tim" wrote in message ... On Wednesday, August 28, 2013 11:12:24 AM UTC-5, F.O.A.D. wrote: On 8/28/13 11:22 AM, wrote: The religious underpinnings and overlay of 12-step programs are off-putting for many addicts. A lot of people simply don't want religion shoved down their throats. There's a lot of substance/alcohol abusers who while in the `12-step' programs , follow the religious overtones closely. --------------------- Last year when I was involved with a family member's rehab and first steps with recovery I got a copy of the "Big Book" to read what the 12 step thing was all about. I had never heard of the "Big Book" and had only heard about the "12 step program" in the form of jokes. I had no clue what they actually were. Pretty naïve I guess for a guy my age. I confess that I didn't read the Big Book cover to cover, but I read enough to get the history, ideas and concepts. I didn't think it overly pushes religion at all, and certainly doesn't push any particular theology. I got the it really doesn't care what you believe in as long as you acknowledge that there are bigger things in the universe than yourselves. I was also fortunate to have several people who I had met (mostly through the guitar shop) who confided their status as recovering addicts to me. Prior to that I had no idea. They helped me and my wife deal with my family member's addiction and explained their respective adaptations of and implementation of the 12 step program as it applied to them . Some took it more literally than others, but it seemed to benefit them all. I certainly don't think it "shoves" religion down anyone's throats. AA pushes the concept of a 'higher power', which may be different for different folks. The higher power may be God, for those who believe, or it may be peer pressure from the group, or maybe just a 'big brother'. One thing is for sure, the success of AA groups does not put a lot of money into the pockets of psychologists. However, many hospitals for those needing psychological treatment also have an AA group on the premises. (That is also true for many military hospitals.) John (Gun Nut) H. Okay, Bill W. I wonder if Herring still attends AA meetings. |
Religious Craziness Sends Man Back to Jail
On 8/29/13 3:11 PM, wrote:
On Thu, 29 Aug 2013 13:23:31 -0400, "F.O.A.D." wrote: On 8/29/13 1:12 PM, wrote: I believe that is because of the support component that Harry dismisses in such a cavalier way. I don't dismiss support programs for substance abusers. Once again, apparently, you cannot comprehend what you read. What I did say is that the religious-osity, as it were, of 12-step programs, is offputting to a substantial percentage of substance abusers. There is significant published criticism for various reasons of 12-step programs. The hard choices an addict needs to make is the main thing that puts them off. They just use "religious-osity" as one more excuse. Gee, I'm glad you have so much experience dealing with the huge variety of substance abusers and therefore feel qualified to state that those who disdain the 12 steps approach because of religious reasons do so as an excuse. Obviously, whatever your profession was, you chose poorly...since you could have been a first-rate therapist. |
| All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:36 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com