|
Tennessee Boaters Killed By Tug and Barges
|
Tennessee Boaters Killed By Tug and Barges
"Wayne.B" wrote in message ... Tragic: http://www.newschannel9.com/news/cre...-capsized.html Terrible loss of life. Not even wearing life jackets... sad. |
Tennessee Boaters Killed By Tug and Barges
On 22/06/2010 6:59 PM, nom=de=plume wrote:
"Wayne.B" wrote in message ... Tragic: http://www.newschannel9.com/news/cre...-capsized.html Terrible loss of life. Not even wearing life jackets... sad. Darwinian actually. It is law, if you are in a shipping lane or channel, and you are more manouvable you ge tthe frac out of the way. Unless you have diver flags out, then the barge would be at fault. Would be interesting to see who they blame. -- The bigger government gets, the more it tends to rule out common sense. |
Tennessee Boaters Killed By Tug and Barges
On Tue, 22 Jun 2010 21:29:00 -0400, W1TEF
wrote: Even more so... "None of the people in the fishing boat were wearing life jackets at time of accident." Sad. It is sad, and it's really not clear exactly how it could have been avoided other than greater vigilance/keeping out of the way. I have to admit that I'm not much into wearing life jackets either except under the most extreme circumstances, and it's not really clear that wearing a life jacket will save you from being run over by 8 barges and a tug. Probably not is my guess but you never know. They probably became distracted by their fishing and didn't notice the barges until too late, or perhaps their engine failed to start at the critical juncture, or maybe they had an anchor down and couldn't get it up, etc. There are lots of possibilities I suppose but it does drive home the danger associated with small recreational boats mixing in with large commercial traffic. |
Tennessee Boaters Killed By Tug and Barges
On Jun 22, 10:34*pm, Wayne.B wrote:
On Tue, 22 Jun 2010 21:29:00 -0400, W1TEF wrote: Even more so... "None of the people in the fishing boat were wearing life jackets at time of accident." Sad. It is sad, and it's really not clear exactly how it could have been avoided other than greater vigilance/keeping out of the way. *I have to admit that I'm not much into wearing life jackets either except under the most extreme circumstances, and it's not really clear that wearing a life jacket will save you from being run over by 8 barges and a tug. *Probably not is my guess but you never know. They probably became distracted by their fishing and didn't notice the barges until too late, or perhaps their engine failed to start at the critical juncture, or maybe they had an anchor down and couldn't get it up, etc. *There are lots of possibilities I suppose but it does drive home the danger associated with small recreational boats mixing in with large commercial traffic. One has to wonder if the tug operator suffers from the same malady that many of the 18 wheeler drivers do. The "I'm a 'professional' driver, and these mere regular people in their cars and trucks need to get out of my way" attitude. Rules of navigation notwithstanding, it's on his conscience now. |
Tennessee Boaters Killed By Tug and Barges
|
Tennessee Boaters Killed By Tug and Barges
On Jun 22, 9:29*pm, W1TEF wrote:
On Tue, 22 Jun 2010 20:09:42 -0400, Wayne.B wrote: Tragic: http://www.newschannel9.com/news/cre...-capsized.html Even more so... "None of the people in the fishing boat were wearing life jackets at time of accident." Sad. It's not likely that a life jacket would have saved someone run over by a bunch of barges and a tug. That's the problem I have with those statistics, the "pro life jacket" people always want to assume that wearing a life jacket would have saved the victim. And that is not always the case. We don't wear life jackets while recreational boating. I only ask people to wear one if they are very young or can't swim. Wearing a life jacket is a situation by situation call. It's hard to imagine tht these three guys could have all missed seeing this bearing down on them. I can understand how the tug operator might have missed seeing them. |
Tennessee Boaters Killed By Tug and Barges
On 6/23/10 8:21 AM, jamesgangnc wrote:
On Jun 22, 9:29 pm, wrote: On Tue, 22 Jun 2010 20:09:42 -0400, Wayne.B wrote: Tragic: http://www.newschannel9.com/news/cre...-capsized.html Even more so... "None of the people in the fishing boat were wearing life jackets at time of accident." Sad. It's not likely that a life jacket would have saved someone run over by a bunch of barges and a tug. That's the problem I have with those statistics, the "pro life jacket" people always want to assume that wearing a life jacket would have saved the victim. And that is not always the case. We don't wear life jackets while recreational boating. I only ask people to wear one if they are very young or can't swim. Wearing a life jacket is a situation by situation call. It's hard to imagine tht these three guys could have all missed seeing this bearing down on them. I can understand how the tug operator might have missed seeing them. According to the news story, the tug was pushing nine barges. What size barges, I don't know, but that far back, it is unlikely the barge operator could see anything in front of him, and, if he could see the small boat, it isn't likely he could have stopped in time or even changed the direction of that train of barges significantly. Perhaps operators of pusher barge trains should be required to post a forward lookout on the bow of the most forward barge. |
Tennessee Boaters Killed By Tug and Barges
"Harry" wrote in message m... On 6/23/10 8:21 AM, jamesgangnc wrote: On Jun 22, 9:29 pm, wrote: On Tue, 22 Jun 2010 20:09:42 -0400, Wayne.B wrote: Tragic: http://www.newschannel9.com/news/cre...-capsized.html Even more so... "None of the people in the fishing boat were wearing life jackets at time of accident." Sad. It's not likely that a life jacket would have saved someone run over by a bunch of barges and a tug. That's the problem I have with those statistics, the "pro life jacket" people always want to assume that wearing a life jacket would have saved the victim. And that is not always the case. We don't wear life jackets while recreational boating. I only ask people to wear one if they are very young or can't swim. Wearing a life jacket is a situation by situation call. It's hard to imagine tht these three guys could have all missed seeing this bearing down on them. I can understand how the tug operator might have missed seeing them. According to the news story, the tug was pushing nine barges. What size barges, I don't know, but that far back, it is unlikely the barge operator could see anything in front of him, and, if he could see the small boat, it isn't likely he could have stopped in time or even changed the direction of that train of barges significantly. Perhaps operators of pusher barge trains should be required to post a forward lookout on the bow of the most forward barge. Or at least a camera. |
| All times are GMT +1. The time now is 05:16 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com