BoatBanter.com

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)
-   Cruising (https://www.boatbanter.com/cruising/)
-   -   Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications. (https://www.boatbanter.com/cruising/97529-power-sail-squadron-recreational-boater-qualifications.html)

terry August 29th 08 10:27 PM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
By end 2009 Canadian all recreational boaters will be required to
possess suitable qualifications.

Been touch with rep. of the Power and Sail Squad. and one of the
claims made is that their course, unlike some of the more
straightforward 'Boating Safety' courses, is the only one that
qualifies for operating a boat in both Canada and USA. While that is
unlikely in short term it could be a significant advantage.

They also have a 12 week one evening per week course which is more
comprehensive which includes the the above qualification.

Any advice regarding this would be most appreciated. It is many years
since did any actual sailing.

Terry

Presently refitting our 26 foot Westerly Tiger; sal****er, out of
Newfoundland, Canada.

Capt. JG August 29th 08 10:34 PM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
"terry" wrote in message
...
By end 2009 Canadian all recreational boaters will be required to
possess suitable qualifications.

Been touch with rep. of the Power and Sail Squad. and one of the
claims made is that their course, unlike some of the more
straightforward 'Boating Safety' courses, is the only one that
qualifies for operating a boat in both Canada and USA. While that is
unlikely in short term it could be a significant advantage.

They also have a 12 week one evening per week course which is more
comprehensive which includes the the above qualification.

Any advice regarding this would be most appreciated. It is many years
since did any actual sailing.

Terry

Presently refitting our 26 foot Westerly Tiger; sal****er, out of
Newfoundland, Canada.



Nothing wrong with taking a class. The best thing would be to take the
onshore class coupled with an aboard class. As far as I know, there's no US
requirement for a class to operate a sailboat unless you have paying guests
or it's a commercial situation. There might be insurance issues, and some
states may have specific requirements, of course.

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com




Roger Long August 29th 08 11:31 PM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
"terry" wrote

By end 2009 Canadian all recreational boaters will be required to
possess suitable qualifications.


Do you know if there will be any requirements for visiting cruisers such as
having an equivelent certificater or training in their home country?

--
Roger Long




Don White August 30th 08 12:27 AM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 

"terry" wrote in message
...
By end 2009 Canadian all recreational boaters will be required to
possess suitable qualifications.

Been touch with rep. of the Power and Sail Squad. and one of the
claims made is that their course, unlike some of the more
straightforward 'Boating Safety' courses, is the only one that
qualifies for operating a boat in both Canada and USA. While that is
unlikely in short term it could be a significant advantage.

They also have a 12 week one evening per week course which is more
comprehensive which includes the the above qualification.

Any advice regarding this would be most appreciated. It is many years
since did any actual sailing.

Terry

Presently refitting our 26 foot Westerly Tiger; sal****er, out of
Newfoundland, Canada.


Great way to spend our cold damp winters.
Way back in 2000 I started with the Boating Course at the Halifax Squadron,
took the Piloting, and Advanced Piloting courses and fit in the VHF and GPS
seminars in between.
I've been lazy since 2002.... but have kept my dues up and plan on getting
back in the saddle one of these days.



Thomas, Spring Point Light August 30th 08 02:25 PM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 

"terry" wrote in message
...
By end 2009 Canadian all recreational boaters will be required to
possess suitable qualifications.

Been touch with rep. of the Power and Sail Squad. and one of the
claims made is that their course, unlike some of the more
straightforward 'Boating Safety' courses, is the only one that
qualifies for operating a boat in both Canada and USA. While that is
unlikely in short term it could be a significant advantage.

They also have a 12 week one evening per week course which is more
comprehensive which includes the the above qualification.

Any advice regarding this would be most appreciated. It is many years
since did any actual sailing.

Terry

Presently refitting our 26 foot Westerly Tiger; sal****er, out of
Newfoundland, Canada.

===========================================

I did the power squadron course a couple years back.. and I remembered
how much I had forgot..

It was a great course. Very informative. I'm glad I took it.




[email protected] August 30th 08 07:05 PM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
On Aug 29, 3:31*pm, "Roger Long" wrote:
"terry" wrote

By end 2009 Canadian all recreational boaters will be required to
possess suitable qualifications.


Do you know if there will be any requirements for visiting cruisers such as
having an equivelent certificater or training in their home country?

--
Roger Long


http://www.tc.gc.ca/marinesafety/deb...ck_visitor.htm

-- Tom.

Ken Heaton, Cape Breton Island, Nova Scotia August 30th 08 08:35 PM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
On Aug 29, 7:31*pm, "Roger Long" wrote:
"terry" wrote

By end 2009 Canadian all recreational boaters will be required to
possess suitable qualifications.


Do you know if there will be any requirements for visiting cruisers such as
having an equivelent certificater or training in their home country?

--
Roger Long


Hi Roger, no requirement unless you stay 45 or more consecutive days.

I looked it up at: http://www.tc.gc.ca/acts-regulations...08/csa108.html


A quote: See 3. (2) (b) below:

3. (1) Subject to subsection (2), no person shall operate a pleasure
craft unless the person

(a) is competent to operate the pleasure craft in accordance with
section 4; and

(b) has proof of competency on board.

(2) Subsection (1) does not apply to a person who

(a) is operating the pleasure craft under the supervision of an
instructor, as part of an accredited course;

(b) is not a resident of Canada and whose pleasure craft is in Canada
for less than 45 consecutive days; or

(c) was born before April 2, 1983, has proof of age on board and
operates a pleasure craft of at least 4 m in length before September
15, 2009; or

(d) has proof on board that they hold a MED-A4 certificate or any
certificate referred to in paragraphs 2(a) to (s), (z.18) or (z.43) of
the Marine Certification Regulations.


Roger Long August 30th 08 08:41 PM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
wrote

http://www.tc.gc.ca/marinesafety/deb...ck_visitor.htm

According to this, if I want to spent more than 45 days operating in Canada
(quite likely if I want to see Newfoundland), I have to have proof of
competency in three forms, one of which only appears applicable if I charter
a boat up there. So...

Take a Canadian boating course. or get (quote):

An operator card or equivalent that meets the requirements of their state or
country.

My state and country do not issue such cards except for USCG licenses. Now
what do I do?

Interesting aside: It appears that in most of Canada alcohol can only be
consumed on boats with permanent sleeping and cooking facilities while they
are tied to a dock. That would be the end of life as we know it for most
boaters here in the US although it wouldn't change my habits any.

--
Roger Long




Roger Long August 30th 08 08:46 PM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
"Ken Heaton, Cape Breton Island, Nova Scotia" wrote

Hi Roger, no requirement unless you stay 45 or more consecutive days.


I definitely plan to so I've got to find out what they will accept from a
state that doesn't issue the kind of documentation they describe.

--
Roger Long




[email protected] August 30th 08 10:47 PM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
On Aug 30, 12:41*pm, "Roger Long" wrote:
....
My state and country do not *issue such cards except for USCG licenses. *Now
what do I do? ...


Apparently you can "challenge" the test. You only need to get 75%
correct and the book from which they are testing is on the web site I
linked. It might be something you could do when you check in. If
you've got a current Merchant Marine ticket of some sort or any state
recreational boater's cred I suspect that would do. I recall that
some states grant licenses over the net. Maybe you could shoot
Transport Canada an email or call them:

-- Tom.



Wayne.B August 30th 08 11:08 PM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
On Sat, 30 Aug 2008 15:46:54 -0400, "Roger Long"
wrote:

"Ken Heaton, Cape Breton Island, Nova Scotia" wrote

Hi Roger, no requirement unless you stay 45 or more consecutive days.


I definitely plan to so I've got to find out what they will accept from a
state that doesn't issue the kind of documentation they describe.


Sounds like this might be your out:

(2) Subsection (1) does not apply to a person who

(c) was born before April 2, 1983, has proof of age on board and
operates a pleasure craft of at least 4 m in length before September
15, 2009; or


Goofball_star_dot_etal August 30th 08 11:25 PM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
On Sat, 30 Aug 2008 15:46:54 -0400, "Roger Long"
wrote:

"Ken Heaton, Cape Breton Island, Nova Scotia" wrote

Hi Roger, no requirement unless you stay 45 or more consecutive days.


I definitely plan to so I've got to find out what they will accept from a
state that doesn't issue the kind of documentation they describe.


I could put in a good word for you, and also mention that your knees
and back were transplanted from a thirty year old.

Ken Heaton, Cape Breton Island, Nova Scotia August 30th 08 11:28 PM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
On Aug 30, 4:46*pm, "Roger Long" wrote:
"Ken Heaton, Cape Breton Island, Nova Scotia" wrote

Hi Roger, no requirement unless you stay 45 or more consecutive days.


I definitely plan to so I've got to find out what they will accept from a
state that doesn't issue the kind of documentation they describe.

--
Roger Long


Hello again Roger, it appears to me theat you can get yourself a
Canadian-issued pleasure craft operator card:

http://www.tc.gc.ca/marinesafety/deb..._visitor.htm#g

"Acceptable Proof of Competency for Non-Residents
For non-residents, proof of competency can take one of three forms:

A Canadian-issued pleasure craft operator card.
A completed boat rental safety check-list (for power-driven rental
boats).
An operator card or equivalent that meets the requirements of their
state or country.
For more information, consult the Competency of Operators of Pleasure
Craft Regulations."

This wording suggest to me a non resident can have a Canadian issued
card. The pleasure craft operator cards are easy enough to get
online as the course is available through several vendors such as:

http://www.boaterexam.com/canada/?gc...FRhhnAodfUctQQ

http://www.theoperatorcard.ca/

http://www.boaterlicences.com/?gclid...FQsiIgodSFYRQw





Don White August 31st 08 12:38 AM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 

"Roger Long" wrote in message
...
"Ken Heaton, Cape Breton Island, Nova Scotia" wrote

Hi Roger, no requirement unless you stay 45 or more consecutive days.


I definitely plan to so I've got to find out what they will accept from a
state that doesn't issue the kind of documentation they describe.

--
Roger Long


Roger... do you have a local Power Squadron in your area?
What a great way to pass the dreary winters in your area(and mine).
You'll probably even meet some new long term friends.
I've just run into a lady i took the Piloting course with. We both walk our
dogs in the same part.
She's still sailing (trying to sell her J-24 to buy a Viking 28 while I'm
reduced to operating an open 15' aluminum boat these days)



Roger Long August 31st 08 01:22 AM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
"Don White" wrote

Roger... do you have a local Power Squadron in your area?


I don't think a Power Squadron certificate counts as state or federally
issued.

--
Roger Long




Roger Long August 31st 08 01:25 AM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
"Wayne.B" wrote

(c) was born before April 2, 1983, has proof of age on board and
operates a pleasure craft of at least 4 m in length before September
15, 2009; or


I'm OK for next year but it is the year after that I expect to be there more
than 45 days.

It's a bit ambiguous though. Do you think it means that you just have to
have prior operating experience of a boat over 4 M if you were born before
1983?

--
Roger Long




Don White August 31st 08 03:51 AM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 

"Roger Long" wrote in message
...
"Don White" wrote

Roger... do you have a local Power Squadron in your area?


I don't think a Power Squadron certificate counts as state or federally
issued.

--
Roger Long



Up here the CPS group has been appointed by the gov't to run the course and
examine applicants for the Pleasure Craft Operator Card.
Way back in 2000 we wrote two exams on the same night after completing 'The
Boating Course'.
The first, shorter test was for the Operator Card, and the longer test was
to receive our diploma for the Boating Course and an invitation to join the
CPS.
http://www.cps-ecp.ca/public.asp?WCE=A=Body|C=11|RefreshS=Container|Refr eshT=224455|K=224455



Ken Heaton, Cape Breton Island, Nova Scotia August 31st 08 10:32 AM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
On Aug 30, 9:25*pm, "Roger Long" wrote:
"Wayne.B" wrote

(c) was born before April 2, 1983, has proof of age on board and
operates a pleasure craft of at least 4 m in length before September
15, 2009; or


I'm OK for next year but it is the year after that I expect to be there more
than 45 days.

It's a bit ambiguous though. *Do you think it means that you just have to
have prior operating experience of a boat over 4 M if you were born before
1983?

--
Roger Long


No, this means up to September 15, 2009 a card is not required if you
are more than 16 years old (by April 2, 2009) and your boat is 4 or
more metres long. After September 15, 2009 everyone has to have the
card if the boat has a motor (rental checklists, etc. excepted).

Roger Long August 31st 08 12:55 PM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
Do you know of the CPS will issue cards to US citizens or if the USPS
certificate is considered equivelent and acceptable?

Just curious at this point. I'm certainly going to have something in
writing before I show up to clear customs with 90 days of cruising planned.

--
Roger Long






Roger Long August 31st 08 02:02 PM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
"Goofball_star_dot_etal" wrote

I could put in a good word for you, and also mention that your knees
and back were transplanted from a thirty year old.


Please do although I wouldn't fudge the truth with the transplant bit.

Actually though, in a summer of some of some ambitious coastal cruising (by
Maine standards anyway)

http://home.maine.rr.com/rlma/GEfile...er08Cruise.kml

the full extent of what are considered normal cruising grounds in this part
of the world including the wilder portions thereof, my back and knees have
felt far better than in my previous three years of sailing. I feel younger
than when I first bought the boat. The enforced rest and therapy, together
with three seasons of nearly daily sailing and two off seasons of extensive
work on the boat, have definitely turned the clock back a bit.

Some of it though is being aware and smarter. When the anchor is really dug
in, I don't just grab on and heave while still stiff in the morning. First
trick is to take the rode back to the midships cleat and get as much tension
on it as possible. I then can put a powerful swig on it by pulling up in
the middle. If the water is shallow and it's mostly chain aboard, I've made
up a tackle with a chain hook. The other end has a loop that I throw around
a winch on the mast. Swigging the fall from a bow cleat creates a pretty
good lift. If I'm motoring off the hook, I can just go ahead on the up and
down rode but I often like to sail away without using the engine.

--
Roger Long





Wayne.B August 31st 08 02:29 PM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
On Sat, 30 Aug 2008 12:35:06 -0700 (PDT), "Ken Heaton, Cape Breton
Island, Nova Scotia" wrote:

On Aug 29, 7:31*pm, "Roger Long" wrote:
"terry" wrote

By end 2009 Canadian all recreational boaters will be required to
possess suitable qualifications.


Do you know if there will be any requirements for visiting cruisers such as
having an equivelent certificater or training in their home country?

--
Roger Long


Hi Roger, no requirement unless you stay 45 or more consecutive days.

I looked it up at: http://www.tc.gc.ca/acts-regulations...08/csa108.html


A quote: See 3. (2) (b) below:

3. (1) Subject to subsection (2), no person shall operate a pleasure
craft unless the person

(a) is competent to operate the pleasure craft in accordance with
section 4; and

(b) has proof of competency on board.

(2) Subsection (1) does not apply to a person who

(a) is operating the pleasure craft under the supervision of an
instructor, as part of an accredited course;

(b) is not a resident of Canada and whose pleasure craft is in Canada
for less than 45 consecutive days; or

(c) was born before April 2, 1983, has proof of age on board and
operates a pleasure craft of at least 4 m in length before September
15, 2009; or

(d) has proof on board that they hold a MED-A4 certificate or any
certificate referred to in paragraphs 2(a) to (s), (z.18) or (z.43) of
the Marine Certification Regulations.


I'm assuming that a USCG Master's ticket would be sufficient proof ?


[email protected] August 31st 08 10:41 PM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
On Sun, 31 Aug 2008 09:29:41 -0400, Wayne.B
wrote:

On Sat, 30 Aug 2008 12:35:06 -0700 (PDT), "Ken Heaton, Cape Breton
Island, Nova Scotia" wrote:

On Aug 29, 7:31*pm, "Roger Long" wrote:
"terry" wrote

By end 2009 Canadian all recreational boaters will be required to
possess suitable qualifications.

Do you know if there will be any requirements for visiting cruisers such as
having an equivelent certificater or training in their home country?

--
Roger Long


Hi Roger, no requirement unless you stay 45 or more consecutive days.

I looked it up at: http://www.tc.gc.ca/acts-regulations...08/csa108.html


A quote: See 3. (2) (b) below:

3. (1) Subject to subsection (2), no person shall operate a pleasure
craft unless the person

(a) is competent to operate the pleasure craft in accordance with
section 4; and

(b) has proof of competency on board.

(2) Subsection (1) does not apply to a person who

(a) is operating the pleasure craft under the supervision of an
instructor, as part of an accredited course;

(b) is not a resident of Canada and whose pleasure craft is in Canada
for less than 45 consecutive days; or

(c) was born before April 2, 1983, has proof of age on board and
operates a pleasure craft of at least 4 m in length before September
15, 2009; or

(d) has proof on board that they hold a MED-A4 certificate or any
certificate referred to in paragraphs 2(a) to (s), (z.18) or (z.43) of
the Marine Certification Regulations.


I'm assuming that a USCG Master's ticket would be sufficient proof ?


I think that in CT, at least, someone with a USCG Master's ticket
would still have to obtain a CT safe boating certificate to operate
recreational craft or PWC's. You can skip the 8 hour class and just
take the test (and pay the fees) Actually, anyone can do it that way
if they feel confident that they can pass the test without the class.
Not recommended, though, as the test is geared to topics covered in
the class, and if you don't pass, you have a waiting period before you
can pay again and take the test again.

Just because you can operate a large tug boat, does not mean you know
how to operate a PWC, any more than it means you know how to drive a
tractor trailer, fly an airplane. or ski down Mt. Everest.




[email protected] September 1st 08 12:30 AM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
On Aug 31, 2:41*pm, wrote:
....
I think that in CT, at least, someone with a USCG Master's ticket
would still have to obtain a CT safe boating certificate to operate
recreational craft or PWC's. ...


That's an interesting thought. It would mean, I presume, that a
person with a master's license could take up to 6 people out on his
own boat for hire but would not be able to cruise it for pleasure...
Wouldn't that be odd. I'm no lawyer and I'm sure one of the local law
critters will point out my errors but I think a federal license that
gives you the right to operate a boat must be recognized by a state.
No?

Just because you can operate a large tug boat, does not mean you know
how to operate a PWC, any more than it means you know how to drive a
tractor trailer, fly an airplane. or ski down Mt. Everest.


Are you joking? A person with a master's license will have a very
good handle on COLREGS and some familiarity with the applicable CFR
chapters and a lot more to loose if he gets busted breaking the law
than a person with just an operators license. There are a few laws
that vary from state to state but I strongly suspect that most pros
could pick them up with a quick glance at the state's boating
handbook. Otherwise, they're likely to have mastered much more
material than will be presented in a state licensing course. YMMV but
I've spent time in small boats with professional mariners and they
were very fine boat operators. And, of course, if you can operate a
tug you can almost certainly operate a PWC (at least a sit down
one).

-- Tom.

[email protected] September 1st 08 01:03 AM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
On Sun, 31 Aug 2008 16:30:30 -0700 (PDT), "
wrote:

On Aug 31, 2:41*pm, wrote:
...
I think that in CT, at least, someone with a USCG Master's ticket
would still have to obtain a CT safe boating certificate to operate
recreational craft or PWC's. ...


That's an interesting thought. It would mean, I presume, that a
person with a master's license could take up to 6 people out on his
own boat for hire but would not be able to cruise it for pleasure...
Wouldn't that be odd. I'm no lawyer and I'm sure one of the local law
critters will point out my errors but I think a federal license that
gives you the right to operate a boat must be recognized by a state.
No?


No.

Just because you can operate a large tug boat, does not mean you know
how to operate a PWC, any more than it means you know how to drive a
tractor trailer, fly an airplane. or ski down Mt. Everest.


Are you joking? A person with a master's license will have a very
good handle on COLREGS and some familiarity with the applicable CFR
chapters and a lot more to loose if he gets busted breaking the law
than a person with just an operators license.


The test covers a lot of things that are not simply laws or COLREGS.

They even have a separate test for PWC's. A regular boating license
doesn't cover those, because they feel you should know things like how
to maintain steerage in an emergency. If you are about to hit
something while on a Jet Ski, instinctively closing the throttle is
the worst thing you could do. They don't have rudders. The jet blast
is how you steer. To avoid collision, you often ACCELERATE to be able
to turn sharper. A person with a master's license may not know that.
It wasn't in any of the tests or classes he took to get that ticket.

That's just ONE example. So far, it looks like you couldn't pass the
test. You don't even know what questions to ask.

There are a few laws
that vary from state to state but I strongly suspect that most pros
could pick them up with a quick glance at the state's boating
handbook. Otherwise, they're likely to have mastered much more
material than will be presented in a state licensing course.


More, perhaps, but not the same, and not a complete overlapping. How
much does a "pro" know about launching a boat at a boat ramp? Did you
know that you are not supposed to "power on" and "power off" a trailer
on a public boat ramp, using the boats motor to force a stuck boat on
or off the trailer? Do you know why? It's on the test.

YMMV but
I've spent time in small boats with professional mariners and they
were very fine boat operators. And, of course, if you can operate a
tug you can almost certainly operate a PWC (at least a sit down
one).


See, that's where you are wrong. Very wrong. It's a different skill
set.


[email protected] September 1st 08 02:09 AM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
On Aug 31, 5:03*pm, wrote:
... I think a federal license that
gives you the right to operate a boat must be recognized by a state.
No?


No.


Really? What about the supremacy clause of the Constitution? You're
saying that if the feds grant a license that allows one to be master
of a motor vessel that Connecticut can make a law that voids the
federal license in CT? As I say I'm no expert but that seems so wrong
that I wonder if you could explain how it would work.

Except to say that PWCs aren't the only thrust vectored vessels and
that they and z-drives, outboards, i/o's, other jet craft, etc are
pretty well understood by professionals I'm not going to bother with
your straw man arguments. Generally professional mariners are
experienced, knowledgeable and careful. As a class I think that they
are better qualified to operate vessels than recreational boaters
who's only cert is a safe boating course.

-- Tom.



Brian Whatcott September 1st 08 02:58 AM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
On Sun, 31 Aug 2008 18:09:48 -0700 (PDT), "
wrote:

... I'm not going to bother with
your straw man arguments. Generally professional mariners are
experienced, knowledgeable and careful. ...
-- Tom.


Not necessarily straw-men. An airline pilot with an atr, perhaps
backed with a cpl multiengine - ir, is not permited to fly a single
alone until he obtains that class

Brian W


cavelamb himself[_4_] September 1st 08 03:46 AM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
Brian Whatcott wrote:
On Sun, 31 Aug 2008 18:09:48 -0700 (PDT), "
wrote:


... I'm not going to bother with
your straw man arguments. Generally professional mariners are
experienced, knowledgeable and careful. ...
-- Tom.



Not necessarily straw-men. An airline pilot with an atr, perhaps
backed with a cpl multiengine - ir, is not permited to fly a single
alone until he obtains that class

Brian W



That's just plain not true.

try again

--

Richard

(remove the X to email)

Wayne.B September 1st 08 07:11 AM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
On Sun, 31 Aug 2008 17:41:18 -0400, wrote:

I think that in CT, at least, someone with a USCG Master's ticket
would still have to obtain a CT safe boating certificate to operate
recreational craft or PWC's.


I've been operating pleasure boats in CT on and off for over 30 years,
first as a NY resident, now FL. As far as I'm concerned I am
grandfathered but who knows. Let's set up a test case, might be fun.
You can turn me in next summer for failure to have a certificate.


[email protected] September 1st 08 12:18 PM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
On Sun, 31 Aug 2008 18:09:48 -0700 (PDT), "
wrote:

On Aug 31, 5:03*pm, wrote:
... I think a federal license that
gives you the right to operate a boat must be recognized by a state.
No?


No.


Really? What about the supremacy clause of the Constitution? You're
saying that if the feds grant a license that allows one to be master
of a motor vessel that Connecticut can make a law that voids the
federal license in CT? As I say I'm no expert but that seems so wrong
that I wonder if you could explain how it would work.



I already explained it, and quite clearly, but you are apparently in
the throes of a thickness attack. An expert on oranges is not an
expert on apples, although there is some overlapping knowledge. CT
does not require a liscence. They require a "Safe Boating
Certificate". It has requirements that are not covered by any USCG
license.



Except to say that PWCs aren't the only thrust vectored vessels and
that they and z-drives, outboards, i/o's, other jet craft, etc are
pretty well understood by professionals I'm not going to bother with
your straw man arguments. Generally professional mariners are
experienced, knowledgeable and careful. As a class I think that they
are better qualified to operate vessels than recreational boaters
who's only cert is a safe boating course.

-- Tom.


None of which matters one bit. You need a Safe Boating Certificate in
CT. A Master Mariner's ticket doesn't cut it, because it is for
something else, with different requirements.



[email protected] September 1st 08 12:32 PM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
On Mon, 01 Sep 2008 02:11:25 -0400, Wayne.B
wrote:

On Sun, 31 Aug 2008 17:41:18 -0400, wrote:

I think that in CT, at least, someone with a USCG Master's ticket
would still have to obtain a CT safe boating certificate to operate
recreational craft or PWC's.


I've been operating pleasure boats in CT on and off for over 30 years,
first as a NY resident, now FL. As far as I'm concerned I am
grandfathered but who knows. Let's set up a test case, might be fun.
You can turn me in next summer for failure to have a certificate.


Sure. Sounds like fun. Let me know when you have exceeded the time
limit, and where they can find you. The Courant will want to do a four
part series on your trial, I'm sure!

For the record, you are not grandfathered in. I was when they first
instituted the Safe Boatuing Certificate, but they phased that out
early on.

If you read the CT Safe Boating Guide booklet as prep, you could
probably just take the test at DEP headquarters and skip the classroom
time. Mostly enforcenment happens when you are busted for something
else and they discover you don't have the cert. I don't think the CG
will even write you up for it. You have to get popped by local law
enforcement, or DEP.



Brian Whatcott September 1st 08 05:17 PM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
On Sun, 31 Aug 2008 21:46:54 -0500, cavelamb himself
wrote:

Not necessarily straw-men. An airline pilot with an atr, perhaps
backed with a cpl multiengine - ir, is not permited to fly a single
alone until he obtains that class

Brian W



That's just plain not true.

try again


Ha! I thought you were a pilot. But now I see you are not.

Brian W

[email protected] September 1st 08 06:08 PM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
On Sep 1, 4:18*am, wrote:
....
None of which matters one bit. You need a Safe Boating Certificate in
CT. A Master Mariner's ticket doesn't cut it, because it is for
something else, with different requirements.


To quote from the Connecticut Boater's Guide:

http://www.ct.gov/dep/lib/dep/boatin...e/part1_08.pdf

A person who has a valid vessel operator license by the United
States Coast Guard does not require a Safe Boating Certificate. They
must have a copy of the license on board the recreational vessel on
which they are operating.

-- Tom.

[email protected] September 1st 08 06:56 PM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
On Mon, 1 Sep 2008 10:08:44 -0700 (PDT), "
wrote:

On Sep 1, 4:18*am, wrote:
...
None of which matters one bit. You need a Safe Boating Certificate in
CT. A Master Mariner's ticket doesn't cut it, because it is for
something else, with different requirements.


To quote from the Connecticut Boater's Guide:

http://www.ct.gov/dep/lib/dep/boatin...e/part1_08.pdf

A person who has a valid vessel operator license by the United
States Coast Guard does not require a Safe Boating Certificate. They
must have a copy of the license on board the recreational vessel on
which they are operating.

-- Tom.


Does NOT cover PWC's! Read it again, but more slowly this time.


Wayne.B September 1st 08 07:30 PM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
On Mon, 01 Sep 2008 13:56:52 -0400, wrote:

To quote from the Connecticut Boater's Guide:

http://www.ct.gov/dep/lib/dep/boatin...e/part1_08.pdf

A person who has a valid vessel operator license by the United
States Coast Guard does not require a Safe Boating Certificate. They
must have a copy of the license on board the recreational vessel on
which they are operating.

-- Tom.


Does NOT cover PWC's! Read it again, but more slowly this time.


My PWC is 49 ft long, 32 net tons.


[email protected] September 1st 08 08:59 PM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
On Sep 1, 10:56*am, wrote:
....
Does NOT cover PWC's! Read it again, but more slowly this time.


Man, why the vitriol? I've been impressed with your knowledgeable,
helpful and well presented cruising tips in another thread. I'd
welcome the same kind of conversation here.

It seems to me that you're shifting ground and I hate to get drawn
into it but just for clarity. You said that: "You need a Safe Boating
Certificate in CT. A Master Mariner's ticket doesn't cut it." The
citation I linked to states that a person who has a US CG license does
not require a "Safe Boating Certificate". The SBC covers all cruising
boats and their support craft except for PWCs, so for r.b.c readers it
is likely the pertinent cert.

It is true that CT also grants a Certificate of Personal Watercraft
Operation. The CPWO allows users to operate PWCs as well as vessels
covered by the SBC. The CPWO is not the SBC which is the ticket I
thought we were talking about since it covers virtually all cruising
vessels and since you used that specific term. It does appear from
the wording in the CT book that CT doesn't accept a CG lic. in place
of a CPWO. While I suspect that CT does not have the authority to
require federally licensed mariners to get a CPWO I don't actually
care very much. The only thing you need a CPWO for in CT is PWCs and
I don't have any desire to PWC in CT and doubt that many other
cruisers do either.

-- Tom.

[email protected] September 1st 08 09:32 PM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
On Mon, 01 Sep 2008 14:30:25 -0400, Wayne.B
wrote:

On Mon, 01 Sep 2008 13:56:52 -0400, wrote:

To quote from the Connecticut Boater's Guide:

http://www.ct.gov/dep/lib/dep/boatin...e/part1_08.pdf

A person who has a valid vessel operator license by the United
States Coast Guard does not require a Safe Boating Certificate. They
must have a copy of the license on board the recreational vessel on
which they are operating.

-- Tom.


Does NOT cover PWC's! Read it again, but more slowly this time.


My PWC is 49 ft long, 32 net tons.


If you say so, Wayne! Do you buzz around in circles near the beach
with it? LOL


[email protected] September 1st 08 09:35 PM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
On Mon, 1 Sep 2008 12:59:24 -0700 (PDT), "
wrote:

On Sep 1, 10:56*am, wrote:
...
Does NOT cover PWC's! Read it again, but more slowly this time.


Man, why the vitriol? I've been impressed with your knowledgeable,
helpful and well presented cruising tips in another thread. I'd
welcome the same kind of conversation here.


Sorry, your first response inthis thtread came across as a very smug,
"USCG cert means I know everything attitude. It was all downhiill from
there.

It seems to me that you're shifting ground and I hate to get drawn
into it but just for clarity. You said that: "You need a Safe Boating
Certificate in CT. A Master Mariner's ticket doesn't cut it." The
citation I linked to states that a person who has a US CG license does
not require a "Safe Boating Certificate". The SBC covers all cruising
boats and their support craft except for PWCs, so for r.b.c readers it
is likely the pertinent cert.

It is true that CT also grants a Certificate of Personal Watercraft
Operation. The CPWO allows users to operate PWCs as well as vessels
covered by the SBC. The CPWO is not the SBC which is the ticket I
thought we were talking about since it covers virtually all cruising
vessels and since you used that specific term. It does appear from
the wording in the CT book that CT doesn't accept a CG lic. in place
of a CPWO. While I suspect that CT does not have the authority to
require federally licensed mariners to get a CPWO I don't actually
care very much. The only thing you need a CPWO for in CT is PWCs and
I don't have any desire to PWC in CT and doubt that many other
cruisers do either.


I sense a post from PWC Cruiser, Rich Forman, coming along shortly!




[email protected] September 1st 08 10:08 PM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
On Sep 1, 1:35*pm, wrote:
On Mon, 1 Sep 2008 12:59:24 -0700 (PDT), "

....
Sorry, your first response inthis thtread came across as a very smug,
"USCG cert means I know everything attitude. It was all downhiill from
there.


Oh. I didn't intent to suggest that at all. It is certainly not
true. My writing skills are pretty grim and I have got a particularly
poor handle on inflection. It doesn't surprise me that screwed it up
but the smugness wasn't intentional. Thanks for pointing it out and
I'm sorry for the mistake.

....
I don't have any desire to PWC in CT and doubt that many other
cruisers do either.


I sense a post from PWC Cruiser, Rich Forman, coming along shortly!


My bad. I look forward the post though. Actually, now that I think of
it, a PWC camping cruise along the inside passage might be a hoot but
CT still doesn't draw me for PWCing. Are there any places you can get
ashore for camping in Connecticut during the summer?

-- Tom.


[email protected] September 1st 08 10:58 PM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
On Mon, 1 Sep 2008 14:08:28 -0700 (PDT), "
wrote:

On Sep 1, 1:35*pm, wrote:
On Mon, 1 Sep 2008 12:59:24 -0700 (PDT), "

...
Sorry, your first response inthis thtread came across as a very smug,
"USCG cert means I know everything attitude. It was all downhiill from
there.


Oh. I didn't intent to suggest that at all. It is certainly not
true. My writing skills are pretty grim and I have got a particularly
poor handle on inflection. It doesn't surprise me that screwed it up
but the smugness wasn't intentional. Thanks for pointing it out and
I'm sorry for the mistake.


Glad we got things back on track. This is much better.

...
I don't have any desire to PWC in CT and doubt that many other
cruisers do either.


I sense a post from PWC Cruiser, Rich Forman, coming along shortly!


My bad. I look forward the post though. Actually, now that I think of
it, a PWC camping cruise along the inside passage might be a hoot but
CT still doesn't draw me for PWCing. Are there any places you can get
ashore for camping in Connecticut during the summer?


Anywhere you don't get caught! My first cruising experiences were as a
teenager in the 1960's in various small, often wooden, and always
decrepit, sailboats. I would sail to "somewhere" and camp on shore.
Usually sans tent. If the weather was especially bad, I would unstep
the mast and turn the boat over for shelter. I really miss those days.
I was the only sailor and camper in my immediate family. Even today, I
sometimes leave everyone behind, and go away by myself for a few days
of solitude on the water. Nicer boat, now...


[email protected] September 2nd 08 05:19 PM

Power and Sail Squadron recreational boater qualifications.
 
On Sep 1, 2:58*pm, wrote:
On Mon, 1 Sep 2008 14:08:28 -0700 (PDT), "
...*Are there any places you can get
ashore for camping in Connecticut during the summer?


Anywhere you don't get caught! My first cruising experiences were as a
teenager in the 1960's in various small, often wooden, and always
decrepit, sailboats. I would sail to "somewhere" and camp on shore.
Usually sans tent. If the weather was especially bad, I would unstep
the mast and turn the boat over for shelter. ...


Very cool. I grew up reading the Ransome books and Capt. Voss and so
on and have always had a romantic vision of small boat camping.

-- Tom.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 01:47 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com