Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#17
![]()
posted to rec.boats.cruising
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Wow. this is dumb.
Roger Long wrote: Balance of sailboats is a huge myth. The whole CP, CLR, Lead business was just a way for yacht designers to look scientific. And the world is flat! The fact that you can make huge area changes, such as the mizzen, without much helm angle change shows how silly the whole idea is. There are schooners with 10% negative lead and they sail fine. I can't even sail my ketch to windward without the mizzen and I can't fall off the wind without headsails set. Same with my sloop, if I take down the main it won't point as high. There goes that theory! Mainsail shape is more of an issue as a tight leach is a huge trim tab. The entire main is a trim tab on a masthead sloop. On a ketch or yawl the mizzen is the trim tab. Mainsail shape and size is critical (which blows your previous comment away again. The primary source of weather helm is the fact that, while heeled, the drag of the hull is over here and the drive of the sails is way out there. That is correct score one point. To go to windward, the hull must make leeway Wrong. The idea is to minimize leeway. More leeway equals less distance to windward. which means there is sideways flow on the rudder. The flow is only sideways in a very poorly designed boat. Boats wants to go pointy end first. The flow across the rudder and keel have a slight angular component but that gives "lift" hydrodynamically. Unless it has way too much balance, it is going to have pressure on it. This had to be a troll........ |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Forum | |||
ANNOUNCE: Cut to size Starboard and plastics fabrication | Marketplace | |||
The Right Size Outboard Gas Engine for a 18-ft Boat? - FollowUp | General | |||
Motor Size | General | |||
What is the Right Size Motor for a 17-Ft Fiberglass Boat? | General | |||
Ideals on Size? | General |