| Home |
| Search |
| Today's Posts |
|
|
|
#1
|
|||
|
|||
|
On Mon, 14 Feb 2005 21:07:37 GMT, Dan Best
wrote: I dissagree. The antenna that the energy is radiating off of is much wider than the mast, so while some of the energy is reflected and scattered, most of it just flows right on past. The reverse happens with the reflected energy. As a result, the targets are weaker, but should still be there. If this were not the case, then whenever you had a mast mounted radar, everything in a fairly wide cone behind you would be invisible and this is obviously not the case. Thanks to you and Otnmbrd for these answers. On a related topic, make sure that you mount the display where it can be seen by the helmsman. A friend of mine has it mounted where it can only be seen at the nav station and having played radar officer calling up instructions to the helm on a foggy night in SF Bay while dodging freighters, I'm here to say that that's not how you want to set it up. It would tend to "compound errors", certainly. I've installed something on my current boat, however, that I haven't seen before. I got a gooseneck armature from an old draftsman's flourescent light and clamped it so that it swings into the companionway. It can be lashed in position with shock cord, if needed, but usually the friction knobs do the trick. On the armature I've secured a handheld GPS on "ship's power" (a 12 V cigarette lighter style adapter). This means I can reference the GPS quickly without using my hands, and without it being loose in the cockpit, without eating batteries (they go through AAs in 2-3 hours of continuous use), without losing "satellite lock" (because they are on all the time and in the companionway can "see" enough sky). Other advantages are (mostly) out of the weather (a ziplock bag will do the trick here as well). Of course, I have a tiller, which means I am standing most of the time by the companionway near the winches and aft of the traveller on the cabin-top. I wonder, however, if my "armature idea" would be useful for any similar devices, as opposed to a "hard-mount" at the wheel? If, for instance, you had a 15" LCD panel and a wireless mouse, the panel could be some distance away and still be readable. R. |
|
#2
|
|||
|
|||
|
rhys wrote:
It would tend to "compound errors", certainly. I've installed something on my current boat, however, that I haven't seen before. I got a gooseneck armature from an old draftsman's flourescent light and clamped it so that it swings into the companionway. It can be lashed in position with shock cord, if needed, but usually the friction knobs do the trick. I've seen this type of mount on many boats, though not using the draftsman's armature. I think the catalogs have brackets intended to swing out in the companionway. On the armature I've secured a handheld GPS on "ship's power" (a 12 V cigarette lighter style adapter). This means I can reference the GPS quickly without using my hands, and without it being loose in the cockpit, without eating batteries (they go through AAs in 2-3 hours of continuous use), without losing "satellite lock" (because they are on all the time and in the companionway can "see" enough sky). Other advantages are (mostly) out of the weather (a ziplock bag will do the trick here as well). Of course, I have a tiller, which means I am standing most of the time by the companionway near the winches and aft of the traveller on the cabin-top. I wonder, however, if my "armature idea" would be useful for any similar devices, as opposed to a "hard-mount" at the wheel? If, for instance, you had a 15" LCD panel and a wireless mouse, the panel could be some distance away and still be readable. My current boat, being a catamaran, has a powerboat-like helm station with the radar mounted on a swinging arm to the side. My previous boat, had a clever idea that might be of use to some - A hatch was mounted in the bulkhead in the forward end of the cockpit, and the radar (a large crt) was mounted on a shelf inside. Its a nice solution for a display that is too large to mount on an arm. However, once you get used to have the controls at the helm, its hard to see how you can properly use a radar that isn't nearby. |
|
#3
|
|||
|
|||
|
On Tue, 15 Feb 2005 11:34:15 -0500, Jeff Morris
wrote: However, once you get used to have the controls at the helm, its hard to see how you can properly use a radar that isn't nearby. As I said, my current boat is tiller-steered, so I am only arm's length from the mainsheet traveller *forward* of the hatch, never mind the companionway itself. Reaching for anything and steering involves using my knees and leaning. If I use the tiller extender, I can go into the galley and get a refreshing beverage, or lash it in place and go forward to handle sails. It's not a small boat, either...nearly 34 feet. Makes me wonder why tillers haven't stayed popular, except that I know if's because socializing in the cockpit trumps steering. But that's another topic, perhaps. R. |
|
#4
|
|||
|
|||
|
I have two singout arms in my hatchway. The raday display is on one and
a gps/fish finder is on the other. Unfortunately, there just wasn't quite enough room to attach both devices to just one arm, my hatch just isn't tall enough to have them one above the other. When both are deployed so the helmsman can see them, it's a little inconvienient since to in or out of the hatch, you have to either carefully step over them or swing one of them out of the way. In reality, this is not a big deal since the radar is only rarely used (but when we do use it, we are REALLY glad we have it). Fair winds - Dan Best rhys wrote: It would tend to "compound errors", certainly. I've installed something on my current boat, however, that I haven't seen before. I got a gooseneck armature from an old draftsman's flourescent light and clamped it so that it swings into the companionway. It can be lashed in position with shock cord, if needed, but usually the friction knobs do the trick. On the armature I've secured a handheld GPS on "ship's power" (a 12 V cigarette lighter style adapter). This means I can reference the GPS quickly without using my hands, and without it being loose in the cockpit, without eating batteries (they go through AAs in 2-3 hours of continuous use), without losing "satellite lock" (because they are on all the time and in the companionway can "see" enough sky). Other advantages are (mostly) out of the weather (a ziplock bag will do the trick here as well). Of course, I have a tiller, which means I am standing most of the time by the companionway near the winches and aft of the traveller on the cabin-top. I wonder, however, if my "armature idea" would be useful for any similar devices, as opposed to a "hard-mount" at the wheel? If, for instance, you had a 15" LCD panel and a wireless mouse, the panel could be some distance away and still be readable. R. |
|
#5
|
|||
|
|||
|
On Tue, 15 Feb 2005 20:35:24 GMT, Dan Best
wrote: I have two singout arms in my hatchway. The raday display is on one and a gps/fish finder is on the other. Unfortunately, there just wasn't quite enough room to attach both devices to just one arm, my hatch just isn't tall enough to have them one above the other. When both are deployed so the helmsman can see them, it's a little inconvienient since to in or out of the hatch, you have to either carefully step over them or swing one of them out of the way. In reality, this is not a big deal since the radar is only rarely used (but when we do use it, we are REALLY glad we have it). Exactly. Would love to see pictures and how you routed the power and other cables to (presumably) the nav station/DC panel. R. |
|
#6
|
|||
|
|||
|
"rhys" wrote in message ... On Tue, 15 Feb 2005 20:35:24 GMT, Dan Best wrote: I have two singout arms in my hatchway. The raday display is on one and a gps/fish finder is on the other. Unfortunately, there just wasn't quite enough room to attach both devices to just one arm, my hatch just isn't tall enough to have them one above the other. When both are deployed so the helmsman can see them, it's a little inconvienient since to in or out of the hatch, you have to either carefully step over them or swing one of them out of the way. In reality, this is not a big deal since the radar is only rarely used (but when we do use it, we are REALLY glad we have it). Exactly. Would love to see pictures and how you routed the power and other cables to (presumably) the nav station/DC panel. R. I'm in the process of installing a JRC 2000 radar on my boat. The first thing I did was install the display. I wanted to be able to see it/operate it without going below. I'm using 2 horizontal RAM mount arms attached to one of there vertical mount bases. This is bolted to a small cabinet on the inside of the bulkhead. I can swing the display out so that I can see it from the wheel but I don't think I'll be able to see fine detail (don't know for sure as not fully operational yet). In this position the display blocks access to below. I can, however swing it to the side so that I can go forward to look at it and also go below easily. The cables are an issue I've been wrestling with. The power and NMEA cables are not really a problem as they are small diameter flexible wire. Easy to route. Its the display-to-scanner cable that is the problem. Big cable and not that flexible. I think I may have to disconnect it each time I swing the display into its storage position inside the boat, against the cabinet. To route this cable to the stern I'm thinking I will have to glue some white 1" diameter water pipe to the overhead in the 1/4 berth and feed the cable through that as I cannot get above the head liner and I need some play in the cable. When not in use I will have a bracket on the cabinet where I can store the cable. It will work but its not going to be as neat as I would like. |
|
#7
|
|||
|
|||
|
Gordon,
Our display-to-scanner cable drops down about 18" before heading aft through a hole in a cabinet. This plus a little slack in the cable makes it so the cable is not unduly flexed or stressed when the arm is swung in or out. Hope this helps - Dan Gordon Wedman wrote: "rhys" wrote in message ... On Tue, 15 Feb 2005 20:35:24 GMT, Dan Best wrote: I have two singout arms in my hatchway. The raday display is on one and a gps/fish finder is on the other. Unfortunately, there just wasn't quite enough room to attach both devices to just one arm, my hatch just isn't tall enough to have them one above the other. When both are deployed so the helmsman can see them, it's a little inconvienient since to in or out of the hatch, you have to either carefully step over them or swing one of them out of the way. In reality, this is not a big deal since the radar is only rarely used (but when we do use it, we are REALLY glad we have it). Exactly. Would love to see pictures and how you routed the power and other cables to (presumably) the nav station/DC panel. R. I'm in the process of installing a JRC 2000 radar on my boat. The first thing I did was install the display. I wanted to be able to see it/operate it without going below. I'm using 2 horizontal RAM mount arms attached to one of there vertical mount bases. This is bolted to a small cabinet on the inside of the bulkhead. I can swing the display out so that I can see it from the wheel but I don't think I'll be able to see fine detail (don't know for sure as not fully operational yet). In this position the display blocks access to below. I can, however swing it to the side so that I can go forward to look at it and also go below easily. The cables are an issue I've been wrestling with. The power and NMEA cables are not really a problem as they are small diameter flexible wire. Easy to route. Its the display-to-scanner cable that is the problem. Big cable and not that flexible. I think I may have to disconnect it each time I swing the display into its storage position inside the boat, against the cabinet. To route this cable to the stern I'm thinking I will have to glue some white 1" diameter water pipe to the overhead in the 1/4 berth and feed the cable through that as I cannot get above the head liner and I need some play in the cable. When not in use I will have a bracket on the cabinet where I can store the cable. It will work but its not going to be as neat as I would like. |
|
#8
|
|||
|
|||
|
Thanks Dan
If I have enough slack in my cable I may be able to work out something similar. I was thinking if I made a coil or two and connected them with small shock cord it would act somewhat like a spring as I swung the display back and forth. I would probably need to suffer the expense of buying a 15m cable to achieve this and then I'd have a 10m cable that would be difficult to sell. Should know in a few weeks as I'm finally getting my radar pole together. "Dan Best" wrote in message ... Gordon, Our display-to-scanner cable drops down about 18" before heading aft through a hole in a cabinet. This plus a little slack in the cable makes it so the cable is not unduly flexed or stressed when the arm is swung in or out. Hope this helps - Dan Gordon Wedman wrote: "rhys" wrote in message ... On Tue, 15 Feb 2005 20:35:24 GMT, Dan Best wrote: I have two singout arms in my hatchway. The raday display is on one and a gps/fish finder is on the other. Unfortunately, there just wasn't quite enough room to attach both devices to just one arm, my hatch just isn't tall enough to have them one above the other. When both are deployed so the helmsman can see them, it's a little inconvienient since to in or out of the hatch, you have to either carefully step over them or swing one of them out of the way. In reality, this is not a big deal since the radar is only rarely used (but when we do use it, we are REALLY glad we have it). Exactly. Would love to see pictures and how you routed the power and other cables to (presumably) the nav station/DC panel. R. I'm in the process of installing a JRC 2000 radar on my boat. The first thing I did was install the display. I wanted to be able to see it/operate it without going below. I'm using 2 horizontal RAM mount arms attached to one of there vertical mount bases. This is bolted to a small cabinet on the inside of the bulkhead. I can swing the display out so that I can see it from the wheel but I don't think I'll be able to see fine detail (don't know for sure as not fully operational yet). In this position the display blocks access to below. I can, however swing it to the side so that I can go forward to look at it and also go below easily. The cables are an issue I've been wrestling with. The power and NMEA cables are not really a problem as they are small diameter flexible wire. Easy to route. Its the display-to-scanner cable that is the problem. Big cable and not that flexible. I think I may have to disconnect it each time I swing the display into its storage position inside the boat, against the cabinet. To route this cable to the stern I'm thinking I will have to glue some white 1" diameter water pipe to the overhead in the 1/4 berth and feed the cable through that as I cannot get above the head liner and I need some play in the cable. When not in use I will have a bracket on the cabinet where I can store the cable. It will work but its not going to be as neat as I would like. |
|
#9
|
|||
|
|||
|
Rhys,
No big deal on routing the cables. The radar (on the port side) has both power and control cables bound together back into a galley cabinet where they split. The control/signal cable heads aft through the a large storage volume we call "the hold" on it's way to the stern mounted radar tower and the power cable turns inboard into another cabiner behind the ladder where all out pumps are (pressure water, sump pump out, etc). It is connected to a fuse block in there. The gps/fishfinder's power cable snakes under some molding to the DC distribution panel. It's transducer and GPS antenna cables enter the pump cabinet where the the swing out arm is mounted. From there, the transducer cab;e goes down along the side of the engine compartment and into the bilge where it goes forward to the transducer. The gps antenna cable goes down into the engine copartment, then aft under the floor of the hold to the stern, then up throughthe deck at the base of the radar tower. Fair winds - Dan rhys wrote: On Tue, 15 Feb 2005 20:35:24 GMT, Dan Best wrote: I have two swingout arms in my hatchway. The raday display is on one and a gps/fish finder is on the other. Exactly. Would love to see pictures and how you routed the power and other cables to (presumably) the nav station/DC panel. R. |
|
#10
|
|||
|
|||
|
On Fri, 18 Feb 2005 00:36:12 GMT, Dan Best
wrote: The gps antenna cable goes down into the engine copartment, then aft under the floor of the hold to the stern, then up throughthe deck at the base of the radar tower. Thanks for the descriptions. I always learn something when I ask stuff like this, because we are forced by technology to rethink this stuff every few years...even though a lot of the boats are still made for '70s and '80s considerations... R. |
| Reply |
| Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
| Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads
|
||||
| Thread | Forum | |||
| sailing sim; need opinions | General | |||
| Orion 27 Opinions? | Cruising | |||
| Opinions on P&H Orca??? | Touring | |||
| West System v SP System resins - opinions wanted | Boat Building | |||
| sailing sim; need opinions | ASA | |||