Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
"Capt. Neal®" wrote in message
Good point but it is physically impossible for a sailboat to windward to stay out of the way of another to leeward if the leeward vessel is more weatherly. The windward vessel cannot point higher to avoid the leeward vessel. He cannot fall off without creating a close quarters situation, and he cannot speed up or slow down because those things depend on the speed of the wind. These facts alone negate rule 13 which works well for motor vessels but not for sailing vessels. It is plain to me if one follows the sailing rules then rule 13 is superfluous. The vessel to windward is not neccessarily close-hauled, it's merely the vessel which is upwind of the other. The reason he is the give-way vessel is because he has a better chance of maintaining full control because the downwind boat may be in his wind shadow - the downwind boat may not be able to maneuvre out of trouble. Even if the windward boat was close-hauled, he can always tack away if he can't point higher to avoid the stand-on vessel. If you'd ever been racing, you'd see this happen a dozen or more times in every race. |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|