BoatBanter.com

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)
-   ASA (https://www.boatbanter.com/asa/)
-   -   Lifelines III (https://www.boatbanter.com/asa/19269-lifelines-iii.html)

Jonathan Ganz February 24th 04 12:29 AM

Lifelines III
 
I've been drenched and mine didn't go off. At one point, I noticed that
the pellet partially melted, so I replaced it.

OzOne wrote in message ...
On Mon, 23 Feb 2004 16:00:05 -0800 (PST), (Thom
Stewart) scribbled thusly:

Kim,

I don't allow my Bow man at the pointy end without a floating device. It
is the self inflating SOSupenders that we don't want up there. It is to
likely to get wet there during a sail change, causing the inflation of
the SOS. A reguler perserver Is what is required now.

Actually on the Wednesday night races, we race in the cruising class (No
flying sails) and the fore deck is kept clear. It is during the long
distance races that we use a Bow man.

Ole Thom


Thom, I'd be interested to know if the SOS had its seasonal service.
Very unusual IMHO to see one go off onboard that was properly
maintained.


Oz1...of the 3 twins.

I welcome you to crackerbox palace,We've been expecting you.




The Carrolls February 24th 04 01:48 AM

Lifelines III
 
All you show here is inexperience with safe practices, good seamanship, and
you are a hazard to newbies who might mistakenly believe you know what you
are talking about. The practice you have described here is inherently
UNSAFE.
"JAXAshby" wrote in message
...
at night, offshore and in utter safety. As much safety as if I were

walking
down 5th Avenue in NYC at 10:00 at night.

maybe *you* wouldn't be safe on a deck at night -- offshore OR coastal --,

but
you know your limitations better than we do.

Please don't claim that because *you* can't walk on a deck without falling

off
that the entire rest of the world can't either.

From: "The Carrolls"

At night, offshore? No you haven't, you may have been lucky but not

using
safe practices, there fore not in utter safety.
"JAXAshby" wrote in message
...
jonny, you stupid, clumsy, spastic clod. I have gone forward at night

offshore
to change headsails without a harness or jackline in utter safety.

You,
on the
other hand, would fall overboard.

Yep... it's better to have two (one short and one so you can stand)

for
rough conditions. As you say, jacklines in sections is the ticket.

Also,
don't forget the instruction to the crew. For example, when off shore,
the rule was that you must be hooked on when you exit the cabin at
night. During the day, this is true only in rough weather.

I have the SOSpenders with the integrated harness. Why do you think
a separate system is better?

"Michael" wrote in message
...
I mentioned earlier that the lifeline is only one integral part of

the
system and then included stanchions and Doug brought in the issue of
stanchion bases. Finally we mentioned jacklines. But's thats' not

all
of
it.

A word on harnesses and tethers. Again this is of interest only for

those
who go where they are needed, or those who need them regardless of

where
they go.

Tethers. I was tempted once upon a time to use one long one. Then

I
had
occasion to test what it was like to be dragged alongside a self

steering
boat and try to get back on board. Not a pretty picture. No it

wasn't
an
accident it was a tested conducted at speeds from one to seven

knots.
Based
on that days work we came up with the following:

Use short tethers. That coupled to a centered jackline will keep

you
from
going over.

Use two tethers in heavy weather. Snap in to the next section of

jackline
before unsnapping the first one. In the worksite use both.

Use snaplinks that are positive locking. The best one's don't come

from
the
marine stores. Go to a store specializing in gear for blue collar

folks.
My personal favorite isWork Wear in Lynwood WA.

Harnesses. The SOSpenders and the stand alone harnesses are neat,
comfortable and do the job PROVIDING they don't pop open. The kind

with
the
buckle that goes through an opening sideways then falls into place

is
not
worth the money. On our fullharnesses we use the kind where the

chest
and
leg straps are a sturdy belt buckle arrangement or a positive snap

link
with
safety release arrangement.

For going aloft or for veryheavy weather I use the industrial kind
withtheleg straps. On these the tether goes in the middle of the

back
or
to
two chest rings. For standard work around the boat I had my

comfortable
chest only harness modified with positive snap hooks to ensure it

wouldn't
come undone.

This sort of gear also makes it easy for other crew to get you back

on
board
or lower you down from an aloft worksite.

Stay away from the belt only kind for deck or going aloft purposes.

These
are banned from commercial ships anymore. Sudden falls to tether end

save
the sailor from going over but damage the spinal cord severely.

When choosing your gear keep this in mind. No one is going to show

up
in
a
few minutes when you are way out there. What you have with you is

all
you
have. Tools not Toys. And those who choose to use none of the

above
won't
be out to help you either.

M.



























The Carrolls February 24th 04 03:56 AM

Lifelines III
 
Off shore at night? Give me a break.
OzOne wrote in message ...
On Mon, 23 Feb 2004 20:48:20 -0500, "The Carrolls"
scribbled thusly:

All you show here is inexperience with safe practices, good seamanship,

and
you are a hazard to newbies who might mistakenly believe you know what

you
are talking about. The practice you have described here is inherently
UNSAFE.


Hmm, I think you're getting a tad uptight here.
It's perfectly safe on deck at night in relatively calm conditions
without a harness providing you have others on deck.
Personally, I never leave a cockpit underway at night without a
strobe.


Oz1...of the 3 twins.

I welcome you to crackerbox palace,We've been expecting you.




The Carrolls February 24th 04 05:58 AM

Lifelines III
 
If you are trying to tell me that offshore and at night foreward with no
attachment to the boat is a safe practice reguardless of sea conditions, you
are fool hardy. I don't always use a lifejacket when sailing, but I will
never tell any one that is a safe practice(no jacket). I am a tinsmith, I
work setting decking on high steel buildings, I am certianly able to walk
things such as a boat deck with out falling, most of the time, I have
slipped in bothbuilding steel and boat decks. Accidents and unforseen
circumstances happen. yes, I have been foreward too at night with no
attachment or jacket, BUT, I would never call it a safe practice on a small
vessel underway. Drop into the calm and come up under that small swell
dropping the boat, on your head. Hit something unseen in the water, either
with the boat or your head, and you have a problem. We have no business
telling a new person to our sport that it is a practice they should be
comefortable with, let them find out for themselves.
OzOne wrote in message ...
On Mon, 23 Feb 2004 22:56:15 -0500, "The Carrolls"
scribbled thusly:

Off shore at night? Give me a break.


Yep, offshore at night!
Chances of you dropping off in calm conditions is virtually zero, and
in the extremly unlikely event the strobe will give you that added
safety.

Hell, I've swum in the middle of the Pacific Ocean while underway,
hundreds of miles from land. Jumped off, a couple of laps around the
boat to exercise and refresh then climbed back on again.


OzOne wrote in message

...
On Mon, 23 Feb 2004 20:48:20 -0500, "The Carrolls"
scribbled thusly:

All you show here is inexperience with safe practices, good

seamanship,
and
you are a hazard to newbies who might mistakenly believe you know what

you
are talking about. The practice you have described here is inherently
UNSAFE.

Hmm, I think you're getting a tad uptight here.
It's perfectly safe on deck at night in relatively calm conditions
without a harness providing you have others on deck.
Personally, I never leave a cockpit underway at night without a
strobe.


Oz1...of the 3 twins.

I welcome you to crackerbox palace,We've been expecting you.





Oz1...of the 3 twins.

I welcome you to crackerbox palace,We've been expecting you.




Thom Stewart February 24th 04 07:39 AM

Lifelines III
 
Oz,

The SOS was in its 1st season. Maybe 2 month in use. Not blaming the
SOS. It did what it was suppose to do We took a wave over the Bow, just
setting up and getting ready to turn down wind. Bow man took enough
water to set off the Auto inflater. The rest of us stayed dry behind the
pilothouse.

The mast man seen it coming and stepped up on the PH roof. He was the
one who save the day. Set the tack as we turned. came Aft with sheet and
Bow man turned Mast man raised the sleeve.

Bob had to release air to drink hot Choc. on long run home.

No one hurt and we still laugh about it. Bow man uses a regular vest
now. Actually I do believe "Pnuema" racing days are over. The Old Fart
has kind of out grown it

Ole Thom


Michael February 24th 04 08:23 AM

Lifelines III
 
Don't forget your giving me loose foot lessons this summer! Racing not
required. I'm buying the oyster sandwiches next time too!

Cheers

M.


"Thom Stewart" wrote in message
...
Oz,

The SOS was in its 1st season. Maybe 2 month in use. Not blaming the
SOS. It did what it was suppose to do We took a wave over the Bow, just
setting up and getting ready to turn down wind. Bow man took enough
water to set off the Auto inflater. The rest of us stayed dry behind the
pilothouse.

The mast man seen it coming and stepped up on the PH roof. He was the
one who save the day. Set the tack as we turned. came Aft with sheet and
Bow man turned Mast man raised the sleeve.

Bob had to release air to drink hot Choc. on long run home.

No one hurt and we still laugh about it. Bow man uses a regular vest
now. Actually I do believe "Pnuema" racing days are over. The Old Fart
has kind of out grown it

Ole Thom




The Carrolls February 24th 04 10:13 AM

Lifelines III
 
Right, a time and place, and at night and offshore is a place for
attachment. No one said any thing about a person in the cockpit, only going
forward in the dark. When we started this point, jax said nothing about calm
weather either. Have you slipped at the dock? Don't tell me there haven't
been times when you have grabbed a shroud or stay to catch your self, even
in calm weather, say catching another boat's wake, perhaps one you didn't
see? I was just reading an article in lattitudes and Attitudes on rogue
waves, they can come at any time.
OzOne wrote in message ...
On Tue, 24 Feb 2004 00:58:38 -0500, "The Carrolls"
scribbled thusly:

If you are trying to tell me that offshore and at night foreward with no
attachment to the boat is a safe practice reguardless of sea conditions,

you
are fool hardy. I don't always use a lifejacket when sailing, but I will
never tell any one that is a safe practice(no jacket). I am a tinsmith, I
work setting decking on high steel buildings, I am certianly able to

walk
things such as a boat deck with out falling, most of the time, I have
slipped in bothbuilding steel and boat decks. Accidents and unforseen
circumstances happen. yes, I have been foreward too at night with no
attachment or jacket, BUT, I would never call it a safe practice on a

small
vessel underway. Drop into the calm and come up under that small swell
dropping the boat, on your head. Hit something unseen in the water,

either
with the boat or your head, and you have a problem. We have no business
telling a new person to our sport that it is a practice they should be
comefortable with, let them find out for themselves.


Yep, offshore forward in calm conditions at night is perfectly safe
provided you don't have sleepy heads in the cockpit.

Honestly the chances are much better that you'll be hit by a London
bus in NYC crossing the road under a full moon.

I'd never say it's 100% safe, nothing is.
I've had two harnesses fail in heavy weather when I've dropped off and
am very very lucky to be alive. I don't put the faith in them that
many do and use the same caution with and without.

We wear lifejackets in the Etchells when racing in moderate breeze and
my bow uses a harness when it gets real big. I wouldn't ever dismiss
the extra safety of a harness but there is a time and place for
everything.


Oz1...of the 3 twins.

I welcome you to crackerbox palace,We've been expecting you.




JAXAshby February 24th 04 02:22 PM

Lifelines III
 
dum-dum, you know *your* limitations, i.e. that *you* are unsafe walking on a
flat deck in calm conditions without falling off, but your ego is such that you
insist the rest of the world has the very same limitations. The rest of the
world does not. Sorry to tell you this, but the fact that you can't ride a
bicycle no handed does not in any way change the fact that millions of children
learn to do so every year.

There is nothing inherently dangerous about the foredeck on a boat. There is
only dangerous walking on the foredeck. There are times when it is a piece of
cake and other times when caution is required. That *you* can't tell the
difference is not my limitation.

All you show here is inexperience with safe practices, good seamanship, and
you are a hazard to newbies who might mistakenly believe you know what you
are talking about. The practice you have described here is inherently
UNSAFE.
"JAXAshby" wrote in message
...
at night, offshore and in utter safety. As much safety as if I were

walking
down 5th Avenue in NYC at 10:00 at night.

maybe *you* wouldn't be safe on a deck at night -- offshore OR coastal --,

but
you know your limitations better than we do.

Please don't claim that because *you* can't walk on a deck without falling

off
that the entire rest of the world can't either.

From: "The Carrolls"

At night, offshore? No you haven't, you may have been lucky but not

using
safe practices, there fore not in utter safety.
"JAXAshby" wrote in message
...
jonny, you stupid, clumsy, spastic clod. I have gone forward at night
offshore
to change headsails without a harness or jackline in utter safety.

You,
on the
other hand, would fall overboard.

Yep... it's better to have two (one short and one so you can stand)

for
rough conditions. As you say, jacklines in sections is the ticket.

Also,
don't forget the instruction to the crew. For example, when off shore,
the rule was that you must be hooked on when you exit the cabin at
night. During the day, this is true only in rough weather.

I have the SOSpenders with the integrated harness. Why do you think
a separate system is better?

"Michael" wrote in message
...
I mentioned earlier that the lifeline is only one integral part of

the
system and then included stanchions and Doug brought in the issue of
stanchion bases. Finally we mentioned jacklines. But's thats' not

all
of
it.

A word on harnesses and tethers. Again this is of interest only for
those
who go where they are needed, or those who need them regardless of
where
they go.

Tethers. I was tempted once upon a time to use one long one. Then

I
had
occasion to test what it was like to be dragged alongside a self
steering
boat and try to get back on board. Not a pretty picture. No it

wasn't
an
accident it was a tested conducted at speeds from one to seven

knots.
Based
on that days work we came up with the following:

Use short tethers. That coupled to a centered jackline will keep

you
from
going over.

Use two tethers in heavy weather. Snap in to the next section of
jackline
before unsnapping the first one. In the worksite use both.

Use snaplinks that are positive locking. The best one's don't come
from
the
marine stores. Go to a store specializing in gear for blue collar
folks.
My personal favorite isWork Wear in Lynwood WA.

Harnesses. The SOSpenders and the stand alone harnesses are neat,
comfortable and do the job PROVIDING they don't pop open. The kind
with
the
buckle that goes through an opening sideways then falls into place

is
not
worth the money. On our fullharnesses we use the kind where the

chest
and
leg straps are a sturdy belt buckle arrangement or a positive snap

link
with
safety release arrangement.

For going aloft or for veryheavy weather I use the industrial kind
withtheleg straps. On these the tether goes in the middle of the

back
or
to
two chest rings. For standard work around the boat I had my
comfortable
chest only harness modified with positive snap hooks to ensure it
wouldn't
come undone.

This sort of gear also makes it easy for other crew to get you back

on
board
or lower you down from an aloft worksite.

Stay away from the belt only kind for deck or going aloft purposes.
These
are banned from commercial ships anymore. Sudden falls to tether end
save
the sailor from going over but damage the spinal cord severely.

When choosing your gear keep this in mind. No one is going to show

up
in
a
few minutes when you are way out there. What you have with you is

all
you
have. Tools not Toys. And those who choose to use none of the

above
won't
be out to help you either.

M.



































JAXAshby February 24th 04 02:23 PM

Lifelines III
 
Off shore at night? Give me a break.

*your* limitation is NOT the limitation of the world.



JAXAshby February 24th 04 02:24 PM

Lifelines III
 
BOO!!

If you are trying to tell me that offshore and at night foreward with no
attachment to the boat is a safe practice reguardless of sea conditions, you
are fool hardy. I don't always use a lifejacket when sailing, but I will
never tell any one that is a safe practice(no jacket). I am a tinsmith, I
work setting decking on high steel buildings, I am certianly able to walk
things such as a boat deck with out falling, most of the time, I have
slipped in bothbuilding steel and boat decks. Accidents and unforseen
circumstances happen. yes, I have been foreward too at night with no
attachment or jacket, BUT, I would never call it a safe practice on a small
vessel underway. Drop into the calm and come up under that small swell
dropping the boat, on your head. Hit something unseen in the water, either
with the boat or your head, and you have a problem. We have no business
telling a new person to our sport that it is a practice they should be
comefortable with, let them find out for themselves.
OzOne wrote in message ...
On Mon, 23 Feb 2004 22:56:15 -0500, "The Carrolls"
scribbled thusly:

Off shore at night? Give me a break.


Yep, offshore at night!
Chances of you dropping off in calm conditions is virtually zero, and
in the extremly unlikely event the strobe will give you that added
safety.

Hell, I've swum in the middle of the Pacific Ocean while underway,
hundreds of miles from land. Jumped off, a couple of laps around the
boat to exercise and refresh then climbed back on again.


OzOne wrote in message

.. .
On Mon, 23 Feb 2004 20:48:20 -0500, "The Carrolls"
scribbled thusly:

All you show here is inexperience with safe practices, good

seamanship,
and
you are a hazard to newbies who might mistakenly believe you know what
you
are talking about. The practice you have described here is inherently
UNSAFE.

Hmm, I think you're getting a tad uptight here.
It's perfectly safe on deck at night in relatively calm conditions
without a harness providing you have others on deck.
Personally, I never leave a cockpit underway at night without a
strobe.


Oz1...of the 3 twins.

I welcome you to crackerbox palace,We've been expecting you.




Oz1...of the 3 twins.

I welcome you to crackerbox palace,We've been expecting you.













All times are GMT +1. The time now is 11:09 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com