BoatBanter.com

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)
-   ASA (https://www.boatbanter.com/asa/)
-   -   Black water? (https://www.boatbanter.com/asa/18059-black-water.html)

Bobsprit October 24th 03 11:36 AM

Black water?
 
When looking through specs on very large cruising yachts I see the terms
referring to "black and grey" water in addition to regular fresh water tankage.
Can someone explain-is this tankage for not potable use, such as heads and
such?

Thanks!

RB

JN October 24th 03 12:06 PM

Black water?
 
Never heard of black water. However, water that is usable but not potable
is usually referred to as grey water. This would be like water from the
sinks, etc. On land this water is usually used for irrigation usage,
usually watering the lawn and maybe washing the car. Therefore I will make
a guess that black water is strictly from the head. If there is a
separation between black and grey water check to see if the 34(36) has three
holding tanks, one for potable water, another for water from the kitchen and
lavatory sinks, and a third for holding crap and stuff.



Bobsprit October 24th 03 12:19 PM

Black water?
 
If there is a
separation between black and grey water check to see if the 34(36) has three
holding tanks, one for potable water, another for water from the kitchen and
lavatory sinks, and a third for holding crap and stuff.

This Black/Grey/Water designation is something I see in specs for mega yachts
generally. Like my C&C 32, the 36 has two fresh water tanks.

RB

Jeff Morris October 24th 03 12:45 PM

Black water?
 
No holding tank? I guess if you only day sail you don't need one.



"Bobsprit" wrote in message
...
If there is a
separation between black and grey water check to see if the 34(36) has three
holding tanks, one for potable water, another for water from the kitchen and
lavatory sinks, and a third for holding crap and stuff.

This Black/Grey/Water designation is something I see in specs for mega yachts
generally. Like my C&C 32, the 36 has two fresh water tanks.

RB




Bobsprit October 24th 03 12:46 PM

Black water?
 
No holding tank? I guess if you only day sail you don't need one

Uh, Jeff, the holding tank is not listed under "fresh water" tankage. Remind me
to bring bottled water if I ever pay you a visit!

Zikes!

RB

Jeff Morris October 24th 03 01:57 PM

Black water?
 
Context, Bob, context. You made two posts about total tankage, not just fresh water, and
even named the thread "black water."

Since you never stay out long enough to use the head you probably don't appreciate that
black water size can be more important than fresh water size.


"Bobsprit" wrote in message
...
No holding tank? I guess if you only day sail you don't need one

Uh, Jeff, the holding tank is not listed under "fresh water" tankage. Remind me
to bring bottled water if I ever pay you a visit!

Zikes!

RB




Steve Zweigart October 24th 03 02:01 PM

Black water?
 
My understanding, in a nutshell, is that "black water" comes from the
toilet, and "grey water" comes from the sink.

Bobsprit wrote:

When looking through specs on very large cruising yachts I see the terms
referring to "black and grey" water in addition to regular fresh water tankage.
Can someone explain-is this tankage for not potable use, such as heads and
such?

Thanks!

RB



Bobsprit October 24th 03 02:02 PM

Black water?
 
Context, Bob, context. You made two posts about total tankage, not just fresh
water, and
even named the thread "black water."

Sorry, Jeff, but my post about the C&C refers specifically to FRESH WATER.
See below. Your comment also refered to the C&C, so it's you who missed the
context, which was exact.

This Black/Grey/Water designation is something I see in specs for mega yachts
generally. Like my C&C 32, the 36 has two fresh water tanks.

I win again...a somewhat meager victory, but a victory all the same!

Yahhhoooooie!

RB

Bobsprit October 24th 03 02:03 PM

Black water?
 
My understanding, in a nutshell, is that "black water" comes from the
toilet, and "grey water" comes from the sink.

So why is grey water and potable water not the same. Why not support a greater
fresh water system overall and eliminate the grey water?

RB

Bobsprit October 24th 03 02:19 PM

Black water?
 
Good Lord!??

Yes, may I help you?

RB

Jeff Morris October 24th 03 02:54 PM

Black water?
 
Holy Bilge Water!

He said grey water "comes from the sink," not "from the sink faucet." Most of us
consider this to be a significant difference!


"Bobsprit" wrote in message
...
My understanding, in a nutshell, is that "black water" comes from the
toilet, and "grey water" comes from the sink.

So why is grey water and potable water not the same. Why not support a greater
fresh water system overall and eliminate the grey water?

RB




Jeff Morris October 24th 03 02:55 PM

Black water?
 
That's a "victory"? No wonder you think you're a winner.


"Bobsprit" wrote in message
...

I win again...a somewhat meager victory, but a victory all the same!

Yahhhoooooie!

RB




Bobsprit October 24th 03 03:07 PM

Black water?
 
He said grey water "comes from the sink," not "from the sink faucet." Most
of us
consider this to be a significant difference!

So grey water is fresh-waste water other than what used in the head?
I was not aware that such systems had to be pumped out on yachts of around 80
feet. What are the regs on waste water from a sink? On a small boat they
typically drain overboard.

RB

Scott Vernon October 24th 03 03:15 PM

Black water?
 
There is no difference, none at all. In fact, you should connect all your
tanks together with 2'' hose, thereby increasing total capacity.

Scotty

wrote in message
...
On 24 Oct 2003 10:36:25 GMT, (Bobsprit) wrote:

When looking through specs on very large cruising yachts I see the terms
referring to "black and grey" water in addition to regular fresh water

tankage.
Can someone explain-is this tankage for not potable use, such as heads

and
such?


Holy Moly!

BB




Bobsprit October 24th 03 04:04 PM

Black water?
 
feet. What are the regs on waste water from a sink? On a small boat they
typically drain overboard.

RB


Wowsers Batman!

I just looked it up for the LIS. Interesting. I'm betting Billy jane has no
idea what the regs are. By the way, some superyachts don't carry grey water
tankage and do indeed combine them as I suspected.
Looks like Jane got it wrong again!

Hooooo ahhh!

RB

Remco Moedt October 24th 03 04:13 PM

Black water?
 
On 24 Oct 2003 14:07:23 GMT, (Bobsprit) wrote:

He said grey water "comes from the sink," not "from the sink faucet." Most
of us
consider this to be a significant difference!

So grey water is fresh-waste water other than what used in the head?
I was not aware that such systems had to be pumped out on yachts of around 80
feet. What are the regs on waste water from a sink? On a small boat they
typically drain overboard.


Honey, grey water is the waste from the kitchen sink, and if present,
the shower and/or bassin from the head.

Black water is your ****...


Fresh water is what you drink.....well, apart from the Wodka...



Cheers!


Remco



Martin Baxter October 24th 03 04:15 PM

Black water?
 
wrote:



RB


Wowsers Batman!


Well BB, this has provided with my best laugh in weeks, the great expert in
all things nautical doesn't have even a passing awareness of any sanitary regulations
as they apply to marine vessels. ROTFLMAO

Cheers
Marty

Bobsprit October 24th 03 04:45 PM

Black water?
 
Well BB, this has provided with my best laugh in weeks, the great expert in
all things nautical doesn't have even a passing awareness of any sanitary
regulations
as they apply to marine vessels. ROTFLMAO

So let me get this straight...I have the ONLY sailboat that drains sink water
directly overboard!
You heard it hear 1st!!!!

Marty, you just dunked your head in the same pile of crap Billy Jane lives in!

RB

Bobsprit October 24th 03 04:47 PM

Black water?
 
I just looked it up for the LIS. Interesting. I'm betting Billy jane has no
idea what the regs are.


It has nothing to do with regs, idiot!

Sure does. And it also depends on the size of a vessel. Regs are quite
specific. I already got the answer from the Yachting Magazine forum and you
don't know what you're talking about!
Busted again!

RB

Bobsprit October 24th 03 05:06 PM

Black water?
 
I'm not the one drinking used bath water - you are! What a complete
dunce! Still want to combine your gray water with your fresh water?

Hey, girly boy, how much grey water tankage does your boat have?
Hmmmmm??!! How about the C&C 36?

Busted!

RB

Martin Baxter October 24th 03 05:11 PM

Black water?
 
Bobsprit wrote:

Well BB, this has provided with my best laugh in weeks, the great expert in
all things nautical doesn't have even a passing awareness of any sanitary
regulations
as they apply to marine vessels. ROTFLMAO

So let me get this straight...I have the ONLY sailboat that drains sink water
directly overboard!
You heard it hear 1st!!!!

Marty, you just dunked your head in the same pile of crap Billy Jane lives in!

RB


Keep flapping Boobs,
Anyone ever tell you that you're nuts!

Cheers
Marty

Donal October 24th 03 05:27 PM

Black water?
 

"Bobsprit" wrote in message
...
Well BB, this has provided with my best laugh in weeks, the great expert

in
all things nautical doesn't have even a passing awareness of any sanitary
regulations
as they apply to marine vessels. ROTFLMAO

So let me get this straight...I have the ONLY sailboat that drains sink

water
directly overboard!


Wrong.
You are the only person here who doesn't know what "grey" water means.

You also demonstrate your incredibly limited thinking once again.

These Mega Yachts that you have referred to, are very likely to visit the
Mediterranian. So they need to meet the regulations that are in force in
the Med, (and any other places that they may wish to visit).



You heard it hear 1st!!!!


Yep!

Regards


Donal
--




Bobsprit October 24th 03 05:31 PM

Black water?
 
Lets all bear in mind that Bobby Sue started this thread asking about
the difference between "gray water" and "black water"!!!

How is this an issue for boats under 50 feet?

RB

Bobsprit October 24th 03 05:32 PM

Black water?
 
My C&C 27 doesn't have gray water tankage. If I took extended cruises
where fresh water was going to be in short supply, I would have gray
water tankage, along with a system for recycling it. I would also take
a bigger boat. For 7-10 day jaunts around the LIS, it's not an issue.

I'm surprised the 27 has any tankage. I know plenty of people who cruise long
distance. They don't have gray water tankage. They have watermakers!
Grey water goes over, dummy!

RB

Bobsprit October 24th 03 05:34 PM

Black water?
 
These Mega Yachts that you have referred to, are very likely to visit the
Mediterranian. So they need to meet the regulations that are in force in
the Med, (and any other places that they may wish to visit).

So then why would this be something to know? Not exactly important info. I only
see it listed for HUGE yachts. Has nothing to do with anyone here.

RB

Bobsprit October 24th 03 05:35 PM

Black water?
 
Keep flapping Boobs,
Anyone ever tell you that you're nuts!

Still waiting to hear what grey water has to do with the boats the people in
this group sail.
And waiting...
And waiting...

RB

Bobsprit October 24th 03 05:39 PM

Black water?
 
I would have gray
water tankage, along with a system for recycling it.

Sweet jesus. It's 1955 again!

RB

Bobsprit October 24th 03 05:45 PM

Black water?
 
Any idea as to the difference in power consumption between making
potable water from the ocean and making potable water from gray water?

On a proper boat with modern charging systems running a watermaker direct works
fine. My boat had a watermaker installed when I bought her/ No grey water
tankage. The 34XL has a water maker. No grey water tankage. The world cruising
Hughes 38 at my yard doesn't carry grey water, nor does the Valiant 40 that
heads south each November.
You know NOTHING, Jane! Buy a real boat and then open your wrinkled yap!

Bwahahahaha!

RB

Bobsprit October 24th 03 06:01 PM

Black water?
 
I'm not the one asking the newbie questions. Many boats do not have
things that other boats have. Many boats have things that other boats
do not have. What's your point, if you have one?

So should I also know all about bow thrusters? How about large deck mounted
windless systems? How about a solid vang? Do I need to be an expert in those
before I actually use one on my own boat?
Jane, I assure you I've sailed more boats than you ever will!

Billy Jane. you remain a total idiot.

RB

Donal October 24th 03 06:29 PM

Black water?
 

"Bobsprit" wrote in message
...
These Mega Yachts that you have referred to, are very likely to visit the
Mediterranian. So they need to meet the regulations that are in force in
the Med, (and any other places that they may wish to visit).

So then why would this be something to know? Not exactly important info. I

only
see it listed for HUGE yachts. Has nothing to do with anyone here.


Don't you ever step aboard a Mega Yacht at a Boat Show?

You should! It might help you to achieve more in life.



Regards


Donal
--



Jeff Morris October 24th 03 06:52 PM

Black water?
 
OK, you've held your breath long enough.

I've sailed many times in places where grey water discharge is not permitted - though I'll
admit not very often in boats big enough to have grey water facilities. But sailors with
trailer boats definitely have to understand this issue, since grey water discharge is not
allow in many fresh water lakes - including most of them in your home state.

When I brought my current boat down from Toronto I looked into the Lake Champlain route -
I was told that I could get hassled because of the grey water issues. Though technically
not illegal, the local authorities don't like to see soap subs around the boat. We
ended up doing the Erie Canal.



"Bobsprit" wrote in message
...
Keep flapping Boobs,
Anyone ever tell you that you're nuts!

Still waiting to hear what grey water has to do with the boats the people in
this group sail.
And waiting...
And waiting...

RB




Bobsprit October 24th 03 10:19 PM

Black water?
 
Knowing at least a little might be nice. Knowing the difference
between greay water and black water

But you just said you don't have a boat with grey water. None of us do. So how
is this "basic" knowledge? It's not mentioned in any of my sailing books.
Should I buy a plumbing book?

Tee hee! It's like beating a baby with his own candy!

RB

Bobsprit October 24th 03 10:20 PM

Black water?
 
see it listed for HUGE yachts. Has nothing to do with anyone here.

Don't you ever step aboard a Mega Yacht at a Boat Show?

Nope. Not interested in mega yachts.

RB

Bobsprit October 24th 03 10:20 PM

Black water?
 
You should! It might help you to achieve more in life.

Yeah! This grey water thing is probably why I didn't start with a Swan!

RB

Donal October 24th 03 11:54 PM

Black water?
 

"Bobsprit" wrote in message
...
see it listed for HUGE yachts. Has nothing to do with anyone here.


Don't you ever step aboard a Mega Yacht at a Boat Show?

Nope. Not interested in mega yachts.


I'm really quite shocked. That is the most revealing thing that you have
ever written about yourself!! It explains why you will never own anything
more than a "stepping stone".

It also explains your degree of success at film making, doesn't it?

BTW ... it also explains why you cannot understand how my boat cost nothing!
Meanwhile, each and every, stepping stone that you purchase has to be an
incredible bargain.

The rest of us have already bought our dream boats. You are condemned to a
life of second choices.



Regards


Donal
--






Rick October 25th 03 12:38 AM

Black water?
 
wrote:


If I took extended cruises
where fresh water was going to be in short supply, I would have gray
water tankage, along with a system for recycling it.


?????? What???

And you are laughing at BSpit?

Please tell us about this gray water recycling system you would use.

Rick


SAIL LOCO October 25th 03 12:40 AM

Black water?
 
When looking through specs on very large cruising yachts I see the terms
referring to "black and grey" water in addition to regular fresh water tankage.
Can someone explain-is this tankage for not potable use, such as heads and
such?

He knows nothing about boats.


S/V Express 30 "Ringmaster"
Trains are a winter sport

Bobsprit October 25th 03 12:56 AM

Black water?
 
Nope. Not interested in mega yachts.

I'm really quite shocked. That is the most revealing thing that you have
ever written about yourself!! It explains why you will never own anything
more than a "stepping stone".

Why would anyone who actually likes to sail be interested in a mega yacht?
Oh, right...you're a Beneteau owner!

RB

Bobsprit October 25th 03 12:57 AM

Black water?
 
The rest of us have already bought our dream boats.

Wow. A Beneteau as a dream boat. Even if it were true, one would hope you'd
have enough self respect not to write such a thing.
I'm sorry, Donal. I had no idea things were so bad for you.

RB

Rick October 25th 03 01:26 AM

Black water?
 
wrote:


Apparently you've been asleep for the past 50 years. Try to keep up.


So humor me and tell us about your graywater recycling system for boats.

Rick



All times are GMT +1. The time now is 06:07 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com