View Single Post
  #3   Report Post  
Old April 26th 04, 11:12 AM
John Fereira
 
Posts: n/a
Default perception or dagger

"Michael Daly" wrote in
:

On 25-Apr-2004, (Dxmetal2003) wrote:

1) Perception 17 eclipse : 2) Perception 16.5 shadow :


Neither of these kayaks performs well in rough conditions and wind.
My SO unloaded her Shadow and got a Solstice GTS.


I haven't paddled any of those in rough conditions but rented a Shadow for a
weekend. I'm about the same size as Dxmetal2003 and the Shadow fit me
*much* better than the Eclipse

I con't comment on Dagger products - the only Dagger I ever got in
was an Ocoee and that's not even a kayak (some would say it's not
a proper canoe either :-)

Unfortunately i do not have a mean to demo these boats personally
before the purchase.


Then you're taking a big risk. I would never buy a kayak based on a
recommendation - especially one from the Internet. Would you buy
hiking boots based on opinions without ever trying them on?


What I have to wonder is if he doesn't have the means to demo those boats
personally why limit the choices to Dagger and Perception.