BoatBanter.com - Coleman Canoe wrapped around a rock

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)

- Touring (https://www.boatbanter.com/touring/)

- - Coleman Canoe wrapped around a rock - need parts (https://www.boatbanter.com/touring/72768-coleman-canoe-wrapped-around-rock-need-parts.html)

Coleman Canoe wrapped around a rock - need parts

Loaned out my Coleman B Model canoe, purchased in 1979. Guess what -
wrecked. Need a Keelson, Center thwart and Gunwale for left side.

Unfortunately, Coleman sold the div to Pelican who no longer have or
stock parts.

Do any of you know where I can still get replacement parts for this
conoe????????

Thanks

Coleman Canoe wrapped around a rock - need parts

"FrogontheLog" wrote in message
oups.com...
Loaned out my Coleman B Model canoe, purchased in 1979. Guess what -
wrecked. Need a Keelson, Center thwart and Gunwale for left side.

Unfortunately, Coleman sold the div to Pelican who no longer have or
stock parts.

Do any of you know where I can still get replacement parts for this
conoe????????

Thanks

Umm, why bother? Coleman boats are notorious for being of low quality, and
your 1979 model is certainly beyond its life expectancy anyway. You could
use this opportunity to replace it with a boat from a more reputable
manufacturer, and get something of quality. Old Town, Mad River, Lincoln and
others have boats in a competitive price range to Coleman, and they will
last much longer. In fact, it's quite possible that an OT Discovery 16'
would not have wrapped in the same situation that destroyed your Coleman, as
the OT hulls are much more rigid and slippery.

--riverman

Coleman Canoe wrapped around a rock - need parts

Here are some reasons to repair:
First - hopefully the cost of repair, which would be very simple,
should be less, and the boat would be good as new. The ramx material
returned to its original shape just fine.
Second - where do you get rid of a half good canoe? and Why would you
want to throw out something that is fixable?

Then upon purchasing another canoe, I would have an extra for even more
fun!

riverman wrote:
"FrogontheLog" wrote in message
oups.com...
Loaned out my Coleman B Model canoe, purchased in 1979. Guess what -
wrecked. Need a Keelson, Center thwart and Gunwale for left side.

Unfortunately, Coleman sold the div to Pelican who no longer have or
stock parts.

Do any of you know where I can still get replacement parts for this
conoe????????

Thanks

Umm, why bother? Coleman boats are notorious for being of low quality, and
your 1979 model is certainly beyond its life expectancy anyway. You could
use this opportunity to replace it with a boat from a more reputable
manufacturer, and get something of quality. Old Town, Mad River, Lincoln and
others have boats in a competitive price range to Coleman, and they will
last much longer. In fact, it's quite possible that an OT Discovery 16'
would not have wrapped in the same situation that destroyed your Coleman, as
the OT hulls are much more rigid and slippery.

--riverman

Coleman Canoe wrapped around a rock - need parts

Bluntly, you're making an unwarranted assumption. When Coleman owned it,
they had a repair kit available for the RAM-X. It was ultimately taken off
the market and they themselves admitted it didn't work. So far as I know
nothing has worked effectively on Ram-X to where someone could trust it
again.
The aluminum alloy in the internal supports is an odd mix. If you try to
straighten it out it doesn't come back to anything near its original
strength is is prone to snapping at the crease marks. Again, not safe.
This sort of exchange has come up on this newsgroup before, and for the most
part, the sentiments expressed are very similar. These boats were intended
for very casual use, say paddling 100 yds out from the dock to do some
fishing then back to it. Not much more. Their prices at the time were
good, and less than most canoes. There was a reason. A serious paddler who
would use it heavily wouldn't be interested. For the casual user, it was a
good deal. That lower price, though, had a hidden cost -- the boat isn't
truly repairable and had a finite lifespan.
If it's not fixable, then it's a waste of a lot of money to attempt it, or
it's zero. Good as new? not likely. Safe? I wouldn't trust it for more
than what's mentioned above. I'm sorry but other than that, they do make
good planters....
If you have become a bit more interested in paddling, you will also find a
world of difference in performance, less effort, ability to move a boat
fairly precisely, etc. in the other brands mentioned in other messages...

Joe P.
*************************

"FrogontheLog" wrote in message
ups.com...
Here are some reasons to repair:
First - hopefully the cost of repair, which would be very simple,
should be less, and the boat would be good as new. The ramx material
returned to its original shape just fine.
Second - where do you get rid of a half good canoe? and Why would you
want to throw out something that is fixable?

Then upon purchasing another canoe, I would have an extra for even more
fun!

riverman wrote:
"FrogontheLog" wrote in message
oups.com...
Loaned out my Coleman B Model canoe, purchased in 1979. Guess what -
wrecked. Need a Keelson, Center thwart and Gunwale for left side.

Unfortunately, Coleman sold the div to Pelican who no longer have or
stock parts.

Do any of you know where I can still get replacement parts for this
conoe????????

Thanks

Umm, why bother? Coleman boats are notorious for being of low quality,
and
your 1979 model is certainly beyond its life expectancy anyway. You
could
use this opportunity to replace it with a boat from a more reputable
manufacturer, and get something of quality. Old Town, Mad River, Lincoln
and
others have boats in a competitive price range to Coleman, and they will
last much longer. In fact, it's quite possible that an OT Discovery 16'
would not have wrapped in the same situation that destroyed your
Coleman, as
the OT hulls are much more rigid and slippery.

--riverman

Coleman Canoe wrapped around a rock - need parts

Froggy, if you have even a modicum of shop skills you should be able to
fabricate a replacement keelson and center thwart for next to nothing.
Just size some thick-walled electrical conduit for the keelson, and use
amything you want for the thwart.

That's the easy part.

The hard part is going to be the gunwale replacement. I'll take you
at your word that Coleman parts are not available. If one gunwale is
unsalvageable you'll need to find something to take its place. The
poly construction of Coleman RamX boats was so floppy that they
absolutely needed both the keelson and strut framework and the those
beefy aluminum gunwales to help maintain their shape.

That being the case I'd suggest that the replacement needs to be a
relatively beefy aluminuim gunwale. Two if you want the gunwales to
match for esthetic reasons (Coleman...esthetics...I guess just one
replacement gunwale will do eh)

Replacement gunwales aren't cheap - think $100+ for a pair. And
they are even more expensive to have shipped (unless they come in with
a load of boats from a manufacturer).

Best case scenario you have a canoe manufacturer (who uses beefy
aluminum gunwales) somewhere within driving distance. Drive out, pick
up the gunwale(s), drive back. Drill out the busted original gunwale.
Remove the strut work and bent keelson. Buy the appropriate conduit and
thwart replacement. Reassemble the canoe and you still have a
crappyclunkyColeman.

Let's add it up (just the cost, not your time and effort):

Gas - $20, gunwale - $60, conduit and other parts, $15.

Hmmmm $95? For another $5 you could just buy a use Coleman RamX from a
Pennysaver ad.

Seriously, it's only worth fixing this junker if you have time,
skills, patience and access to reasonable priced materials. And even
then it's awfully close to polishing a turd.

FrogontheLog wrote:
Here are some reasons to repair:
First - hopefully the cost of repair, which would be very simple,
should be less, and the boat would be good as new. The ramx material
returned to its original shape just fine.
Second - where do you get rid of a half good canoe? and Why would you
want to throw out something that is fixable?

Then upon purchasing another canoe, I would have an extra for even more
fun!

riverman wrote:
"FrogontheLog" wrote in message
oups.com...
Loaned out my Coleman B Model canoe, purchased in 1979. Guess what -
wrecked. Need a Keelson, Center thwart and Gunwale for left side.

Unfortunately, Coleman sold the div to Pelican who no longer have or
stock parts.

Do any of you know where I can still get replacement parts for this
conoe????????

Thanks

Umm, why bother? Coleman boats are notorious for being of low quality, and
your 1979 model is certainly beyond its life expectancy anyway. You could
use this opportunity to replace it with a boat from a more reputable
manufacturer, and get something of quality. Old Town, Mad River, Lincoln and
others have boats in a competitive price range to Coleman, and they will
last much longer. In fact, it's quite possible that an OT Discovery 16'
would not have wrapped in the same situation that destroyed your Coleman, as
the OT hulls are much more rigid and slippery.

--riverman

Coleman Canoe wrapped around a rock - need parts

Michael Daly wrote:
I know those old canoes - but wood is stiffer than aluminum in bending, pound
for pound. I'm pretty sure that stiffness is more important than strength in
those Colemans - the plastic hull is so flexible that it relies on the frame and
gunwale to keep its shape.

I think a slightly heavier than average version of a canoe gunwale would do.
Hardwood would be best. In fact, two strips - one inside. one out - screwed
through the hull at regular intervals would probably be easier and better than
one big hunk of wood. It would also be easier to bend to the shape of the canoe.

Mike
Inwale and outwale screwed together is what I was suggesting, although
I was joking about using pressure treated 2x4's.

Or at least partially joking - I was serious about a wrapped '79
Coleman not being worth spending more than $25 or 25 minutes fixing.
Used Colemans are fairly common in the $100 range.

The cost of new wood gunwales is undoubtedly out of the question
($150++). And finding 16' lengths of decent hardwood is hard enough,
at least where I live. And pricy to boot.

Even if something like 16' lengths of halfround hardwood trim were
used it'll still need several coats of oil or varnish and then time
and materials to screw the inwale and outwale together.

If you can pick up a similar used canoe for $100, or even $150 how much
money, time and effort is it worth to bandage up a 27 year old model
that's been wrapped?

T + E + $ (Time plus Effort plus Money), all to polish a turd..

Coleman Canoe wrapped around a rock - need parts