BoatBanter.com

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)
-   General (https://www.boatbanter.com/general/)
-   -   Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie (https://www.boatbanter.com/general/95442-tragic-loss-life-lake-erie.html)

JimH[_2_] June 19th 08 10:15 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
http://www.sanduskyregister.com/arti...ont/795327.txt
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Quote: Authorities have not ruled out operator inattention, speed or
alcohol as a cause of the accident. They did not believe wind or water
conditions played a role.

While Steinle was never tested for alcohol in his system, his boat was
boarded and inspected by the U.S. Coast Guard minutes before the
crash. One of his lights had a problem that was corrected on the spot,
Johnston said.

Miller's recovered body will undergo toxicology tests.

The Ohio Department of Natural Resources in Columbus does not have a
record of Miller ever owning a boating education card. The law is that
anyone born after Jan. 1, 1982, must complete an education course
before operating a watercraft of greater than 10 horsepower.

"According to our records, he did not have any completion of any
boater safety class that we're aware of," Wisse said. "It doesn't mean
he didn't complete something, somewhere, but we don't have a record of
it."

End quote.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

[email protected] June 20th 08 12:28 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
On Jun 19, 5:15*pm, JimH wrote:
http://www.sanduskyregister.com/arti...ont/795327.txt
---------------------------------------------------------------------------*--------------------------------

Quote: *Authorities have not ruled out operator inattention, speed or
alcohol as a cause of the accident. They did not believe wind or water
conditions played a role.



What's your point? The "authorities" also haven't ruled out suicide,
heart attack, seizure, diabetic coma, a fall, and on and on.

JimH[_2_] June 20th 08 02:21 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
On Jun 20, 7:28*am, wrote:
On Jun 19, 5:15*pm, JimH wrote:

http://www.sanduskyregister.com/arti...ont/795327.txt
---------------------------------------------------------------------------*--------------------------------


Quote: *Authorities have not ruled out operator inattention, speed or
alcohol as a cause of the accident. They did not believe wind or water
conditions played a role.


What's your point? The "authorities" also haven't ruled out suicide,
heart attack, seizure, diabetic coma, a fall, and on and on.



sigh

I should have known better than to post something relating to boating
here.

GDSmith June 20th 08 03:16 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 

sigh

I should have known better than to post something relating to boating
here.


I wouldn't worry about it too much - there are ignorant people
everywhere.

I'd like to thank you for posting the note - my brother lives just off
Lake Erie on the other side of Cleveland and we've taken our boat up
there for several lake runs - always a good time. It just surprises
me that people go out running that late at night (approx 12:30 am),
presumably above 20mph, with MINIMAL lighting on the boat. I'm sorry
that this resulted in a loss of life, but I can't imagine running
around in those conditions - even if there was a (near) full moon on
Monday.

--------------------------
GDSmith
Harpers Ferry, WV

2003 Baja 242 Islander
http://ICanHelp56.homestead.com/Baja001.html

[email protected] June 20th 08 03:27 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
On Jun 20, 9:21*am, JimH wrote:
On Jun 20, 7:28*am, wrote:

On Jun 19, 5:15*pm, JimH wrote:


http://www.sanduskyregister.com/arti...ont/795327.txt
---------------------------------------------------------------------------**--------------------------------


Quote: *Authorities have not ruled out operator inattention, speed or
alcohol as a cause of the accident. They did not believe wind or water
conditions played a role.


What's your point? The "authorities" also haven't ruled out suicide,
heart attack, seizure, diabetic coma, a fall, and on and on.


sigh

I should have known better than to post something relating to boating
here.


I should have known you aren't bright enough to understand. It's the
tone and tact with which you posted, quoting a small part of the big
picture. And the quote was just plain silly, no matter who made it.

[email protected] June 20th 08 03:29 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
On Jun 20, 10:27*am, wrote:
On Jun 20, 9:21*am, JimH wrote:





On Jun 20, 7:28*am, wrote:


On Jun 19, 5:15*pm, JimH wrote:


http://www.sanduskyregister.com/arti...ont/795327.txt
---------------------------------------------------------------------------***--------------------------------


Quote: *Authorities have not ruled out operator inattention, speed or
alcohol as a cause of the accident. They did not believe wind or water
conditions played a role.


What's your point? The "authorities" also haven't ruled out suicide,
heart attack, seizure, diabetic coma, a fall, and on and on.


sigh


I should have known better than to post something relating to boating
here.


I should have known you aren't bright enough to understand. It's the
tone and tact with which you posted, quoting a small part of the big
picture. And the quote was just plain silly, no matter who made it.- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -


I didn't think so, but anyway.. I am sitting here wondering why most
boats I have been on have a "dead man's throttle". I think I will
start a thread.

JimH[_2_] June 20th 08 03:49 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
On Jun 20, 10:29*am, wrote:
On Jun 20, 10:27*am, wrote:



On Jun 20, 9:21*am, JimH wrote:


On Jun 20, 7:28*am, wrote:


On Jun 19, 5:15*pm, JimH wrote:


http://www.sanduskyregister.com/arti...ont/795327.txt
---------------------------------------------------------------------------***--------------------------------


Quote: *Authorities have not ruled out operator inattention, speed or
alcohol as a cause of the accident. They did not believe wind or water
conditions played a role.


What's your point? The "authorities" also haven't ruled out suicide,
heart attack, seizure, diabetic coma, a fall, and on and on.


sigh


I should have known better than to post something relating to boating
here.


I should have known you aren't bright enough to understand. It's the
tone and tact with which you posted, quoting a small part of the big
picture. And the quote was just plain silly, no matter who made it.- Hide quoted text -


- Show quoted text -


I didn't think so, but anyway.. I am sitting here wondering why most
boats I have been on have a "dead man's throttle". I think I will
start a thread.


The accident I reported is a prime reason for the kill switch w/
lanyard. Many (most?) States require them on boats and PWC's. Even
the 5 hp outboard I have has one.

JimH[_2_] June 20th 08 03:51 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
On Jun 20, 10:16*am, GDSmith wrote:
sigh

I should have known better than to post something relating to boating
here.


I wouldn't worry about it too much - there are ignorant people
everywhere.

I'd like to thank you for posting the note - my brother lives just off
Lake Erie on the other side of Cleveland and we've taken our boat up
there for several lake runs - always a good time. *It just surprises
me that people go out running that late at night (approx 12:30 am),
presumably above 20mph, with MINIMAL lighting on the boat. *I'm sorry
that this resulted in a loss of life, but I can't imagine running
around in those conditions - even if there was a (near) full moon on
Monday.

--------------------------
GDSmith
Harpers Ferry, WV

2003 Baja 242 Islanderhttp://ICanHelp56.homestead.com/Baja001.html


I agree with you regarding the operators being out at such a late hour
and traveling at excessive speeds.

I would be surprised if it is determined that alcohol was not involved.

[email protected] June 20th 08 04:39 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
On Jun 20, 10:51*am, JimH wrote:
On Jun 20, 10:16*am, GDSmith wrote:





sigh


I should have known better than to post something relating to boating
here.


I wouldn't worry about it too much - there are ignorant people
everywhere.


I'd like to thank you for posting the note - my brother lives just off
Lake Erie on the other side of Cleveland and we've taken our boat up
there for several lake runs - always a good time. *It just surprises
me that people go out running that late at night (approx 12:30 am),
presumably above 20mph, with MINIMAL lighting on the boat. *I'm sorry
that this resulted in a loss of life, but I can't imagine running
around in those conditions - even if there was a (near) full moon on
Monday.


--------------------------
GDSmith
Harpers Ferry, WV


2003 Baja 242 Islanderhttp://ICanHelp56.homestead.com/Baja001.html


I agree with you regarding the operators being out at such a late hour
and traveling at excessive speeds.

I would be surprised if it is determined that alcohol was not involved.- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -


Nice, guilty already.......typical.

DK June 21st 08 01:48 AM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
GDSmith wrote:
sigh

I should have known better than to post something relating to boating
here.


I wouldn't worry about it too much - there are ignorant people
everywhere.

I'd like to thank you for posting the note - my brother lives just off
Lake Erie on the other side of Cleveland and we've taken our boat up
there for several lake runs - always a good time. It just surprises
me that people go out running that late at night (approx 12:30 am),
presumably above 20mph, with MINIMAL lighting on the boat. I'm sorry
that this resulted in a loss of life, but I can't imagine running
around in those conditions - even if there was a (near) full moon on
Monday.

--------------------------
GDSmith
Harpers Ferry, WV

2003 Baja 242 Islander
http://ICanHelp56.homestead.com/Baja001.html


JimH would consider your boat to be a "I call them "Go Fast" or
"Obnoxious" boats."

Tread lightly. He can be a huge asshole.

[email protected] June 21st 08 01:27 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
On Jun 20, 8:48*pm, DK wrote:
GDSmith wrote:
sigh


I should have known better than to post something relating to boating
here.


I wouldn't worry about it too much - there are ignorant people
everywhere.


I'd like to thank you for posting the note - my brother lives just off
Lake Erie on the other side of Cleveland and we've taken our boat up
there for several lake runs - always a good time. *It just surprises
me that people go out running that late at night (approx 12:30 am),
presumably above 20mph, with MINIMAL lighting on the boat. *I'm sorry
that this resulted in a loss of life, but I can't imagine running
around in those conditions - even if there was a (near) full moon on
Monday.


--------------------------
GDSmith
Harpers Ferry, WV


2003 Baja 242 Islander
http://ICanHelp56.homestead.com/Baja001.html


JimH would consider your boat to be a "I call them "Go Fast" or
"Obnoxious" boats."

Tread lightly. *He can be a huge asshole.- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -


Here's something funny. I see over at Chuck's that JimH is chastising
someone because he has interests "other than boating". He then comes
here and whines like a little baby because every single post isn't
about boating........

HK June 21st 08 02:20 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
wrote:
On Jun 20, 8:48 pm, DK wrote:
GDSmith wrote:
sigh
I should have known better than to post something relating to boating
here.

I wouldn't worry about it too much - there are ignorant people
everywhere.
I'd like to thank you for posting the note - my brother lives just off
Lake Erie on the other side of Cleveland and we've taken our boat up
there for several lake runs - always a good time. It just surprises
me that people go out running that late at night (approx 12:30 am),
presumably above 20mph, with MINIMAL lighting on the boat. I'm sorry
that this resulted in a loss of life, but I can't imagine running
around in those conditions - even if there was a (near) full moon on
Monday.
--------------------------
GDSmith
Harpers Ferry, WV
2003 Baja 242 Islander
http://ICanHelp56.homestead.com/Baja001.html
JimH would consider your boat to be a "I call them "Go Fast" or
"Obnoxious" boats."

Tread lightly. He can be a huge asshole.- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -


Here's something funny. I see over at Chuck's that JimH is chastising
someone because he has interests "other than boating". He then comes
here and whines like a little baby because every single post isn't
about boating........




Chuck's:

A good place to discuss boats.

http://boatingforum.proboards91.com/index.cgi

HK June 21st 08 04:27 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
wrote:
On Jun 20, 8:48 pm, DK wrote:
GDSmith wrote:
sigh
I should have known better than to post something relating to boating
here.

I wouldn't worry about it too much - there are ignorant people
everywhere.
I'd like to thank you for posting the note - my brother lives just off
Lake Erie on the other side of Cleveland and we've taken our boat up
there for several lake runs - always a good time. It just surprises
me that people go out running that late at night (approx 12:30 am),
presumably above 20mph, with MINIMAL lighting on the boat. I'm sorry
that this resulted in a loss of life, but I can't imagine running
around in those conditions - even if there was a (near) full moon on
Monday.
--------------------------
GDSmith
Harpers Ferry, WV
2003 Baja 242 Islander
http://ICanHelp56.homestead.com/Baja001.html
JimH would consider your boat to be a "I call them "Go Fast" or
"Obnoxious" boats."

Tread lightly. He can be a huge asshole.- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -


Here's something funny. I see over at Chuck's that JimH is chastising
someone because he has interests "other than boating". He then comes
here and whines like a little baby because every single post isn't
about boating........



For someone with as much disdain for Chuck's Place as you have
demonstrated here, you sure spend a lot of time reading the posts there
and commenting on them here, even the ones you don't understand, which,
apparently, is most of them.

Interesting you don't post there. No balls for *that* either, I suppose.

-rick- June 21st 08 06:46 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
wrote:

...He then comes
here and whines like a little baby because every single post isn't
about boating........


how about we just ignore it...

HK June 21st 08 07:11 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
-rick- wrote:
wrote:

...He then comes
here and whines like a little baby because every single post isn't
about boating........


how about we just ignore it...



If Loogy & Gang couldn't whine and post off-topic, why, they'd have no
reason to post here or anywhere else.

JimH[_2_] June 21st 08 09:13 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
On Jun 20, 10:16*am, GDSmith wrote:
sigh

I should have known better than to post something relating to boating
here.


I wouldn't worry about it too much - there are ignorant people
everywhere.

I'd like to thank you for posting the note - my brother lives just off
Lake Erie on the other side of Cleveland and we've taken our boat up
there for several lake runs - always a good time. *It just surprises
me that people go out running that late at night (approx 12:30 am),
presumably above 20mph, with MINIMAL lighting on the boat. *I'm sorry
that this resulted in a loss of life, but I can't imagine running
around in those conditions - even if there was a (near) full moon on
Monday.

--------------------------
GDSmith
Harpers Ferry, WV

2003 Baja 242 Islanderhttp://ICanHelp56.homestead.com/Baja001.html


I was talking with one of the owners of our marina yesterday and this
accident came up. I then brought up another fatal accident several
years back also involving a cigarette boat hitting another boat at a
high rate of speed.

He told me that the man who was killed was a docker at his marina. He
had just graduated from college with high honors and his parent
purchased him the 29 foot boat as a graduation gift. They went out on
the boat for the first time when a man from Leamington, Canada plowed
his 38 foot boat at 50 mph into the young mans boat.

The accident occurred in broad daylight.

http://justice.org/homepage/boat1008.aspx

http://www-catalog.cpl.org/CLENIX/ACT-4248

Don White June 21st 08 09:53 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 

"JimH" wrote in message
...
On Jun 20, 10:16 am, GDSmith wrote:
sigh

I should have known better than to post something relating to boating
here.


I wouldn't worry about it too much - there are ignorant people
everywhere.

I'd like to thank you for posting the note - my brother lives just off
Lake Erie on the other side of Cleveland and we've taken our boat up
there for several lake runs - always a good time. It just surprises
me that people go out running that late at night (approx 12:30 am),
presumably above 20mph, with MINIMAL lighting on the boat. I'm sorry
that this resulted in a loss of life, but I can't imagine running
around in those conditions - even if there was a (near) full moon on
Monday.

--------------------------
GDSmith
Harpers Ferry, WV

2003 Baja 242 Islanderhttp://ICanHelp56.homestead.com/Baja001.html


I was talking with one of the owners of our marina yesterday and this
accident came up. I then brought up another fatal accident several
years back also involving a cigarette boat hitting another boat at a
high rate of speed.

He told me that the man who was killed was a docker at his marina. He
had just graduated from college with high honors and his parent
purchased him the 29 foot boat as a graduation gift. They went out on
the boat for the first time when a man from Leamington, Canada plowed
his 38 foot boat at 50 mph into the young mans boat.

The accident occurred in broad daylight.

http://justice.org/homepage/boat1008.aspx

http://www-catalog.cpl.org/CLENIX/ACT-4248

At least the drunk operator received some jail time. If the event had
occured up here, he may have gotten house arrest.
http://www.cbc.ca/canada/nova-scotia...e.html?ref=rss



JimH[_2_] June 21st 08 10:04 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
On Jun 21, 4:53*pm, "Don White" wrote:
"JimH" wrote in message

...
On Jun 20, 10:16 am, GDSmith wrote:



sigh


I should have known better than to post something relating to boating
here.


I wouldn't worry about it too much - there are ignorant people
everywhere.


I'd like to thank you for posting the note - my brother lives just off
Lake Erie on the other side of Cleveland and we've taken our boat up
there for several lake runs - always a good time. It just surprises
me that people go out running that late at night (approx 12:30 am),
presumably above 20mph, with MINIMAL lighting on the boat. I'm sorry
that this resulted in a loss of life, but I can't imagine running
around in those conditions - even if there was a (near) full moon on
Monday.


--------------------------
GDSmith
Harpers Ferry, WV


2003 Baja 242 Islanderhttp://ICanHelp56.homestead.com/Baja001.html


I was talking with one of the owners of our marina yesterday and this
accident came up. *I then brought up another fatal accident several
years back also involving a cigarette boat hitting another boat at a
high rate of speed.

He told me that the man who was killed was a docker at his marina. *He
had just graduated from college with high honors and his parent
purchased him the 29 foot boat as a graduation gift. *They went out on
the boat for the first time when a man from Leamington, Canada plowed
his 38 foot boat at 50 mph into the young mans boat.

The accident occurred in broad daylight.

http://justice.org/homepage/boat1008.aspx

http://www-catalog.cpl.org/CLENIX/ACT-4248

At least the drunk operator received some jail time. *If the event had
occured up here, he may have gotten house arrest.http://www.cbc.ca/canada/nova-scotia...ackay-sentence...



He was able to transfer his assets in a timely manner and his boat
conveniently was torched while it was still insured. Nice guy.

DK June 22nd 08 02:31 AM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
wrote:
On Jun 20, 8:48 pm, DK wrote:
GDSmith wrote:
sigh
I should have known better than to post something relating to boating
here.

I wouldn't worry about it too much - there are ignorant people
everywhere.
I'd like to thank you for posting the note - my brother lives just off
Lake Erie on the other side of Cleveland and we've taken our boat up
there for several lake runs - always a good time. It just surprises
me that people go out running that late at night (approx 12:30 am),
presumably above 20mph, with MINIMAL lighting on the boat. I'm sorry
that this resulted in a loss of life, but I can't imagine running
around in those conditions - even if there was a (near) full moon on
Monday.
--------------------------
GDSmith
Harpers Ferry, WV
2003 Baja 242 Islander
http://ICanHelp56.homestead.com/Baja001.html
JimH would consider your boat to be a "I call them "Go Fast" or
"Obnoxious" boats."

Tread lightly. He can be a huge asshole.- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -


Here's something funny. I see over at Chuck's that JimH is chastising
someone because he has interests "other than boating". He then comes
here and whines like a little baby because every single post isn't
about boating........


He's a piece of work. He will bitch about anything - here or there.

Jim June 22nd 08 07:55 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 

"DK" wrote in message
...
GDSmith wrote:
sigh

I should have known better than to post something relating to boating
here.


I wouldn't worry about it too much - there are ignorant people
everywhere.

I'd like to thank you for posting the note - my brother lives just off
Lake Erie on the other side of Cleveland and we've taken our boat up
there for several lake runs - always a good time. It just surprises
me that people go out running that late at night (approx 12:30 am),
presumably above 20mph, with MINIMAL lighting on the boat. I'm sorry
that this resulted in a loss of life, but I can't imagine running
around in those conditions - even if there was a (near) full moon on
Monday.

--------------------------
GDSmith
Harpers Ferry, WV

2003 Baja 242 Islander
http://ICanHelp56.homestead.com/Baja001.html


JimH would consider your boat to be a "I call them "Go Fast" or
"Obnoxious" boats."

Tread lightly. He can be a huge asshole.


What do you mean "can be"?


JimH[_2_] June 22nd 08 08:17 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
On Jun 22, 2:55*pm, "Jim" wrote:
"DK" wrote in message

...



GDSmith wrote:
sigh


I should have known better than to post something relating to boating
here.


I wouldn't worry about it too much - there are ignorant people
everywhere.


I'd like to thank you for posting the note - my brother lives just off
Lake Erie on the other side of Cleveland and we've taken our boat up
there for several lake runs - always a good time. *It just surprises
me that people go out running that late at night (approx 12:30 am),
presumably above 20mph, with MINIMAL lighting on the boat. *I'm sorry
that this resulted in a loss of life, but I can't imagine running
around in those conditions - even if there was a (near) full moon on
Monday.


--------------------------
GDSmith
Harpers Ferry, WV


2003 Baja 242 Islander
http://ICanHelp56.homestead.com/Baja001.html


JimH would consider your boat to be a "I call them "Go Fast" or
"Obnoxious" boats."


Tread lightly. *He can be a huge asshole.


What do you mean "can be"?


How old did you boys say you are?

JimH[_2_] June 22nd 08 08:22 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
On Jun 21, 4:53*pm, "Don White" wrote:
"JimH" wrote in message

...
On Jun 20, 10:16 am, GDSmith wrote:



sigh


I should have known better than to post something relating to boating
here.


I wouldn't worry about it too much - there are ignorant people
everywhere.


I'd like to thank you for posting the note - my brother lives just off
Lake Erie on the other side of Cleveland and we've taken our boat up
there for several lake runs - always a good time. It just surprises
me that people go out running that late at night (approx 12:30 am),
presumably above 20mph, with MINIMAL lighting on the boat. I'm sorry
that this resulted in a loss of life, but I can't imagine running
around in those conditions - even if there was a (near) full moon on
Monday.


--------------------------
GDSmith
Harpers Ferry, WV


2003 Baja 242 Islanderhttp://ICanHelp56.homestead.com/Baja001.html


I was talking with one of the owners of our marina yesterday and this
accident came up. *I then brought up another fatal accident several
years back also involving a cigarette boat hitting another boat at a
high rate of speed.

He told me that the man who was killed was a docker at his marina. *He
had just graduated from college with high honors and his parent
purchased him the 29 foot boat as a graduation gift. *They went out on
the boat for the first time when a man from Leamington, Canada plowed
his 38 foot boat at 50 mph into the young mans boat.

The accident occurred in broad daylight.

http://justice.org/homepage/boat1008.aspx

http://www-catalog.cpl.org/CLENIX/ACT-4248

At least the drunk operator received some jail time. *If the event had
occured up here, he may have gotten house arrest.http://www.cbc.ca/canada/nova-scotia...ackay-sentence...


We have some members here who continue to want to take this NG into
the sewer. Their childish and insulting comments in this *on topic*
thread prove it.

Too bad.

Canuck57[_3_] June 22nd 08 09:20 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 

"JimH" wrote in message
...
On Jun 20, 7:28 am, wrote:
On Jun 19, 5:15 pm, JimH wrote:

http://www.sanduskyregister.com/arti...ont/795327.txt
---------------------------------------------------------------------------*--------------------------------


Quote: Authorities have not ruled out operator inattention, speed or
alcohol as a cause of the accident. They did not believe wind or water
conditions played a role.


What's your point? The "authorities" also haven't ruled out suicide,
heart attack, seizure, diabetic coma, a fall, and on and on.



sigh

I should have known better than to post something relating to boating
here.
----------

Interesting post. Sounds like both boats were under power.

I am no maritime law expert, but I suspect the surviving captain has some
answering to do. Leaving the scene not looking for the other boats
passengers to start. Since both are under power, some fault goes to both.
His argument leaving might hold, but safety over the boat.... will make an
interesting read when the reports come out.



Canuck57[_3_] June 22nd 08 09:25 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 

"Don White" wrote in message
...

"JimH" wrote in message
...
On Jun 20, 10:16 am, GDSmith wrote:
sigh

I should have known better than to post something relating to boating
here.


I wouldn't worry about it too much - there are ignorant people
everywhere.

I'd like to thank you for posting the note - my brother lives just off
Lake Erie on the other side of Cleveland and we've taken our boat up
there for several lake runs - always a good time. It just surprises
me that people go out running that late at night (approx 12:30 am),
presumably above 20mph, with MINIMAL lighting on the boat. I'm sorry
that this resulted in a loss of life, but I can't imagine running
around in those conditions - even if there was a (near) full moon on
Monday.

--------------------------
GDSmith
Harpers Ferry, WV

2003 Baja 242 Islanderhttp://ICanHelp56.homestead.com/Baja001.html


I was talking with one of the owners of our marina yesterday and this
accident came up. I then brought up another fatal accident several
years back also involving a cigarette boat hitting another boat at a
high rate of speed.

He told me that the man who was killed was a docker at his marina. He
had just graduated from college with high honors and his parent
purchased him the 29 foot boat as a graduation gift. They went out on
the boat for the first time when a man from Leamington, Canada plowed
his 38 foot boat at 50 mph into the young mans boat.

The accident occurred in broad daylight.

http://justice.org/homepage/boat1008.aspx

http://www-catalog.cpl.org/CLENIX/ACT-4248

At least the drunk operator received some jail time. If the event had
occured up here, he may have gotten house arrest.
http://www.cbc.ca/canada/nova-scotia...e.html?ref=rss


Also cost him 4.1M.

Part of his sentence should have been pulling his drivers license and never
to drive a boat again. I remember reading something they are starting to do
this in Canada where if you are intoxicated, they treat it just like DWI.
Good deal.



JimH[_2_] June 22nd 08 10:29 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
On Jun 22, 4:25*pm, "Canuck57" wrote:
"Don White" wrote in message

...





"JimH" wrote in message
....
On Jun 20, 10:16 am, GDSmith wrote:
sigh


I should have known better than to post something relating to boating
here.


I wouldn't worry about it too much - there are ignorant people
everywhere.


I'd like to thank you for posting the note - my brother lives just off
Lake Erie on the other side of Cleveland and we've taken our boat up
there for several lake runs - always a good time. It just surprises
me that people go out running that late at night (approx 12:30 am),
presumably above 20mph, with MINIMAL lighting on the boat. I'm sorry
that this resulted in a loss of life, but I can't imagine running
around in those conditions - even if there was a (near) full moon on
Monday.


--------------------------
GDSmith
Harpers Ferry, WV


2003 Baja 242 Islanderhttp://ICanHelp56.homestead.com/Baja001.html


I was talking with one of the owners of our marina yesterday and this
accident came up. *I then brought up another fatal accident several
years back also involving a cigarette boat hitting another boat at a
high rate of speed.


He told me that the man who was killed was a docker at his marina. *He
had just graduated from college with high honors and his parent
purchased him the 29 foot boat as a graduation gift. *They went out on
the boat for the first time when a man from Leamington, Canada plowed
his 38 foot boat at 50 mph into the young mans boat.


The accident occurred in broad daylight.


http://justice.org/homepage/boat1008.aspx


http://www-catalog.cpl.org/CLENIX/ACT-4248


At least the drunk operator received some jail time. *If the event had
occured up here, he may have gotten house arrest.
http://www.cbc.ca/canada/nova-scotia...ackay-sentence...


Also cost him 4.1M.

Part of his sentence should have been pulling his drivers license and never
to drive a boat again. *I remember reading something they are starting to do
this in Canada where if you are intoxicated, they treat it just like DWI.
Good deal.


A cheap price to pay for taking the life of a 'top of his class' young
man.

BAR[_2_] June 23rd 08 01:21 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
JimH wrote:

A cheap price to pay for taking the life of a 'top of his class' young
man.


What is the price to pay for taking the life of a 'bottom of his class'
young man? Who determines the value of a life? Who determines the
potential of that life.

HK June 23rd 08 01:33 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
BAR wrote:
JimH wrote:

A cheap price to pay for taking the life of a 'top of his class' young
man.


What is the price to pay for taking the life of a 'bottom of his class'
young man?



You planning to "off" yourself to collect the insurance?

:)

BAR[_2_] June 23rd 08 01:33 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
HK wrote:
BAR wrote:
JimH wrote:

A cheap price to pay for taking the life of a 'top of his class' young
man.


What is the price to pay for taking the life of a 'bottom of his
class' young man?



You planning to "off" yourself to collect the insurance?

:)


You wish!

JimH[_2_] June 23rd 08 01:51 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
On Jun 23, 8:21*am, BAR wrote:
JimH wrote:

A cheap price to pay for taking the life of a 'top of his class' young
man.


What is the price to pay for taking the life of a 'bottom of his class'
young man? Who determines the value of a life? Who determines the
potential of that life.



Potential lifetime earnings.

Life is always precious and as sad as it may sound but the life of a
doctor is worth more to the jury than the life of someone who dropped
out of high school.

HK June 23rd 08 01:52 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
BAR wrote:
HK wrote:
BAR wrote:
JimH wrote:

A cheap price to pay for taking the life of a 'top of his class' young
man.

What is the price to pay for taking the life of a 'bottom of his
class' young man?



You planning to "off" yourself to collect the insurance?

:)


You wish!




Whoosh.

BAR[_2_] June 23rd 08 01:54 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
JimH wrote:
On Jun 23, 8:21 am, BAR wrote:
JimH wrote:

A cheap price to pay for taking the life of a 'top of his class' young
man.

What is the price to pay for taking the life of a 'bottom of his class'
young man? Who determines the value of a life? Who determines the
potential of that life.



Potential lifetime earnings.

Life is always precious and as sad as it may sound but the life of a
doctor is worth more to the jury than the life of someone who dropped
out of high school.


Bill Gates, a college dropout.

The CEO's of many of the Fortune 500 companies never graduated from
college, yet they earn more than just about every doctor on the face of
the earth.

The ability to earn is not based upon your ability to lean it is based
upon your ability to actually do a job and get paid for that job.


JimH[_2_] June 23rd 08 01:58 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
On Jun 23, 8:54*am, BAR wrote:
JimH wrote:
On Jun 23, 8:21 am, BAR wrote:
JimH wrote:


A cheap price to pay for taking the life of a 'top of his class' young
man.
What is the price to pay for taking the life of a 'bottom of his class'
young man? Who determines the value of a life? Who determines the
potential of that life.


Potential lifetime earnings.


Life is always precious and as sad as it may sound but the life of a
doctor is worth more to the jury than the life of someone who dropped
out of high school.


Bill Gates, a college dropout.

The CEO's of many of the Fortune 500 companies never graduated from
college, yet they earn more than just about every doctor on the face of
the earth.

The ability to earn is not based upon your ability to lean it is based
upon your ability to actually do a job and get paid for that job.


There are always exceptions to the rule.

You want to argue about this for some reason. I am just telling you
how juries compute the price of a life.

Now go try to pick a fight with someone else.

HK June 23rd 08 02:09 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
BAR wrote:
JimH wrote:
On Jun 23, 8:21 am, BAR wrote:
JimH wrote:

A cheap price to pay for taking the life of a 'top of his class' young
man.
What is the price to pay for taking the life of a 'bottom of his class'
young man? Who determines the value of a life? Who determines the
potential of that life.



Potential lifetime earnings.

Life is always precious and as sad as it may sound but the life of a
doctor is worth more to the jury than the life of someone who dropped
out of high school.


Bill Gates, a college dropout.

The CEO's of many of the Fortune 500 companies never graduated from
college, yet they earn more than just about every doctor on the face of
the earth.


Why would that matter to you? You're not going to be the CEO of anything
of consequence. And the fact that some CEO's earn more than physicians
only shows how sick out society is.

[email protected] June 23rd 08 02:15 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
On Jun 23, 8:51*am, JimH wrote:
On Jun 23, 8:21*am, BAR wrote:

JimH wrote:


A cheap price to pay for taking the life of a 'top of his class' young
man.


What is the price to pay for taking the life of a 'bottom of his class'
young man? Who determines the value of a life? Who determines the
potential of that life.


Potential lifetime earnings.

That's certainly all YOU are worth to society.

HK June 23rd 08 02:18 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
wrote:
On Jun 23, 8:51 am, JimH wrote:
On Jun 23, 8:21 am, BAR wrote:

JimH wrote:
A cheap price to pay for taking the life of a 'top of his class' young
man.
What is the price to pay for taking the life of a 'bottom of his class'
young man? Who determines the value of a life? Who determines the
potential of that life.

Potential lifetime earnings.

That's certainly all YOU are worth to society.



In your case, that would be what, $9.99?

BAR[_2_] June 23rd 08 02:43 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
HK wrote:
BAR wrote:
JimH wrote:
On Jun 23, 8:21 am, BAR wrote:
JimH wrote:

A cheap price to pay for taking the life of a 'top of his class' young
man.
What is the price to pay for taking the life of a 'bottom of his class'
young man? Who determines the value of a life? Who determines the
potential of that life.


Potential lifetime earnings.

Life is always precious and as sad as it may sound but the life of a
doctor is worth more to the jury than the life of someone who dropped
out of high school.


Bill Gates, a college dropout.

The CEO's of many of the Fortune 500 companies never graduated from
college, yet they earn more than just about every doctor on the face
of the earth.


Why would that matter to you? You're not going to be the CEO of anything
of consequence. And the fact that some CEO's earn more than physicians
only shows how sick out society is.


Why? A CEO employs more people than an MD. A does more good for society
than an MD. Bad CEOs are weaned out fairly quickly, however, the medical
profession protects bad MDs in an attempt to protect all MDs with the
thinking that if they can get the bad ones then they can get the good
ones too. Good old socialist thinking at its best.

HK June 23rd 08 02:58 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
BAR wrote:
HK wrote:
BAR wrote:
JimH wrote:
On Jun 23, 8:21 am, BAR wrote:
JimH wrote:

A cheap price to pay for taking the life of a 'top of his class'
young
man.
What is the price to pay for taking the life of a 'bottom of his
class'
young man? Who determines the value of a life? Who determines the
potential of that life.


Potential lifetime earnings.

Life is always precious and as sad as it may sound but the life of a
doctor is worth more to the jury than the life of someone who dropped
out of high school.

Bill Gates, a college dropout.

The CEO's of many of the Fortune 500 companies never graduated from
college, yet they earn more than just about every doctor on the face
of the earth.


Why would that matter to you? You're not going to be the CEO of
anything of consequence. And the fact that some CEO's earn more than
physicians only shows how sick out society is.


Why? A CEO employs more people than an MD. A does more good for society
than an MD. Bad CEOs are weaned out fairly quickly, however, the medical
profession protects bad MDs in an attempt to protect all MDs with the
thinking that if they can get the bad ones then they can get the good
ones too. Good old socialist thinking at its best.



Your lack of understanding and intelligence never ceases to amaze. You
must be one of Loogie's many fathers.

BAR[_2_] June 23rd 08 03:09 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
HK wrote:
BAR wrote:
HK wrote:
BAR wrote:
JimH wrote:
On Jun 23, 8:21 am, BAR wrote:
JimH wrote:

A cheap price to pay for taking the life of a 'top of his class'
young
man.
What is the price to pay for taking the life of a 'bottom of his
class'
young man? Who determines the value of a life? Who determines the
potential of that life.


Potential lifetime earnings.

Life is always precious and as sad as it may sound but the life of a
doctor is worth more to the jury than the life of someone who dropped
out of high school.

Bill Gates, a college dropout.

The CEO's of many of the Fortune 500 companies never graduated from
college, yet they earn more than just about every doctor on the face
of the earth.

Why would that matter to you? You're not going to be the CEO of
anything of consequence. And the fact that some CEO's earn more than
physicians only shows how sick out society is.


Why? A CEO employs more people than an MD. A does more good for
society than an MD. Bad CEOs are weaned out fairly quickly, however,
the medical profession protects bad MDs in an attempt to protect all
MDs with the thinking that if they can get the bad ones then they can
get the good ones too. Good old socialist thinking at its best.



Your lack of understanding and intelligence never ceases to amaze. You
must be one of Loogie's many fathers.


Really? What is the value of your average GP MD type to the world? He
does nothing more than pass out pills and referrals.

The practice of medicine is still as much a guessing game as it is a
science. Hell 200 years ago they were bleeding people to make them
better! Anti-biotics hadn't been fully understood until about 60 years
ago. They still don't really know how the brain works. Chemical
reactions in the body? Have you read some of the package inserts for
some medicines? They can't tell you why it works but they can tell you
what you are putting into your body and what happens to your body after
it metabolizes what you just ingested.

You shouldn't place MDs on such high pedestals.

HK June 23rd 08 03:27 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
BAR wrote:
HK wrote:
BAR wrote:
HK wrote:
BAR wrote:
JimH wrote:
On Jun 23, 8:21 am, BAR wrote:
JimH wrote:

A cheap price to pay for taking the life of a 'top of his class'
young
man.
What is the price to pay for taking the life of a 'bottom of his
class'
young man? Who determines the value of a life? Who determines the
potential of that life.


Potential lifetime earnings.

Life is always precious and as sad as it may sound but the life of a
doctor is worth more to the jury than the life of someone who dropped
out of high school.

Bill Gates, a college dropout.

The CEO's of many of the Fortune 500 companies never graduated from
college, yet they earn more than just about every doctor on the
face of the earth.

Why would that matter to you? You're not going to be the CEO of
anything of consequence. And the fact that some CEO's earn more than
physicians only shows how sick out society is.

Why? A CEO employs more people than an MD. A does more good for
society than an MD. Bad CEOs are weaned out fairly quickly, however,
the medical profession protects bad MDs in an attempt to protect all
MDs with the thinking that if they can get the bad ones then they can
get the good ones too. Good old socialist thinking at its best.



Your lack of understanding and intelligence never ceases to amaze. You
must be one of Loogie's many fathers.


Really? What is the value of your average GP MD type to the world? He
does nothing more than pass out pills and referrals.


Your lack of understanding and intelligence never ceases to amaze.

You demonstrate attitudes very typical of those who never did well in
school and resent those who did.

Reginald P. Smithers III[_9_] June 23rd 08 05:23 PM

Tragic Loss of Life on Lake Erie
 
HK wrote:
BAR wrote:
HK wrote:
BAR wrote:
HK wrote:
BAR wrote:
JimH wrote:
On Jun 23, 8:21 am, BAR wrote:
JimH wrote:

A cheap price to pay for taking the life of a 'top of his
class' young
man.
What is the price to pay for taking the life of a 'bottom of his
class'
young man? Who determines the value of a life? Who determines the
potential of that life.


Potential lifetime earnings.

Life is always precious and as sad as it may sound but the life of a
doctor is worth more to the jury than the life of someone who
dropped
out of high school.

Bill Gates, a college dropout.

The CEO's of many of the Fortune 500 companies never graduated
from college, yet they earn more than just about every doctor on
the face of the earth.

Why would that matter to you? You're not going to be the CEO of
anything of consequence. And the fact that some CEO's earn more
than physicians only shows how sick out society is.

Why? A CEO employs more people than an MD. A does more good for
society than an MD. Bad CEOs are weaned out fairly quickly, however,
the medical profession protects bad MDs in an attempt to protect all
MDs with the thinking that if they can get the bad ones then they
can get the good ones too. Good old socialist thinking at its best.


Your lack of understanding and intelligence never ceases to amaze.
You must be one of Loogie's many fathers.


Really? What is the value of your average GP MD type to the world? He
does nothing more than pass out pills and referrals.


Your lack of understanding and intelligence never ceases to amaze.

You demonstrate attitudes very typical of those who never did well in
school and resent those who did.


Do you mean the kind of person who would have to leave New England, home
of the best schools in the world, and go to school at a 4th tier school
such as University of Kansas?


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:23 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com