Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #1   Report Post  
posted to rec.boats
 
Posts: n/a
Default A bad day on the boat

Jim, tht doesn't sound good at all. I think you may have burnt valves,
a blown head gasket[s], maybe even cracked heads.


Sorry for the downtime, man. especially when your vacation is just now
starting..

Good Luck!

JimH wrote:
Cut out of work at noon and scrambled to the boat to hook up with friends of
ours, meeting them at the mouth of the Vermilion River with boat our boats.
We arrived first and once safely past the breakwall idled while waiting for
them. The trip was perhaps 15 minutes tops.

I started to smell something burning and saw puffs of smoke coming out of
the engine compartment. I shut down the engine and grabbed a fire
extinguisher while my wife threw out the anchor, then opened the engine
compartment to see smoke coming off the engine and to hear hissing and
popping. Gave it a shot from the ABC dry chemical fire extinguisher
thinking there may be a fire. Saw the temperature gauge pegged at 250F.

Radioed our friends who towed us back to our marina. The marina mechanic
checked to see if there was any foaming or burnt smell with the engine oil
(none) or oil in the bilge (none). Sigh, maybe a good sign, or at least I
hope so.

We ended up leaving the boat with our mechanic and spent the day on our
friends boat. After 3 or so hours I got a call from the marina, telling me
they checked out the engine (after letting it cool) and judge it to be OK,
although the impeller needs replacing. They said I could safely move the
boat to my slip if I wanted to until repairs are made.

We got back to the marina later today and I took the boat from the gas dock
to our slip, with the temperature rising to 220F during that short trip from
the gas dock to our slip (5 minutes). The boat also ran very rough during
that short trip

So.......besides replacing the impellor any other suggestions on what I
should ask the marina to do? What is causing the rough engine, especially
after having a tune up only 4 engine hours ago? Is there some internal
damage I may have done?

Single 1997 Volvo Penta 4.3L, Chevy 190 HP.

TIA for your answers.

BTW: My vacation started this afternoon (one week of it) and this was the
last thing I expected to have to deal with.


  #2   Report Post  
posted to rec.boats
JohnH
 
Posts: n/a
Default A bad day on the boat

On 30 Jun 2006 21:03:23 -0700, wrote:

Jim, tht doesn't sound good at all. I think you may have burnt valves,
a blown head gasket[s], maybe even cracked heads.


Sorry for the downtime, man. especially when your vacation is just now
starting..

Good Luck!

JimH wrote:
Cut out of work at noon and scrambled to the boat to hook up with friends of
ours, meeting them at the mouth of the Vermilion River with boat our boats.
We arrived first and once safely past the breakwall idled while waiting for
them. The trip was perhaps 15 minutes tops.

I started to smell something burning and saw puffs of smoke coming out of
the engine compartment. I shut down the engine and grabbed a fire
extinguisher while my wife threw out the anchor, then opened the engine
compartment to see smoke coming off the engine and to hear hissing and
popping. Gave it a shot from the ABC dry chemical fire extinguisher
thinking there may be a fire. Saw the temperature gauge pegged at 250F.

Radioed our friends who towed us back to our marina. The marina mechanic
checked to see if there was any foaming or burnt smell with the engine oil
(none) or oil in the bilge (none). Sigh, maybe a good sign, or at least I
hope so.

We ended up leaving the boat with our mechanic and spent the day on our
friends boat. After 3 or so hours I got a call from the marina, telling me
they checked out the engine (after letting it cool) and judge it to be OK,
although the impeller needs replacing. They said I could safely move the
boat to my slip if I wanted to until repairs are made.

We got back to the marina later today and I took the boat from the gas dock
to our slip, with the temperature rising to 220F during that short trip from
the gas dock to our slip (5 minutes). The boat also ran very rough during
that short trip

So.......besides replacing the impellor any other suggestions on what I
should ask the marina to do? What is causing the rough engine, especially
after having a tune up only 4 engine hours ago? Is there some internal
damage I may have done?

Single 1997 Volvo Penta 4.3L, Chevy 190 HP.

TIA for your answers.

BTW: My vacation started this afternoon (one week of it) and this was the
last thing I expected to have to deal with.


This sounds very much like the symptoms I had with a plugged
manifold/riser. The smoke I got came from a rubber coated cable which was
resting on an exhaust elbow that overheated. I didn't have to use the fire
extinguisher though.

New manifolds and risers and exhaust parts made it run like new. Luckily, I
had no water get into the exhaust, but if a manifold gasket went bad, that
could also be a problem. When the engine is running, normally, I can place
my hand on a riser for a few seconds. When it was plugged, a slight touch
burned like hell!
--
John H

******************************************
***** Have a Spectacular Day! *****
******************************************
  #3   Report Post  
posted to rec.boats
JohnH
 
Posts: n/a
Default A bad day on the boat

On Sat, 01 Jul 2006 07:29:20 -0400, JohnH wrote:

On 30 Jun 2006 21:03:23 -0700, wrote:

Jim, tht doesn't sound good at all. I think you may have burnt valves,
a blown head gasket[s], maybe even cracked heads.


Sorry for the downtime, man. especially when your vacation is just now
starting..

Good Luck!

JimH wrote:
Cut out of work at noon and scrambled to the boat to hook up with friends of
ours, meeting them at the mouth of the Vermilion River with boat our boats.
We arrived first and once safely past the breakwall idled while waiting for
them. The trip was perhaps 15 minutes tops.

I started to smell something burning and saw puffs of smoke coming out of
the engine compartment. I shut down the engine and grabbed a fire
extinguisher while my wife threw out the anchor, then opened the engine
compartment to see smoke coming off the engine and to hear hissing and
popping. Gave it a shot from the ABC dry chemical fire extinguisher
thinking there may be a fire. Saw the temperature gauge pegged at 250F.

Radioed our friends who towed us back to our marina. The marina mechanic
checked to see if there was any foaming or burnt smell with the engine oil
(none) or oil in the bilge (none). Sigh, maybe a good sign, or at least I
hope so.

We ended up leaving the boat with our mechanic and spent the day on our
friends boat. After 3 or so hours I got a call from the marina, telling me
they checked out the engine (after letting it cool) and judge it to be OK,
although the impeller needs replacing. They said I could safely move the
boat to my slip if I wanted to until repairs are made.

We got back to the marina later today and I took the boat from the gas dock
to our slip, with the temperature rising to 220F during that short trip from
the gas dock to our slip (5 minutes). The boat also ran very rough during
that short trip

So.......besides replacing the impellor any other suggestions on what I
should ask the marina to do? What is causing the rough engine, especially
after having a tune up only 4 engine hours ago? Is there some internal
damage I may have done?

Single 1997 Volvo Penta 4.3L, Chevy 190 HP.

TIA for your answers.

BTW: My vacation started this afternoon (one week of it) and this was the
last thing I expected to have to deal with.


This sounds very much like the symptoms I had with a plugged
manifold/riser. The smoke I got came from a rubber coated cable which was
resting on an exhaust elbow that overheated. I didn't have to use the fire
extinguisher though.

New manifolds and risers and exhaust parts made it run like new. Luckily, I
had no water get into the exhaust, but if a manifold gasket went bad, that
could also be a problem. When the engine is running, normally, I can place
my hand on a riser for a few seconds. When it was plugged, a slight touch
burned like hell!


Whoops, should have said, "...no water get into the cylinders..."

Also, my manifolds/risers were seven seasons old when this happened. I've
heard that ten years is about max life.
--
John H

******************************************
***** Have a Spectacular Day! *****
******************************************
  #5   Report Post  
posted to rec.boats
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by BoatBanter: Jul 2006
Posts: 1,315
Default A bad day on the boat


wrote in message
oups.com...
Jim, tht doesn't sound good at all. I think you may have burnt valves,
a blown head gasket[s], maybe even cracked heads.


Sorry for the downtime, man. especially when your vacation is just now
starting..

Good Luck!

JimH wrote:
Cut out of work at noon and scrambled to the boat to hook up with friends
of
ours, meeting them at the mouth of the Vermilion River with boat our
boats.
We arrived first and once safely past the breakwall idled while waiting
for
them. The trip was perhaps 15 minutes tops.

I started to smell something burning and saw puffs of smoke coming out of
the engine compartment. I shut down the engine and grabbed a fire
extinguisher while my wife threw out the anchor, then opened the engine
compartment to see smoke coming off the engine and to hear hissing and
popping. Gave it a shot from the ABC dry chemical fire extinguisher
thinking there may be a fire. Saw the temperature gauge pegged at 250F.

Radioed our friends who towed us back to our marina. The marina mechanic
checked to see if there was any foaming or burnt smell with the engine
oil
(none) or oil in the bilge (none). Sigh, maybe a good sign, or at least
I
hope so.

We ended up leaving the boat with our mechanic and spent the day on our
friends boat. After 3 or so hours I got a call from the marina, telling
me
they checked out the engine (after letting it cool) and judge it to be
OK,
although the impeller needs replacing. They said I could safely move the
boat to my slip if I wanted to until repairs are made.

We got back to the marina later today and I took the boat from the gas
dock
to our slip, with the temperature rising to 220F during that short trip
from
the gas dock to our slip (5 minutes). The boat also ran very rough
during
that short trip

So.......besides replacing the impellor any other suggestions on what I
should ask the marina to do? What is causing the rough engine,
especially
after having a tune up only 4 engine hours ago? Is there some internal
damage I may have done?

Single 1997 Volvo Penta 4.3L, Chevy 190 HP.

TIA for your answers.

BTW: My vacation started this afternoon (one week of it) and this was
the
last thing I expected to have to deal with.



As Eisboch pointed out and as was confirmed by our mechanic (and a mechanic
friend of ours we saw today) it is probably not that bad if we did not see
water in the oil and as the heads are cast iron.

The impeller is being replaced on Wednesday and we will see if that does the
trick.

As a side note: I had asked the marina to change the impeller at the
beginning of the season as I did not know when the last time it was changed
(we bought the boat last summer). They said they checked it and it looked
fine. Something had to have happened between then and last Friday.




  #6   Report Post  
posted to rec.boats
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by BoatBanter: Jul 2006
Posts: 879
Default A bad day on the boat

Jim, a blown head gasket isn't necessarily determined by water in the
oil. It could be the "rough running" is because of some fire
extinguisher stuff, got in the distributor, but I doubt it. OR the
engine was hot enough that it's causing the fuel to pre-detonate. or
even vapor lock in the intake manifold. That bad thing is that even if
the heads and gaskets are ok, the over heating can still cause the
valve seals to get brittle and eventually start leaking oil into the
valves, this is usually evident by a puff of blue smoke on initial
start up. Hope all works out for you.


JimH wrote:
wrote in message
oups.com...
Jim, tht doesn't sound good at all. I think you may have burnt valves,
a blown head gasket[s], maybe even cracked heads.


Sorry for the downtime, man. especially when your vacation is just now
starting..

Good Luck!

JimH wrote:
Cut out of work at noon and scrambled to the boat to hook up with friends
of
ours, meeting them at the mouth of the Vermilion River with boat our
boats.
We arrived first and once safely past the breakwall idled while waiting
for
them. The trip was perhaps 15 minutes tops.

I started to smell something burning and saw puffs of smoke coming out of
the engine compartment. I shut down the engine and grabbed a fire
extinguisher while my wife threw out the anchor, then opened the engine
compartment to see smoke coming off the engine and to hear hissing and
popping. Gave it a shot from the ABC dry chemical fire extinguisher
thinking there may be a fire. Saw the temperature gauge pegged at 250F.

Radioed our friends who towed us back to our marina. The marina mechanic
checked to see if there was any foaming or burnt smell with the engine
oil
(none) or oil in the bilge (none). Sigh, maybe a good sign, or at least
I
hope so.

We ended up leaving the boat with our mechanic and spent the day on our
friends boat. After 3 or so hours I got a call from the marina, telling
me
they checked out the engine (after letting it cool) and judge it to be
OK,
although the impeller needs replacing. They said I could safely move the
boat to my slip if I wanted to until repairs are made.

We got back to the marina later today and I took the boat from the gas
dock
to our slip, with the temperature rising to 220F during that short trip
from
the gas dock to our slip (5 minutes). The boat also ran very rough
during
that short trip

So.......besides replacing the impellor any other suggestions on what I
should ask the marina to do? What is causing the rough engine,
especially
after having a tune up only 4 engine hours ago? Is there some internal
damage I may have done?

Single 1997 Volvo Penta 4.3L, Chevy 190 HP.

TIA for your answers.

BTW: My vacation started this afternoon (one week of it) and this was
the
last thing I expected to have to deal with.



As Eisboch pointed out and as was confirmed by our mechanic (and a mechanic
friend of ours we saw today) it is probably not that bad if we did not see
water in the oil and as the heads are cast iron.

The impeller is being replaced on Wednesday and we will see if that does the
trick.

As a side note: I had asked the marina to change the impeller at the
beginning of the season as I did not know when the last time it was changed
(we bought the boat last summer). They said they checked it and it looked
fine. Something had to have happened between then and last Friday.


  #7   Report Post  
posted to rec.boats
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by BoatBanter: Jul 2006
Posts: 389
Default A bad day on the boat

It would be good to give us more details on the boat. Age, enigne
size. Age of the manifolds and risers. Last major work. Salt water,
fresh water, or both? Raw water cooling or heat exchanger?

If it ran rough as soon as your started it back up that may be a bad
sign. Running rough while actually overheated is not a problem. In
either case you have to fix the overheating problem. As lost of other
posters have pointed out the manifolds and risers are always the first
suspect if they are more than 5 years old. The thermostat could also
be a problem.

Unfortunately overheating causes other damage. Heads warp. Gaskets
start leaking. Rubber exhaust parts melt. Once you fix the
overheating if it still runs rough I'd suggest a compression test to
rule out major engine damage.

wrote:
Jim, a blown head gasket isn't necessarily determined by water in the
oil. It could be the "rough running" is because of some fire
extinguisher stuff, got in the distributor, but I doubt it. OR the
engine was hot enough that it's causing the fuel to pre-detonate. or
even vapor lock in the intake manifold. That bad thing is that even if
the heads and gaskets are ok, the over heating can still cause the
valve seals to get brittle and eventually start leaking oil into the
valves, this is usually evident by a puff of blue smoke on initial
start up. Hope all works out for you.


JimH wrote:
wrote in message
oups.com...
Jim, tht doesn't sound good at all. I think you may have burnt valves,
a blown head gasket[s], maybe even cracked heads.


Sorry for the downtime, man. especially when your vacation is just now
starting..

Good Luck!

JimH wrote:
Cut out of work at noon and scrambled to the boat to hook up with friends
of
ours, meeting them at the mouth of the Vermilion River with boat our
boats.
We arrived first and once safely past the breakwall idled while waiting
for
them. The trip was perhaps 15 minutes tops.

I started to smell something burning and saw puffs of smoke coming out of
the engine compartment. I shut down the engine and grabbed a fire
extinguisher while my wife threw out the anchor, then opened the engine
compartment to see smoke coming off the engine and to hear hissing and
popping. Gave it a shot from the ABC dry chemical fire extinguisher
thinking there may be a fire. Saw the temperature gauge pegged at 250F.

Radioed our friends who towed us back to our marina. The marina mechanic
checked to see if there was any foaming or burnt smell with the engine
oil
(none) or oil in the bilge (none). Sigh, maybe a good sign, or at least
I
hope so.

We ended up leaving the boat with our mechanic and spent the day on our
friends boat. After 3 or so hours I got a call from the marina, telling
me
they checked out the engine (after letting it cool) and judge it to be
OK,
although the impeller needs replacing. They said I could safely move the
boat to my slip if I wanted to until repairs are made.

We got back to the marina later today and I took the boat from the gas
dock
to our slip, with the temperature rising to 220F during that short trip
from
the gas dock to our slip (5 minutes). The boat also ran very rough
during
that short trip

So.......besides replacing the impellor any other suggestions on what I
should ask the marina to do? What is causing the rough engine,
especially
after having a tune up only 4 engine hours ago? Is there some internal
damage I may have done?

Single 1997 Volvo Penta 4.3L, Chevy 190 HP.

TIA for your answers.

BTW: My vacation started this afternoon (one week of it) and this was
the
last thing I expected to have to deal with.


As Eisboch pointed out and as was confirmed by our mechanic (and a mechanic
friend of ours we saw today) it is probably not that bad if we did not see
water in the oil and as the heads are cast iron.

The impeller is being replaced on Wednesday and we will see if that does the
trick.

As a side note: I had asked the marina to change the impeller at the
beginning of the season as I did not know when the last time it was changed
(we bought the boat last summer). They said they checked it and it looked
fine. Something had to have happened between then and last Friday.


  #8   Report Post  
posted to rec.boats
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by BoatBanter: Jul 2006
Posts: 1,315
Default A bad day on the boat

1997 43.L Chevy 350 6 cylinder. Freshwater. Manifolds and risers are
original.

Tuned up just weeks ago with only 4.2 hours on the engine following the
tune-up.

Thermostat was replaced in spring.



"jamesgangnc" wrote in message
oups.com...
It would be good to give us more details on the boat. Age, enigne
size. Age of the manifolds and risers. Last major work. Salt water,
fresh water, or both? Raw water cooling or heat exchanger?

If it ran rough as soon as your started it back up that may be a bad
sign. Running rough while actually overheated is not a problem. In
either case you have to fix the overheating problem. As lost of other
posters have pointed out the manifolds and risers are always the first
suspect if they are more than 5 years old. The thermostat could also
be a problem.

Unfortunately overheating causes other damage. Heads warp. Gaskets
start leaking. Rubber exhaust parts melt. Once you fix the
overheating if it still runs rough I'd suggest a compression test to
rule out major engine damage.

wrote:
Jim, a blown head gasket isn't necessarily determined by water in the
oil. It could be the "rough running" is because of some fire
extinguisher stuff, got in the distributor, but I doubt it. OR the
engine was hot enough that it's causing the fuel to pre-detonate. or
even vapor lock in the intake manifold. That bad thing is that even if
the heads and gaskets are ok, the over heating can still cause the
valve seals to get brittle and eventually start leaking oil into the
valves, this is usually evident by a puff of blue smoke on initial
start up. Hope all works out for you.


JimH wrote:
wrote in message
oups.com...
Jim, tht doesn't sound good at all. I think you may have burnt
valves,
a blown head gasket[s], maybe even cracked heads.


Sorry for the downtime, man. especially when your vacation is just
now
starting..

Good Luck!

JimH wrote:
Cut out of work at noon and scrambled to the boat to hook up with
friends
of
ours, meeting them at the mouth of the Vermilion River with boat our
boats.
We arrived first and once safely past the breakwall idled while
waiting
for
them. The trip was perhaps 15 minutes tops.

I started to smell something burning and saw puffs of smoke coming
out of
the engine compartment. I shut down the engine and grabbed a fire
extinguisher while my wife threw out the anchor, then opened the
engine
compartment to see smoke coming off the engine and to hear hissing
and
popping. Gave it a shot from the ABC dry chemical fire
extinguisher
thinking there may be a fire. Saw the temperature gauge pegged at
250F.

Radioed our friends who towed us back to our marina. The marina
mechanic
checked to see if there was any foaming or burnt smell with the
engine
oil
(none) or oil in the bilge (none). Sigh, maybe a good sign, or at
least
I
hope so.

We ended up leaving the boat with our mechanic and spent the day on
our
friends boat. After 3 or so hours I got a call from the marina,
telling
me
they checked out the engine (after letting it cool) and judge it to
be
OK,
although the impeller needs replacing. They said I could safely
move the
boat to my slip if I wanted to until repairs are made.

We got back to the marina later today and I took the boat from the
gas
dock
to our slip, with the temperature rising to 220F during that short
trip
from
the gas dock to our slip (5 minutes). The boat also ran very rough
during
that short trip

So.......besides replacing the impellor any other suggestions on
what I
should ask the marina to do? What is causing the rough engine,
especially
after having a tune up only 4 engine hours ago? Is there some
internal
damage I may have done?

Single 1997 Volvo Penta 4.3L, Chevy 190 HP.

TIA for your answers.

BTW: My vacation started this afternoon (one week of it) and this
was
the
last thing I expected to have to deal with.


As Eisboch pointed out and as was confirmed by our mechanic (and a
mechanic
friend of ours we saw today) it is probably not that bad if we did not
see
water in the oil and as the heads are cast iron.

The impeller is being replaced on Wednesday and we will see if that
does the
trick.

As a side note: I had asked the marina to change the impeller at the
beginning of the season as I did not know when the last time it was
changed
(we bought the boat last summer). They said they checked it and it
looked
fine. Something had to have happened between then and last Friday.




Reply
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules

Smilies are On
[IMG] code is Off
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Interesting boat ride on a 26 Twin Vee [email protected] General 5 March 29th 06 05:58 AM
Any thoughts onhow to make this boat better [email protected] ASA 82 January 24th 06 04:16 AM
Need a Plan to Protect Boat from UV and Mildew All Year Round - 2 [email protected] General 2 December 15th 05 06:25 AM
Carribean Sail Don White General 16 November 18th 05 01:23 AM
rec.boats.paddle sea kayaking FAQ [email protected] General 0 October 19th 05 05:38 AM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 01:29 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2025 BoatBanter.com.
The comments are property of their posters.
 

About Us

"It's about Boats"

 

Copyright © 2017