BoatBanter.com

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)
-   General (https://www.boatbanter.com/general/)
-   -   Auto Pilot for trolling (https://www.boatbanter.com/general/65005-auto-pilot-trolling.html)

Art Yokell January 7th 06 05:51 PM

Auto Pilot for trolling
 
We have a 30' grady which we use mostly for fishing. We had installed a C
series Raymarine GPS, Fish Finder and a 4' open array radar. I had hoped to
install a decent auto pilot this winter. I am getting a bunch of jazz from
Ray and a reccomendation for a $4,000 system plus the cost of install. I
find out that this system is not reccomended for slow speeds nd doesn't have
any predetermined trolling patterns as part of the system. I wonder if
anyone here might have an alternate suggestion that will work and not be so
outrageously expensive. Thanks for any ideas.

Art Yokell
Riverview FL
Gray-White Marlin



Wayne.B January 7th 06 09:51 PM

Auto Pilot for trolling
 
On Sat, 07 Jan 2006 17:51:16 GMT, "Art Yokell"
wrote:

I wonder if
anyone here might have an alternate suggestion that will work and not be so
outrageously expensive. Thanks for any ideas.


======================================

Take a look at Simrad. They have several models designed for smaller
boats that might be less expensive but I doubt that you'll find
anything less than $3K. None of this stuff is mass produced and there
isn't a lot of competition.


K. Smith January 7th 06 10:48 PM

Auto Pilot for trolling
 
Art Yokell wrote:
We have a 30' grady which we use mostly for fishing. We had installed a C
series Raymarine GPS, Fish Finder and a 4' open array radar. I had hoped to
install a decent auto pilot this winter. I am getting a bunch of jazz from
Ray and a reccomendation for a $4,000 system plus the cost of install. I
find out that this system is not reccomended for slow speeds nd doesn't have
any predetermined trolling patterns as part of the system. I wonder if
anyone here might have an alternate suggestion that will work and not be so
outrageously expensive. Thanks for any ideas.

Art Yokell
Riverview FL
Gray-White Marlin



Along the same lines as Wayne's repl, but add Navman to you list of
stuff to check.

Here downunder it's really doing well, their Autopilot is in the price
range of the simrad as you'll see in the Whitworth's link in A$ (Take A$
X 0.74 to get US$) the dearest hydraulic unit is about $US2737
& those prices include our 10% goods & services tax, which you
shouldn't be paying. Low speed setup shouldn't be an issue because being
NZ it's all with yachts in mind. Navman is in use by smaller commercial
users here.

http://www.navman.com/marine/product...ots/index.html

http://www.whitworths.com.au/main_home.asp

(just put autopilot into their search thingo)


K

Skipper January 8th 06 12:43 AM

Auto Pilot for trolling
 
"K. Smith" wrote:

Add Navman to you list of stuff to check.


Downunder it's really doing well, their Autopilot is in the price
range of the simrad...Navman is in use by smaller commercial
users here.


http://www.navman.com/marine/product...ots/index.html


What a fantastic looking A/P. Do you know if it's another great
Brunswick product? I know the Navman mapper I got for the truck is a
super product...and under $300!!! Unbelievable how it knows about
*every* road and offramp shape...and very clear voice directions.

--
Skipper

K. Smith January 8th 06 12:58 AM

Auto Pilot for trolling
 
Skipper wrote:
"K. Smith" wrote:


Add Navman to you list of stuff to check.



Downunder it's really doing well, their Autopilot is in the price
range of the simrad...Navman is in use by smaller commercial
users here.




http://www.navman.com/marine/product...ots/index.html



What a fantastic looking A/P. Do you know if it's another great
Brunswick product? I know the Navman mapper I got for the truck is a
super product...and under $300!!! Unbelievable how it knows about
*every* road and offramp shape...and very clear voice directions.

--
Skipper


Well it's not that pretty but I think I was bordering on spam there for
a minute so apologies in advance if others think I crossed over.


K

Skipper January 8th 06 01:09 AM

Auto Pilot for trolling
 
"K. Smith" wrote:

http://www.navman.com/marine/product...ots/index.html


What a fantastic looking A/P. Do you know if it's another great
Brunswick product? I know the Navman mapper I got for the truck is a
super product...and under $300!!! Unbelievable how it knows about
*every* road and offramp shape...and very clear voice directions.


Well it's not that pretty but I think I was bordering on spam there for
a minute so apologies in advance if others think I crossed over.


I don't see how discussing another great new Brunswick product can be
seen as bordering on spam.

--
Skipper

Wayne.B January 8th 06 01:25 AM

Auto Pilot for trolling
 
On Sun, 08 Jan 2006 11:58:40 +1100, "K. Smith" wrote:

Well it's not that pretty but I think I was bordering on spam there for
a minute so apologies in advance if others think I crossed over.


There is no issue with recommending products that you are not selling.


Wayne.B January 8th 06 01:28 AM

Auto Pilot for trolling
 
On Sat, 07 Jan 2006 19:09:10 -0600, Skipper wrote:

I don't see how discussing another great new Brunswick product can be
seen as bordering on spam.


Let's just hope that Brunswick does not turn Hatteras into mediocrity.


K. Smith January 8th 06 01:52 AM

Auto Pilot for trolling
 
Wayne.B wrote:
On Sun, 08 Jan 2006 11:58:40 +1100, "K. Smith" wrote:


Well it's not that pretty but I think I was bordering on spam there for
a minute so apologies in advance if others think I crossed over.



There is no issue with recommending products that you are not selling.


Thanks Wayne certainly no connections with either & no benefit can flow
to me in any manner.

Skip keeps saying Navman is Brunswick so I assume he means they've
bought the NZ Co out?? or they're the US distributors???


K

Wayne.B January 8th 06 03:28 AM

Auto Pilot for trolling
 
On Sat, 07 Jan 2006 20:31:13 -0500, Harry Krause
wrote:

A dealer I know told me that most boat new boat prices will be up more
than usual in the spring because of higher petrol prices. Oil has an
impact on manufacture and on delivery.


==========================================

Oil had a huge impact on boat prices between the mid 70s and mid 80s.
The price of new boats just about tripled in 10 years, and people were
selling used boats for 50 to 100% over what they had paid originally.

That was about the time when exotic coring materials became popular
because they not only made boats lighter and faster, but also cheaper
to build because of reduced fiberglass/resin content.


Wayne.B January 8th 06 03:50 AM

Auto Pilot for trolling
 
On Sat, 07 Jan 2006 22:33:44 -0500, Harry Krause
wrote:

I'm not convinced "coring" is a good thing below the waterline, and I
sure as hell wouldn't consider a boat with balsa coring anywhere. I
have, however, owned a couple of boats with klegecell foam in the
transom, but that application is nothing like the foam used between
layers of fiberglass in the hull.


The longevity of balsa cored decks and hulls has not been impressive.
I know of a number of balsa cored sailboats that were junked because
the cost of repairs exceeded the value of the boat. Foam cores seem
to do better but they are not immune, and when they do fail, it is
sometimes in spectacular fashion. Do you remember the America's Cup
contender that literally broke in two and sank within seconds?


-rick- January 8th 06 06:05 AM

Auto Pilot for trolling
 

"Art Yokell" wrote ...

We have a 30' grady which we use mostly for fishing. We had installed a C
series Raymarine GPS, Fish Finder and a 4' open array radar. I had hoped to
install a decent auto pilot this winter. I am getting a bunch of jazz from Ray
and a reccomendation for a $4,000 system plus the cost of install. I find out
that this system is not reccomended for slow speeds nd doesn't have any
predetermined trolling patterns as part of the system. I wonder if anyone here
might have an alternate suggestion that will work and not be so outrageously
expensive. Thanks for any ideas.


I use a Nautamatic TR-1 gold on the kicker and it works pretty well. It runs
about $2300 if I recall correctly. It has a zig-zag pattern but I've never tried
it.

http://www.nautamatic.com/

-rick-






markvictor January 8th 06 04:26 PM

Auto Pilot for trolling
 
One thing to keep in mind...
the installation and more importantly the proper set up and calibration
is the key to success with any autopilot....get someone who thoroughly
knows not only how to install it but also how to use it...it can make
all the difference...
regards,
markvictor

http://groups.google.com/group/badboatbiz


markvictor January 8th 06 04:31 PM

Auto Pilot for trolling
 
One thing to keep in mind...
the installation and more importantly the proper set up and calibration
is the key to success with any autopilot....get someone who thoroughly
knows not only how to install it but also how to use it...it can make
all the difference...
regards,
markvictor

http://groups.google.com/group/badboatbiz


markvictor January 8th 06 06:02 PM

Auto Pilot for trolling
 
One thing to keep in mind...
the installation and more importantly the proper set up and calibration
is the key to success with any autopilot....get someone who thoroughly
knows not only how to install it but also how to use it...it can make
all the difference...
regards,
markvictor

http://groups.google.com/group/badboatbiz


Bill McKee January 8th 06 11:02 PM

Auto Pilot for trolling
 

"Wayne.B" wrote in message
...
On Sat, 07 Jan 2006 20:31:13 -0500, Harry Krause
wrote:

A dealer I know told me that most boat new boat prices will be up more
than usual in the spring because of higher petrol prices. Oil has an
impact on manufacture and on delivery.


==========================================

Oil had a huge impact on boat prices between the mid 70s and mid 80s.
The price of new boats just about tripled in 10 years, and people were
selling used boats for 50 to 100% over what they had paid originally.

That was about the time when exotic coring materials became popular
because they not only made boats lighter and faster, but also cheaper
to build because of reduced fiberglass/resin content.


I am getting ready to replace the back redwood deck with Trex. Price is up
about 8% in the last 2 months, just because of the oil content. But the
petro used for the plastic part and the energy to make it.



Eisboch January 9th 06 01:38 AM

Auto Pilot for trolling
 

"Bill McKee" wrote in message
ink.net...


I am getting ready to replace the back redwood deck with Trex. Price is
up about 8% in the last 2 months, just because of the oil content. But
the petro used for the plastic part and the energy to make it.


Stuff is great but if you haven't done it before make sure you predrill for
any screws that are within an inch or so of the edge of the planks. It's
not supposed to split, but it does.
(Learned this the hard way)

Eisboch



Bill McKee January 9th 06 01:43 AM

Auto Pilot for trolling
 

"Eisboch" wrote in message
...

"Bill McKee" wrote in message
ink.net...


I am getting ready to replace the back redwood deck with Trex. Price is
up about 8% in the last 2 months, just because of the oil content. But
the petro used for the plastic part and the energy to make it.


Stuff is great but if you haven't done it before make sure you predrill
for any screws that are within an inch or so of the edge of the planks.
It's not supposed to split, but it does.
(Learned this the hard way)

Eisboch



Buddy did his deck, and I have been informed.



Capt John January 9th 06 05:40 PM

Auto Pilot for trolling
 
Art,

Slow speed trolling with an autopilot on a small boat like yours can be
a problem on days where you have a bit of a sea, and wind, to contend
with. Now when you talk about slow speed I assume your talking about 2
to 4 knots. As the speed increases, and the boat gets bigger, it's less
of a problem. Your best bet is to ask people that have the same boat as
yours if they have had problems, what system they have and how fast
they troll.

Don't feel too bad, I've run some larger boats that have a problem with
this as well, they just don't run slow enough on two engines, you have
to troll on one engine. All it takes is one wave at the right time and
your back to manual fighting the boat. I've even seen them change props
late in the season (smaller wheel or less pitch) so they can slow troll
with both engines in gear. So if a system works OK most of the time,
your probably doing better than most.


markvictor January 9th 06 08:45 PM

Auto Pilot for trolling
 
Also,springing for the rate-sensor instead of the standard heading
sensor will help with low speed stability...You guessed it...more
money...
regards,
markvictor



All times are GMT +1. The time now is 05:13 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com