Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#13
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() On 1-Sep-2005, Mr. C wrote: It would show how closely the maximum hull speed formula in Brians link applies to kayaks. Does anybody know if this has ever been done? We know it doesn't apply strongly and it is not worth worrying about. First of all, there's no such "maximum" speed. The hull speed given by Froude's speed-length ratio of 1.34 is an somewhat arbitrary value that links the waterline length to the wavelength of the bow wave. Unfortunately, a lot of folks have interpreted it as a speed limit of some sort. The page Brian linked to discusses the speed-length ratio in terms of sailboats. In the case of a displacement sailboat, most designers know that you can't realistically increase the speed over the so-called hull speed, so the design of the sail rig is based on that. If you could carry a _lot_ more sail, you could start pushing past the hull speed. However, that sail rig would cost a lot (if a significant speed increase is wanted) and it would be a bitch to handle in most conditions. Since the average sailor never sees his craft exceed the hull speed with a typical sail rig, the speed-length rule of thumb starts to look like an absolute law and it enters into the sailors' legends. Multihulls and other displacement craft show that the speed-length ratio is not so much of a limit. Olympic class kayaks do it routinely: http://www.kayakforum.com/cgi-sys/cgiwrap/guille/wiki.pl?Hull_Speed The way to interpret the speed-length ratio or the hull speed is to recognize that it represents a speed that takes a lot of work to achieve. If you want to paddle fast all the time, then a longer waterline length is one thing to look for. However, it isn't an absolute guide to the behavior of a kayak. For example, based on the analyses of a bunch of kayaks reviewed in Sea Kayak magazine, you can see the following http://www.greatlakeskayaker.ca/loaVSlwl.htm You can see that the resistance generally goes down with waterline length, but there are some exceptions. Mike |