BoatBanter.com

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)
-   General (https://www.boatbanter.com/general/)
-   -   The dinghy problem again (https://www.boatbanter.com/general/133772-dinghy-problem-again.html)

Frogwatch[_2_] June 13th 11 04:26 PM

The dinghy problem again
 
I've given away another dinghy.
So far, over the years, i have tried various dinghies for my 28'
sailboat:
A very heavy 8' Nautilus rigid dinghy that was too large to fit on
the foredeck and too heavy.
A Sevylor inflatable.........nearly worthless.
A Sevylor "Sea Eagle" inflatable kayak, a little better but paddled
poorly.
A home built 2-Paw-9 nesting dinghy, rows very well and almost fits on
the foredeck (I just gave it away)

So, I considered a 10' portabote but it is too long to fit inside the
shrouds on the side deck. An 8' one might work but their capacity is
low. I am 180 lbs wife is about 135, carrying capacity is only about
350 lbs

Another inflatable? This would also mean an engine for it and
carrying gas.

Ideas?

I_am_Tosk June 13th 11 04:45 PM

The dinghy problem again
 
In article 0c13b1af-61ec-4fb8-b3e9-
,
says...

I've given away another dinghy.
So far, over the years, i have tried various dinghies for my 28'
sailboat:
A very heavy 8' Nautilus rigid dinghy that was too large to fit on
the foredeck and too heavy.
A Sevylor inflatable.........nearly worthless.
A Sevylor "Sea Eagle" inflatable kayak, a little better but paddled
poorly.
A home built 2-Paw-9 nesting dinghy, rows very well and almost fits on
the foredeck (I just gave it away)

So, I considered a 10' portabote but it is too long to fit inside the
shrouds on the side deck. An 8' one might work but their capacity is
low. I am 180 lbs wife is about 135, carrying capacity is only about
350 lbs

Another inflatable? This would also mean an engine for it and
carrying gas.

Ideas?


Is there a reason you don't want a tow behind? Hell, a nice peanut pram
with a waterproof cover would do what you need from what I can see.

--
Team Rowdy Mouse, Banned from the Mall for life!

Frogwatch[_2_] June 13th 11 05:02 PM

The dinghy problem again
 
On Jun 13, 11:45*am, I_am_Tosk
wrote:
In article 0c13b1af-61ec-4fb8-b3e9-
,
says...





I've given away another dinghy.
So far, over the years, i have tried various dinghies for my 28'
sailboat:
A very heavy 8' *Nautilus rigid dinghy that was too large to fit on
the foredeck and too heavy.
A Sevylor inflatable.........nearly worthless.
A Sevylor "Sea Eagle" inflatable kayak, a little better but paddled
poorly.
A home built 2-Paw-9 nesting dinghy, rows very well and almost fits on
the foredeck (I just gave it away)


So, I considered a 10' portabote but it is too long to fit inside the
shrouds on the side deck. *An 8' one might work but their capacity is
low. *I am 180 lbs wife is about 135, carrying capacity is only about
350 lbs


Another inflatable? *This would also mean an engine for it and
carrying gas.


Ideas?


Is there a reason you don't want a tow behind? Hell, a nice peanut pram
with a waterproof cover would do what you need from what I can see.

--
Team Rowdy Mouse, Banned from the Mall for life!


Eventually, it has to come aboard when you are crossing any rough
water.

Frogwatch[_2_] June 13th 11 09:08 PM

The dinghy problem again
 
On Jun 13, 1:18*pm, Marc Auslander
wrote:
I suspect you're not going to sea, but doing coastal cruising. *I've
towed my hard dink through pretty wild coastal weather - and
never got into trouble. *A long painter prevents it from riding up
your stern.


Well, I've sailed several times from St. Marks, FL to St Petersburg,
FL, about 140 miles. West palm to West End across the Gulf stream and
am ready to cross from marsh Harbor to Spanish Wells (only 50 miles).
I expect most of my crossings to be less than 200 miles. Towing the
dingy on any of these would have been a pain. I also do not towing a
dinghy in thunderstorms.
I've decided that my current 28' S2 with 3'10" draft is ideal for the
bahamas and anything larger would be too much for me to singlehand.
Her moderate size and shoal draft has gotten me many places a larger
boat could not go which also contributes to some degree of safety.

Wayne B June 13th 11 10:19 PM

The dinghy problem again
 
On Mon, 13 Jun 2011 09:02:20 -0700 (PDT), Frogwatch
wrote:

Is there a reason you don't want a tow behind? Hell, a nice peanut pram
with a waterproof cover would do what you need from what I can see.

--
Team Rowdy Mouse, Banned from the Mall for life!


Eventually, it has to come aboard when you are crossing any rough
water.


The only thing you are likely to be happy with is one of the roll up
models with an inflatable keel and integral floor slats or
interlocking aluminum panels like the Avons. They typically have a
rigid transom, and some can be used with outboards up to 10 or 15 hp,
although you'll probably want something lighter than that. We still
have our old Avon roll up and usually carry it as a spare.


Richard Casady June 14th 11 01:56 AM

The dinghy problem again
 
On Mon, 13 Jun 2011 13:18:09 -0400, Marc Auslander
wrote:

I suspect you're not going to sea, but doing coastal cruising. I've
towed my hard dink through pretty wild coastal weather - and
never got into trouble. A long painter prevents it from riding up
your stern.


Long painters are a mistake if you have a motor. In that case the
painter should stop short of the propeller. You can use a long tow
line with it.

Casady

Wayne B June 14th 11 03:31 AM

The dinghy problem again
 
On Mon, 13 Jun 2011 19:56:00 -0500, Richard Casady
wrote:

On Mon, 13 Jun 2011 13:18:09 -0400, Marc Auslander
wrote:

I suspect you're not going to sea, but doing coastal cruising. I've
towed my hard dink through pretty wild coastal weather - and
never got into trouble. A long painter prevents it from riding up
your stern.


Long painters are a mistake if you have a motor. In that case the
painter should stop short of the propeller. You can use a long tow
line with it.


In big seas a long tow line is absolutely necessary. Frankly I don't
understand your distinction between a tow line and a painter unless
you are referring to the painter as the line used for everyday tie up,
as opposed to long distance towing. Best solution for a painter is
floating line like polypro (miserable as it is for other reasons), or
to install some small floats at regular intervals. All this of course
is to prevent the painter from getting sucked into the props
accidently.


I_am_Tosk June 14th 11 03:39 AM

The dinghy problem again
 
In article ,
says...

On Mon, 13 Jun 2011 19:56:00 -0500, Richard Casady
wrote:

On Mon, 13 Jun 2011 13:18:09 -0400, Marc Auslander
wrote:

I suspect you're not going to sea, but doing coastal cruising. I've
towed my hard dink through pretty wild coastal weather - and
never got into trouble. A long painter prevents it from riding up
your stern.


Long painters are a mistake if you have a motor. In that case the
painter should stop short of the propeller. You can use a long tow
line with it.


In big seas a long tow line is absolutely necessary. Frankly I don't
understand your distinction between a tow line and a painter unless
you are referring to the painter as the line used for everyday tie up,
as opposed to long distance towing. Best solution for a painter is
floating line like polypro (miserable as it is for other reasons), or
to install some small floats at regular intervals. All this of course
is to prevent the painter from getting sucked into the props
accidently.


Well, for protected water I always made the painter about a foot too
short to hit the prop... If I needed more length, I would bend on
another line.

--
Team Rowdy Mouse, Banned from the Mall for life!

North Star June 14th 11 02:18 PM

The dinghy problem again
 
On Jun 13, 11:39*pm, I_am_Tosk
wrote:
In article ,
says...







On Mon, 13 Jun 2011 19:56:00 -0500, Richard Casady
wrote:


On Mon, 13 Jun 2011 13:18:09 -0400, Marc Auslander
wrote:


I suspect you're not going to sea, but doing coastal cruising. *I've
towed my hard dink through pretty wild coastal weather - and
never got into trouble. *A long painter prevents it from riding up
your stern.


Long painters are a mistake if you have a motor. In that case the
painter should stop short of the propeller. You can use a long tow
line with it.


In big seas a long tow line is absolutely necessary. *Frankly I don't
understand your distinction between a tow line and a painter unless
you are referring to the painter as the line used for everyday tie up,
as opposed to long distance towing. *Best solution for a painter is
floating line like polypro (miserable as it is for other reasons), or
to install some small floats at regular intervals. *All this of course
is to prevent the painter from getting sucked into the props
accidently.


Well, for protected water I always made the painter about a foot too
short to hit the prop... If I needed more length, I would bend on
another line.

--
Team Rowdy Mouse, Banned from the Mall for life!- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -


Duh!
That's the norm to keep a boat's own painter out of it's 'OWN'
propellor.
When towing you'd have to have the dinghy right up againt the mother
boat's stern to avoid that problem and then you create others... such
as the dinghy ramming the mother boat.

iBoat June 14th 11 03:42 PM

The dinghy problem again
 
In article 17128384-3f79-4202-bded-978f41fe1d32
@i4g2000yqg.googlegroups.com, says...

On Jun 13, 11:39*pm, I_am_Tosk
wrote:
In article ,
says...







On Mon, 13 Jun 2011 19:56:00 -0500, Richard Casady
wrote:


On Mon, 13 Jun 2011 13:18:09 -0400, Marc Auslander
wrote:


I suspect you're not going to sea, but doing coastal cruising. *I've
towed my hard dink through pretty wild coastal weather - and
never got into trouble. *A long painter prevents it from riding up
your stern.


Long painters are a mistake if you have a motor. In that case the
painter should stop short of the propeller. You can use a long tow
line with it.


In big seas a long tow line is absolutely necessary. *Frankly I don't
understand your distinction between a tow line and a painter unless
you are referring to the painter as the line used for everyday tie up,
as opposed to long distance towing. *Best solution for a painter is
floating line like polypro (miserable as it is for other reasons), or
to install some small floats at regular intervals. *All this of course
is to prevent the painter from getting sucked into the props
accidently.


Well, for protected water I always made the painter about a foot too
short to hit the prop... If I needed more length, I would bend on
another line.

--
Team Rowdy Mouse, Banned from the Mall for life!- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -


Duh!
That's the norm to keep a boat's own painter out of it's 'OWN'
propellor.
When towing you'd have to have the dinghy right up againt the mother
boat's stern to avoid that problem and then you create others... such
as the dinghy ramming the mother boat.


Why aren't you over at Harry's new fantastic group?


Frogwatch[_2_] June 14th 11 04:53 PM

The dinghy problem again
 
On Jun 14, 10:42*am, iBoat wrote:
In article 17128384-3f79-4202-bded-978f41fe1d32
@i4g2000yqg.googlegroups.com, says...





On Jun 13, 11:39*pm, I_am_Tosk
wrote:
In article ,
says...


On Mon, 13 Jun 2011 19:56:00 -0500, Richard Casady
wrote:


On Mon, 13 Jun 2011 13:18:09 -0400, Marc Auslander
wrote:


I suspect you're not going to sea, but doing coastal cruising. *I've
towed my hard dink through pretty wild coastal weather - and
never got into trouble. *A long painter prevents it from riding up
your stern.


Long painters are a mistake if you have a motor. In that case the
painter should stop short of the propeller. You can use a long tow
line with it.


In big seas a long tow line is absolutely necessary. *Frankly I don't
understand your distinction between a tow line and a painter unless
you are referring to the painter as the line used for everyday tie up,
as opposed to long distance towing. *Best solution for a painter is
floating line like polypro (miserable as it is for other reasons), or
to install some small floats at regular intervals. *All this of course
is to prevent the painter from getting sucked into the props
accidently.


Well, for protected water I always made the painter about a foot too
short to hit the prop... If I needed more length, I would bend on
another line.


--
Team Rowdy Mouse, Banned from the Mall for life!- Hide quoted text -


- Show quoted text -


Duh!
That's the norm to keep a boat's own painter out of it's 'OWN'
propellor.
When towing you'd have to have the dinghy right up againt the mother
boat's stern to avoid that problem and then you create others... such
as the dinghy ramming the mother boat.


Why aren't you over at Harry's new fantastic group?


My experiences towing dinghies have been uniformly bad or comical
depending on your perspective. How many inconvenient or dangerous
places can you have your dinghy come loose? It is always something
bizarre too like a carabiner breaking or the rope breaks because the
dinghy fills with water and you are trying to pull a 2000' drag. My
old Nautilus dinghy was a true escape artist; no matter how well I'd
tie her up for the night, sure enough she'd have gone wandering during
the night and be on the other side of the harbor. It was so bad that
the first thing I'd do when I got up would be to grab the binocs
before I went outside so I could scan the harbor to spot the wayward
dinghy. If I tied her too securely, she'd take revenge by petulently
ramming the main boat all night keeping us awake. Instead of "Honey,
will you go let the dog out", it'd be, "Honey, can you go loosen the
dinghy" and sure enough she'd be gone in the morning. My tendency to
take my sailboat in very shallow places she shouldn't go stems from
chasing down that damned Nautilus dinghy. Once I tried to take
advantage of her wandering by filling her with several days of trash
hoping she'd wander away with it, no luck.

Harryk June 14th 11 05:31 PM

The dinghy problem again
 
On 6/14/11 11:53 AM, Frogwatch wrote:
On Jun 14, 10:42 am, wrote:
In article17128384-3f79-4202-bded-978f41fe1d32
@i4g2000yqg.googlegroups.com, says...





On Jun 13, 11:39 pm,
wrote:
In ,
says...


On Mon, 13 Jun 2011 19:56:00 -0500, Richard Casady
wrote:


On Mon, 13 Jun 2011 13:18:09 -0400, Marc Auslander
wrote:


I suspect you're not going to sea, but doing coastal cruising. I've
towed my hard dink through pretty wild coastal weather - and
never got into trouble. A long painter prevents it from riding up
your stern.


Long painters are a mistake if you have a motor. In that case the
painter should stop short of the propeller. You can use a long tow
line with it.


In big seas a long tow line is absolutely necessary. Frankly I don't
understand your distinction between a tow line and a painter unless
you are referring to the painter as the line used for everyday tie up,
as opposed to long distance towing. Best solution for a painter is
floating line like polypro (miserable as it is for other reasons), or
to install some small floats at regular intervals. All this of course
is to prevent the painter from getting sucked into the props
accidently.


Well, for protected water I always made the painter about a foot too
short to hit the prop... If I needed more length, I would bend on
another line.


--
Team Rowdy Mouse, Banned from the Mall for life!- Hide quoted text -


- Show quoted text -


Duh!
That's the norm to keep a boat's own painter out of it's 'OWN'
propellor.
When towing you'd have to have the dinghy right up againt the mother
boat's stern to avoid that problem and then you create others... such
as the dinghy ramming the mother boat.


Why aren't you over at Harry's new fantastic group?


My experiences towing dinghies have been uniformly bad or comical
depending on your perspective. How many inconvenient or dangerous
places can you have your dinghy come loose? It is always something
bizarre too like a carabiner breaking or the rope breaks because the
dinghy fills with water and you are trying to pull a 2000' drag. My
old Nautilus dinghy was a true escape artist; no matter how well I'd
tie her up for the night, sure enough she'd have gone wandering during
the night and be on the other side of the harbor. It was so bad that
the first thing I'd do when I got up would be to grab the binocs
before I went outside so I could scan the harbor to spot the wayward
dinghy. If I tied her too securely, she'd take revenge by petulently
ramming the main boat all night keeping us awake. Instead of "Honey,
will you go let the dog out", it'd be, "Honey, can you go loosen the
dinghy" and sure enough she'd be gone in the morning. My tendency to
take my sailboat in very shallow places she shouldn't go stems from
chasing down that damned Nautilus dinghy. Once I tried to take
advantage of her wandering by filling her with several days of trash
hoping she'd wander away with it, no luck.


I never liked towing a dink, but I don't recall one coming loose on its
own. I sort of remember the tow line spliced onto an eye ring at the bow
on my Dyer dink.


--
Want to discuss recreational boating and fishing in a forum where
personal insults are not allowed?

http://groups.google.com/group/rec-boating-fishing

Frogwatch[_2_] June 14th 11 05:41 PM

The dinghy problem again
 
On Jun 14, 12:31*pm, Harryk wrote:
On 6/14/11 11:53 AM, Frogwatch wrote:



On Jun 14, 10:42 am, *wrote:
In article17128384-3f79-4202-bded-978f41fe1d32
@i4g2000yqg.googlegroups.com, says...


On Jun 13, 11:39 pm,
wrote:
In ,
says...


On Mon, 13 Jun 2011 19:56:00 -0500, Richard Casady
*wrote:


On Mon, 13 Jun 2011 13:18:09 -0400, Marc Auslander
*wrote:


I suspect you're not going to sea, but doing coastal cruising. *I've
towed my hard dink through pretty wild coastal weather - and
never got into trouble. *A long painter prevents it from riding up
your stern.


Long painters are a mistake if you have a motor. In that case the
painter should stop short of the propeller. You can use a long tow
line with it.


In big seas a long tow line is absolutely necessary. *Frankly I don't
understand your distinction between a tow line and a painter unless
you are referring to the painter as the line used for everyday tie up,
as opposed to long distance towing. *Best solution for a painter is
floating line like polypro (miserable as it is for other reasons), or
to install some small floats at regular intervals. *All this of course
is to prevent the painter from getting sucked into the props
accidently.


Well, for protected water I always made the painter about a foot too
short to hit the prop... If I needed more length, I would bend on
another line.


--
Team Rowdy Mouse, Banned from the Mall for life!- Hide quoted text -


- Show quoted text -


Duh!
That's the norm to keep a boat's own painter out of it's 'OWN'
propellor.
When towing you'd have to have the dinghy right up againt the mother
boat's stern to avoid that problem and then you create others... such
as the dinghy ramming the mother boat.


Why aren't you over at Harry's new fantastic group?


My experiences towing dinghies have been uniformly bad or comical
depending on your perspective. *How many inconvenient or dangerous
places can you have your dinghy come loose? *It is always something
bizarre too like a carabiner breaking or the rope breaks because the
dinghy fills with water and you are trying to pull a 2000' drag. *My
old Nautilus dinghy was a true escape artist; no matter how well I'd
tie her up for the night, sure enough she'd have gone wandering during
the night and be on the other side of the harbor. *It was so bad that
the first thing I'd do when I got up would be to grab the binocs
before I went outside so I could scan the harbor to spot the wayward
dinghy. *If I tied her too securely, she'd take revenge by petulently
ramming the main boat all night keeping us awake. *Instead of "Honey,
will you go let the dog out", it'd be, "Honey, can you go loosen the
dinghy" and sure enough she'd be gone in the morning. *My tendency to
take my sailboat in very shallow places she shouldn't go stems from
chasing down that damned Nautilus dinghy. *Once I tried to take
advantage of her wandering by filling her with several days of trash
hoping she'd wander away with it, no luck.


I never liked towing a dink, but I don't recall one coming loose on its
own. I sort of remember the tow line spliced onto an eye ring at the bow
on my Dyer dink.

--
Want to discuss recreational boating and fishing in a forum where
personal insults are not allowed?

http://groups.google.com/group/rec-boating-fishing


If I ever run out of other things to do I'll make an ultra-lightweight
collapsible dinghy that will go into a large duffle. BTW, an 8'
dinghy is simply too small for 3 people.

Frogwatch[_2_] June 14th 11 05:51 PM

The dinghy problem again
 
On Jun 14, 12:41*pm, Frogwatch wrote:
On Jun 14, 12:31*pm, Harryk wrote:



On 6/14/11 11:53 AM, Frogwatch wrote:


On Jun 14, 10:42 am, *wrote:
In article17128384-3f79-4202-bded-978f41fe1d32
@i4g2000yqg.googlegroups.com, says...


On Jun 13, 11:39 pm,
wrote:
In ,
says...


On Mon, 13 Jun 2011 19:56:00 -0500, Richard Casady
*wrote:


On Mon, 13 Jun 2011 13:18:09 -0400, Marc Auslander
*wrote:


I suspect you're not going to sea, but doing coastal cruising. *I've
towed my hard dink through pretty wild coastal weather - and
never got into trouble. *A long painter prevents it from riding up
your stern.


Long painters are a mistake if you have a motor. In that case the
painter should stop short of the propeller. You can use a long tow
line with it.


In big seas a long tow line is absolutely necessary. *Frankly I don't
understand your distinction between a tow line and a painter unless
you are referring to the painter as the line used for everyday tie up,
as opposed to long distance towing. *Best solution for a painter is
floating line like polypro (miserable as it is for other reasons), or
to install some small floats at regular intervals. *All this of course
is to prevent the painter from getting sucked into the props
accidently.


Well, for protected water I always made the painter about a foot too
short to hit the prop... If I needed more length, I would bend on
another line.


--
Team Rowdy Mouse, Banned from the Mall for life!- Hide quoted text -


- Show quoted text -


Duh!
That's the norm to keep a boat's own painter out of it's 'OWN'
propellor.
When towing you'd have to have the dinghy right up againt the mother
boat's stern to avoid that problem and then you create others... such
as the dinghy ramming the mother boat.


Why aren't you over at Harry's new fantastic group?


My experiences towing dinghies have been uniformly bad or comical
depending on your perspective. *How many inconvenient or dangerous
places can you have your dinghy come loose? *It is always something
bizarre too like a carabiner breaking or the rope breaks because the
dinghy fills with water and you are trying to pull a 2000' drag. *My
old Nautilus dinghy was a true escape artist; no matter how well I'd
tie her up for the night, sure enough she'd have gone wandering during
the night and be on the other side of the harbor. *It was so bad that
the first thing I'd do when I got up would be to grab the binocs
before I went outside so I could scan the harbor to spot the wayward
dinghy. *If I tied her too securely, she'd take revenge by petulently
ramming the main boat all night keeping us awake. *Instead of "Honey,
will you go let the dog out", it'd be, "Honey, can you go loosen the
dinghy" and sure enough she'd be gone in the morning. *My tendency to
take my sailboat in very shallow places she shouldn't go stems from
chasing down that damned Nautilus dinghy. *Once I tried to take
advantage of her wandering by filling her with several days of trash
hoping she'd wander away with it, no luck.


I never liked towing a dink, but I don't recall one coming loose on its
own. I sort of remember the tow line spliced onto an eye ring at the bow
on my Dyer dink.


--
Want to discuss recreational boating and fishing in a forum where
personal insults are not allowed?


http://groups.google.com/group/rec-boating-fishing


If I ever run out of other things to do I'll make an ultra-lightweight
collapsible dinghy that will go into a large duffle. *BTW, an 8'
dinghy is simply too small for 3 people.


Rowing a good dinghy is fairly pleasant but it becomes a chore when
the boat is overcrowded as when an 8' one has two people in it. So a
dinghy for rowability carrying two people should be about 9'.

Richard Casady June 14th 11 05:52 PM

The dinghy problem again
 
On Tue, 14 Jun 2011 12:31:12 -0400, Harryk
wrote:

On 6/14/11 11:53 AM, Frogwatch wrote:
On Jun 14, 10:42 am, wrote:
In article17128384-3f79-4202-bded-978f41fe1d32
@i4g2000yqg.googlegroups.com, says...





On Jun 13, 11:39 pm,
wrote:
In ,
says...

On Mon, 13 Jun 2011 19:56:00 -0500, Richard Casady
wrote:

On Mon, 13 Jun 2011 13:18:09 -0400, Marc Auslander
wrote:

I suspect you're not going to sea, but doing coastal cruising. I've
towed my hard dink through pretty wild coastal weather - and
never got into trouble. A long painter prevents it from riding up
your stern.

Long painters are a mistake if you have a motor. In that case the
painter should stop short of the propeller. You can use a long tow
line with it.

In big seas a long tow line is absolutely necessary. Frankly I don't
understand your distinction between a tow line and a painter unless
you are referring to the painter as the line used for everyday tie up,
as opposed to long distance towing. Best solution for a painter is
floating line like polypro (miserable as it is for other reasons), or
to install some small floats at regular intervals. All this of course
is to prevent the painter from getting sucked into the props
accidently.

Well, for protected water I always made the painter about a foot too
short to hit the prop... If I needed more length, I would bend on
another line.

--
Team Rowdy Mouse, Banned from the Mall for life!- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -

Duh!
That's the norm to keep a boat's own painter out of it's 'OWN'
propellor.
When towing you'd have to have the dinghy right up againt the mother
boat's stern to avoid that problem and then you create others... such
as the dinghy ramming the mother boat.

Why aren't you over at Harry's new fantastic group?


My experiences towing dinghies have been uniformly bad or comical
depending on your perspective. How many inconvenient or dangerous
places can you have your dinghy come loose? It is always something
bizarre too like a carabiner breaking or the rope breaks because the
dinghy fills with water and you are trying to pull a 2000' drag. My
old Nautilus dinghy was a true escape artist; no matter how well I'd
tie her up for the night, sure enough she'd have gone wandering during
the night and be on the other side of the harbor. It was so bad that
the first thing I'd do when I got up would be to grab the binocs
before I went outside so I could scan the harbor to spot the wayward
dinghy. If I tied her too securely, she'd take revenge by petulently
ramming the main boat all night keeping us awake. Instead of "Honey,
will you go let the dog out", it'd be, "Honey, can you go loosen the
dinghy" and sure enough she'd be gone in the morning. My tendency to
take my sailboat in very shallow places she shouldn't go stems from
chasing down that damned Nautilus dinghy. Once I tried to take
advantage of her wandering by filling her with several days of trash
hoping she'd wander away with it, no luck.


I never liked towing a dink, but I don't recall one coming loose on its
own. I sort of remember the tow line spliced onto an eye ring at the bow
on my Dyer dink.


A painter is not a tow line. Its purpose it to keep the thing attached
to the shore. The towline is part of the larger vessle, not the
dinghy. Ever see a barge with a big reel of wire on the nose.? They
put that on the tug every single time.

Casady

Richard Casady June 14th 11 05:54 PM

The dinghy problem again
 
On Tue, 14 Jun 2011 09:41:57 -0700 (PDT), Frogwatch
wrote:

If I ever run out of other things to do I'll make an ultra-lightweight
collapsible dinghy that will go into a large duffle. BTW, an 8'
dinghy is simply too small for 3 people.


There was a Brit who owned a duffle bag boat. When he decided to see
San Francisco, he sailed it there.l

Casady

I_am_Tosk June 14th 11 05:56 PM

The dinghy problem again
 
In article 6c3c08af-c7e3-45d4-99a9-6bb9c414c5ee@
28g2000yqu.googlegroups.com, says...

On Jun 14, 12:31*pm, Harryk wrote:
On 6/14/11 11:53 AM, Frogwatch wrote:



On Jun 14, 10:42 am, *wrote:
In article17128384-3f79-4202-bded-978f41fe1d32
@i4g2000yqg.googlegroups.com, says...


On Jun 13, 11:39 pm,
wrote:
In ,
says...


On Mon, 13 Jun 2011 19:56:00 -0500, Richard Casady
*wrote:


On Mon, 13 Jun 2011 13:18:09 -0400, Marc Auslander
*wrote:


I suspect you're not going to sea, but doing coastal cruising. *I've
towed my hard dink through pretty wild coastal weather - and
never got into trouble. *A long painter prevents it from riding up
your stern.


Long painters are a mistake if you have a motor. In that case the
painter should stop short of the propeller. You can use a long tow
line with it.


In big seas a long tow line is absolutely necessary. *Frankly I don't
understand your distinction between a tow line and a painter unless
you are referring to the painter as the line used for everyday tie up,
as opposed to long distance towing. *Best solution for a painter is
floating line like polypro (miserable as it is for other reasons), or
to install some small floats at regular intervals. *All this of course
is to prevent the painter from getting sucked into the props
accidently.


Well, for protected water I always made the painter about a foot too
short to hit the prop... If I needed more length, I would bend on
another line.


--
Team Rowdy Mouse, Banned from the Mall for life!- Hide quoted text -


- Show quoted text -


Duh!
That's the norm to keep a boat's own painter out of it's 'OWN'
propellor.
When towing you'd have to have the dinghy right up againt the mother
boat's stern to avoid that problem and then you create others... such
as the dinghy ramming the mother boat.


Why aren't you over at Harry's new fantastic group?


My experiences towing dinghies have been uniformly bad or comical
depending on your perspective. *How many inconvenient or dangerous
places can you have your dinghy come loose? *It is always something
bizarre too like a carabiner breaking or the rope breaks because the
dinghy fills with water and you are trying to pull a 2000' drag. *My
old Nautilus dinghy was a true escape artist; no matter how well I'd
tie her up for the night, sure enough she'd have gone wandering during
the night and be on the other side of the harbor. *It was so bad that
the first thing I'd do when I got up would be to grab the binocs
before I went outside so I could scan the harbor to spot the wayward
dinghy. *If I tied her too securely, she'd take revenge by petulently
ramming the main boat all night keeping us awake. *Instead of "Honey,
will you go let the dog out", it'd be, "Honey, can you go loosen the
dinghy" and sure enough she'd be gone in the morning. *My tendency to
take my sailboat in very shallow places she shouldn't go stems from
chasing down that damned Nautilus dinghy. *Once I tried to take
advantage of her wandering by filling her with several days of trash
hoping she'd wander away with it, no luck.


I never liked towing a dink, but I don't recall one coming loose on its
own. I sort of remember the tow line spliced onto an eye ring at the bow
on my Dyer dink.

--
Want to discuss recreational boating and fishing in a forum where
personal insults are not allowed?

http://groups.google.com/group/rec-boating-fishing

If I ever run out of other things to do I'll make an ultra-lightweight
collapsible dinghy that will go into a large duffle. BTW, an 8'
dinghy is simply too small for 3 people.


I have an old kayak that is collapsible. It is made of tubular aluminum
and it stretches around a frame that breaks down to two backpacks with
the skin in one and frame in the other. It could be done pretty simply I
would guess to make a 15 footer by making it all of 8 foot panels for
sides, and 6 foot for the thwart, say 5 feet for the transom. The
biggest issue is the floor. I might break down and have a roll out type
floor that holds the thing together.. Interesting, I don't think it
would be all that hard to make, a bit of guesswork and figuring involved
but it could be done easily with some thought I would guess...

--
Team Rowdy Mouse, Banned from the Mall for life!

iBoat June 14th 11 06:53 PM

The dinghy problem again
 
In article ,
says...

On 6/14/11 11:53 AM, Frogwatch wrote:
On Jun 14, 10:42 am, wrote:
In article17128384-3f79-4202-bded-978f41fe1d32
@i4g2000yqg.googlegroups.com, says...





On Jun 13, 11:39 pm,
wrote:
In ,
says...

On Mon, 13 Jun 2011 19:56:00 -0500, Richard Casady
wrote:

On Mon, 13 Jun 2011 13:18:09 -0400, Marc Auslander
wrote:

I suspect you're not going to sea, but doing coastal cruising. I've
towed my hard dink through pretty wild coastal weather - and
never got into trouble. A long painter prevents it from riding up
your stern.

Long painters are a mistake if you have a motor. In that case the
painter should stop short of the propeller. You can use a long tow
line with it.

In big seas a long tow line is absolutely necessary. Frankly I don't
understand your distinction between a tow line and a painter unless
you are referring to the painter as the line used for everyday tie up,
as opposed to long distance towing. Best solution for a painter is
floating line like polypro (miserable as it is for other reasons), or
to install some small floats at regular intervals. All this of course
is to prevent the painter from getting sucked into the props
accidently.

Well, for protected water I always made the painter about a foot too
short to hit the prop... If I needed more length, I would bend on
another line.

--
Team Rowdy Mouse, Banned from the Mall for life!- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -

Duh!
That's the norm to keep a boat's own painter out of it's 'OWN'
propellor.
When towing you'd have to have the dinghy right up againt the mother
boat's stern to avoid that problem and then you create others... such
as the dinghy ramming the mother boat.

Why aren't you over at Harry's new fantastic group?


My experiences towing dinghies have been uniformly bad or comical
depending on your perspective. How many inconvenient or dangerous
places can you have your dinghy come loose? It is always something
bizarre too like a carabiner breaking or the rope breaks because the
dinghy fills with water and you are trying to pull a 2000' drag. My
old Nautilus dinghy was a true escape artist; no matter how well I'd
tie her up for the night, sure enough she'd have gone wandering during
the night and be on the other side of the harbor. It was so bad that
the first thing I'd do when I got up would be to grab the binocs
before I went outside so I could scan the harbor to spot the wayward
dinghy. If I tied her too securely, she'd take revenge by petulently
ramming the main boat all night keeping us awake. Instead of "Honey,
will you go let the dog out", it'd be, "Honey, can you go loosen the
dinghy" and sure enough she'd be gone in the morning. My tendency to
take my sailboat in very shallow places she shouldn't go stems from
chasing down that damned Nautilus dinghy. Once I tried to take
advantage of her wandering by filling her with several days of trash
hoping she'd wander away with it, no luck.


I never liked towing a dink, but I don't recall one coming loose on its
own. I sort of remember the tow line spliced onto an eye ring at the bow
on my Dyer dink.


Why don't you post that over at your new group?

iBoat June 14th 11 06:55 PM

The dinghy problem again
 
In article ,
says...

On Tue, 14 Jun 2011 12:31:12 -0400, Harryk
wrote:

On 6/14/11 11:53 AM, Frogwatch wrote:
On Jun 14, 10:42 am, wrote:
In article17128384-3f79-4202-bded-978f41fe1d32
@i4g2000yqg.googlegroups.com, says...





On Jun 13, 11:39 pm,
wrote:
In ,
says...

On Mon, 13 Jun 2011 19:56:00 -0500, Richard Casady
wrote:

On Mon, 13 Jun 2011 13:18:09 -0400, Marc Auslander
wrote:

I suspect you're not going to sea, but doing coastal cruising. I've
towed my hard dink through pretty wild coastal weather - and
never got into trouble. A long painter prevents it from riding up
your stern.

Long painters are a mistake if you have a motor. In that case the
painter should stop short of the propeller. You can use a long tow
line with it.

In big seas a long tow line is absolutely necessary. Frankly I don't
understand your distinction between a tow line and a painter unless
you are referring to the painter as the line used for everyday tie up,
as opposed to long distance towing. Best solution for a painter is
floating line like polypro (miserable as it is for other reasons), or
to install some small floats at regular intervals. All this of course
is to prevent the painter from getting sucked into the props
accidently.

Well, for protected water I always made the painter about a foot too
short to hit the prop... If I needed more length, I would bend on
another line.

--
Team Rowdy Mouse, Banned from the Mall for life!- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -

Duh!
That's the norm to keep a boat's own painter out of it's 'OWN'
propellor.
When towing you'd have to have the dinghy right up againt the mother
boat's stern to avoid that problem and then you create others... such
as the dinghy ramming the mother boat.

Why aren't you over at Harry's new fantastic group?

My experiences towing dinghies have been uniformly bad or comical
depending on your perspective. How many inconvenient or dangerous
places can you have your dinghy come loose? It is always something
bizarre too like a carabiner breaking or the rope breaks because the
dinghy fills with water and you are trying to pull a 2000' drag. My
old Nautilus dinghy was a true escape artist; no matter how well I'd
tie her up for the night, sure enough she'd have gone wandering during
the night and be on the other side of the harbor. It was so bad that
the first thing I'd do when I got up would be to grab the binocs
before I went outside so I could scan the harbor to spot the wayward
dinghy. If I tied her too securely, she'd take revenge by petulently
ramming the main boat all night keeping us awake. Instead of "Honey,
will you go let the dog out", it'd be, "Honey, can you go loosen the
dinghy" and sure enough she'd be gone in the morning. My tendency to
take my sailboat in very shallow places she shouldn't go stems from
chasing down that damned Nautilus dinghy. Once I tried to take
advantage of her wandering by filling her with several days of trash
hoping she'd wander away with it, no luck.


I never liked towing a dink, but I don't recall one coming loose on its
own. I sort of remember the tow line spliced onto an eye ring at the bow
on my Dyer dink.


A painter is not a tow line. Its purpose it to keep the thing attached
to the shore. The towline is part of the larger vessle, not the
dinghy. Ever see a barge with a big reel of wire on the nose.? They
put that on the tug every single time.

Casady


Harry's just lying as usual, so there's bound to be flaws in his lie.

Marc Auslander[_2_] June 17th 11 02:02 AM

The dinghy problem again
 
Richard Casady writes:


Long painters are a mistake if you have a motor. In that case the
painter should stop short of the propeller. You can use a long tow
line with it.

Casady


Polypropylene solves the prop problem. You need to replace it every
few years when the sun makes it unpleasant.

Jay[_5_] June 17th 11 12:48 PM

The dinghy problem again
 
On 6/17/2011 12:52 AM, wrote:
On Thu, 16 Jun 2011 21:02:58 -0400, Marc Auslander
wrote:

Richard writes:


Long painters are a mistake if you have a motor. In that case the
painter should stop short of the propeller. You can use a long tow
line with it.

Casady


Polypropylene solves the prop problem. You need to replace it every
few years when the sun makes it unpleasant.


I wouldn't trust polypropylene more than a year in the Florida sun.


Tell that to the fellas operating the parasail boat on Ocho Rios. The
poly-propylene tow line was full of fish hooks(wire rope term), and all
the color was faded out. I thought to myself, "Am I going to die
today?"Then I rationalized that if it broke, the sail would drift the
200 or 300 feet to the surface and the boys would at least come over to
retrieve their chute. My survival chances would be pretty good.

Wayne B June 17th 11 06:56 PM

The dinghy problem again
 
On Fri, 17 Jun 2011 12:50:50 -0400, wrote:

On Fri, 17 Jun 2011 07:48:06 -0400, Jay wrote:

I wouldn't trust polypropylene more than a year in the Florida sun.


Tell that to the fellas operating the parasail boat on Ocho Rios.



Mexican parasailing is like discount bungee jumping.

Ya pays yo money ya takes yer chances.


The parasailing at Ft Myers Beach has not exactly been incident free
either. Most of the guys who run those boats look like they are
barely out of high school. Are they required to have a captain's
license?


Jay[_5_] June 17th 11 06:59 PM

The dinghy problem again
 
On 6/17/2011 12:50 PM, wrote:
On Fri, 17 Jun 2011 07:48:06 -0400, wrote:

I wouldn't trust polypropylene more than a year in the Florida sun.


Tell that to the fellas operating the parasail boat on Ocho Rios.



Mexican parasailing is like discount bungee jumping.

Ya pays yo money ya takes yer chances.


You mean Jamaica, right?


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:58 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com