On Sat, 02 Aug 2003 02:49:56 GMT, "Denman" wrote:

I was wondering if anybody had experience with either of these and if so,
which they preferred. Right now I would use it for my wife's Pungo. I
would likely get another for a touring/sea kayak when I purchase a new one.

Thanks

Denman

Disclaimer - I have no personal knowledge of these carriers. However,
from what I have read and the recommendation of the kayak shop owner
near me, the older model Thule J cradles were prone to breakage, right
at the clamp. This may have been because the clamps used to be
plastic. I think the new models come with a metal clamp, which may
address this. The shop owner actually recommended the foam blocks
over the Thule J cradles! I use foam blocks, and my friend uses the
Subaru kayak attachment (like an older version of the Yakima stakers)
with no problems. Good luck!

Dan