Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
![]()
posted to rec.boats.electronics
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
I'm interested in developing marine electronics for educational
research purposes. The NMEA 2000 standard looks interesting. But $3999.00 for just the main document? (actually, from what I glean from the order page the entire suite costs you $11,648) Are they kidding??? Now I've come to expect such stupidity from closed, proprietary standards but check this out: http://www.nmea.org/pdf/NMEA2000info.pdf It actually says, as the title: "NMEA 2000® Marine Network Standard, The Open Non-Proprietary Industry Wide Standard" What the f??? This is niether "Open" or "Non-Proprietary"! It's certainly proprietary, here's a definition of proprietary: 1. belonging to a proprietor. 2. being a proprietor; holding property: the proprietary class. 3. pertaining to property or ownership: proprietary wealth. 4. belonging or controlled as property. 5. manufactured and sold only by the owner of the patent, formula, brand name, or trademark associated with the product: proprietary medicine. 6. privately owned and operated for profit: proprietary hospitals. I *have* to pay for it (or break copyright laws) and that makes it proprietary. It isn't open because once I know the information I am not allowed to republish it. So It's no more open than anything else I reverse engineer. Hey: NMEA... Did you notice that sales of the last standard weren't fabulous and so with the new standard you thought "Hey, we've got to make more money with this. How? We'll jack up the price by TEN TIMES as much. But people won't want to pay that much. They will if we market the hell out of it and use popular buzz words such as "Open" and "Non-proprietary". It's working for Linux it will work for us too!" Well, I've got news for you... It's working for others because their standards ARE actually open and non-proprietary. If I had the funds, I'd sue you for false advertising. |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Cheap navigation system | ASA | |||
nmea 2000 gps antenna? | Electronics | |||
NMEA: What confusion is that? | Electronics | |||
Connect Raymarine ST60 Multi to laptop | Electronics | |||
NMEA 2000 standard is gaining ground? | Electronics |