![]() |
Approaching a slip with a strong current
On Mon, 03 Jul 2006 00:24:46 -0500, sherwindu
wrote: I can line up the boat with the slip, but a strong current will throw my stern down stream. I can maintain steerage going in, but if I enter too fast I am in danger of hitting the concrete wall at the front of the slip. These are slips with small metal piers pointing into the river. There are two slips between each pier, with a wooden post at the head of the slip dividing the slip for two boats. I have to avoid hitting the pier, the wooden piling, and/or the boat in the downstream side of the slip. Sherwin D. Yi, that's ugly. I guess you're on the waiting list for a slip on the downstream side of the slot and the upstream slips are much more readily available. If it's a short finger-pier, man, I thought I had it tough with a downwind double-finger that was 6 inches wider than my boat beam. What about accepting a clunk as inevitable and hanging a long fender board overboard and nestling the aft quarter of your boat into the post and pulling it upstream from the pier? |
Approaching a slip with a strong current
Thanks for all the tips. I guess I was looking more for a maneuvering solution using
the engine (both forward and reverse) to offset the current. I'm also going to ask my neighboring boat owners how they manage to handle the current. Sherwin D. Dick Locke wrote: On Mon, 03 Jul 2006 00:24:46 -0500, sherwindu wrote: I can line up the boat with the slip, but a strong current will throw my stern down stream. I can maintain steerage going in, but if I enter too fast I am in danger of hitting the concrete wall at the front of the slip. These are slips with small metal piers pointing into the river. There are two slips between each pier, with a wooden post at the head of the slip dividing the slip for two boats. I have to avoid hitting the pier, the wooden piling, and/or the boat in the downstream side of the slip. Sherwin D. Yi, that's ugly. I guess you're on the waiting list for a slip on the downstream side of the slot and the upstream slips are much more readily available. If it's a short finger-pier, man, I thought I had it tough with a downwind double-finger that was 6 inches wider than my boat beam. What about accepting a clunk as inevitable and hanging a long fender board overboard and nestling the aft quarter of your boat into the post and pulling it upstream from the pier? |
Approaching a slip with a strong current
On Sat, 01 Jul 2006 23:45:20 -0500, sherwindu
wrote: It's a bit tricky, and there is a tendency for the stern to swing downstream before we have a chance to get a line to it. Any suggestions? Many boats (not all) will lay to the pier against considerable wind or current with a judicious application of power and helm against a springline. With the spring running aft from your midships cleat, a small amount of power will cause the spring to pull the bow right against the pier. A bit of rudder (or outboard traverse) will push the stern in. Of course, the spring should be short enough to keep the bow from hitting anything else, and it should run aft to the end of the finger pier, not straight out to the side. On my boat, I try to cut power and coast into the slip. I either grap the spring from the dock, or (if away from home) drop a loop on the dock cleat with about 2/3 of a boat length of slack. When the spring is secured at both ends, the remaining momentum of the boat will start it over to the side. I put the engine in gear at idle, dial in a bit of rudder, and wait for everything to stop moving. It's just that easy. Obviously, the critical part is to get the spring on before you are too far into the slip. But if you aren't going too fast, you have time to fall back on Plan B. That's why I coast into the slip and add power only when the spring is fastened. YMMV - very beamy boats with poor rudder authority might not take well to this tactic. __________________________________________________ __________ Glen "Wiley" Wilson usenet1 SPAMNIX at world wide wiley dot com To reply, lose the capitals and do the obvious. Take a look at cpRepeater, my NMEA data integrator, repeater, and logger at http://www.worldwidewiley.com/ |
Approaching a slip with a strong current
On Mon, 03 Jul 2006 11:45:06 -0500, sherwindu
wrote: Thanks for all the tips. I guess I was looking more for a maneuvering solution using the engine (both forward and reverse) to offset the current. I'm also going to ask my neighboring boat owners how they manage to handle the current. Sherwin D. Depending on which way your stern walks in reverse (probably not a strong effect with a small outboard propellor) you might be able to come in at a fairly good speed, have someone jump off and secure the bow while you reverse like hell to pull the stern toward the dock. |
Approaching a slip with a strong current
Dick Locke wrote: Depending on which way your stern walks in reverse (probably not a strong effect with a small outboard propellor) you might be able to come in at a fairly good speed, have someone jump off and secure the bow while you reverse like hell to pull the stern toward the dock. That would probably work, but it puts the boat at risk should the engine die at the wrong time, or you don't apply the reverse at precisely the correct time and power. The head of the slip is a nice solid cement wall, which I would not like to hit. By the way, this 9.9 Yamaha has plenty of thrust with a very large prop, so I don't think that this is any kind of limitation. |
Approaching a slip with a strong current
Glen \"Wiley\" Wilson wrote: On Sat, 01 Jul 2006 23:45:20 -0500, sherwindu wrote: It's a bit tricky, and there is a tendency for the stern to swing downstream before we have a chance to get a line to it. Any suggestions? Many boats (not all) will lay to the pier against considerable wind or current with a judicious application of power and helm against a springline. With the spring running aft from your midships cleat, a small amount of power will cause the spring to pull the bow right against the pier. A bit of rudder (or outboard traverse) will push the stern in. Of course, the spring should be short enough to keep the bow from hitting anything else, and it should run aft to the end of the finger pier, not straight out to the side. On my boat, I try to cut power and coast into the slip. I either grap the spring from the dock, or (if away from home) drop a loop on the dock cleat with about 2/3 of a boat length of slack. When the spring is secured at both ends, the remaining momentum of the boat will start it over to the side. I put the engine in gear at idle, dial in a bit of rudder, and wait for everything to stop moving. It's just that easy. Obviously, the critical part is to get the spring on before you are too far into the slip. But if you aren't going too fast, you have time to fall back on Plan B. That's why I coast into the slip and add power only when the spring is fastened. YMMV - very beamy boats with poor rudder authority might not take well to this tactic. __________________________________________________ __________ Glen "Wiley" Wilson usenet1 SPAMNIX at world wide wiley dot com To reply, lose the capitals and do the obvious. Take a look at cpRepeater, my NMEA data integrator, repeater, and logger at http://www.worldwidewiley.com/ Glen, Your recommendations sound like they would be good for securing the boat once it is in the slip, not helping to position the boat while it is entering. If there were no side current, one would have more time to grab spring lines, etc. However, going in slowly may find you being pushed into the next slip before you have time to take corrective measures. The slower you enter the slip, the more time the side current has to push the boat over. The best thing I can think of is to aim the boat just upstream of the slip, so that on approach you are reasonably lined up for entry. The problem then becomes holding that allignment as you enter the slip. There are generally two of us aboard, one on the engine and the other there to fend off, which doesn't leave much room for error. The reason I am hanging on to this slip is that it is reasonably inexpensive and very convenient for access to my vehicle. Sherwin |
Approaching a slip with a strong current
In article ,
Dick Locke wrote: On Mon, 03 Jul 2006 11:45:06 -0500, sherwindu wrote: Thanks for all the tips. I guess I was looking more for a maneuvering solution using the engine (both forward and reverse) to offset the current. I'm also going to ask my neighboring boat owners how they manage to handle the current. Sherwin D. Depending on which way your stern walks in reverse (probably not a strong effect with a small outboard propellor) you might be able to come in at a fairly good speed, have someone jump off and secure the bow while you reverse like hell to pull the stern toward the dock. Jumping isn't a good idea. Also, high speed isn't a good idea either in close quarters. -- Capt. JG @@ www.sailnow.com |
Approaching a slip with a strong current
sherwindu wrote:
Glen \"Wiley\" Wilson wrote: On Sat, 01 Jul 2006 23:45:20 -0500, sherwindu wrote: It's a bit tricky, and there is a tendency for the stern to swing downstream before we have a chance to get a line to it. Any suggestions? Many boats (not all) will lay to the pier against considerable wind or current with a judicious application of power and helm against a springline. With the spring running aft from your midships cleat, a small amount of power will cause the spring to pull the bow right against the pier. A bit of rudder (or outboard traverse) will push the stern in. Of course, the spring should be short enough to keep the bow from hitting anything else, and it should run aft to the end of the finger pier, not straight out to the side. On my boat, I try to cut power and coast into the slip. I either grap the spring from the dock, or (if away from home) drop a loop on the dock cleat with about 2/3 of a boat length of slack. When the spring is secured at both ends, the remaining momentum of the boat will start it over to the side. I put the engine in gear at idle, dial in a bit of rudder, and wait for everything to stop moving. It's just that easy. Obviously, the critical part is to get the spring on before you are too far into the slip. But if you aren't going too fast, you have time to fall back on Plan B. That's why I coast into the slip and add power only when the spring is fastened. YMMV - very beamy boats with poor rudder authority might not take well to this tactic. __________________________________________________ __________ Glen "Wiley" Wilson usenet1 SPAMNIX at world wide wiley dot com To reply, lose the capitals and do the obvious. Take a look at cpRepeater, my NMEA data integrator, repeater, and logger at http://www.worldwidewiley.com/ Glen, Your recommendations sound like they would be good for securing the boat once it is in the slip, not helping to position the boat while it is entering. If there were no side current, one would have more time to grab spring lines, etc. However, going in slowly may find you being pushed into the next slip before you have time to take corrective measures. The slower you enter the slip, the more time the side current has to push the boat over. The best thing I can think of is to aim the boat just upstream of the slip, so that on approach you are reasonably lined up for entry. The problem then becomes holding that allignment as you enter the slip. There are generally two of us aboard, one on the engine and the other there to fend off, which doesn't leave much room for error. The reason I am hanging on to this slip is that it is reasonably inexpensive and very convenient for access to my vehicle. OK, I'm trying to visualize this - originally I thought it would be better to come in going upstream which would be the natural way to approach the slip, against the current so you would have more control. How about leaving a spring line on the upstream piling, and coming the other way (going with the current), and putting the side of the boat next to the pier/dock which has the spring line on it while still parallel to the current. Have the non-engine person pick up this line and cleat it down fairly short a bit aft of center and then warp yourself around this piling into the slip, using the current and the engine to help you get perpendicular to it. We have a problem with our boat being a modified full keel, with a lot of windage and very heavy, so that I can't - by myself- hold the boat against current or wind if there is any that is significant. Also, our slip is longer than our boat, so if the boat is nicely in the slip, we can't reach the last pilings - we have to do that on the way into the slip. But it doesn't look like you have those problems - so after you get the boat secured in the middle, you let the current put the boat parallel to the slip. The stern won't be able to swing too far because it is cleated down. grandma Rosalie S/V RosalieAnn, Leonardtown, MD CSY 44 WO #156 http://home.mindspring.com/~gmbeasley/id1.html |
Approaching a slip with a strong current
The problem is that there is no one right answer to your problem.
The solution can involve any number of things such as line handling and engine and rudder usage. Best bet....... find someone around your dock area who seems to make his/her approaches with little difficulty (takes some time and observation) and ask them for advice. Because your situation involves an off the dock current, for the most part you will need to use a combination of line handling and engine/rudder maneuvers to come up with something that works well. Don't be afraid to use your line from different points on the dock as well as the boat and be ready to "work" those lines to your advantage. As for engine and rudder, try maximum rudder and minimum engine first and then increase or decrease as experience teaches. As a final thought..... don't forget your anchor...... there may be a maneuver that could benefit from it's use. otn On Mon, 03 Jul 2006 11:45:06 -0500, sherwindu wrote: Thanks for all the tips. I guess I was looking more for a maneuvering solution using the engine (both forward and reverse) to offset the current. I'm also going to ask my neighboring boat owners how they manage to handle the current. Sherwin D. |
Approaching a slip with a strong current
I think Glen has the idea. Mount a line on the piling at the end of
your slip finger, then have your crew stand on the bow. Come in like you do now but get the bow close enough that the crew member can reach the line. If they miss the line, no problems as you have not commited to docking yet. Just back out, and try again until the crew has the spring line in hand before starting to end the slip. Once the have it, then you let the bow fall off a bit to line up with your slip and proceed in. During this time the crew member walks the line back to a mid-ship cleat and takes one wrap. As you proceed in, the boat will start to drift down stream. With your crew member holding the spring line and taking up slack and you giving some forward power, this will pull your boat back to your side of the docks. Continue in slowly with the crew member slipping the spring line through the cleat (this is why they took a turn as opposed to made it fast) as you proceed in. When you get to where you want, the crew member makes the spring fast. Leave the motor in forward, and the action will pin your boat to your upstream finger. Then retrieve the rest of the lines. After all is set you can cut the power. If you dont have a piling at the end of your dock, you can tie the spring line to the dock and affix some stand pipe which would hold the free end of the spring line ready and at a height that is easy for the crew member to reach. This will also work at a visiting dock, but the crew member has to be good at 'lassoing' a piling or dock cleat :-) Hope this helps. -al- On Mon, 03 Jul 2006 23:22:39 -0500, sherwindu wrote: Glen \"Wiley\" Wilson wrote: On Sat, 01 Jul 2006 23:45:20 -0500, sherwindu wrote: It's a bit tricky, and there is a tendency for the stern to swing downstream before we have a chance to get a line to it. Any suggestions? Many boats (not all) will lay to the pier against considerable wind or current with a judicious application of power and helm against a springline. With the spring running aft from your midships cleat, a small amount of power will cause the spring to pull the bow right against the pier. A bit of rudder (or outboard traverse) will push the stern in. Of course, the spring should be short enough to keep the bow from hitting anything else, and it should run aft to the end of the finger pier, not straight out to the side. On my boat, I try to cut power and coast into the slip. I either grap the spring from the dock, or (if away from home) drop a loop on the dock cleat with about 2/3 of a boat length of slack. When the spring is secured at both ends, the remaining momentum of the boat will start it over to the side. I put the engine in gear at idle, dial in a bit of rudder, and wait for everything to stop moving. It's just that easy. Obviously, the critical part is to get the spring on before you are too far into the slip. But if you aren't going too fast, you have time to fall back on Plan B. That's why I coast into the slip and add power only when the spring is fastened. YMMV - very beamy boats with poor rudder authority might not take well to this tactic. __________________________________________________ __________ Glen "Wiley" Wilson usenet1 SPAMNIX at world wide wiley dot com To reply, lose the capitals and do the obvious. Take a look at cpRepeater, my NMEA data integrator, repeater, and logger at http://www.worldwidewiley.com/ Glen, Your recommendations sound like they would be good for securing the boat once it is in the slip, not helping to position the boat while it is entering. If there were no side current, one would have more time to grab spring lines, etc. However, going in slowly may find you being pushed into the next slip before you have time to take corrective measures. The slower you enter the slip, the more time the side current has to push the boat over. The best thing I can think of is to aim the boat just upstream of the slip, so that on approach you are reasonably lined up for entry. The problem then becomes holding that allignment as you enter the slip. There are generally two of us aboard, one on the engine and the other there to fend off, which doesn't leave much room for error. The reason I am hanging on to this slip is that it is reasonably inexpensive and very convenient for access to my vehicle. Sherwin |
All times are GMT +1. The time now is 07:22 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com