BoatBanter.com

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)
-   Cruising (https://www.boatbanter.com/cruising/)
-   -   Inflatable Canoes (https://www.boatbanter.com/cruising/66760-inflatable-canoes.html)

Harlan Lachman February 21st 06 04:35 PM

Inflatable Canoes
 
In article , "Dene"
wrote:

Storage in a 25 foot boat.


I easily store my 9' inflatable under a back seat in my less than 25'
Regal.

When cruising off shore, it seems stupid to me to not have some sort of
inflatable that one can rely on.

I agree with all those who are trying to convince you that the
substandard inflatable is not that.

h

--
To respond, obviously drop the "nospan"?

[email protected] February 22nd 06 03:46 AM

Inflatable Canoes
 
We have a Sevylor "Tahiti" inflatable kayak. It is junk. Too hard to
paddle compared to any rigid boat. Worthless.


Lars Johansson February 22nd 06 01:32 PM

Inflatable Canoes
 

"Doug Kanter" wrote in message
...
OK. Just find out (unless you already know) the relationship between water
temp and minutes to death. Isn't it something like 20 minutes, with the
water around 40 degrees? Sometimes, a life vest ends up being just a nice,
fat handle for lifting your corpse. :-)


Yes, something like 50% chance of survival after 20 minutes. But you loos
you ability to do anything about your situation much faster than that. 4-5
minutes maybe.
/Lars J



Rosalie B. February 22nd 06 02:14 PM

Inflatable Canoes
 
"Lars Johansson" wrote:


"Doug Kanter" wrote in message
...
OK. Just find out (unless you already know) the relationship between water
temp and minutes to death. Isn't it something like 20 minutes, with the
water around 40 degrees? Sometimes, a life vest ends up being just a nice,
fat handle for lifting your corpse. :-)


Yes, something like 50% chance of survival after 20 minutes. But you loos
you ability to do anything about your situation much faster than that. 4-5
minutes maybe.
/Lars J

It isn't a straight line function. The occupational physician that I
was working with when I fell off the dock in November (in Maryland - I
was folding the sails) said that there was a 50-50-50 rule. In water
of 50 degrees F, 50% of people will survive for 50 minutes. From that
I infer that some people have more resistance to cold water than
others. And in fact that is what one sees when people's boat sinks
when it is in cold water. Some people die quicker and some people
hang on longer.

grandma Rosalie

Doug Kanter February 22nd 06 02:41 PM

Inflatable Canoes
 

"Rosalie B." wrote in message
...
"Lars Johansson" wrote:


"Doug Kanter" wrote in message
...
OK. Just find out (unless you already know) the relationship between
water
temp and minutes to death. Isn't it something like 20 minutes, with the
water around 40 degrees? Sometimes, a life vest ends up being just a
nice,
fat handle for lifting your corpse. :-)


Yes, something like 50% chance of survival after 20 minutes. But you loos
you ability to do anything about your situation much faster than that. 4-5
minutes maybe.
/Lars J

It isn't a straight line function. The occupational physician that I
was working with when I fell off the dock in November (in Maryland - I
was folding the sails) said that there was a 50-50-50 rule. In water
of 50 degrees F, 50% of people will survive for 50 minutes. From that
I infer that some people have more resistance to cold water than
others. And in fact that is what one sees when people's boat sinks
when it is in cold water. Some people die quicker and some people
hang on longer.

grandma Rosalie


All this assumes that you are still conscious. Sometimes people are injured
before hitting the water. Anyway....your point is still valid.



Don White February 22nd 06 03:11 PM

Inflatable Canoes
 
wrote:
We have a Sevylor "Tahiti" inflatable kayak. It is junk. Too hard to
paddle compared to any rigid boat. Worthless.



That would be my impression. The original poster should try paddling a
normal plastic rigid version vs a blow-up in a variety of conditions.
I doubt he'd buy the blow-up.

prodigal1 February 22nd 06 03:29 PM

Inflatable Canoes
 
On Wed, 22 Feb 2006 14:14:14 +0000, Rosalie B. wrote:

The occupational physician that I
was working with said that there was a 50-50-50 rule. In water
of 50 degrees F, 50% of people will survive for 50 minutes. From that
I infer that some people have more resistance to cold water than
others.


absolutely, on a hot midsummer day I went into a cold -sub 60- bay in the
North Channel with a thin wet suit and skin diving gear on to check the
underside of the boat and was rendered dangerously hypothermic in less
than 20 minutes. I knew I was in trouble when I could no longer tell
which way was up. I had extreme difficulty getting myself up the ladder
under my own power -my wife had to get a sling under my backside to
assist- and it took me over an hour and a half with the wet suit on
sitting in the sun in the cockpit to get my internal temperature
stabilized. I'm over 50, marathon fit and lack shall we say much body
insulation.

Gary February 23rd 06 01:20 AM

Inflatable Canoes
 
Don White wrote:
wrote:

We have a Sevylor "Tahiti" inflatable kayak. It is junk. Too hard to
paddle compared to any rigid boat. Worthless.



That would be my impression. The original poster should try paddling a
normal plastic rigid version vs a blow-up in a variety of conditions.
I doubt he'd buy the blow-up.

I have both an ABS canoe and an inflatable. The ABS is a much better
paddler but difficult to store in a locker. The inflatable is hardly
worthless but the price the ask for them reflects the relative value.
ABS - $1500
PVC - $150

Gary

Jere Lull March 2nd 06 12:45 AM

Inflatable Canoes
 
In article .com,
wrote:

We have a Sevylor "Tahiti" inflatable kayak. It is junk. Too hard to
paddle compared to any rigid boat. Worthless.


We've had one of them for a decade and it's been perfect for getting out
to a mooring and other close work. It's a PITA with only one set of
paddles for exploring the anchorage very far, but I'd call it worthy of
its purpose. If I got a second set of paddles for the Admiral, I expect
we'd have a far larger range.

--
Jere Lull
Xan-a-Deux ('73 Tanzer 28 #4 out of Tolchester, MD)
Xan's Pages:
http://members.dca.net/jerelull/X-Main.html
Our BVI FAQs (290+ pics) http://homepage.mac.com/jerelull/BVI/


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 08:21 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com