Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#8
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
glenn, just where is it you found you "facts" that "a medium displacement boat"
has 2,866.66666666 pounds of drag? btw, "a medium displacement boat" that does 8 knots continuous is rare indeed. btw-2: that 15% that is so often bandied about comes from a marketing department at a folding prop company. btw-3: ------ folding -------- three blade props are rare indeed. btw-4: the subject of this thread is folding, not feathering (a hugely more expensive breed of cat) btw-5, the 170# figures from MIT were for --------- three --------- bladed props. Two bladed props have much less drag, and two bladed props aligned behind the keel have even less. btw-6, when the winds are sufficient to drive ""a medium displacement boat" at 8 knots, you have more than enough wind to drive the boat at 8 knots with a bucket dragging behind just by putting up anothe 20 square feet of sail. btw-7: most folding/feathering props are promoted by their marketers as an improvement in **LITE** airs, not heavy. As usual, Jax has taken some good data and come up with a completely erroneous conclusion. The drag from the prop increases as the square of the speed. Using the MIT figures, at 8 knots you are looking at something over 430 pounds of drag. For a medium displacement boat that can add up to 15% or more in improved performance. For a 40' LWL cruiser that means an extra 20 to 25 miles a day. Paul L wrote: Its real easy to test, as I can get my folding 3 blade to stay open. I can see the boat speed, then have it fold and measure the speed. It is significant. If the MIT tests say otherwise then they are not testing reality - wanna guess what errors they made in the test or you in the interpretation??. Paul www.jcruiser.org "JAXAshby" wrote in message ... You will definitely will see a decent speed improvement under sail with a folding prop no, you won't. folding props only hve value for racing boats, where 2 seconds a mile means the difference between 2nd place and 6th. According to MIT tests, a folding prop means a savings of a mere 170 pounds drag at 5 knots (or 40 pounds drag at 2-1/2 knots, or 10 pounds drag at 1-1/4 knots) over a --------- three ------------ blade prop. ***Much*** less with compared to a two-blade, and even less compared to a two-blade rotated verticle behind the keel. Wanna guess just how much powered is required to pull 170# at 5 knots? -- Glenn Ashmore I'm building a 45' cutter in strip/composite. Watch my progress (or lack there of) at: http://www.rutuonline.com Shameless Commercial Division: http://www.spade-anchor-us.com |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Rigid vang...pros & cons? | General |