C&C vs. Siedelmann
 

Scotty Potty has indicated that cost was not a factor in choosing his
current Siedelmann 30 over a C&C 30. He PREFERED the Siedelmann and
now says he LIED when he said he couldn't afford the C&C boats.

I'm very familiar with the C&C line and have been aboard many of the
well respected designs, from the small 25 to the 30, 34 and 37 and of
course my own C&C 32, Alien.

I'd like to know what aspects of the Siedelmann 30's design and build
are superior to the C&C boats in particular. Perhaps Siedelmann's
reputation as one of the worst production boats ever was not
deserved.


Thanks for any input!



RB
35s5
NY

C&C vs. Siedelmann
 

"Capt. Rob" wrote in message
oups.com...
Scotty Potty has indicated that cost was not a factor in choosing his
current Siedelmann 30 over a C&C 30. He PREFERED the Siedelmann and
now says he LIED when he said he couldn't afford the C&C boats.

I'm very familiar with the C&C line and have been aboard many of the
well respected designs, from the small 25 to the 30, 34 and 37 and of
course my own C&C 32, Alien.

I'd like to know what aspects of the Siedelmann 30's design and build
are superior to the C&C boats in particular. Perhaps Siedelmann's
reputation as one of the worst production boats ever was not
deserved.


Thanks for any input!



RB
35s5
NY


I don't own a boat! Sold it and bought an RV!

Happy as a clam!

C&C vs. Siedelmann
 

Happy as a clam!



And about as clever.



RB
35s5
NY

C&C vs. Siedelmann
 

"Capt. Rob" wrote in message
ups.com...
Happy as a clam!



And about as clever.



RB
35s5
NY


Speaking of clams, Sudsy has a bit too much body fat, not a ton but enough
to say she's not athletic lean. No muscle definition either. Get that home
gym and get Sudsy burnining at least 1500 extra calories/day. Get her off of
processed food and onto whole grains, vegetables and lean meats. Cut back on
her booze too, each bottle of Piels she swills down in 240 calories. Why do
you have so much hair on your back and so little on your head?

C&C vs. Siedelmann
 

"Capt. **** Head" wrote in message
oups.com..
..
Scotty Potty has indicated that cost was not a factor in
choosing his
current Siedelmann 30 over a C&C 30. He PREFERED the
Siedelmann and
now says he LIED when he said he couldn't afford the C&C
boats.

I'm very familiar with the C&C line and have been aboard
many of the
well respected designs, from the small 25 to the 30, 34
and 37 and of
course my own C&C 32, Alien.

I'd like to know what aspects of the Siedelmann 30's
design and build
are superior to the C&C boats in particular.

draft.

C&C vs. Siedelmann
 

On Thu, 30 Aug 2007 23:52:52 -0400, "Scotty" wrote:

..

draft.



Ah, always the first and most important consideration in the area I
sail in. Where you looking for less or more?

Frank

C&C vs. Siedelmann
 

Ah, always the first and most important consideration in the area I
sail in. Where you looking for less or more?



This oughta be good! Scotty Potty claimed he couldn't afford the C&C
30. Draft was never mentioned. Doesn't his boat have a 5 foot draft?
I'm dying to hear about his issues with the 5 foot draft of the C&C 30
in his area. But since cost was NOT the issue, I'd like to hear why he
bought the boat of other better low draft designs.


RB
35s5
NY

C&C vs. Siedelmann
 

"Frank Boettcher" wrote in message
...
On Thu, 30 Aug 2007 23:52:52 -0400, "Scotty"
wrote:

.

draft.



Ah, always the first and most important consideration in
the area I
sail in. Where you looking for less or more?

Less. The Chessy is shallow, and I'm a gunkholer at heart.
I only draw 3' 4''.


Scotty

C&C vs. Siedelmann
 

"Scotty" wrote in message
. ..

"Frank Boettcher" wrote in message
...
On Thu, 30 Aug 2007 23:52:52 -0400, "Scotty"
wrote:

.

draft.



Ah, always the first and most important consideration in
the area I
sail in. Where you looking for less or more?

Less. The Chessy is shallow, and I'm a gunkholer at heart.
I only draw 3' 4''.


So, you're saying that Boob-Tube isn't correct on this?

WOW! I'm amazed.

C&C vs. Siedelmann
 

On Fri, 31 Aug 2007 10:26:32 -0400, "Scotty" wrote:


"Frank Boettcher" wrote in message
.. .
On Thu, 30 Aug 2007 23:52:52 -0400, "Scotty"
wrote:

.

draft.



Ah, always the first and most important consideration in
the area I
sail in. Where you looking for less or more?

,..... and I'm a gunkholer at heart.
.


Me too. The upper gulf has so many great places to go and so many
unpopulated barrier islands, but shallow draft is a basic requirement.
My last boat drew 4'10" and that was far too much.

Frank

Scotty

C&C vs. Siedelmann
 

Less. The Chessy is shallow, and I'm a gunkholer at heart.
I only draw 3' 4''.



NOW HEAR THIS:

A Siedelmann 30 is the best choice for a shallow draft sailboat! Also,
boats with 5 foot draft are not popular on the Chessy! Also,
centerboards are not popular on the Chessy!
So that leaves the Siedelmann 30! Best pick!!!!


Seriously!

RB
35s5
NY

C&C vs. Siedelmann
 

"Capt. Rob" wrote in message
oups.com..
..
Less. The Chessy is shallow, and I'm a gunkholer at
heart.
I only draw 3' 4''.


Also,
centerboards are not popular on the Chessy!


really? I love mine.

SBV

C&C vs. Siedelmann
 

"Frank Boettcher" wrote in message
...

Me too. The upper gulf has so many great places to go and
so many
unpopulated barrier islands, but shallow draft is a basic
requirement.
My last boat drew 4'10" and that was far too much.

There are tons of nice anchorage's off the Chessy, but, they
get a little crowded in the summer. I like to head 'up
creek', away from the weekend warriors.

Scotty

C&C vs. Siedelmann
 

On Fri, 31 Aug 2007 15:01:20 -0000, "Capt. Rob"
wrote:

Less. The Chessy is shallow, and I'm a gunkholer at heart.
I only draw 3' 4''.



NOW HEAR THIS:

A Siedelmann 30 is the best choice for a shallow draft sailboat! Also,
boats with 5 foot draft are not popular on the Chessy! Also,
centerboards are not popular on the Chessy!
So that leaves the Siedelmann 30! Best pick!!!!


Seriously!

RB
35s5
NY


Speaking of draft, I think you are running your bait too close to the
surface. Not getting any good hook sets. I suggest you use a planer
to run a little deeper.

This may help.

Frank

http://www.basspro.com/webapp/wcs/st...earchRe sults

C&C vs. Siedelmann
 

Speaking of draft, I think you are running your bait too close to the
surface. Not getting any good hook sets. I suggest you use a planer
to run a little deeper.

This may help.



LOL, Frank. But do look at my nets. They are quite full. Next will be
the typical "oh, but we've caught YOU!" posts even as I turn up the
heat.
Anyway...I'll be off sailing for the weekend, so they can all sit at
home and wait for me to return. At least I'll post some sailing pics
and vids to keep things lively here.


RB
35s5
NY