"Scotty" wrote in message
...
So, if Joe says Robert Brody is a pedophile, and I reply to
his post
that says Robert Brody is a pedophile, even though the
''Robert Brody is a pedophile'' would be property quoted to
Joe.
Would that be slander?

You have to actually say it for it to be slander. If you write it, it's
libel.
Scout