BoatBanter.com

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)
-   ASA (https://www.boatbanter.com/asa/)
-   -   The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper (https://www.boatbanter.com/asa/62084-attributes-outstanding-skipper.html)

DSK November 3rd 05 02:01 PM

The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
 
Joe wrote:
Both Doug and Bart are wrong on this one.........


No, we're not.

... courage is very
important trait for an "outstanding skipper".


I would never want to go sailing with an outstandingly brave skipper. In
fact, a skipper who makes declarations that he's not afraid, or that
the crew should not be afraid, etc etc, is exactly the kind of macho
butt head who is dangerous on the water. The kind of skipper who is
intent on proving how brave he is, and (just for example) would refuse
to 'run away' from a Cat 5 hurricane.

JL hit the nail on the head.

Fresh Breezes- Doug King


Seahag November 3rd 05 02:03 PM

The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
 

"Scotty" wrote:

"Seahag" wrote:

"Scotty" wrote:

"Bart Senior" .@. wrote:
What are the attributes of an outstanding skipper?

Allowing the 'crew' to sunbathe on the foredeck while
you
handle
the boat.

Allowing the crew to work the helm and sails while I go
below to
eat fried chicken.


Take a good hard look at yourself, and tell me which
attributes you feel need improvement in yourself.


Need to lose weight.



Tell me what you plan to do to effect such
improvements.


Buy larger clothes.


Heehee! Allowing the crew to smoke downwind is nice
too...



That wasn't ''allowed'', that was MUTINY !


At least the dog didn't barf in the cockpit!

Seahag



Joe November 3rd 05 04:02 PM

The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
 
Doug,

Having worked beside and for 100's of skippers I can tell you when the
**** hit the fans having courage can save you and your crews life. And
a coward can get you all killed.

We were talking about "outstanding Skippers" not just good or OK
skippers or average weekend trawler Captn's

Jolly Rogers is right... that sometimes the bravest thing to do is
refuse to do the job, but he is dead wrong when he left out batteling
the elements. Many times Ive seen "Outstanding Skippers " as you guys
would call them fall into the weekend warrior status due to not have
the courage to tackle the task at hand.

Has nothing to do with going out and acting macho IMO.

And I would not sail with anyone who makes declarations that he's never
afraid. I do not like liars. And if he's never been afraid at sea, then
he hasen't been to sea long enough to know sqwat .....and is no one I
would trust.

The most courage you can see is a man or woman doing his or her job
despite the fear.
Thats what makes them "Outstanding" IMO.

Joe


Capt. Neal® November 3rd 05 04:05 PM

The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
 

"Joe" wrote in message oups.com...
| Doug,
|
| Having worked beside and for 100's of skippers I can tell you when the
| **** hit the fans having courage can save you and your crews life. And
| a coward can get you all killed.
|
| We were talking about "outstanding Skippers" not just good or OK
| skippers or average weekend trawler Captn's
|
| Jolly Rogers is right... that sometimes the bravest thing to do is
| refuse to do the job, but he is dead wrong when he left out batteling
| the elements. Many times Ive seen "Outstanding Skippers " as you guys
| would call them fall into the weekend warrior status due to not have
| the courage to tackle the task at hand.
|
| Has nothing to do with going out and acting macho IMO.
|
| And I would not sail with anyone who makes declarations that he's never
| afraid. I do not like liars. And if he's never been afraid at sea, then
| he hasen't been to sea long enough to know sqwat .....and is no one I
| would trust.
|
| The most courage you can see is a man or woman doing his or her job
| despite the fear.
| Thats what makes them "Outstanding" IMO.
|
| Joe
|

But, is it not generally understood that fear causes degradation in clear
thinking? And is not clear thinking of paramount importance in any emergency?

CN

DSK November 3rd 05 04:08 PM

The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
 
Joe wrote:

Doug,

Having worked beside and for 100's of skippers I can tell you when the
**** hit the fans having courage can save you and your crews life. And
a coward can get you all killed.


???

How about not being there in the first place?

Any skipper who deliberately exposes his vessel & crew to unnecessary
danger because he is "brave" is a fool and a hazard.


We were talking about "outstanding Skippers" not just good or OK
skippers or average weekend trawler Captn's


Yes we were.


Jolly Rogers is right... that sometimes the bravest thing to do is
refuse to do the job, but he is dead wrong when he left out batteling
the elements. Many times Ive seen "Outstanding Skippers " as you guys
would call them fall into the weekend warrior status due to not have
the courage to tackle the task at hand.


Like what?


Has nothing to do with going out and acting macho IMO.

And I would not sail with anyone who makes declarations that he's never
afraid. I do not like liars. And if he's never been afraid at sea, then
he hasen't been to sea long enough to know sqwat .....and is no one I
would trust.


Agreed.


The most courage you can see is a man or woman doing his or her job
despite the fear.
Thats what makes them "Outstanding" IMO.


Agreed again.

Now please explain how a skipper who avoids danger, in other words a
"coward" in your terms, can get his crew killed.

DSK


Joe November 3rd 05 04:17 PM

The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
 
My point exactly.

If they have courage they can overcome the fear and do what is needed
to be done.
Thats the difference between skippers and outstanding skippers.

Anyone one top of a 60 foot mast offshore in a storm alone better be
skeered enough for the adrieline to kick in and provide super human
strength needed :0).

A person without courage may decide it is safer to hope the sail
shreads and might hide below.

Joe


Scotty November 3rd 05 05:03 PM

The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
 

"Seahag" wrote


Heehee! Allowing the crew to smoke downwind is nice
too...



That wasn't ''allowed'', that was MUTINY !


At least the dog didn't barf in the cockpit!



this time.





Joe November 3rd 05 05:05 PM

The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
 
87. DSK
Nov 3, 10:08 am show options

Newsgroups: alt.sailing.asa
From: DSK - Find messages by this author
Date: Thu, 03 Nov 2005 11:08:12 -0500
Local: Thurs, Nov 3 2005 10:08 am
Subject: The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
Reply | Reply to Author | Forward | Print | Individual Message | Show
original | Report Abuse



Joe wrote:
Doug,


Having worked beside and for 100's of skippers I can tell you when the
**** hit the fans having courage can save you and your crews life. And
a coward can get you all killed.




???

How about not being there in the first place?

How about not having a choice? The sea can change in a heartbeat Doug.
You should know that.


Any skipper who deliberately exposes his vessel & crew to unnecessary
danger because he is "brave" is a fool and a hazard.

Yes he is.

A coward may always opt out .....and say it is not necessary that it is
just to dangerious.

A person with courage will say it is necessary and do what is needed.
If he is an "outstanding" skipper he will get the job done and not one
will be hurt.



We were talking about "outstanding Skippers" not just good or OK
skippers or average weekend trawler Captn's



Yes we were.


Jolly Rogers is right... that sometimes the bravest thing to do is
refuse to do the job, but he is dead wrong when he left out batteling
the elements. Many times Ive seen "Outstanding Skippers " as you guys
would call them fall into the weekend warrior status due to not have
the courage to tackle the task at hand.



Like what?

To refuse a load and get everyone fired, takes courage IMO.

Out racing on a 62 pearson and the owner had a tape drive foresail on
one of those dangerious roll up furlers.

A tape delaminted and tangled the fore sail making it stuck half way
open. He bitched and wined and was ready to throw in the towel because
he thought it was just way to dangerious to shimmy up 15 feet with a
knife and cut the tape fouling things up. I shimmied up and cut it
without a problem after taking 10 min to convince him, we lost the race
btw.

One time while working for Mobil we were in route to a rig offshore
rig when another companies rig hit a poison gas pocket, no helos would
land, The SB boat in the area refused to move in but my skipper moved
in offloaded everyone. I thought it took alot of courage and we were
all scared. They say if you smell this gas your dead.

Had he asked the corporate office for permission the bean counters
would of freaked and shut it down, had he hesitated the guys on the rig
would of all died if the wind shifted.




Now please explain how a skipper who avoids danger, in other words a
"coward" in your terms, can get his crew killed.

I never said a person who avoids danger is a coward,................
you did.

Joe

DSK


Scotty November 3rd 05 05:09 PM

Redcloud
 
Joe, how was your trip?

Scotty


"Joe" wrote in message
oups.com...
Doug,

Having worked beside and for 100's of skippers I can tell you

when the
**** hit the fans having courage can save you and your crews

life. And
a coward can get you all killed.

We were talking about "outstanding Skippers" not just good or

OK
skippers or average weekend trawler Captn's

Jolly Rogers is right... that sometimes the bravest thing to do

is
refuse to do the job, but he is dead wrong when he left out

batteling
the elements. Many times Ive seen "Outstanding Skippers " as

you guys
would call them fall into the weekend warrior status due to not

have
the courage to tackle the task at hand.

Has nothing to do with going out and acting macho IMO.

And I would not sail with anyone who makes declarations that

he's never
afraid. I do not like liars. And if he's never been afraid at

sea, then
he hasen't been to sea long enough to know sqwat .....and is no

one I
would trust.

The most courage you can see is a man or woman doing his or her

job
despite the fear.
Thats what makes them "Outstanding" IMO.

Joe




Joe November 3rd 05 05:27 PM

Redcloud
 
Great. Have lots of fish is the freezer. Perfect weather (5-15 knots
2-3 ft seas) cept we had one wicked front move thru, but we found a
nice backdown bouy to ride it out on. Lots of weird stuff in the flosum
lines, made great cover for the dolphin and lings, lots of lawn chairs
and lumber,.... and a poly pro line that I had to cut out of the prop.
Spent the first few days about 110 miles SSE of Galveston at my
favorite fishing spot, then went into Freeport for a Halloween party,
had a perfect night sail coming back up the coast... the darkest sky
you ever seen with so many shooting stars we lost count. Spent a night
anchored off redfish island and skipper had a blast being free to run.
Got in last night around 22:00...


Did I miss any thing here?
Whats this 35.5 blister problems i hear about?

Joe


DSK November 3rd 05 06:19 PM

The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
 
Joe wrote:
Having worked beside and for 100's of skippers I can tell you when the
**** hit the fans having courage can save you and your crews life. And
a coward can get you all killed.





???

How about not being there in the first place?


Joe wrote:
How about not having a choice? The sea can change in a heartbeat Doug.
You should know that.


Actually, I don't know that.
The sea can surprise you, but with study & forethought, surprises can be
minimized... probably not ever eliminated totally.

Anything as big as an ocean cannot change "suddenly" but the factors
affecting it can bring about a change that may be overlooked, until it
becomes all too obvious.

A bad driver is often "surprised" by things in traffic that seem to pop
up in front of him. An observant, defensive driver sees things long before.


Any skipper who deliberately exposes his vessel & crew to unnecessary
danger because he is "brave" is a fool and a hazard.


Joe wrote:
Yes he is.

A coward may always opt out .....and say it is not necessary that it is
just to dangerious.

A person with courage will say it is necessary and do what is needed.
If he is an "outstanding" skipper he will get the job done and not one
will be hurt.


Like what?
if you are talking about warships, then part of that job is to perform
dangerous tasks. Otherwise, I have a hard time picturing a danger that
is "necessary."



Like what?

To refuse a load and get everyone fired, takes courage IMO.


Yep.


Out racing on a 62 pearson and the owner had a tape drive foresail on
one of those dangerious roll up furlers.

A tape delaminted and tangled the fore sail making it stuck half way
open. He bitched and wined and was ready to throw in the towel because
he thought it was just way to dangerious to shimmy up 15 feet with a
knife and cut the tape fouling things up. I shimmied up and cut it
without a problem after taking 10 min to convince him, we lost the race
btw.


Sounds like poor judgement coupled with poor maintenance. This is what I
mean by having the foresight to avoid danger... this whole situation
should have been avoided.

OTOH your action was risky but it enabled the vessel to carry on.
Probably one of those cases where it may seem "brave" but is actually
taking the less risky of available options.



One time while working for Mobil we were in route to a rig offshore
rig when another companies rig hit a poison gas pocket, no helos would
land, The SB boat in the area refused to move in but my skipper moved
in offloaded everyone. I thought it took alot of courage and we were
all scared. They say if you smell this gas your dead.

Had he asked the corporate office for permission the bean counters
would of freaked and shut it down, had he hesitated the guys on the rig
would of all died if the wind shifted.


IMHO that's another case of taking the less risky of available
options... while one is obligated to rescue others at sea, it is not an
obligation to place one's own life, vessel, or crew in peril. It sounds
like the men on the platform would probably have died if your boat had
not rescued them... for them, it was *far* less risky!

An outstanding skipper also has the knowledge & skills (and foresight)
to minimize dangers that may trap other skippers... and has confidence.
Some might call this bravery.

DSK


Bart Senior November 3rd 05 06:24 PM

The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
 
We are talking skippers now, not crew.

Courage is diffucult to define. I view courage as
doing something that might get you killed, despite the
known risks. Would an outstanding skipper do
something so risky as to possibly lose his/her life?

Skippers have no business doing anything risky,
except as a last resort.

A good skipper doesn't have fear, because he/she
always has a backup plan. When you are leading
you are making decisions about actions. Actions
conqueor fear.

Recognizing the dangers of a situation and staying
calm--is that courage? Or is it level-headedness?

"Capt. Neal®" wrote

"Joe" wrote
|
| Having worked beside and for 100's of skippers I can tell you when the
| **** hit the fans having courage can save you and your crews life. And
| a coward can get you all killed.
|
| And I would not sail with anyone who makes declarations that he's never
| afraid. I do not like liars. And if he's never been afraid at sea, then
| he hasen't been to sea long enough to know sqwat .....and is no one I
| would trust.
|
| The most courage you can see is a man or woman doing his or her job
| despite the fear.
| Thats what makes them "Outstanding" IMO.
|
| Joe
|

But, is it not generally understood that fear causes degradation in clear
thinking? And is not clear thinking of paramount importance in any

emergency?

CN




Scotty November 3rd 05 06:55 PM

Redcloud
 

"Joe" wrote in message
ups.com...
Great. Have lots of fish is the freezer. Perfect weather (5-15

knots
2-3 ft seas) cept we had one wicked front move thru, but we

found a
nice backdown bouy to ride it out on. Lots of weird stuff in

the flosum
lines, made great cover for the dolphin and lings, lots of lawn

chairs
and lumber,.... and a poly pro line that I had to cut out of

the prop.
Spent the first few days about 110 miles SSE of Galveston at my
favorite fishing spot, then went into Freeport for a Halloween

party,
had a perfect night sail coming back up the coast... the

darkest sky
you ever seen with so many shooting stars we lost count. Spent

a night
anchored off redfish island and skipper had a blast being free

to run.
Got in last night around 22:00...


Did I miss any thing here?


nope, same old ****. Glad to hear you had a good time. just the
3 of you, right?
I got to go for a 3 day cruise, weather was nice.

Scotty



Capt.Mooron November 3rd 05 07:50 PM

The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
 

"Capt. Neal®" wrote in message

But, is it not generally understood that fear causes degradation in clear
thinking? And is not clear thinking of paramount importance in any
emergency?


No Cappy.... fear is a wonderful thing... it causes clarity of thought.....
what you are describing is Panic... like when Bobsprit loses sight of land!!
:-)

Courage is merely the ability to harness fear......

CM




Capt.Mooron November 3rd 05 07:53 PM

The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
 
As I stated to Capt Neal...... you folks are mistaking fear for panic and
courage for fearlessness. Stupidity does not discriminate between the brave
and the cowardly.....

CM

"Bart Senior" .@. wrote in message ...
We are talking skippers now, not crew.

Courage is diffucult to define. I view courage as
doing something that might get you killed, despite the
known risks. Would an outstanding skipper do
something so risky as to possibly lose his/her life?

Skippers have no business doing anything risky,
except as a last resort.

A good skipper doesn't have fear, because he/she
always has a backup plan. When you are leading
you are making decisions about actions. Actions
conqueor fear.

Recognizing the dangers of a situation and staying
calm--is that courage? Or is it level-headedness?

"Capt. Neal®" wrote

"Joe" wrote
|
| Having worked beside and for 100's of skippers I can tell you when the
| **** hit the fans having courage can save you and your crews life. And
| a coward can get you all killed.
|
| And I would not sail with anyone who makes declarations that he's never
| afraid. I do not like liars. And if he's never been afraid at sea, then
| he hasen't been to sea long enough to know sqwat .....and is no one I
| would trust.
|
| The most courage you can see is a man or woman doing his or her job
| despite the fear.
| Thats what makes them "Outstanding" IMO.
|
| Joe
|

But, is it not generally understood that fear causes degradation in clear
thinking? And is not clear thinking of paramount importance in any

emergency?

CN






Capt.Mooron November 3rd 05 07:55 PM

The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
 

"DSK" wrote in message

How about not being there in the first place?


Why?

Any skipper who deliberately exposes his vessel & crew to unnecessary
danger because he is "brave" is a fool and a hazard.


.....can you cite me an example of necessary danger?

CM



Capt. Neal® November 3rd 05 07:56 PM

The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
 

"Capt.Mooron" wrote in message news:qStaf.101592$Io.7003@clgrps13...
|
| "Capt. Neal®" wrote in message
|
| But, is it not generally understood that fear causes degradation in clear
| thinking? And is not clear thinking of paramount importance in any
| emergency?
|
| No Cappy.... fear is a wonderful thing... it causes clarity of thought.....
| what you are describing is Panic... like when Bobsprit loses sight of land!!
| :-)
|
| Courage is merely the ability to harness fear......
|
| CM
|

Thought is linear. One cannot experience fear (a thought) without taking away
from other thought processes. Time spent thinking fearfully is time taken
from thinking constructively. Fear is the mind killer - the little death . . .

CN


DSK November 3rd 05 08:00 PM

The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
 
Capt.Mooron wrote:
Why?


Why not?


Any skipper who deliberately exposes his vessel & crew to unnecessary
danger because he is "brave" is a fool and a hazard.



....can you cite me an example of necessary danger?


Yep. But that's what I was asking Joe, so let him go first ;)

DSK



Capt.Mooron November 3rd 05 08:02 PM

The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
 

"DSK" wrote in message

Actually, I don't know that.
The sea can surprise you, but with study & forethought, surprises can be
minimized... probably not ever eliminated totally.


Heh... what about the Trans Atlantic sailors. They don't have much room to
"get out of the way" of approaching bad weather. Is it foolhardy and
dangerous to subject vessel & crew to a crossing? Is that skipper a danger
and a menace?

Anything as big as an ocean cannot change "suddenly"


Pardon Me???? Look Man... I commercial fished the east coast of Nova
Scotia. It'll change on you in 20 minutes without warning and totally
oblivious of the weather forecast..... usually when you have your deep set
gill pulled and half clear.

CM



Joe November 3rd 05 08:33 PM

The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
 
How about slapping open a pelican hook loose holding 65,000 pounds of
anchor and chain flaked out on deck under a heavy strain. Its
dangerious work, but necessary, working on a deck awash, diving under a
boat in rough seas, offloading underway in a 15 ft wake, I can think of
a thousand things that are dangerious and necessary to accomplish many
jobs at sea. The Alaskan crabbers have the most dangerious job on
earth, with offshore oilfield workers next in line. Not all skippers
have the courage to do the job. They are not outstanding IMO and need
to stick to safer occupations our ventures.

Joe


Bart Senior November 3rd 05 08:36 PM

The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
 
You watch too many poorly done SciFi movies.

"Capt. Neal®" wrote

from thinking constructively. Fear is the mind killer - the little death .

.. .



Joe November 3rd 05 08:45 PM

Redcloud
 
yelp just the 3 of us..a great escape for sure. It was a perfect week,
had a small problem with the gen set, somehow fuel got into the oil.
Will have to check it out this weekend and find out what happened.

Recharged and ready to clear the decks and get back to work

Joe


Joe November 3rd 05 10:40 PM

The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
 
Can you walk and chew bubble gum at the same time?

Joe


Scotty November 4th 05 02:09 AM

The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
 

"DSK" wrote in
Joe wrote:
How about not having a choice? The sea can change in a

heartbeat Doug.
You should know that.


Actually, I don't know that.
The sea can surprise you, but with study & forethought,

surprises can be
minimized... probably not ever eliminated totally.

Anything as big as an ocean cannot change "suddenly" but the

factors
affecting it can bring about a change that may be overlooked,

until it
becomes all too obvious.



But the sea changes colours...
but the sea...
Does not change

SN




Jonathan Ganz November 4th 05 04:53 AM

The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
 
In article , Bart Senior .@. wrote:
We are talking skippers now, not crew.

Courage is diffucult to define. I view courage as
doing something that might get you killed, despite the
known risks. Would an outstanding skipper do
something so risky as to possibly lose his/her life?

Skippers have no business doing anything risky,
except as a last resort.

A good skipper doesn't have fear, because he/she
always has a backup plan. When you are leading
you are making decisions about actions. Actions
conqueor fear.

Recognizing the dangers of a situation and staying
calm--is that courage? Or is it level-headedness?


Courage can also be defined as not doing something just because your
crew wants to do it.

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com



Bart Senior November 4th 05 07:19 AM

The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
 
That's backbone.

"Jonathan Ganz" wrote

Bart Senior .@. wrote:

A good skipper doesn't have fear, because he/she
always has a backup plan. When you are leading
you are making decisions about actions. Actions
conqueor fear.


Courage can also be defined as not doing something just because your
crew wants to do it.

"j" ganz @@




Jonathan Ganz November 4th 05 07:16 PM

The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
 
In article , Bart Senior .@. wrote:
That's backbone.

"Jonathan Ganz" wrote

Bart Senior .@. wrote:

A good skipper doesn't have fear, because he/she
always has a backup plan. When you are leading
you are making decisions about actions. Actions
conqueor fear.


Courage can also be defined as not doing something just because your
crew wants to do it.


I wish some of our leaders on both side of the aisle had more of it.

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com



DSK November 4th 05 07:33 PM

The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
 
Joe wrote:

How about slapping open a pelican hook loose holding 65,000 pounds of
anchor and chain flaked out on deck under a heavy strain. Its
dangerious work, but necessary, working on a deck awash, diving under a
boat in rough seas, offloading underway in a 15 ft wake, I can think of
a thousand things that are dangerious and necessary to accomplish many
jobs at sea. The Alaskan crabbers have the most dangerious job on
earth, with offshore oilfield workers next in line. Not all skippers
have the courage to do the job. They are not outstanding IMO and need
to stick to safer occupations our ventures.


Joe, I think those are good examples of jobs that take some bravery, but
not really applicable to being an outstanding skipper. Does the skipper
personally knock out the key link to drop anchor? Alaskan crabbers & oil
field workers do what they do for money. It doesn't have a thing to do
with being outstanding, only being willing to to take risks for pay.

That said, I have a high regard for most guys who work at sea under
almost any conditions. It's a tough way to make a living and takes a lot
of guts as well as some brainpower.

DSK


Joe November 4th 05 07:54 PM

The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
 
the skipper tells the deck hand when to trip open the hook, therefore
he is responsiable for the deckape.
Like I said, some Skippers handle anchors, some handle tourist on bird
watching boats and some run yachts for lubbers.



The outstanding ones are the ones who get the job done no matter what
is thrown at them. The ones who step up to the plate and have the
courage to swing. Lets face it Doug, some people do not have the
courage to be good skippers.

Joe


jlrogers November 10th 05 11:59 AM

The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
 
Stupidity is not the same as courage.

"Peter Wiley" wrote in message
. ..
In article , DSK
wrote:

Joe wrote:
Both Doug and Bart are wrong on this one.........


No, we're not.

... courage is very
important trait for an "outstanding skipper".


I would never want to go sailing with an outstandingly brave skipper. In
fact, a skipper who makes declarations that he's not afraid, or that
the crew should not be afraid, etc etc, is exactly the kind of macho
butt head who is dangerous on the water. The kind of skipper who is
intent on proving how brave he is, and (just for example) would refuse
to 'run away' from a Cat 5 hurricane.


Yeah - what Doug said.

I've been in F12 gales in the Southern Ocean. The inexperienced and the
macho brave thought it was fun. The skipper was watching the 2nd mate
on the helm, I was watching the radar and all 3 of us were not happy
campers.

It's real hard to pick up a bergy bit either visual or radar in a gale.

PDW




Peter Wiley November 10th 05 06:14 PM

The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
 
In article , DSK
wrote:

Joe wrote:
Both Doug and Bart are wrong on this one.........


No, we're not.

... courage is very
important trait for an "outstanding skipper".


I would never want to go sailing with an outstandingly brave skipper. In
fact, a skipper who makes declarations that he's not afraid, or that
the crew should not be afraid, etc etc, is exactly the kind of macho
butt head who is dangerous on the water. The kind of skipper who is
intent on proving how brave he is, and (just for example) would refuse
to 'run away' from a Cat 5 hurricane.


Yeah - what Doug said.

I've been in F12 gales in the Southern Ocean. The inexperienced and the
macho brave thought it was fun. The skipper was watching the 2nd mate
on the helm, I was watching the radar and all 3 of us were not happy
campers.

It's real hard to pick up a bergy bit either visual or radar in a gale.

PDW

Jonathan Ganz November 10th 05 07:07 PM

The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
 
In article ,
Peter Wiley wrote:
In article , DSK
wrote:

Joe wrote:
Both Doug and Bart are wrong on this one.........


No, we're not.

... courage is very
important trait for an "outstanding skipper".


I would never want to go sailing with an outstandingly brave skipper. In
fact, a skipper who makes declarations that he's not afraid, or that
the crew should not be afraid, etc etc, is exactly the kind of macho
butt head who is dangerous on the water. The kind of skipper who is
intent on proving how brave he is, and (just for example) would refuse
to 'run away' from a Cat 5 hurricane.


Yeah - what Doug said.

I've been in F12 gales in the Southern Ocean. The inexperienced and the
macho brave thought it was fun. The skipper was watching the 2nd mate
on the helm, I was watching the radar and all 3 of us were not happy
campers.

It's real hard to pick up a bergy bit either visual or radar in a gale.


Looking at some of the footage of the single handed around alone
crowd, none of them seemed particulary happy during those sort of
conditions. They looked like they were just trying to make it out
alive.



--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com



Donal November 11th 05 12:19 AM

The Attributes of an Outstanding Skipper
 

"Peter Wiley" wrote in message
. ..
In article , DSK
wrote:

Joe wrote:
Both Doug and Bart are wrong on this one.........


No, we're not.

... courage is very
important trait for an "outstanding skipper".


I would never want to go sailing with an outstandingly brave skipper. In
fact, a skipper who makes declarations that he's not afraid, or that
the crew should not be afraid, etc etc, is exactly the kind of macho
butt head who is dangerous on the water.


There is a very subtle difference between "an outstandingly brave skipper"
and a skipper who keeps his worries hidden from the crew.

The crew "think" that the skipper has total control over the boat - and the
elements!!!


A few years ago, there was an incident on Setanta where the crew saw that I
was a bit nervous. The result was the crew became extremely distressed.

If I had been a better skipper, then the crew would have been relaxed.


The kind of skipper who is
intent on proving how brave he is, and (just for example) would refuse
to 'run away' from a Cat 5 hurricane.


Yeah - what Doug said.


It isn't about bravery!

Regards


Donal
--







All times are GMT +1. The time now is 05:06 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com