BoatBanter.com

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)
-   ASA (https://www.boatbanter.com/asa/)
-   -   Let's (https://www.boatbanter.com/asa/28253-re-lets.html)

katysails February 18th 05 12:04 PM

Let's
 
I thought you couldn't hold dual citizenship in the US unless you were under
18....

"jlrogers±³©" wrote in message
. com...
http://news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=stor...ette&printer=1

--



jlrogers±³©
Beaten by George W. Bush! Now that's funny!





Capt. Mooron February 18th 05 12:11 PM

Canada allows dual citizenship...... maybe it's just a matter of her not
renouncing her Canadian citizen status.

CM

"katysails" wrote in message
...
I thought you couldn't hold dual citizenship in the US unless you were
under 18....

"jlrogers±³©" wrote in message
. com...
http://news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=stor...ette&printer=1

--



jlrogers±³©
Beaten by George W. Bush! Now that's funny!







Martin Baxter February 18th 05 12:21 PM

jlrogers±³© wrote:

http://news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=stor...ette&printer=1


Our plan is working, next we're going to ship you Celine Dion! Don Cherry will follow to clean things up.

Cheers
Marty


[email protected] February 18th 05 01:02 PM

katysails wrote:
I thought you couldn't hold dual citizenship in the US unless you

were under
18....


That's a widely held misconception, and it's simply not true. The US
does not require dual citizens to choose one citizenship when they
reach a certain age.

Some other countries do have this type of requirement. So, a person
who
was a citizen of both the US and a country with such a requirement
would have to choose only one citizenship. But, it would be the other
country that is forcing him to make the choice, not the US. If neither
country requires a choice, then the person
can remain a dual citizen for life.

This website discusses the US policies on Dual Citizenship, along with
the many misunderstandings surrounding it. It is, surprisingly,
allowed in many/most cases.

http://www.richw.org/dualcit/

Stephen Gallagher


[email protected] February 18th 05 01:10 PM

Capt. Mooron wrote:
Canada allows dual citizenship...... maybe it's just a matter of her

not
renouncing her Canadian citizen status.


As far as the US is concerned, she did renounce it, because the US
naturalization oath has a statement of renunciation. BUT, that
statement has no affect under Canadian law, and Canadian law determines
who is and who isn't a Canadian citizen. So, while she must deal with
the US as a US citizen, she can continue to deal with Canada as a
Canadian because Canada says that she is a Canadian.

Stephen Gallagher


Capt. Mooron February 18th 05 01:49 PM


wrote in message
ups.com...
Capt. Mooron wrote:
Canada allows dual citizenship...... maybe it's just a matter of her

not
renouncing her Canadian citizen status.


As far as the US is concerned, she did renounce it, because the US
naturalization oath has a statement of renunciation. BUT, that
statement has no affect under Canadian law, and Canadian law determines
who is and who isn't a Canadian citizen. So, while she must deal with
the US as a US citizen, she can continue to deal with Canada as a
Canadian because Canada says that she is a Canadian.


Interesting...... I can't become a Canadian citizen without losing my
Belgian citizenship. Belgium does not allow dual citizenship..... odd for a
European country within the EEC. I have elected to remain as a Permanent
Resident of Canada. The only advantage I have with a Canadian citizenship is
the ability to vote..... and to date I have never been able to cast a vote
in my entire life.

CM



Capt. Mooron February 18th 05 01:50 PM


"Martin Baxter" wrote in message
...
jlrogers±³© wrote:

http://news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=stor...ette&printer=1


Our plan is working, next we're going to ship you Celine Dion! Don Cherry
will follow to clean things up.


Damn... if we can get rid of those 2... we'll be way ahead of the game. They
best keep their hands off of Shania Twain!!!

CM



Jeff Morris February 18th 05 02:39 PM

Capt. Mooron wrote:
Interesting...... I can't become a Canadian citizen without losing my
Belgian citizenship. Belgium does not allow dual citizenship..... odd for a
European country within the EEC. I have elected to remain as a Permanent
Resident of Canada. The only advantage I have with a Canadian citizenship is
the ability to vote..... and to date I have never been able to cast a vote
in my entire life.


Doesn't Belgium allow you to vote? Do they know something about you?



Capt. Mooron February 18th 05 03:21 PM


"Jeff Morris" wrote in message

Doesn't Belgium allow you to vote? Do they know something about you?


I don't know if they allow me to vote or not. They do know about me.... I
have to renew my passport every 5 years.

But it begs the question... why would I even want to vote on an election in
Belgium?

CM



JG February 18th 05 07:30 PM

I thought that there are some countries with which one can hold dual
citizenship... Canada being one of them.

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com

wrote in message
ups.com...
Capt. Mooron wrote:
Canada allows dual citizenship...... maybe it's just a matter of her

not
renouncing her Canadian citizen status.


As far as the US is concerned, she did renounce it, because the US
naturalization oath has a statement of renunciation. BUT, that
statement has no affect under Canadian law, and Canadian law determines
who is and who isn't a Canadian citizen. So, while she must deal with
the US as a US citizen, she can continue to deal with Canada as a
Canadian because Canada says that she is a Canadian.

Stephen Gallagher




JG February 18th 05 07:31 PM

Thanks for the link.

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com

wrote in message
oups.com...
katysails wrote:
I thought you couldn't hold dual citizenship in the US unless you

were under
18....


That's a widely held misconception, and it's simply not true. The US
does not require dual citizens to choose one citizenship when they
reach a certain age.

Some other countries do have this type of requirement. So, a person
who
was a citizen of both the US and a country with such a requirement
would have to choose only one citizenship. But, it would be the other
country that is forcing him to make the choice, not the US. If neither
country requires a choice, then the person
can remain a dual citizen for life.

This website discusses the US policies on Dual Citizenship, along with
the many misunderstandings surrounding it. It is, surprisingly,
allowed in many/most cases.

http://www.richw.org/dualcit/

Stephen Gallagher




katysails February 18th 05 10:04 PM

Get with it, Marty...Celine already owns a large chunk of Vegas....got her
own venue there...

"Martin Baxter" wrote in message
...
jlrogers±³© wrote:

http://news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=stor...ette&printer=1


Our plan is working, next we're going to ship you Celine Dion! Don Cherry
will follow to clean things up.

Cheers
Marty




katysails February 18th 05 10:06 PM

thanks...it is of special interest to me since 3 of my grandchildren now
hold dual citizenship...I was under the impression that they would have to
choose Korea or here at the age of 18...guess I'll have to find out what
Korea thinks...


wrote in message
oups.com...
katysails wrote:
I thought you couldn't hold dual citizenship in the US unless you

were under
18....


That's a widely held misconception, and it's simply not true. The US
does not require dual citizens to choose one citizenship when they
reach a certain age.

Some other countries do have this type of requirement. So, a person
who
was a citizen of both the US and a country with such a requirement
would have to choose only one citizenship. But, it would be the other
country that is forcing him to make the choice, not the US. If neither
country requires a choice, then the person
can remain a dual citizen for life.

This website discusses the US policies on Dual Citizenship, along with
the many misunderstandings surrounding it. It is, surprisingly,
allowed in many/most cases.

http://www.richw.org/dualcit/

Stephen Gallagher




Maxprop February 18th 05 10:46 PM


"katysails" wrote in message

Get with it, Marty...Celine already owns a large chunk of Vegas....got her
own venue there...


Didn't she go down with the Titanic?

No?

Hmm, too bad.

Max



[email protected] February 18th 05 11:33 PM

www.sailnow.com

wrote in message
ups.com...
Capt. Mooron wrote:
Canada allows dual citizenship...... maybe it's just a matter of

her
not
renouncing her Canadian citizen status.


As far as the US is concerned, she did renounce it, because the US
naturalization oath has a statement of renunciation. BUT, that
statement has no affect under Canadian law, and Canadian law

determines
who is and who isn't a Canadian citizen. So, while she must deal

with
the US as a US citizen, she can continue to deal with Canada as a
Canadian because Canada says that she is a Canadian.

Stephen Gallagher


I thought that there are some countries with which one can hold dual
citizenship... Canada being one of them.

--
"j" ganz @@

A US citizen can be a dual citizen with any other country that also
allows
dual citizenship. The US doesn't have special agreements to allow dual

citizenship. It's allowed because there are no laws which prohibit it.

Stephen Gallagher


[email protected] February 19th 05 04:28 AM

I thought you couldn't hold dual citizenship in the US unless you
were under
18....


http://www.post-gazette.com/nation/2...dual0515p4.asp


An interesting article, but there are several blatently incorrect
statements in it.

The statement that Britain considers citizenship to be irrevocable, for
example. That's incorrect. If a British citizen wants to give up his
citizenship, he can do so by visiting a British consulate and signing a
statement of renunciation.

That's just one of several inaccuracies.

Stephen


[email protected] February 19th 05 04:29 AM

I thought you couldn't hold dual citizenship in the US unless you
were under
18....


http://www.post-gazette.com/nation/2...dual0515p4.asp


An interesting article, but there are several blatently incorrect
statements in it.

The statement that Britain considers citizenship to be irrevocable, for
example. That's incorrect. If a British citizen wants to give up his
citizenship, he can do so by visiting a British consulate and signing a
statement of renunciation.

That's just one of several inaccuracies.

Stephen


[email protected] February 19th 05 04:30 AM

I thought you couldn't hold dual citizenship in the US unless you
were under
18....


http://www.post-gazette.com/nation/2...dual0515p4.asp


An interesting article, but there are several blatently incorrect
statements in it.

The statement that Britain considers citizenship to be irrevocable, for
example. That's incorrect. If a British citizen wants to give up his
citizenship, he can do so by visiting a British consulate and signing a
statement of renunciation.

That's just one of several inaccuracies.

Stephen


JG February 19th 05 08:12 PM

Well, Dave's a better poodle than a lawyer.

--
"j" ganz @@
www.sailnow.com

wrote in message
ps.com...
I thought you couldn't hold dual citizenship in the US unless you

were under
18....


http://www.post-gazette.com/nation/2...dual0515p4.asp


An interesting article, but there are several blatently incorrect
statements in it.

The statement that Britain considers citizenship to be irrevocable, for
example. That's incorrect. If a British citizen wants to give up his
citizenship, he can do so by visiting a British consulate and signing a
statement of renunciation.

That's just one of several inaccuracies.

Stephen





All times are GMT +1. The time now is 11:08 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com