BoatBanter.com

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)
-   ASA (https://www.boatbanter.com/asa/)
-   -   sub damage pics (https://www.boatbanter.com/asa/27532-sub-damage-pics.html)

Gilligan January 27th 05 11:31 PM

sub damage pics
 
http://www.navy.mil/view_gallery.asp?category_id=17




Scott Vernon January 28th 05 02:14 AM


OzOne wrote


Scary ****.


As is everything to you.

Boo!

;)




otnmbrd January 28th 05 02:33 AM

I'd call that a damned fine testimonial of USN Damage Control

Thom Stewart January 28th 05 06:10 AM

Gilly,

What a great post!! Thank you.

Ole Thom


http://community.webtv.net/tassail/ThomsHomePage


Gilligan January 28th 05 02:49 PM

No luck. The United States has had the best Navy in the world for almost 250
years, thanks to people such as myself, DSK, Joe, Ole Thom, and people of
Naval Auxilaries such as Capt Neal of the Merchant Marine, a finer officer
there never was! You can thank your lucky stars that America has shielded
Australia with its nuclear umbrella and that when one point of its nuclear
triad runs directly into a mountain, it gets back to port with absolutely no
danger from a nuclear accident. The whole incident is a testimonial to
excellence - American excellence!

Gilligan
OzOne wrote in message ...
On Fri, 28 Jan 2005 02:33:49 GMT, otnmbrd
scribbled thusly:

I'd call that a damned fine testimonial of USN Damage Control


marinated in lots of luck.


Oz1...of the 3 twins.

I welcome you to crackerbox palace,We've been expecting you.




Fuzzy Logic January 28th 05 06:32 PM

OzOne wrote in :

http://www.navy.mil/view_gallery.asp?category_id=17


I wonder just how many serious injuries were sustaine in a grounding
that hard?


1 death...no mention of injuries he

http://www.cnn.com/2005/US/01/27/sub...ged/index.html

Apparently the underwater 'speed bump' wasn't on the charts?!

Joe January 28th 05 08:28 PM

Right you are Gilligan,

The picture shows the vessel after most of the damaged skin was
removed. Most the compartment you see open to the air are forward of
the collision bulkhead. Infact you can see the collision bulkhead in
the picture. What was lost seems to be ballast tanks, torpedo tubes
equipment spaces ect.

Thats why a collision bulkhead is of extreme importance on a ocean
going vessel. Take RedCloud for instance, she has 5 foot of bow that
could be smashed in and still sail along without taking on any water.
Then 3 other seperate water tight compartments.

Also I think the sub hit a mound or ledge not a speed bump as some
call it, unless they were flying sideways. Almost looks like they
rammed a ship off the port quarter. I wonder if the story we hear is
just a cover-up?

Thanks for the link.

Joe


Capt. Neal® January 28th 05 08:35 PM

Right you are, Joe. It's clear from the damaged area
on the bow that they had to run the thing into the upper
part of an underwater cave opening and not a seamount.
Either that or a steeply inverted seamount. Yeh Right!

It's clear even to this novice that there was plenty
of shear action taking place. Do seamounts move
at a high rate of speed?

It seems to me they hit a ship or another sub and are
engaging in a cover up. Probably rammed a Russian sub.
Good riddance, I say.

The Russian sub probably sunk and was crushed with all
hands lost. God is good.

CN


"Joe" wrote in message oups.com...
Right you are Gilligan,

The picture shows the vessel after most of the damaged skin was
removed. Most the compartment you see open to the air are forward of
the collision bulkhead. Infact you can see the collision bulkhead in
the picture. What was lost seems to be ballast tanks, torpedo tubes
equipment spaces ect.

Thats why a collision bulkhead is of extreme importance on a ocean
going vessel. Take RedCloud for instance, she has 5 foot of bow that
could be smashed in and still sail along without taking on any water.
Then 3 other seperate water tight compartments.

Also I think the sub hit a mound or ledge not a speed bump as some
call it, unless they were flying sideways. Almost looks like they
rammed a ship off the port quarter. I wonder if the story we hear is
just a cover-up?

Thanks for the link.

Joe


Joe January 28th 05 08:50 PM

No.. if it were a Russian sub Moscow would be banging on the door
demanding lots of greenback.

Maybe a Japanese Long liner or Purse Seainer or Whaling ship.

Sheeeze recovering the last Japanese fishing ship cost over a billion
dollars..... all because of the outdated self centered Japanese
culture.

If I go down on a ship or boat leave me there..A finer grave you will
not find.

Joe


Capt. Neal® January 28th 05 08:55 PM


"Joe" wrote in message ups.com...
No.. if it were a Russian sub Moscow would be banging on the door
demanding lots of greenback.

Maybe a Japanese Long liner or Purse Seainer or Whaling ship.

Sheeeze recovering the last Japanese fishing ship cost over a billion
dollars..... all because of the outdated self centered Japanese
culture.

If I go down on a ship or boat leave me there..A finer grave you will
not find.


I'd rather be cradled in the arms of morphine . . .

CN

Scott Vernon January 28th 05 09:42 PM

"Joe" wrote

Thats why a collision bulkhead is of extreme importance on a ocean
going vessel. Take RedCloud for instance, she has 5 foot of bow that
could be smashed in and still sail along without taking on any

water.
Then 3 other seperate water tight compartments.


That's mighty impressive, Joe.

BTW how deep *is* your slip?

Scotty





Joe January 28th 05 09:53 PM


Scott Vernon wrote:
"Joe" wrote

Thats why a collision bulkhead is of extreme importance on a ocean
going vessel. Take RedCloud for instance, she has 5 foot of bow

that
could be smashed in and still sail along without taking on any

water.
Then 3 other seperate water tight compartments.


That's mighty impressive, Joe.



Not impressive Scotty, Safe and well engineered.
How many water tight compartments do you have on your boat?



BTW how deep *is* your slip?


High tide or low tide? North wind or South? Close to the dock, or out
towards the center? Port or Starboard side?

Joe



Scotty



Thom Stewart January 28th 05 11:16 PM

Joe,

Are you saying "Redcloud" doesn't have limbar holes in her Bilge?

How many bilge pumps do you have?
Are they automatic pumps with their own level switches?

Ole Thom


http://community.webtv.net/tassail/ThomsHomePage


Joe January 28th 05 11:47 PM

4.

One main self priming 4hp electric with manifold and hard piping to all
three compartments. Pump is in engineroom mounted the same height as
the Gen set approx 3 ft above waterline

3 Atwells on float switches, one in each WT compartment.

Yes I have limber holes but not between each compartment. Solid
bulkheads up to the deck with all items running thru the bulkhead are
in compression fitting and are water tight as well.

Joe


Scott Vernon January 29th 05 01:05 AM


"Joe" wrote in message
ups.com...

Scott Vernon wrote:
"Joe" wrote

Thats why a collision bulkhead is of extreme importance on a

ocean
going vessel. Take RedCloud for instance, she has 5 foot of bow

that
could be smashed in and still sail along without taking on any

water.
Then 3 other seperate water tight compartments.


That's mighty impressive, Joe.



Not impressive Scotty, Safe and well engineered.
How many water tight compartments do you have on your boat?


Uh.....counting the holding and water tank? two.


SV



Gilligan January 29th 05 02:17 AM

I would have said it rammed one of your Collins class subs but I don't think
any have gotten out of port yet.


OzOne wrote in message ...
On Fri, 28 Jan 2005 14:49:26 GMT, "Gilligan"
scribbled thusly:

No luck. The United States has had the best Navy in the world for almost

250
years, thanks to people such as myself, DSK, Joe, Ole Thom, and people

of
Naval Auxilaries such as Capt Neal of the Merchant Marine, a finer

officer
there never was! You can thank your lucky stars that America has shielded
Australia with its nuclear umbrella and that when one point of its

nuclear
triad runs directly into a mountain, it gets back to port with absolutely

no
danger from a nuclear accident. The whole incident is a testimonial to
excellence - American excellence!


Ahh yes, it appears that the US is well versed in 'damage control'



Oz1...of the 3 twins.

I welcome you to crackerbox palace,We've been expecting you.




Thom Stewart January 29th 05 02:36 AM

Redcloud got Pneuma beat all to hell. That is very fine planning and
construction

Ole Thom


http://community.webtv.net/tassail/ThomsHomePage


Capt. Neal® January 29th 05 05:31 AM


"Thom Stewart" wrote

Redcloud got Pneuma beat all to hell.


So does a Mac26X . . .

CN

bell January 29th 05 05:51 AM

Capt. Neal® wrote:
"Thom Stewart" wrote

Redcloud got Pneumonia beat all to hell.


So does a Mac26X . . .

CN





Joe January 29th 05 09:47 PM

I would be proud to claim it was my planning and construction, but
thats the way she came.

Joe



All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:38 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com