Is this a trick question? If you don't include factors that are against heavy gear, what
you're left with are the factors in favor. Yes, in general, with two similar designed
anchors, the heavier/larger will hold better. But holding power is only part of the
story. For instance, in certain consistencies of mud, a smaller anchor will dig in
quicker. The large shank of the CQR can work against it in this situation.


"CANDChelp" wrote in message
...
So to answer your question, heavy gear deployed in a marginal position is not
as desirable
as lighter gear deployed in an optimal location.

But all other factors being equal, and space not being an issue, is there not a
clear advantage for the heavier hook?

RB