Yes, there's a single point of failure -- actually points -- everything
from the stuffing box aft. Everything on a boat is a compromise of some
sort, and that includes the get home.
The good news -- single screw boats are much less likely to have propeller
and shaft problems than twins, and most of those are from hitting something.
While it is certainly possible to imagine something that would take out
Fintry's propeller, it is unlikely. The shaft is 5.75" diameter, which is
way oversize for 400hp at 400 shaft rpm. The propeller is right behind
considerable deadwood. The propeller itself is massively built. (see
http://www.mvfintry.com/pix/sternqtr800.png)
So while it isn't perfect, it's a relatively short money answer to a main
engine failure in mid ocean....
As far as doing without the gearbox (if I understand you correctly), by
using a low pitch wheel, the numbers don't work. The boat's designed for a
59" wheel and you simply can't turn a propeller anywhere near that size
without substantial reduction, in this case 4.5 to 1.
--
Jim Woodward
www.mvFintry.com
..
"Ed" wrote in message ...
One thought.... After 20 years of diesel boating I have had to limp home
3 times...(I have almost always had twins) Two times from prop issues
and once due to a broken shaft... If you are looking at a "get-home"
solution I would lean towards something that is 100% redundant. Even
with Spare shaft and a low pitch wheel, you still have single point of
failure with the strut, etc. If you do decide to go forward with
this I would suggest getting a very low pitch wheel and dumping the
gearbox.
Jim Woodward wrote:
We're sort of doing this on Fintry.
We have a Perkins 6-354 that was driving a 30 kw 220VDC genset that
we're
going to use for hydraulics, primarily for a sixty horse bow thruster,
but
also for docking capstans, crane, windlass, etc. The main reason for not
driving the hydraulics off the Cat 3406 main is that while docking, you
probably want the main to be idling most of the time, just when you want
to
be taking sixty horse for the thruster.
In the conversation with John Champion at American Bow Thruster, he
asked
about get-home.
We've ended up specifying an extra hydraulic motor driving a roller
chain
sprocket on the propeller shaft. We've calculated the sprocket sizes so
that the shaft will turn the right rpm with the available horsepower
(sixty
less losses). We'll put the chain over the two sprockets only when
needed.
For short term use, lubrication is not a real issue -- hitting it with
an
oil can every few hours will get us home from anywhere. This may get
messy,
but it's an emergency.
So, while your idea should work, and my instinct tells me that 6hp may
be
enough, I'm not sure I would go electric. For one thing, a 6hp diesel
will
not drive a 5hp electric motor. For another, you'll turn on the motor
with
the shaft stopped, so you'll need enough torque to start it turning.
That
will require careful design.
If the main is soft mounted, you need to think about the fact that the
shaft
will be moving around -- either mount the get home motor on the main
engine
or look at how much relative motion the chain drive will accept.
One thing to do carefully. Ask your propeller manufacturer or naval
architect what shaft speed will absorb the horsepower you have available
at
the shaft. This has to be done in steps, because then you have figure
out
how fast the boat will move at that shaft speed and adjust the number
for
the slip at that speed. This is one place where having hydraulic or
variable speed electric drive would help, as you can accelerate the
shaft
slowly up to speed as the boat gets moving, taking only as much HP at
each
speed as you have.