On Aug 31, 8:26*am, BAR wrote:
hk wrote:
Richard Casady wrote:
On Fri, 29 Aug 2008 08:38:58 -0400, HK wrote:

Eisboch wrote:
"Vic Smith" wrote in message
m...
On Fri, 29 Aug 2008 07:52:57 -0400, "Eisboch" wrote:

Tricky stuff.
I usually let out the loud, commanding shout like you did, but I may
have just called 911 instead. *Getting too old to have my heart
racing.

--Vic

You've got that right. * I have a shotgun that I keep locked up in
the house. *Never used it.
Bought it in Florida after finding a huge rattlesnake at our front
door.

As I hid behind the tree I was thinking about it, and the cell phone
I had left on the table in the house.
I am glad I didn't think about taking the shotgun. *I'd probably be
in the hospital right now.

I think if I awoke and discovered someone *in* our house, I'd
probably use it.

Eisboch

You have no duty under the laws of your state to retreat in your
house if you think an intruder is going to harm you or a family
member. I'm not sure you would get the same pass for an outdoor
trespasser.

You are entitled to use the gun anytime you have a reasonable fear of
death or great bodily harm, and no good non lethal option seems
available. You don't necessarily shoot to protect the TV, lf you tell
him to put it down, and he reaches for a gun... *Get a shotgun.

Casady

As you say, it has to be a reasonable fear of personal injury or death.

Someone breaking into your outdoor barn when no one is in it might just
be a thief or trespasser. I'm not sure in my state or any other
progressive state with "castle doctrine" that you would get away with
shooting a trespasser simply on your property or breaking into a barn.
This isn't Texas, after all.

When I discussed a threat we had received with our local sheriff, he was
very clear that I couldn't legally just shoot at the "perp" if he was on
the property, but he was equally clear that if the "perp" busted in the
door or even tried to do so, I could blow the idiot away with my 12
gauge. When I asked about "retreat," the sheriff said, "Retreat to
where? A bedroom?" and then he laughed.

What did the sheriff says about pinning the guy against the garage wall
and breaking his legs with your F-150?- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -

The conv never happened.. it was a Harrytale, that's why he won't
address it again..