Hi

"Meindert Sprang" skrev i en meddelelse
...
"Scott Downey" wrote in message
...

Yes. But in a conventional carvel hull, the caulking absorbs the extra
dimension of the expanding wood.

WHAT ?????

Don't anyone in this forum have any hands-on experience ?
Caulking is done at the outher third of the seam and the seam is prepared
for caulking, ------- It's bloddy _not_ the damned caulking that make the
hull watertight when you build a cravel planked boat, as the bloody seams
are TIGHT even before the caulking is there.
Do you realy think cravel build boats are just a bunch of planks with seems
inbetween that you look right thru , and that you just forget about the
craftmanship as you just Bang in caulking ???
Well that's _not_ how you build a cravel planked boat hull ------- and be
glad for that, as if this was how, no craftmanship or respect for the crafts
would survive the sailers counting on boatbuilders having the knowleage to
make a safe vessel.
Just becaurse you as amature builder, seen an old mistreated hull, with
inverts opened seams, do damn'ed not mean that this sort of bad
craftmanship, was what made these beautifull vessels ------ all it mean is,
that some ignorant Amature been doing a temp. repair, where a profesional
would have replaced the plank. ( nice case you trust your life upon ).

Bet you even think that caulking is just about banging in stuffing untill
the whole plank is forced to destroy the seams around and above, ------ seem
like you even mix two compleatly different technikes by talking about
caulking with Lapstrake building ; YOU DO NOT CAULK A LAPSTRAKE HULL, unless
it's old and worn , unless the planks shuld have been replaced decades ago,
don't you Amature boatbuilders know the difference between Lapstrake and
Cravel ; then how the hell can you avoid to crack the plank edge if you
start caulking a Lapstrake hull -------- don't you se it, don't you even
know that you can destroy a lapstrake hull by caulking it ????

P.C.