Thread: I decided
View Single Post
  #204   Report Post  
posted to rec.boats.cruising,alt.sailing.asa
[email protected] dougking888@yahoo.com is offline
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by BoatBanter: Feb 2007
Posts: 900
Default I decided

JimC wrote:
1) A boat that is not essentially limited to being sailed in the
immediate area. - The Mac26M can be quickly and easily transported by
the owner (with a pickup or SUV) in one weekend to waters hundreds of
miles from it's berth or storage area.


So can many many many other small ~ medium sized sailboats. My
sailboat data base has about 1600 trailerable boats (and this is
probably less than half of all the different types that have been
produced in the U.S. & Canada).


2) A boat that doesn't have to be berthed in a marina.


Isn't this kinda the same as #1?

3) A coastal cruiser that can be sailed in a variety of waters,


Isn't this kinda the same as #1, again?

including offshore, with the understanding that it isn't recommended for
extended ocean crossings and isn't as comfortable in heavy weather.


Ha ha ha... you mean, if you bring lots of duct tape you might return
with most of what you started with?

Frankly, having seen Mac 26Xs & Ms sailing in relatively sheltered
waters in 15 knot winds & 2 ~ 3 feet of chop... and having trouble
coping with these conditions when not actually suffering breakdowns...
I can't imagine sailing one "offshore in heavy weather" for more than
about 15 minutes.


4} A boat that incorporates a number of safety features, including
positive floatation


Again, a common feature shared by many other boats.

.... The boat is also designed to accommodate a large outboard
which gives the skipper more options in the event of heavy weather,
e.g., for returning to port quickly.


Again, ha ha ha. For one thing, the speed of the Mac26X~M is very much
exaggerated. It certainly won't outrun any storms at 15 knots or
less; and the hull shape & stability is such that it will be very
problematic to handle it at any speed in really rough weather.


7) A boat that is priced substantially lower than conventional larger
boats


Or conventional boats of similar accomodation... and there you have it
in a nutshell. The Mac26X~M is a portable cheap hotel room. Not that
there's anything wrong with that.




9) A boat that can have a 5.5 feet draft for sailing (with dagger-board
down) but that can be converted to one with only 1.5-ft draft in
shallow waters


Again, a feature shared by many many many other boats.


10) A sailboat that, unlike 90 percent of the boats discussed on this
ng, isn't limited to hull speed.


Isn't this a repeat of something from #4 above?



12) Finally, I see a boat that is FUN TO SAIL!


A matter of taste. If the "magic of sail" to you means having big
white pieces of cloth flopping around from a pole while you lurch
aimlessly across the water, yeah that'll do it.

Try sailing a Laser or an Albacore or a 505 or an Etchells or a Nacra
or a Melges 24 or any of hundreds of actual high performance sailing
craft... you don't even have to get stressed out and try one of the
double-trap skiffs... boats that will equal or exceed the wind
velocity and plane readily UNDER SAIL.

Frankly, for anybody with any experience on sailing craft of any real
performance level, the "magic" of sailing a Mac26X~M is a big yawn.
But it's all a matter of taste. You clearly like your boat, what's
funny is the level of delusion you have to maintain.

DSK