Guys, Dave Gerr (Elements of Boat Strength, pg.186) and others have
written volumes about 5000 vs. 6000 series aluminum alloys. They all
recommend 5000 series for marine applications, but caution that it's NOT
taboo to substitute 6000 series for use other than hull plate--including
non-intregal fuel tanks.
Welded aluminum sounds horribly weak from the drift of this discussion.
I guess that's why aluminum tankers supply the fuel to our local gas
stations? Think about it. That tanker you passed on the freeway this
morning held 5000 gallons of gasoline enclosed inside an aluminum
skin--0.180" sides/top and 0.220" belly--and it bridged 30' kingpin to
center of axles. The girth weld, 15' from the nearest bearing support is
a simple butt joint and was probably hand mig welded by a kid who didn't
finish high school.
Forget the semi trailer, the 50 gallon round or rectangular saddle tanks
hung off brackets bolted outboard from the truck chassis were most
likely welded aluminum and at 0.161" to 0.250" plate thickness--thicker
than they need to be--for added protection against puncture. And they
are hung--suspended by fabricated straps and/or U-brackets.
So please don't malign welded aluminum tanks. They've been the fuel tank
of choice for 50 years where light weight, low maintenance and cost
effectiveness are appreciated.
Regards,
Boat Dreams